20 September, 2021

Blog

Covid Pandemic, KNDU Debate & Civil-Military Relations

By Laksiri Fernando

Dr. Laksiri Fernando

Covid-19 pandemic undoubtedly is the central challenge Sri Lanka is facing today along with other countries. All indications are that the world might not be able to come to ‘normal’ at least until 2023. This is assuming that our governments would be able to implement viable vaccination programs and other necessary measures with people’s cooperation. 

Gravity of the Pandemic

Even that ‘normal’ might not be the ‘past normal’ with most countries facing economic devastations, weak workforces on health conditions, international trade relations dislocated, and environmental catastrophes continuing. It is not clear what kind of a political-economic ‘model’ would hold for the future as liberal capitalism being the root cause for most of the present disasters plundering natural resources, polluting the environment, dislocating animals and overexploiting the humans. 

In the case of Sri Lanka, so far the challenge of the coronavirus pandemic has been handled satisfactorily, although the necessary cooperation from some important sections has not been forthcoming. The near future, however, is not very clear given the devastating effects of the fast spreading new Delta variant. Nevertheless, there are sections in the polity who want to desperately continue their past politics, protests, strikes or even ‘planning to overthrow the government’ disregarding these conditions.

To the people, politics in a democratic system is about choices through trial and error. They did a trial in 2015 and found an error. They have again done a new trail in 2019/2020 and may be evaluating the results. The best possible choice for the people under democracy is to get the best out of any government that they elect during the tenure through dialogue, cooperation, non-cooperation, criticism and constructive criticism etc. This is exactly what is happening in a country like Australia where I live at present. Strikes and protests are normally in the democratic menu, but not exactly under the conditions like the present coronavirus pandemic.    

Measures in Australia and Sri Lanka 

Until recently Australia managed the pandemic fairly well given the cooperation the central government and state governments received from the oppositions, medical professionals, health workers, trade unions and the public. Unlike a country like France, there were no much opposition to lockdowns, face masks, social distancing, or strict guidelines. Australia was managing quite well like New Zealand until recently.

Australian Civil-Military Council (ACMC)

Perhaps because of the successes, Australia also got little complacent and the vaccination rollouts got delayed. This appears to be the key reason why the virus started to spread again particularly in Sydney (NSW), in addition to the attack by the virulent Delta variant since last month. Now there are strict rules again. Compared to Sri Lanka, the public health system is quite advanced and the private sector is cooperating. There were no strikes or protests by the doctors or the nurses although there are similar pay anomalies and grievances on the part of them. They were patient and tolerant. 

Of course the grievances in Sri Lanka are more, as a poor and a developing country. Moreover, politics is exceedingly hot. Education is an area greatly affected in  both countries with obvious future repercussions. In Australia, teachers are cooperating fully in conducting online teaching. In Sri Lanka, obviously there are problems, but teacher protests are completely undermining the efforts in resolving them.

To offset the adverse economic effects on employment and businesses, because of lockdowns and other restrictions, Australia has necessary resources to offset them through job-keeper, job-seeker and business concessions. However these possibilities in Sri Lanka are limited. In controlling the virus spread, Australia is implementing extremely effective contact tracing measures and asking the people to follow strict rules. While this type of accurate measures are difficult in Sri Lanka, many people who infected or possibly effected appear to be taking these instructions lightly.

Because of people’s widespread mistrust of the police, the rule application through the police in Sri Lanka has become difficult. This is not the case in Australia. There is no apparent opposition to lockdowns or other government measures by opposition political parties at the national or state/provincial levels. The Labor Party in the opposition is cooperating with the government, critically as necessary.

There were some protest demonstrations against lockdowns recently in Sydney and Melbourne which were forcefully dispersed and the perpetrators were brought to justice with punishments and heavy fines. This kind of pandemic control might not be possible in Sri Lanka given the present political culture and people exercising freedoms without responsibilities.

The NSW government has brought the military into the scene and prevented any protest happening during the last weekend. Civil-military relations are high in Australia compared to Sri Lanka. The soldiers are also employed to ‘knock door-to-door’ in local government areas where strict lockdowns are implemented to reprimand those who disobey. Of course these measures are implemented with civility and respect for people’s other rights.

KNDU Debate

Although the pandemic is the main challenge at the moment, the government, the opposition, the civil society, the media, academics or any other should not neglect addressing or discussing other issues What is necessary is to understand the present juncture, and prepare for the next stage without unnecessarily postponing anything. Therefore, the KNDU (Kotelawala National Defence University) debate is important but it should better be placed in the broader context. What is it?

There is a pressing need to expand, upgrade and diversify university education, of course without violating the basic principles of free education. While around 350,000 students sit for the admissions examination (GCE-A), and around 200,000 students qualify for admissions, only around 30,000 are admitted to the universities. This year the UGC is indenting to enroll additional 10,000 students to bring the number to around 40,000. Annually over 10,000 students go abroad for their education. These figures very clearly show the need to further expand the university education.

Under the UGC (University Grants Commission), there are 15 universities and the average student intake is around 2,000. The expansion of university education has been lethargic, to my experience, due to the centralized control of the UGC. At least the universities like Colombo, Peradeniya and Moratuwa should have been given autonomy a long time ago to expand, be efficient and innovate.

KDU has been under the Ministry of Defence and independent from the UGC. The property was given generously by Sir John Kotelawala and as a fee levying university it has become largely self-reliant. Its capacity has increased over five-fold, admitting less than 200 students at the beginning and  increasing eventually to around 1,000 per year. KDU is primarily a defence university (special purpose), but admits civil students. The teachers are mainly military but with reputed other academics participating.

Some Questions

There can be (and are) inconsistencies and weaknesses in the proposed bill for the KNDU. But such weaknesses are there even in the Universities Act (1978). It is up to the government and the opposition to sort them out.

1. KNDU is primarily opposed claiming it kills free education. KDA/U was there since 1981, but there was no such opposition before. There are private universities, but those are also not opposed, but patronized by some. KNDU fees should be reasonable and it should not be a profit making enterprise. Free education should not be understood artificially. Some public universities running on a fair-fee basis, with other assistance, would help expanding ‘fully free education’ for needy students while expanding the university system in the country as a whole.

A university (first) degree today is considered only a basic qualification internationally. Therefore, expansion of university education is a must for the Sri Lanka to become par with other countries in knowledge, skills and capacities. KNDU appears to make a useful contribution towards this end.     

2. KNDU is also opposed because of its military affiliation or nature. This is largely a misplaced and/or an emotional outburst. During 2005 and 2010, I was affiliated with the KDU, mainly teaching human rights. I have known many civilian academics teaching different subjects then and thereafter. Since then, the civilian student population has expanded even with foreign students. The interaction of civil and military, local and international is a healthy atmosphere at the KDU. .

It is the case that student unions are not allowed at KDU. Instead there are social clubs. Military training is only for military cadets. Perhaps civilian students should be promoted for sports (aiming at Olympics!). Sri Lanka is poor in sports except for cricket. Of course the quality and standards of KNDU courses, curricula and teaching should be reviewed by UGC or any such organization.

Civil-Military Relations

I believe the newly proposed KNDU can play a major role in civil-military relations. This is something neglected in Sri Lanka. Defence forces are and should be ‘People’s Defence Forces.’ They are not enemies of the people and should not be the case. The defence personnel, and also the police, also should learn how to deal with the people in civility.

In Australia, there is a Civil-Military Center (ACMC) promoting this task. The Center also includes the police in its programs. Its mission says “We work in contexts where there are no easy answers, where the environment is always changing. Our purpose is to support civil-military-police capabilities to prevent, prepare for and respond more effectively to conflicts and disasters.” 

Particularly in a context of pandemics like coronavirus, recurrent floods, landslides and droughts, and ocean disasters like X-Press Pearl, the field of study of ‘civil-military relations’ both in theory and practice is important. In all these activities women should be given an equal place. The proposed KNDU Bill, with positive amendments, can expand university education, upgrade and diversify courses and curricula, and also promote civil-military relations, of course without killing free education.   

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 9
    0

    Dr. Laksiri says:
    “The property was given generously by Sir John Kotelawala and as a fee levying university it has become largely self-reliant”
    In fact, it is not. According to the Sunday Times:
    “Among the Kotelawala Defence University’s (KDU) borrowings over the years is a foreign currency loan of US$ 177.33mn (Rs 35bn) in addition to a local currency loan of Rs 3.16bn obtained from the National Savings Bank (NSB) on a Treasury guarantee in April 2013, documents show.”
    Moving to the military, he says :”Defence forces are and should be ‘People’s Defence Forces.’ They are not enemies of the people” Well then , if (some) of the people are not the enemy, who is the enemy? Why do we need 350,000 people in the forces when even the UK, which has its own separatist problems, has only 200,000?
    Isn’t this a thinly disguised way to keep the majority community quiet and in employment? It is ridiculous to talk about maintaining free education while justifying a huge and non- productive military. We can’t have both at the same time.

    • 3
      0

      old codger

      You have raised several valid questions regarding KDU and Dr. Laksiri Fernando justification for what the state has planned to do.

      When did we ever get rational fact based answers from him?

      Thanks for reminding us to check Sunday Times.

  • 8
    0

    Dr.Laksiri, You proposed honorary doctorates to Mahinda Rajapakse and Gotabaya Rajapakse.
    Why?
    Did this promote Civil-Military relations?
    Gotabaya is now to all intents and purposes, a Military Dictator with massive power over everyone in Sri Lanka.
    Do you approve this state of affairs?
    Military colleges/schools are institutions teach the Are of War and coach students to excel in military matters.
    They must be kept apart from universities which teach academic disciplines.
    This is what happens in all other countries.
    Civility is ingrained in academia – civil and military.

  • 4
    0

    Sorry – Art of War

  • 10
    0

    In general I agree with your concept but the question, is our government thinking as sincere , the way you do ??? Laksiri, you accuse of the opposition and TU playing politics, but it the government/Rajapaksas who conducted elections during peak of pandemic, allowed funeral procession to get votes, pardoned and released murderers including Duminda, bribed MP,s to pass 20 A, used lock down for unfair election campaigning, brought tourist and foreigners, president intervened to change the morality from 100 to 15 —etc—etc. To be honest it is the opposition (SJB) which kept warning government of potential spread, early lock down and other measures when Rajapaksas were denying it. As long education is concerned, I too believe no govt alone can support essential sectors (education,health, transport). With the potential we had Lanka could have easily been a world renowned hub (if not in Asia) for health and education which together with tourism could have been a real money maker even during adversities such as pandemic/economic crisis. Such early start could have helped later in expanding into IT, research and development, Pharma sector and service providing hubs. But our govt went with standardization, unemployment, revolt and brain drain. Now, even with privatization, many educated will leave country to make a living.

  • 9
    0

    I have in recent times had a niggling fear that this writer, who had generally acquired some credibility due to his academic credentials, was fast becoming an unethical sycophant affiliated to the present regime in Sri Lanka. His angle in this article tends to confirm that fear. If my fear turns out to be justified, it would add to the shame of the several “academics” who have stooped low to scrape the bottom of the barrel with the parasitic political class. Examples that come to mind are GL Peiris, Jayasumana, Senaratne, Pathirana et al.

  • 5
    0

    It is interesting to find Dr Laksiri Fernado was teaching human rights at KNDU and in the process learned that human duties are much more important than human rights.

    Nevertheless, every democracy has civilian political leadership over the military. It is in order to ensure that military will not develop any unjustifiable ambition to take over power in their hands. As long as the military is kept in place, democracy is safe.

    Australia and Sri Lanka could not be compared since Australia is a country of immigrants and immigration is controlled, and different benchmark is used for whites and nonwhites.

  • 2
    0

    Q. DO YOU THINK KDNU PROVIDES A LIBERAL(FREEDOM) EDUCATION?

    https://www.aacu.org/blog/call-it-what-it-liberal-education
    banner

    Call It What It Is: Liberal Education

  • 2
    0

    Laksiri Thinking out of box. Military training for Olympic gold. Can you suggest putting entire cricket team and management in KNDU. I guess that is how Australians succeeded.

  • 1
    0

    “Nevertheless, there are sections in the polity who want to desperately continue their past politics, protests, strikes or even ‘planning to overthrow the government’ disregarding these conditions.”

    Who overthrow the government in 2019 with the start of the pandemic?

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 7 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.