9 September, 2024

Blog

Education Is Not A Business But A Way Of Life!

By Samadhi Athauda

Samadhi Athauda

To dive down to the deepest lengths of education and to acknowledge its contribution to society, we all should have an understanding of what is truly meant by the term, “Education”. As far as my knowledge goes, I think we can all agree that education is not merely the studying of books. The whole point of education is to gain new knowledge. But to realize that almost everyone thinks that this knowledge can ONLY be achieved by books is truly disheartening. This fact can indeed be proved wrong by looking closely at the early stages of human civilization.

At first, they made pots using clay, then burned them as time passed and also used tools made of stone and later started to make ones using metal. I can guarantee you that the so-called ‘books” which are the only way to education according to some individuals, were not considered when they made such changes in their lifestyle, which benefited us as well since we evolved from them. Then how did they know what to do? it was “experience” that taught them that burning the clay would make their pots stronger. That metal-based tools would be more efficient than stone-based ones. It was continuous trial and error which contributed to creating the world we know today. They used their own experiences to educate themselves to make sure they never made the same mistake twice and also to ensure that WE wouldn’t. And that is indeed why education is a lifestyle. Education is simply the way of life, helping us to develop from the day we were born. All the experiences we gain every day by facing new adventures are assurances that we are going to do better in life.

With the advancement of Science and Technology, we all have access to educational platforms on a global level. While this has immensely helped many individuals to educate themselves, we should also remember that everything comes at a cost. So even though this has enabled many educational opportunities, it is not for everyone because it has the ability of emptying wallets. As an O/L student who is trying her best to keep up with both theoretical and practical studies, I should say that our syllabus mainly focuses only on theoretical parts which puts anyone with a good memory (those who love by heartening) at the front of the race called “exams”.  We study such a big syllabus that we rarely find time to look beyond textbooks to gather new knowledge relevant to our subjects, by exploring the environment around us which then results in children who lack practical sense when it comes to daily activities, affecting their survival skills in the human society.

I’m confident that this was never the intention of C.W.W. Kannangara, also known as “The father of free education” in Sri Lanka. He took the initiative to make sure that the economic state of a child WOULD NOT affect his or her access to education. This was a giant leap taken by a human, for the benefit of humans. This opened many doors for children living in rural areas, to educate themselves to their desire, as education was made free of charge, from child development programs until university education. However, in today’s society, what seems like free education from afar is a ravenous monster feeding off of money of the oppressed.

As educational expenses reach the sky’s limit, children who don’t face a huge economic crisis, are also faced with some difficulties, making education an unreachable door knob to the unprivileged children, living in rural areas. This drastic change in access to education took place because of governmental authorities that do not pay enough attention to education which is simply, the future. And from that fact alone we can understand the narrow minds of those in power today. As daily expenses keep increasing due to the inflectional situation of the country, it seems to show NO MERCY to education as well. Some educational institutions take advantage of the helpless state of parents who work hard, day and night to fill the stomachs of their little ones.

Tuition classes which are advertised as institutions that provide education besides schools are becoming a trend among children. This so-called “extra education” is provided by teachers who teach at schools, mainly because their monthly income isn’t enough to pay their bills. Sometimes it’s with the true intention of sharing their knowledge with children to build a generation that knows what they’re doing. Teaching is a profession that goes unnoticed by many despite the great service they do for the country. Once in a while, people who seem to destroy the reputation of this Godly service of educating youngsters appear, which drags the quality and the intention of this service of providing extra education to children, to the lowest grounds receiving backlash and hate which is not just thrown to them but also towards teachers who are just trying to do their best for the country. These extra classes or tuition come in handy for those who are engaged in a lot of extracurricular activities because they are bound to miss a lot of classes in school due to being occupied in so-called activities. But today, it has become a trend among children to attend tuition classes while the matter remains unknown.  Either the education they receive from the school isn’t enough or there aren’t any qualified teachers to teach or it is because of the cluelessness of parents. Most students attend tuition classes for anything but scholarly purposes. The best remedy for this is enlightening parents on what to do and what not to do when it comes to children’s education. Parents should pay enough attention to the needs of their children to understand if they need it or if they are acting to do so to get their intentions that are not so good, fulfilled. In my opinion, tuition classes are unnecessary, if schools provide proper education to children. This is the last discussion I bring through this writing.

Pedagogy, as explained earlier is a Divine service if done the right way. But in today’s society, the accuracy of this statement is highly questionable. We see teachers who hold extra classes for children, who are already learning from them in school. Now the basic intention of tuition classes doesn’t seem to apply in a situation like this. So, what we can understand from a this situation is, that if the teacher had done his or her job properly at school, it is completely unnecessary to hold private classes meaning that the teacher sees this as a possibility to make money out of. wrong on so many levels because teachers aren’t allowed to hold private classes for the children they teach in school. And if a parent had chosen to not send the child to the particular class, the child would be treated differently by the teacher because the syllabus might have already been covered in the class. So, this puts the children who wish to not attend the classes behind everyone else which affects the child’s mental health when he or she associates with classmates. To contain this from transpiring, many parents make sure to send their kids to the class despite all the troubles they may be facing. How on earth is this free education? What would happen to children who don’t have a strong economic situation in their families? they would get bullied in school and would soon feel unmotivated to even go to school anymore. No child should be put in this situation and just because they are unable to afford extra classes doesn’t mean it’s the parents’ fault as well. Education is a basic human right, and everybody has the right to educate themselves, in this case, free from all charges since this is a country that has an ongoing free education system.

The pressure the current syllabus puts on children is overwhelming. As a student who is learning this syllabus, I would appreciate it if educational authorities took action to include more practical lessons so that our learning experience could be fun without being impractical or hard. A system where we get to do research and presentations to teach ourselves doesn’t just benefit us but also takes the burden off of our parents’ shoulders of always having to worry about bearing educational expenses or tuition fees. Education is a lifestyle and therefore cannot be limited to the pages of a book. It lies in everything we do in our day-to-day lives. It should also not be treated as a business because you are dealing with innocent children’s lives and their future is on the line. The people who have made education into a business making millions out of the hard-earned money of parents, by brainwashing them into thinking that there is no other way of learning, is truly shameful. They should know that what goes around, comes around.  Education is indeed the most important thing of all as it determines the future of a country.

As stated by Nelson Mandela, “Education is the most powerful weapon, which you can use to change the world”

*About the author: S. Athauda is a song-writer, who is a student of grade 10. She will be sitting for O/L in 2025.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 1
    4

    In the beginning of human civilisation , it was believed or blindly believed
    that Religion was a way of life . Is it still the case today ? I will make it as
    short as possible . It is a business today . My challenge to prove it , do it
    without Money involvement , I men not small amounts , huge amounts are
    being pumped out to Run Religions Everywhere . It is the same with the
    education and anybody who tries to paint it with a different brush , seems to
    have lost touch with ground reality . Everything has evolved into unimaginable
    levels and Education does not stand Holy there . A surrogate Mother is a woman
    who carries a baby in her womb for Money from someone who can not have a
    child through his wife and remember , With The Consent of His Wife . And
    equally you can buy sperm for your wife if you do not produce healthy one .
    In life , people are today able to buy many things they do not get free or they do not
    want free . And the most important thing in my view about the education in our
    country is , Free education does not prepare students for Modern Living with New
    Skills .. I was in close contact with some A level passed and degree holding younger
    generation and found that their mother tongue skills were in a bad state . They
    do not manage to talk efficiently and thoughtfully . This is the situation we are in .

    • 4
      1

      “In the beginning of human civilisation , it was believed or blindly believed
      that Religion was a way of life “
      Was it?
      There is no set model of religion anywhere. Several religions emerged from community rituals. Some out of social customs. Practice led to theory rather than theory leading to religious practice.
      There is organized religion which is tied up with money and power.
      There is also community based religion without a religious hierarchy.
      *
      Frankly I find it hard to figure out what you are driving at.

      • 0
        0

        ” Was it ? ” Yes , it was and still is . Education is Business and that is
        what I meant . Money is at the heart of everything and everybody is
        running after .

      • 1
        0

        SJ
        Right on point 👍🙏

    • 1
      0

      “… religion was a way of life…” I think all of us are aware of the fact that in early human civilization, people were worshipping rocks, animals, trees, sun, moon and many natural treasures… It might have been that way because, they were able to fulfill their daily needs thanks to Mother nature. But what happened after this ? People started doing “bili puja” and different kinds of these offerings, which resulted in many being killed. They thought that by offering the life of someone, they could be able to balance the lifestyle. “Nature gives and we offer a soul in return” isn’t that impractical ? Just because it is what was being done, doesn’t mean it is what should be done. That is why we no longer do that. But why ? Because we are EDUCATED. As the humans evolved we omitted the so called rituals that were harmful to our own kind. In order to survive in life, we should base our action, tallying with nature. So how did we understand this ? We learnt many things along the way. We learnt of experiences. We became critical. And that is why you and me are here, giving our thoughts on this article. But still, today, some people still carry out those rituals that i mentioned earlier and if we look close into their lives they are people who are remote from developed places and people.

  • 18
    10

    Very good article about the situation!

    Best things to be done:

    1. Ban all tuition classes.
    _
    2. Parent with school-going children to pay a flat percentage school tax according to income (except for ones below the poverty line…they will be subsidized). School tax will be so much cheaper than tuition classes.

    3. Increase teacher’s salaries with this school tax. Ensure that teachers teach according to the curriculum, and ensure they use notes and text-books they previously used for the tuition-classes, and deleberately kept away from the classroom .

    • 16
      17

      Ramona,
      Very good suggestions. But it won’t happen. Even the NPP’s economics expert has a tuition class.

      • 17
        10

        Oc,

        Has to stop whatever the government is, for the sake of the future of Lankan children and society.

        Ban intra and inter-school teacher-led tuition businesses.
        Teachers should not be able to teach the same students who are in their classrooms, in their school, or any other school. Homework help can be supervised by parent corporatives, high-school and university students, and educational aides. They can utilize notes and textbooks provided by the school via the school-tax money. Private places that want to run educational services have to purchase their own copyrighted notes, textbooks and equipment.

      • 5
        17

        Tuition Classes are the Living source of the so-called, non-elitist Proletariat Sri Lankans who are being nurtured for SL’s Salvation!!!?? Also includes, famous Leftists of Yore, to continue to sustain their lifestyle!!!???
        Viable alternative solutions to compensate the Government Teacher professional anomalies!?

        • 14
          4

          Mahila,

          Maybe, but that’s because teachers are starving and have no other recourse.
          But once the school-tax is brought in and the oligarch and elite parents pay their share of the flat-rate school taxes, country can move forwards with its educational reforms. (Private school goers to pay the same flat tax ).

    • 7
      1

      Hello Ramona,
      I have seen some of the English Text Books used in the Schools. Thy need to be brought into the 20th Century in many cases let alone the 21st. The use of Victorian English should only be seen in Charles Dicken’s Classic Books, not in English Grammar or Reading Books. Even the more up to date material uses English of a bygone era.
      I know this will be controversial, but you need to drastically reduce (if not get rid of completely) time allocated to Religious Education/Instruction.
      The whole Curriculum needs to be the Subject of an Intensive Governmental Review with the help of Educational Specialists from Europe, North America or any Country that can provide Guidance and Support to enable change to take place.
      Education and Health should be paid out of General Taxation and the Government should embark on a Programme of making sure that all Schools provide Professional Teaching of a high standard that would reduce the necessity for Tuition Classes.
      Teachers should also be a part of a Professional Development Programme such as the UK example https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/teachers-professional-development-in-schools/independent-review-of-teachers-professional-development-in-schools-phase-1-findings
      Best regards

      • 19
        6

        LankaScot,

        If Victorian and early 20th century British literature is all they have for literature, it is an excellent and cost-effective thing. Our Lankans do have a careful old-fashioned lyrical expression when speaking. Part of the charm (yeah some still sound exactly like the grandparents). Country mustn’t waste money in trying to make Lankans sound “modern”. Now Ranil will take his chance to spend the money of the hardworking-suffering-Lankan-Masses on your educational suggestions and stall the elections!

        • 14
          8

          LS,

          What they need is updated geography, history, math, and science texts. It will cost money. Online texts are also expensive, unless given as a donation……in that case it will be a bit outdated and not interconnected. But school- taxes should take care of it. I mean, if parents can pay so much money on tuition classes, they can easily pay a reduced amount on school taxes (trouble is, there’s too much individualistic and discriminatory mindsets amongst our people, from caste to class, but a government school-tax mandate should put an end to it and work wonders).

          • 16
            7

            And LankaScot, religious Education/Instruction is an imperative. They have advanced literature and social and psychological concepts that enhance the social being, minus the need for mind-altering medication that is doled out in the secular West. Buddhism/Hindu classes for the masses does give a feeling of normalcy for the unique Lankan genetic make-up. Other religions too boost up the moral and spirit. Glad Motherland attends to this and keeps the country together in the midst of poverty and misery.

            • 6
              17

              Ramona,
              “What they need is updated geography, history, math, and science texts.”
              Yes, but while one teacher tells them about aerodynamics, the other one tells them that the Buddha and Ravana had flying machines. Or yet another insists that pork is a deadly poison. How can students make up their minds what is true when they are force-fed religion and science at the same time?

              • 12
                4

                Oc…..those are just the mythological sections. Rest is very profound.

                • 6
                  17

                  Ramona,
                  But the monks take these mythological tales very seriously. Is there any monk who will deny that the Buddha visited Sri Lanka?

                  • 12
                    5

                    Oc…..government edict and all will change. Sinhalese need to evolve to the time before the Tamil Hindu Kings and Angarika Darmapala.

                  • 1
                    17

                    Let me join in, out of sheer boredom.
                    old codger,
                    During the time of Sir John Kotelawala the monks were put in their proper place. Political exigency cum expediency altered the dynamics.
                    Who would be bold enough to restore the equilibrium.

                    • 6
                      17

                      Nathan,
                      You mustn’t forget that Sir JK wasn’t a Buddhist. He wasn’t profound at all.😁
                      That’s why we must have diversity in leadership.
                      Even educated Buddhists won’t challenge the clergy.

            • 5
              0

              Hello Ramona,
              Please show me examples of the “advanced literature”.
              The Mahavamsa, Culavamsa, Mahābhārata, Bhagavad Gita and Ramayana are all excellent historical/mythical examples of the role that Religion plays in fomenting violence in its name.
              “Glad Motherland attends to this and keeps the country together in the midst of poverty and misery” – I am sure that Galagoda Aththe Gnanasara Thera will do his bit to contribute to the ” social and psychological concepts that enhance the social being”.
              Best regards

              • 14
                6

                I’ve been to Buddhist temples. They don’t teach the Mahavamsa and Chulavsmsa. All the Pali chantings, prayers, philosophical and psychological concepts, and being reborn after you die are profound! The literature in Pali, its Sinhala translation, and Sinhala itself, are works of literary art. Of course some places also teach these books, but it is just historical mythology like the creation of the world 6,000 years ago, and Jonah swallowed by a whale.

                • 7
                  17

                  Ramona,
                  “All the Pali chantings, prayers, philosophical and psychological concepts, and being reborn after you die are profound! “
                  Can you explain why you yourself were not welcomed in a US temple when you went there, because of your name? You mentioned it yourself.

                  • 12
                    5

                    Oc…..did i mention anything?……, Ah….maybe once, sometime long ago I mentioned it, but not because of my married name. Anyway, it was mistaken notion on my part (after reading comments in CT….you get false ideas when reading misinformation ). Lots of Fernandos, Buddhist and otherwise, attend the temples. But once in a rare moon, a person thinks I am Kandyan and starts beating me around….reverse “castism.” All was explained eventually.

                    • 7
                      17

                      Ramona,
                      So, you do accept that there is casteism among Sri Lankan Buddhist clergy?
                      Not so profound…

                    • 12
                      5

                      Oc……clergy? No, once in a blue moon Lankan adherent.

                • 5
                  0

                  Hello Ramona,
                  “All the Pali chantings, prayers, philosophical and psychological concepts, and being reborn after you die are profound!”
                  No, not profound, just plain wrong. Show me a shred of objective evidence.
                  Best regards

                  • 14
                    5

                    LankaScot…..

                    Heaven and Hell don’t have objective evidence either. But I have objective proof: Country becomes secular, and use of psychiatric drugs go up. In this vast universe, beings need that abstraction.
                    Even the atom is nothing but abstractness.

                    • 12
                      5

                      True a small percentage go madder with religion. But without it, a far larger number will be totally mad.

                    • 5
                      0

                      Hello Ramona,
                      A Durian fruit is made of atoms. Try standing under a tree and see if the abstraction (Durian) falling on your head does you any harm.
                      Just about every Country in Europe (around 33) are officially Secular. Are they all Basket Cases on Psychiatric Drugs?
                      The USA was formed as probably the First Secular State, and remains so despite the amount of Religious Right Wingers that want to put God on the Throne.
                      Best regards

                    • 16
                      4

                      LankaScot

                      Who cares about the Durian. It doesn’t have a brain. Physical realm is only a minute part of the enormity of the Quantum realm. Sentient beings have a soul, or have continuation of Samsara.

                      Only reason USA is secular is because of the many different religions in the country – only way for them to keep peace in the midst of how they handle Middle Eastern places. Europe follows suit to keep up with the US monetary status, and they also know what they did with their religion. Anyway, they incorporated the peaceful parts of the religious concepts into their culture. Sri Lanka did far better with Buddhism of course, except for the parts that Olcott and Angarika Darmapala brought about.

                    • 14
                      4

                      And LankaScot, if that durian kills you, you will probably go to heaven. If it doesn’t kill you, you will go into your own unique abstraction. Religion prepares you for the vastness of all kinds of abstractness.

                    • 4
                      0

                      Hello Ramona,
                      Where is your Evidence? Any Videos, Telescopic Images or Photographs welcomed.
                      Best regards

                    • 9
                      4

                      LankaScot

                      Consider the atom. Show me a pic. of the psyche.

                    • 4
                      0

                      Hello Ramona,
                      A picture of Atoms – still an abstraction? https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/see-the-highest-resolution-atomic-image-ever-captured/
                      Best regards

                    • 8
                      3

                      That’s a picture of stacks of atoms, LankaScot, with 99.9999999999996% empty space lighted up.

    • 5
      0

      This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy. The key to maintaining the website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

      For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

  • 8
    0

    Hello Samadhi Athauda,
    This is an excellent Article and your command of English Grammar and Vocabulary should put many Contributors in CT to shame.
    I was educated in the 1950s and 60s in the Scottish Primary and Secondary (now called Academies) Schools. Even back then our Teachers expressed the same views as yourself – “Education is a lifestyle and therefore cannot be limited to the pages of a book”. They encouraged us to see Education as not just a method to pass exams, but also to enrich our outlooks and experiences. Many of our Teachers engaged in extra-curricular activities (unpaid) that were both fun and Educational. We went to School Camps (in the countryside) in Tents, Canoeing, Orienteering, Sports of all kinds, Swimming every week, Visits to Theatres, Orchestras and many other activities.
    In the Academies we were encouraged to ask questions and even back then “rote learning” was discouraged. We read a wide range of books, Classics and Modern. We read Tolkien, Shakespeare and much more. I read The Hobbit at 8 years old and Lord of the Rings at 14. We were also expected to be critical of the books that we read.
    Keep writing Articles.
    Best regards

    • 8
      6

      I see that Dammika Paniya has kicked into action. 😉 So you work for meat eh? I guess welding is the most conducive activity at your age and one has to somehow survive.

    • 6
      0

      This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy. The key to maintaining the website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

      For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

    • 1
      17

      Hello LankaScot
      deepest lengths??

      • 0
        0

        Hello Nathan,
        And “Highest breadths” to you too😎.
        Best regards

    • 0
      19

      LankaScot,
      The child may not necessarily know that Education is just a formal way of Learning, and hence, is just one way of learning.
      A learned person is an educated person; However, the reverse may not hold.
      I stand to be corrected.
      .
      There is Learning by accident. Some of the best knowledge is acquired accidentally.

      • 3
        0

        Hello Nathen,
        Yes I agree, however standing under a Durian Tree is not the best way to gain that type of accidental knowledge. For this type of knowledge listen to your parents/elders etc.
        Best regards

    • 5
      0

      This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy. The key to maintaining the website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

      For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

  • 7
    0

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy. The key to maintaining the website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

    For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

    • 7
      0

      This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy. The key to maintaining the website as an inviting space is to focus on intelligent discussion of topics.

      For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

    • 11
      18

      What’s your grouse, Ruchi baba?

      • 7
        0

        Hello OC,
        He’s stuck for words😉.
        On a different subject, when I was in the Gulf I saw a film called “Countdown to Looking Glass” about the start of a Nuclear War around the Straits of Hormuz. The Americans have Aircraft Carriers in exactly the same position now. Scary or what?
        Best regards

        • 6
          18

          LS,
          I’m collecting firewood and planting manioc, just in case.

        • 8
          6

          Mr. Scott,
          .
          “He’s stuck for words😉.”.
          .
          No more derogatory terms left in his vocabulary.
          .
          No doubt his is pathological, almost everyone is clear today.
          .
          Look how he comments on the leaders of the country.
          .
          He hates everyone 😔, his only friends are ChatGPT God Lester and SM. SM is somehow silent on R today.?????
          .

      • 8
        0

        OC
        Finally our CT moderators have woken up and are giving Ruchira the treatment he deserves.
        Thank You CT 😊😊😊

        • 8
          19

          HT,
          Amen! I hope they keep it up.

  • 17
    7

    Hello Samadhi Athauda,

    You are correct that education is a life-long process and books should not be the only source of knowledge. However, do not discount the importance of books. Textbooks are often written by experts with many decades in their field of expertise. Going through the book may seem tedious. But this is still the best method for learning, at least at the elementary level. Videos (social media) are nice, but many details are left out. Sorry to say, you cannot learn Java in 6 hours or Python in 9 hours. The same is true for maths. The theory is rather deep. My recommendation – read the book first, then watch the video for max benefit. These days you have another tool called “AI.” Once you have a foundation, you can test new ideas against the AI.
    Regarding tuition, it is actually beneficial. The best universities (Oxford & Cambridge) require their students to attend tutoring sessions. Tuition is only beneficial if you have prepared ahead of time. The tutor is not a mind reader. Be ready with your questions.

    • 18
      7

      One other thing about learning. You will only learn if you are challenged. Try to expand your foundation. Public schools do not do this because the teachers themselves have limited knowledge. You cannot teach someone something you don’t know. This goes back to the original point. Textbooks can assist with self-learning. The smartest minds in the world are very good at self-learning.

      • 10
        2

        Hello Lester,
        One of the first lessons I learned at the age of 4, was not to belittle your teacher’s knowledge. My cousin Carol was a couple of years older than me. We were looking out of a Window and we spotted some Forky-tails on the Window sill. I asked her what they were and she told me they were Insects called Earwigs. I asked if they were like flies and she said, yes they have six legs and wings. I replied that they didn’t have wings, so she fetched a hammer and tapped one on the back. And lo and behold the shell cases now opened and revealed their wings. Please don’t disparage Teachers, they all have something to teach us.
        If you don’t understand a Text Book you cannot ask it a question. They are limited in how much information they can include. A good Teacher will listen to your problem and work out the best way(s) to answer. They may even ask one of the other students to answer, just to start a discussion of the problem that may reveal some of the misunderstandings that other students may also have.
        Best regards

        • 16
          5

          Scot,

          Education is a business. Look at the school fees for an institution like Harrow or Eton. One of my acquaintances went to a school called “Dulwich” (the same as Nigel Farage). He was never interested in education (would rather play cricket, which he excelled at), but the father insisted. The wealthy begin their social journey early on. I reckon it’s similar to grooming a horse for the big race.
          “If you don’t understand a Text Book you cannot ask it a question. “
          You have to choose a textbook that matches your level.
          “A good Teacher will listen to your problem and work out the best way(s) to answer.”
          Here is the way to look at it: a physics teacher at a public grammar school understands only Newtonian mechanics. The physics professor at the university understands quantum mechanics and maybe beyond that, e.g. String Theory. The uni chap understands the limitations of Newtonian mechanics far better than his grammar school counterpart. He can give more insightful examples and challenge the student without any difficulty. As for the private school, it can hire the PhD by offering a very high salary.

          • 7
            0

            Hello Lester,
            I was taught Quantum Mechanics, Fourier Analysis, Laplace Transforms and how to use Schrodinger’s Equation etc.
            I don’t know what a Public Grammar School is but to teach Physics in Scottish Secondary Schools you need a Degree – “To become a secondary school teacher of physics, you must have a degree (SCQF Level 9-10) in physics plus a Professional Graduate Diploma (SCQF Level 11) in Education (PGDE) OR the BSc Hons in Physics with Teaching from the University of Strathclyde OR the BSc in Physics with Education” https://www.planitplus.net/JobProfiles/View/452/121
            Best regards

            • 8
              18

              LS,
              “I don’t know what a Public Grammar School is “
              It seems that the private-school educated ChatGPT user doesn’t know either 🤣🤣🤣🤣.
              So much for his “UK-resident” claims.

              • 9
                18

                “As far as my knowledge goes, I think we can all agree that education is not merely the studying of books” says young Samadhi.
                Living proof that someone who hasn’t even passed OL can be more educated than those who claim that three wheeler drivers aren’t educated, or those that discount the opinions of people who haven’t been to university.

                • 15
                  8

                  “or those that discount the opinions of people who haven’t been to university.”

                  So you admit you haven’t been to university. Automatic low IQ. 🤣🤣🤣

                  • 5
                    11

                    “So you admit you haven’t been to university. “
                    Yes, of course. As I always say, I am a Muslim three wheeler driver with no education.
                    I respect people like Samadhi because she already knows that a degree doesn’t give you wisdom or education. It doesn’t give you the ability to be decent. It doesn’t teach you not to sneer at others because they are housemaids or janitors, or Tamil doctors, or uneducated.
                    ChatGPT doesn’t make you wise, or humane.
                    Now go and give yourself some upvotes. At least it will give you something to do with that miserable life of yours.

                  • 6
                    0

                    Hello Lester,
                    One of the cleverest Electronic Design Engineers that I worked with did not have a Degree.
                    He designed a revolutionary Gait Analysis System that integrated Pressure Mats, Video Cameras, Body Sensors and Computers in conjunction with an Orthopaedic Professor at a famous Orthopaedic Hospital. This Gait Laboratory System ORLAU was used to analyse a Patients mode of Ambulation prior to fabricating the Prosthetics/Implants and subsequent Surgery when necessary. Their Joint Paper is still online “Butler P, Engelbrecht M, Major RE, Tait JH, Stallard J. Patrick JH (1984) Physiological cost index of walking for normal children and its use as an indicator of physical handicap. Dev Med Child Neurol 26, 607-612.”

                    When I worked with him he designed State of the Art, High Speed Bit Error Rate Analysers for the Telecom Industry. Lately they produced Fibre Optic DWDM Equipment (Dense Wavelength Division Multiplexing) for High Speed Networks.
                    Is the above a sign of low IQ?
                    Best regards

                    • 6
                      11

                      LS,
                      Weren’t Bill Gates and Steve Jobs both college dropouts? They must have had pretty low IQs.
                      “Bill Gates decided to drop out to pursue his dreams of joining the software revolution! “
                      “After just one semester, Jobs dropped out of Reed College without telling his parents. Jobs later explained this was because he did not want to spend his parents’ money on an education that seemed meaningless to him.”
                      .
                      Did Lester’s parents spend their money on a meaningless “education”?
                      But would Lester exist if Gates and Jobs hadn’t dropped out?

                    • 11
                      4

                      Scot,

                      I presume he was licensed; if not, and the machine failed, the hospital would face severe penalties. Most companies will not hire you without a license for that reason alone. Obtaining a license requires some kind of certification or degree. This is what happens when you hire unqualified people: https://theworldwatch.com/videos/1609765/carnival-ride-malfunctions-in-india/. A civil engineer or architect must have degree, as is the case for engineers working on public projects, who should also be registered with the Engineering Council.
                      Regarding IQ, it is a predictor of job success: Nisbett et al. (2012) say “the measurement of intelligence—which has been done primarily by IQ tests—has utilitarian value because it is a reasonably good predictor of grades at school, performance at work, and many other aspects of success in life”
                      https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4557354/
                      From the ChatGPT:

                      Correlation with Intelligence

                      Moderate Correlation: Research shows a moderate positive correlation (typically around 0.5 to 0.7) between IQ scores and various measures of intelligence, indicating that higher IQ scores are generally associated with higher cognitive abilities

                    • 11
                      4

                      Scot,

                      *Must have a degree

                      Now that we have established IQ is not hocus-pocus, we can check whether there is a positive correlation between IQ and educational achievement. The answer again is, yes.

                      “Educational attainment has been shown to correlate positively with intelligence test scores (Deary & Johnson, 2010; Neisser et al., 1996; Strenze, 2007). The positive correlation suggests that pursuing an education may increase the individual’s intelligence.”

                      https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289619302016

                    • 4
                      11

                      “I presume he was licensed;”
                      If Lester had any say in it, we wouldn’t have electric lights, motors, or affordable cars today.
                      Henry Ford did not have a college degree
                      Alva Edison, one of the most famous and influential inventors to walk the earth, never attended high school or college.
                      Marconi was awarded the Nobel Prize for Physics (1909) for the development of wireless telegraphy;
                      There are plenty more, but first let’s hear what Lester PhD has achieved with his 300 psi degree?

                  • 2
                    0

                    L, oc
                    Stereotype tests can hardly measure intelligence.
                    The tests themselves are biased, with the choice of criteria and weightage assigned to each criterion utterly subjective.
                    Many indigenous populations outside Europe will score poorly, although their ancestors built great civilizations, but became victims of deceit and aggression.

                    • 3
                      11

                      SJ,
                      Some insist that Brahmins are the smartest.

                    • 12
                      2

                      SJ,

                      “Stereotype tests can hardly measure intelligence.”

                      Do you have a proposal for a better test? Singing and dancing? Football? Human rights?

                    • 2
                      12

                      “Stereotype tests can hardly measure intelligence.”
                      Do you have a proposal for a better test? “
                      How about the ability to detect Dutch Time Machines in Kandy?

            • 15
              9

              Scot,

              “I was taught Quantum Mechanics, Fourier Analysis, Laplace Transforms and how to use Schrodinger’s Equation etc.”

              I don’t want to give the wrong impression to the young lady. However, theoretical mathematics is rather dull and tedious for most people. Most people should learn the minimum and move on. Scientists and engineers will need more.

              “I don’t know what a Public Grammar School is”

              There are private, fee-paying grammar schools now. I know of one such school, King Edward VI School in Hampshire.

              • 5
                11

                “There are private, fee-paying grammar schools now.”
                With 300 psi toilets, I presume.

              • 5
                0

                Hello Lester,
                It is not a Grammar School. From their Website “King Edward’s is a leading independent day school in Hampshire”. It was a Grammar School in the past.
                Best regards

                • 5
                  11

                  “”UK resident” Lester doesn’t know what a Grammar School is, or a Public School.
                  So now, Lester PhD is neither Sinhalese nor Buddhist nor “UK resident “.
                  So pathetic.

                  • 4
                    9

                    This despicable man (Lester) may be roaming in Belarus.Belarus is isolated in europe.
                    I remember at that time the former head of the UN Human Rights Council visited SLANKA, MaRa, the nation’s cancer was hiding in Belarus. The Sri Lanken ariline flights were misused for his visit. People knew how Mara and his family abused flights from Sri Lanka as it was their family’s airline.

                  • 4
                    0

                    Hello OC,
                    My Colleague without the Degree, was overwhelmed by the Formality and Stress of Communal Exams.
                    I started in IT/Electronics about the same time as Bill Gates and Paul Allen. IBM wanted an Operating System (OS) for their soon to be IBM PC. Gates bought QDos ( a rip-off from Digital Research’s CPM OS) and turned it into MS-DOS. I used both CPM and MS-DOS; MS-DOS was “flaky”, CPM was stable.
                    Gary Kildall of Digital Research threatened to sue IBM, however they reached an agreement.
                    Friends of mine used to ask about me and Bill Gates starting in IT at the same time, why was I not Rich and Famous. I used to reply, jokingly, that I was honest.
                    Best regards

                    • 11
                      3

                      Scot,

                      Bill Gates is a terrible example. He went to an elite school called Harvard. The acceptance rate was 3.2% in 2022. I reckon it was something similar during his time. According to Quora, historically, the average Harvard undergraduate IQ is around 136. According to World Data, the United States has an average IQ of 97 points. If you know about the Bell Curve, then Gates falls into the category of “outlier.” You cannot assess the general population using outliers. If someone has an IQ of 136, then I agree with you that such a person can succeed without a degree. However, in STEM fields, university provides great opportunities for collaboration and research. Especially in tech, you cannot do cutting-edge research in your living room.

                    • 11
                      3

                      Scot,

                      If you are as smart as Bill Gates, then you should be able to pass a course called “Math 55.” They teach four years of maths in one year.

                      “Historical retention In 1970, Math 55 covered almost four years worth of department coursework in two semesters, and subsequently, it drew only the most diligent of undergraduates. Of the 75 students who enrolled in the 1970 offering, by course end, only 20 remained due to the advanced nature of the material and time-constraints under which students were given to work.”

                      Here you go, all the lectures and problem sets: https://people.math.harvard.edu/~elkies/M55a.02/index.html. Bill Gates took this course his first year (age 17).This is how they teach maths at elite schools (Harvard, Oxbridge, etc.)

                      Get back to us with your one year result.

                    • 2
                      11

                      Did Bill Gates’ school pay him to drop out?

                • 11
                  6

                  Scot,

                  It functions exactly as a normal grammar school would, including the entrance exam, except for fees. So in this sense, it’s a private fee-paying grammar school.

                  • 4
                    0

                    Hello Lester,
                    In reply to your Math 55 example. “A core goal of Math 55, according to Auroux, is to build a sense of community. Other schools might encourage advanced first-year students to take upper level undergraduate or even graduate classes, but Math 55 helps build a cohort of like-minded people who really like math, are good at it, and want to do a lot of it during their time at Harvard”. https://www.math.harvard.edu/demystifying-math-55/
                    That counts both you and me out, you for this “cohort of like-minded people” – there is only one Lester. I am out due to “really like math, are good at it, and want to do a lot of it “.
                    Bill Gates decided to go for Applied Maths before he dropped out of Harvard and yes he was very clever.
                    As for Licensing could you be more specific? You obviously do not understand how this Analysis Equipment was used, and apart from that I did NOT say my colleague was unqualified. Doctors need to be Licensed to practice in the NHS UK.
                    IQ tests might be used by HR (Human Resources) numpties, but most normal people ignore them completely.
                    Best regards

              • 5
                12

                “There are private, fee-paying grammar schools”
                -says Lester.
                So now, his ChatGPT has told him there are schools which pay students to attend.🤣🤣🤣🤣

  • 6
    3

    Samadhi
    Thank you for an unconventional and illuminating article on education.
    You have illustrated the difference between education and knowledge.
    In the process of getting educated, what we should be gathering is actually knowledge.
    Not just knowledge, we should be gathering knowledge with a view to achieving an aim.
    Just gathering information and keeping it in our heads does not serve anyone any good, especially in this day and age where everything thing we know is changing.
    The job of keeping records and information we gather is handled by computers. Computers go an extra mile crunching gathered human data using Ai algorithms and extracting more knowledge out of big data.
    This is like someone doing research in a certain field but to a much higher extent.
    This knowledge is used further to add to what we know and our knowledge base keeps growing. This is the nature of the world we live in.
    So you are very correct in your view when you say that conventional perception about the entire education system has to be reviewed and re-evaluated so we as humans can face the future as modern beings geared up for a very different environment than we have been used to in our near past.
    Time to get a grip and move forward.

  • 9
    15

    Training one’s mind to think …… is more important than education.

    Education is absorbing knowledge that’s already out there ……. when properly utilized, education’s important contribution has been training people to think …….. but it doesn’t always happen ……… especially in societies that have bedded-down preconceived passed-down unexamined biases/prejudices (the proper word/term eludes me here) ……..

    Education for passing exams ……. is a whole different kettle of fish ……. I studied the night before the exam, passed it (well, if I may add) …….. and forgot everything the next day ……

    I’ve been blissfully uneducated ……. ever since …….

    Education is grossly oversold …… if you ask me ……. or Donald Trump ……. or any of his supporters ……..

    • 5
      0

      Hello Nimal,
      One Professor reminded us that Critical Thinking is essential in Science and Engineering, but also very useful outside those fields. He also said that in Engineering we should think about what problem we are trying to solve.

      By the way I don’t believe you “forgot everything the next day ……”.
      Best regards

      • 11
        6

        Scot,

        In unrelated news, people in the UK are being arrested for social media posts: https://www.cambridge-news.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/northampton-woman-arrested-after-social-29690377. Have Sinhala-Buddhists gotten hold of Labour?

        • 4
          0

          Hello Lester,
          Be careful what you post, especially if you are anywhere near Peterborough. “Have Sinhala-Buddhists gotten hold of Labour?” No, the Zionists are fully in Control for now. But seriously as I said before there has always been a Racist/Fascist undercurrent that at times of crisis will appeal to a section of the population. The lie that those 3 young girls were murdered in Southport by a Muslim Immigrant was rapidly spread by the Fascist Tommy Robinson (real name Stephen Yaxley-Lennon) on Social Media. It will be very difficult to restore calm in many Cities in the UK. Tensions have been simmering for many decades.
          Best regards

          • 11
            3

            Scot,

            Fair enough, the attacker was a Christian who suffered from autism. He must have had a mental breakdown. Anyway, there is a larger problem that needs to be addressed and that is the rising Muslim demographic combined with lack of assimilation. This is setting up for a Malthusian esque grand finale. Sri Lanka has a similar problem. Gnanasara tried to highlight it but was ridiculed. And then the Easter Attacks happened. The Ranil government needs to end child marriage and encourage birth control. Unfortunately, Ranil will never exit his glass house (except for foreign jaunts with taxpayer money). He was overseas when the Easter Attacks happened, having ignored multiple warnings.

      • 3
        11

        Dear LS,
        .
        You would be interested in watching the following video with subtitles in English.

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XDvHKL34Fwk&t=1176s
        :
        This is how srilanken magistrates act in some areas.
        The senior journalist found something as to why the law and order is stuck in this country for such a long time.

    • 3
      0

      You seems to be a great fan of Pink Floyd – Another brick in the wall. Education is not just high school exams. Or about memorizing. It is a learning process a good student can enjoy as they move on with acquiring new knowledge or understandings how things happen in this universe. Cognition is not an accident, it happens with education. Have you ever heard about assignments, thesis, research etc in higher education institutes which are far away from the memorizing exam protocols? These things have added a lot to this universe, to enhance human life, to make the world a better place to live for all. Have added values to improve our health, extend our life, engaged physics and chemistry to get us things that comfort our lives, improve our finances, enhance our social life, maintain our sanity by creating new kind of music, motion pictures….the list is quite long!! They all happen under a thing called education.

      • 9
        11

        What you say has merit …….. but many of the notable achievers are dropouts ……. Education gave Einstein the start …… but few things that clicked in the process gave his mind the impetus to think …… and carry forward his thinking. It’s thinking that achieved results.

        Einstein’s achievements speak for themselves ……. no one knows or is bothered about what schools/colleges he went to. But there are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, who are defined by the universities they went to rather than their achievements. That’s why people clamour to get into top universities. …….. Where they do nothing much more than just gild mediocrity.

        • 9
          11

          Nimal,
          “But there are hundreds of thousands, if not millions, who are defined by the universities they went to rather than their achievements.”
          You nailed it.

        • 2
          0

          Yes, it is so true that vital aspects of education are being exploited or abused by vast segments in any society. More prominent is the institutional elitism proliferated by so called Ivy leagues, elite private schools or such other ‘high ranking’ universities which are part of this gambit. And I do not have any dispute with your statement that college dropouts can become successful in their life. True, there are many other pathways for anyone to learn things, gather knowledge or even test such knowledge, deviating from the formal pedagogical methods of classroom or examination based systems. Education is not a one-size-fits-all journey and different paths can lead to success for different people.
          On one hand, it highlights the importance of innovation, creativity, and the pursuit of one’s passions, which can lead to success even without a traditional college degree. The key is to find what works best for each individual. Ironically, so many elite colleges such as Harvard invite such personalities to be special guest speakers or lecturers in their institutions once they prove to be successful in their own pathways and become famous. By doing so, I often wonder what message they give to their own students!

          • 12
            5

            Jit,

            A college dropout from Harvard (Bill Gates) is very different than someone who never goes to university. Most people will never gain admission to such a school, to begin with. In the case of Jobs, he simply met the right people at the right time. Example: Wozniak, who designed the Apple I & Apple II ( “Between Woz and Jobs, Woz was the innovator, the inventor. Steve Jobs was the marketing person.” — Apple employee #12 Daniel Kottke). Jobs was obviously not stupid; the man had very good business sense. He saw opportunities that no one else saw and took full advantage.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.