By Vishwamithra –
“So long as the human spirit thrives on this planet, music in some living form will accompany and sustain it and give it expressive meaning.” ~ Aaron Copland
Today the country resembles a vast moving carpet of water. Cyclone Ditwah was a tropical cyclone that formed in the Bay of Bengal and brought heavy rains and strong winds to Sri Lanka and southern India, particularly Tamil Nadu. It’s ferocious and destructive powers consumed Sri Lanka, almost every district, as never before. From Dondra Point to Point Pedro, the destruction it caused was unprecedented; its beginning could be forecast, yet there was no forewarning. Maybe at a very cursory level the people may have exchanged elementary information amongst themselves about the cyclone and its potential, but in a very scientific sense, no information was disseminated by the government machinery as to the precautions one should take, what shelters are available at what point or what village and at what temple or school or community center, etc.
In the total absence of such treasured and valuable information, when the mighty waters crash on your threshold, what can one do, other than collect whatever nearby, gather the family and run? But the question remains whether they had any time left, even to run. The official numbers released by the Disaster Management officials are close to five hundred (500) presumed to be dead and many hundreds still missing, categorized under ‘uncounted’. The very images seen on television have elicited many a teardrop; but those who were so resilient to survive and extend a helping hand to his or her neighbor were many and a heartwarming communication to all of us indeed.
Human spirit has survived thousands years and its unceasing cascade through millions of men, women and children would continue to course through their veins and bring forth the very essence of the human family and its invulnerable existence through untimely crashes and devastation. They can be bent but never broken. Men and women were clad in whatever they were wearing at the time of the unkind waters making an unwelcome visit to their dwellings; and making their belongings disappear in seconds was another sad episode of the drama that was being played in front of Smartphone cameras; the social media transmitted these pictures depicting courage on the one side and despondence on the other; portraying the validity of both survival and death of their own brothers and sisters to the millions of Facebook, Instagram, Ticktock and Whatsapp recipients is no waste of time and energy; the moving drama of human tragedy played its most vital role on the vanishing banks of the mighty Mahaweli, Kalu, Kelani, Walawe and all other major and minor gangas (rivers) in Sri Lanka.
Waters that fed the earth and nurtured that soil with richness without any prejudice and discrimination as to who and which colored-Lankan that shaped and cultivated the land, were in a ferocious mood and its course was not controlled or governed in terms of any preselected fashion or configuration. The contours were not crafted by irrigation engineering specialists. Water finds its own level, as the cliche goes. Those who never suspected that their fate was foretold by their beloved fortune-tellers years earlier had to disown their own superstitious ways of living and their unsubtle ways of religious beliefs.
None of the politicos were adversely affected. None of the Colombo-dwelling millionaires and billionaires had to suffer the obscenities of having to abandon their household belongings and run away in search of higher plains. The most vulnerable segments of society, the poorest of the poor and the middleclass have come together to form a platoon of those who had to remake their lives altogether in the most tragic and unfortunate circumstances.
A young couple, husband clad in a sarong and holding its bottom up and the wife in her homegrown jacket and skirt was carrying a basin on their shoulders. Their profiles were a picture of desolate audacity; a Picasso-painted masterpiece exhibiting what devotion to parental duty and stoicism beyond measure is; carrying in the basin was their only baby-child, secured and held high above the gushing waters, this couple displayed to the onlookers what ‘grace under pressure’ is. So was the most heart-wrenching scene of a small herd of elephants, raising their trunks ever so proudly, attempting to keep abreast of the flow with the angry and all consuming waters of the floods.
The ‘spirit of man’ never diminishes in the face of calamity, whether man-made or natural. A solitary man having climbed to the top of a coconut tree, waiting for more than six hours to be rescued by an Air force helicopter, more than seventy neighbors surviving on top of a roof until they were spotted and extricated by our law enforcement men, a poignant episode of men, women and children in the savagely violent waters that were once their roadways and green land, could be viewed on every television screen; their forceful lingering and undefeated posture were a marvelous preface to the next chapter that is waiting to be written by our historians in time yet to dawn.
Now the waters are receding; its potential reascendance will be unwelcome and its possibility is sparse. It’s time to rebuild and recapture the same dedication and boldness shown during the testing and trying times to the present and near future. Resilience is a sublime human quality that has never abandoned man since the beginning of times. Never failing to answer the call, man, on the beaten track of civilization and with each uncounted millions and billions of small steps, has arrived at the modern station of astonishing and glorious inventions such the Smartphone and Artificial Intelligence.
The courageous drama of man would not allow him to rest and be apathetic; it would not let him wonder in a barren land of hopelessness and despair; he shall pick up each and every piece that has fallen while he was being smashed by the extravagant yet ugly visits of natural disasters. He needs help; the government’s pledges, whatever they are, must be followed to the end, until the last penny is settled as they promised.
The burden on President AKD and his men is enormous; they too cannot be resting and meandering along inhospitable paths of delusion and political hallucinations. What is confronting them is not a mere economic bankruptcy; it is not within the boundaries of human endurance. What awaits them has gone beyond bankruptcies and ordinary suffering of man. Uplifting of a nation from the dredges of deep catastrophe and awakening it to a fresh tapestry of vistas and possibilities is well within the reach of man and that maxim has been proven beyond all shades of doubt by Japan and her people after the Second World War. Destroyed by an experiment advanced and propounded by Albert Einstein about two decades prior to its successful fruition, the world entered the dreaded ‘Nuclear Era’. Today Japan stands tall with other nations in the world as a smart and resilient member of the human family.
If Japan could do it, so can Sri Lanka. But she needs help, not only from her own men and women, but more from her international partners. Aid would begin to pour in. And unlike the notorious ‘Helping Hambantota’ project that made the Rajapaksas rich and the countrymen poor, helping Lanka should be a genuine and sincere commitment to the next step she could take towards normalcy. Let the ‘Real Sri Lankan’ come out now. Not the profit-thirsty, shortsighted and dishonest and corrupt one. But the real one whose ideals are more mingled with the sublime teachings of Siddhartha Gautama the Buddha.
While attending to the urgent and immediate needs of the South, equal or even more focused attention needs to be paid to the Northern and Eastern Tamils and Muslims. The hill-country Tamil population must have been devastated beyond help. No citizen must be ignored nor spared. Disbursement of relief funds, temporary assistance to schoolchildren, timely repairs to the broken culverts and disturbed field channels on the paddy fields, speedy repairs to submerged industry workshops are all but a very few of the thousands of tasks ahead for the country, its leaders and her population.
It’s time the real Sri Lankan came out!
*The writer can be reached at vishwamithra1984@gmail.com
nimal fernando / December 5, 2025
Talk about a space cadet ………. what’s wrong with Ranil? ………. Does he still think he is important? …… https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN_lN5EZh9U :))))))))))
–
No wonder he was never voted president! ……. There are more rational thinkers in SL than I thought!!
–
Native, guess you’re not a rational thinker, eh?
–
Do you find this sublime …….. in ye ir-rational thinker mind?
/
whywhy / December 5, 2025
Does he still think he is importnt ?
About a couple of years back , a Srilankn woman of 60 trying to
cross boeders just to get into Israel , fell dead on her way . There
are men and women in our country at their 70s , still thinking
they can start a new life . They don’t even understand it’s all over
now . Why ? Because it is not taught to them that there is n end
and our journey is on that direction . Poor greedy creatures !
/
SJ / December 6, 2025
Is it greed for one to want a better life?
/
whywhy / December 8, 2025
Wanting a better life is not greed but wanting it en route to
where life nearing its dead end is not only greed , supreme
selfish too. In UK , you are not welcome at job centres if you
are 60 and a woman and for men it is 67 . End of Job hunt .
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
WW and other rational and intelligent thinkers,
The truth is that hatred has clouded the sky above Sri Lanka, not only the unusual weather variations. Badmouthing forces provide content in support of the survival politics of liars and L-board performers. Wait and see how far AKD leadership will take it….. I’ve been pessimistic from their creation… aiyooooooooooooooo.
whatever is said and done against senior and former leaders is completely improper. Their tenures may have resulted in some major failures (JRJ, CBK, Rajapakshe, Ranil, etc.), but they have some expertise on which L-board performers should and may depend. This is typical in both North American and European democracies. Pompousness will not help us go forward. AKD has no idea who he should contact in a disaster case. Gotabaya is claimed to have handled the “COVID crisis” admirably, while Sirisena is said to have gained valuable expertise over the course of five decades. I believe AKD and Dr. HA should come down and do what they must, including listening to prior presidents.
/
whywhy / December 8, 2025
L M ,
End of NPP term will put Ranil over 80 , UNP is still not
ready with a new leader . By then , AKD will again be the
only leader with experience . There is a possibility , Namal
and Sajith will fight each other that will land AKD back in
his seat if EP is still functioning . As things stand today .
/
leelagemalli / December 8, 2025
Hello, WW.
Did you know this? We are currently on a forum where the majority of people delight in upvoting their “own comments”: ours do not appear to matter. If the AKD-led weather department had done its job correctly, a few hundred people may have been saved.
–
Please view the video below.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ji-aZ6V9Jgo
/
whywhy / December 8, 2025
L M ,
The point why I am writing here is to do some contribution
from my knowledge and experience to those who have a
thurst for it . I do not write here to stand out of the rest . I am
not used to it . Other contributors , some of them encourage us
while some others can not digest us . We can not write to
please every Tom , Dick and Harry can we ? And , upvotes or
down won’t decide how we feel about what we write here .
About the delay in reaching out with help and advice , yes we
hear complaints , again , are we still not talking about the
Easter bombings that could have been prevented ? We do have
this culture of rushing to point our fingers at others while we
all are behaving the same way on all situations . Is there any
possibility we can learn to change ? If the answer is a big NO
then that is the end .
/
Native Vedda / December 6, 2025
nimal fernando
–
Welcome back.
Here is a clip in which the Singapore prime minister Lawrence Wong describes the present global situation.
https://www.tiktok.com/@financialtimes/video/7564331298072874262?_r=1&_t=ZN-91yYhqwTWJ5
–
Well how many Americans do grasp his analysis and warning?
Have you recently read any warning from Sri Lankan Pundits?
I love to here from Haraka Council on foreign and domestic policies.
–
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXTmbNnXxs4
–
By the way have you noticed Hindian armed forces are airlifting Bailey Bridges, planning to connect roads
https://www.facebook.com/reel/1873027006908387
Why is the Sangha in silent mode?
They are supposed to warn the government, explain and make serious noises about Hindian expansion, reject their bridge building adventure, …..
–
Why don’t these people think?
Hindians can arrive in canoes if they want to, or swim, …. in their aircraft carriers, submarines by their C130 or Ilyushin Il-76 and Antonov An-72, … (I am just dropping name)
–
I haven’t heard anything from Moda Dayan.
/
nimal fernando / December 7, 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VXTmbNnXxs4
–
Native,
–
That’s a good clip. I’ve come across it but never watched until you put it up.
–
There are more things going behind the scenes that the ordinary man is not aware of.
–
Trump removed most of the tariffs on food imports ……. prices were getting very high when the Americans were actually paying the tariffs. Couldn’t someone have thought of it before imposing the tariffs? …….. If one thought only Lankans were stupid!
–
The point missed by most …….. 99.8% of Americans have contributed zilch for America’s “greatness” but are ever eager to take credit and wallow in pride for it. …….. If they were born somewhere else ……. wouldn’t have been able to punch themselves out of a wet paper bag.
–
I tell ya …… humans are a strange lot.
/
old codger / December 7, 2025
Native,
Bailey bridges? Now we have to be very careful. They might slip in a bridge across the Palk Srait on the sly. What if they want the tooth relic back?
/
Native Vedda / December 7, 2025
old codger
–
Lets take the relic, we have our Sanghas.
–
I am worried about the bridge building exercise/genericity of Hindians however I am confident Champa,Ramona, Lester,Udhaya, Svendra, Wimal, Weerasekera, Channa, Dhinesh …. and Shenali Waduge are keeping an eye on the Hindian Engineers.
–
As far as the relief work is concerned it is an eyewash. As you they must be hiding arms munition, howitzers, SAM 7s, Bramos, Agni .., ….Arjun MKI, HAL Tejas, ….. Varunastra, Brahmastra, Mace (Gada), Bow and Arrow, … at every nook and corner.
–
Now there must be millions of boat people fro South India. Svendras island somewhere in the North West may come handy.
/
nimal fernando / December 6, 2025
Even though I once was a supporter …….. I truly believe Ranil is the greatest catastrophe to befall the nation. More catastrophic and destructive than the tsunami, cyclone, bankruptcy, pandemic, Easter bombings, Rajapakses, …….. . With any other electable leader in the UNP the SLFP-side of politics wouldn’t have been in power continuously from 1994. More importantly, the Rajapakses wouldn’t have been entrenched for so long. Power would’ve alternated between the UNP and SLFP like before Ranil’s leadership of the UNP. 30 years one party/side in power without a viable/electable challenge entrenches endemic corruption and limitless abuse of power.
–
Lanka is a strange place where unnatural things happen more than the usual statistical average ……… one side of politics gets castrated and neutered for 30 years. …………. A president and a bunch of pols emerge and run the country without much perks and personal benefits for themselves: a former violent lawless bunch of youth reform themselves and run the country to the letter and spirit of the law without any abuse of power.
–
What’s real is what’s happening on the ground ……. not hallucinations in a detractor/s mind/s.
–
I too have hallucinations …… in a hazy distant memory I believe ……. I bedded a young Brigitte Bardot ………
/
nimal fernando / December 6, 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OI8trnK74dI ……. Read the comments: SL rational thinkers say it all …….. in lucid rational language.
–
What’s important is the decency of deeds …….. more than the decency of words/language. That’s why I use bad language to make the point to Native in no uncertain terms.
–
@palithavithana1699 Sombiya hadanne rata agardayata danna plan gahana ekai. Mun marila yanne naha nei.
–
@chadaihstsu Ratea sampath horakapu Ponna wesige puthu
–
@Shamalee-e6l PONNA RANILO THOPIWA KUNU BAKKIYATA DALA EWRAI.
–
@gnanasiripiyathilaka1212 Expired politics of Ranil the hypocrite.
–
@razeekhassim257 Ranil AKD or NPP no need your advice 159 is not no need past President Mahinda Rani help hambantoa funds banku horu batalanda minimaru Rs 166 lakhs mahajaya mudal nasty karala horu ekka yanna api deal naha banku horu jativadiya commission bribery thugs namal minimaru thajdeen ekeneigoda lasantha minimaru
–
@thakshilasena6606 Kalakanni sombiya ta…thawath hora kanna anna..yaman thani damaniyen edapan
–
@thakshilasena6606 Me naki kalakanni haththa serama kaba kadanawa
/
chiv / December 6, 2025
Wow, that looks like an in depth discussion to me ( real Sri Lankans discussing real issues)
/
Jit / December 6, 2025
“…Does he still think he is important? ….”
Yes, he does!
Some can never leave their hallucinations.
/
Ajith / December 5, 2025
“Let The Real Sri Lankan Come Out Now!!”
It is the question for the past 77 years? Who is the real Sri Lankan? where was he until now?
/
whywhy / December 5, 2025
Did you try diggin in cemetaries ? Real men existed long time ago .
/
Native Vedda / December 7, 2025
whywhy
–
“Did you try diggin in cemetaries ? Real men existed long time ago .”
–
You mean Vijaya, Dutta Gamani, ….. Ellala, ….. Sangiliyan, Soora Saratiel, Dharmapala, …Band, his assassins, …OC Corea, …. JR, … Somawansa, Prabaharan, …. DIG Premadasa, ….
/
whywhy / December 8, 2025
Native ,
Honestly , so pleased to read you . Thanks . And , let me be
clear on this . I was talking about common man from all
communities . If you take DIG Premadasa and VP , don’t you
agree that for a section of the public , what they did was the
need of the hour ? You missed one important guy here , Cyril
Mathew . My whole point was , the good common man that
we bumped into at every nook and corner went missing .
/
Rajash / December 6, 2025
They briefly came out for Aragalay but now they are not visible as the racist fog has engulfed them again.
/
Native Vedda / December 7, 2025
Ajith
–
“Who is the real Sri Lankan? where was he until now?”
–
I am the real islander, very much around, rest of them are Kallathonie converts. What are you looking for?
–
Another “our leader”, ….. who can part the sea, ….. who has god like abilities Omnipotence, Omniscience, Omnipresence, Omnibenevolence/Love, …….. etc
/
whywhy / December 5, 2025
Where is this man , davidthegood ? He is to blame for this disaster !
He vanished !
/
SJ / December 6, 2025
ww
Do you miss him?
There are other entertainers around who are just as daft and dishonest.
/
whywhy / December 7, 2025
S J ,
Yes , I do , very much . This discussion is asking him to
come out with his mercy mission . Man missing , with
no sign of his cross to be found in the devastation .
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
Should you not pray for him then?
/
whywhy / December 8, 2025
He may be hiding to escape from public eye . His Boss is
the one who unleashed this catastrophe . He must be
on the run .
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
WW,
I don’t think he is caught up in the crisis. He may have been licking the church floor, like my fanatical neighbours do. When I read from Ramona and DTG, I was reminded of the type of people who are completely deceived by religions; too much of a good thing may lead to negative results
/
Douglas / December 6, 2025
“Let Sri Lanka Come Out”. Yes. It would happen, and here is the PLAN. Watch:
https://www.youtube.com/live/W5mUgLzQfXQ?si=d26TcC-R18Vm2Tb0
A ‘Presidential Task Force’ to undertake all planning is to be established.
Alternatively, Ranil W at the meeting of all Opposition Party Representatives proposed a similar ‘Task Force’ headed by the ‘Mahanayakas’ of the ‘Three Nikayas of the Buddhist Monks’.
How do you compare the President’s Task Force with that proposed by Ranil W and the Opposition?
/
Ajith / December 6, 2025
“How do you compare the President’s Task Force with that proposed by Ranil W and the Opposition?”
It is not about comparing between one President to other Presidents. We all agree that the current president is better than the past leaders or past governments. The question is what is needed is how the country can get rid of the barriers that the past will not happen in the future by any other governments who come to power.
/
Douglas / December 6, 2025
Ajith: “……how to get rid of the barriers…?
The “Barriers” have already been identified. They are none other than the ‘Political Leadership’ of the present Opposition. Some of the front liners are Ranil Wickremesinghe of the UNP, Sajith Premadasa of the SJP, Namal Rajapaksa, the aspirant to the Presidency (who wants to topple the present Government by hook or crook), and their ‘Cohorts,’ who associate and advise them.
You might ask how we have identified them. Simple. Just assess what they have done as a responsible Opposition since the present Government was installed. Look at how they are handling the present crisis of devastation that the country is facing. Have you seen the official public announcement that the UNP issued a few days back? It mentions nothing other than the way the present President and the Government could be charged in the SC on violation of the Constitution and ‘Fundamental Rights’ of the citizens. This narrative is also followed by the SJB, as announced by MP Marikkar. Namal ‘Baby’ has also followed it.
Is that what the country needs and expects from a responsible ‘Opposition’ and its ‘Leaders’ at this moment? All of them must be ‘GOT RID OF’ Period!
/
Douglas / December 7, 2025
Ajith: I mentioned that the President has appointed a “Presidential Task Force” to manage the project “Rebuild Sri Lanka”. The President noted the detailed working of this “task Force”. The Opposition, in their objections to appointed members of this ‘Yask Force” stated that this is composed of a set of “Rogues”. Do you want to know them? Watch:
https://youtu.be/mQ_7j28ugkU?si=GdJ1y6WjkLCMEbfm
The only missing members are the ‘Saffron Clad Mahanaykas’ of the ‘Three Nikayas’ of ‘Buddhagama’ proposed by the ‘Convenor’ of the ‘United Opposition’ and the Leader of the UNP, Ranil Wickramasinghe.
/
Native Vedda / December 7, 2025
Douglas
–
Did you hear Namal Baby has offered to donate one month salary to relief fund .
–
We must immediately stop him. How could we possibly allow Namal Baby to donate a whole month’s salary? Next thing you know, he’ll be out there trying to help people during a crisis. I must say it is completely unacceptable.
–
We must protect him from this dangerous habit of generosity before he ends up with the ultimate tragedy, being a kind human being.
–
I wonder who gave him the idea?
Is it nimal fernando?
Compassion has gone too far.
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
NV,
.
The president’s decision looks misguided
–
Given all that, experts worldwide would likely judge the decision to “ignore” or de-prioritise disaster-management structures — in favor of general public-security laws — as ill-advised, and risky.
–
It undermines long-term planning, early warning, mitigation, and public accountability — all of which reduce disaster risk before calamity strikes.
–
It increases vulnerability by strengthening emergency, top-down powers rather than community-level resilience and institutional trust.
–
It heightens the risk of governance failures, mismanagement, and suppression of dissent under the guise of “public protection.”
–
In short: yes — from a global best-practice standpoint, relying on a robust, institutionalised disaster-management framework is far more effective and responsible than depending on ad-hoc public-security powers.
–
Tbc
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
NV and all other true souls,
.
Please read the DM and that will prove you a lot.
.
https://www.dmc.gov.lk/images/DM_Act_English.pdf
–
Soon, our President will have to be crowned “the champion of all donkey-presidents in this world”. Not even tribal Africa has produced such a ruler thus far… hee haws of AKD is truly fooling the battle-weary country.
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
cont.
.
What seems to be going wrong in Sri Lanka
–
Recent events suggest the choice by Anura Kumara Dissanayake (current president) to rely on a “public-security / Emergency / Public Protection Pact / Ordinance” rather than the Disaster Management Act has had serious drawbacks:
–
The catastrophic impact of Cyclone Ditwah shows that existing disaster-management institutions (under the 2005 Act) were underfunded, neglected or not functioning effectively. Many experts and commentators blame “years of neglect on the disaster-management front” for the scale of destruction and loss of life.
Postcolonial Politics
dailymirror.lk
–
Critics say the government “ignored warning signals”, failed to activate disaster-management mechanisms in time, and lacked a “unified relief-and-rescue” system — which a functioning DMC (Disaster Management Centre) should have provided.
The Times of India
LNW Lanka News Web
–
The use of emergency powers under “public-security” laws has raised fears among civil-society groups that these laws may be used to suppress dissent, control information, or sideline democratic oversight — rather than only for genuine disaster response.
tamilguardian.com
IFJ
–
Thus — rather than compensating for weak disaster laws — the shift toward emergency / public-security powers appears to have deepened structural weaknesses, at a time when robust disaster-management was most needed.
/
Naman / December 6, 2025
The country is STILL awaiting for a true Statesman to lead the country.
As long as violent thuggish Buddhists either clergy or laymen are around the country can not come out of the hell hole
/
Rajash / December 6, 2025
They came out during Aragalaya ..have they fizzled away?
I guess the author is not considering the Politicians of all colours as Real Sri Lankans ? The opposition politicians are boasting how they could have done better instead of uniting and salivating at the opportunity of cashing in from the disaster.
But what is the Sri Lankan meteorological Dept doing? The weather forecast is so advanced these days. How did they fail to give advance warning for the people of high risk areas to move to a safe place. So many lives could have been saved.
/
SebastianSR / December 6, 2025
“equal or even more focused attention needs to be paid to the Northern and Eastern Tamils and Muslims. The hill-country Tamil population must have been devastated beyond help“
This statement suggests that disaster aid should be based on ethnicty? NO. It should be based only on dire need WITHOUT regard for ethnicity, caste, creed or political affiliation. The hill-county population, Tamil, Sinhalese, etc., as well as even the ecosystem have all been devastated. Remeber the first version of University Admissions by Minister Bad-Ud-Deen Mohammad that discriminated agaist tamils claiming to “set the playing field level” for the Sinhalese? NO more Ethnic quotas please in the name of, or under the pretense of, “affirmative action”.
/
SJ / December 6, 2025
“Admissions by Minister Bad-Ud-Deen Mohammad that discriminated agaist tamils claiming to “set the playing field level” for the Sinhalese?”
Do not pin the blame on Badi-ud-din for a government policy decision. The decision was not his. But some still use it to twist it into a Muslim agenda.
There was a case to rectify the outcome of a very bad imbalance the results, but the way it was done was clumsy.
No political party in the south including the UNP and JVP had uttered a word against standardization, to this very day.
The FP was cynically insensitive to the political impact of the results, and capitalized on the impact of standardization on the northern Tamil middle class.
The district quota scheme, not the best alternative though, deflated Tamil objections by helping educationally backward Tamil districts.
/
SebastianSR / December 6, 2025
Bad-ud-din Mohammad was the minister who put in the 1st version of the standardization of University admissions scheme and, what ever it is, he has to take the blame or the credit. His secretary was Paskaralingam, who cynically played bothways should also take the blame and the crdit. SJ is correct when he says that the second University Admission Scheme, based on District quotas, was a much better scheme that actually helped children of poor districts, be they Tamil or not. But no Tamil party had admitted this, and still talk of the University admissions standerdization as a part of Genocide of the Tamils. In any case, the ease that Visvamithra showed in advocating a policy of special treatment for Tamils and Mulsims in regard to Cyclone damage shows that people like him still dont understand that we cannot favour people on the basis of ethnicity, caste, creed etc.
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
Regardless, Tamil Nadu followed similar policies as Sri Lanka. Rejecting Hindi as an official language (only Tamil taught in schools and used in the civil service), reservation, etc.
Tamil is the sole language of administration, lower courts, and most government work in the state. While English continues to be used in the High Court and Supreme Court benches, and in some central government offices, day-to-day civil service (TNPSC exams, government orders, police, revenue, local bodies) functions almost entirely in Tamil.
Knowledge of Tamil is mandatory to become a state government employee (except a few all-India services posts).
The idea being that 80 million people need not accommodate a small minority of non-Tamils who live and work there. Just as you had race riots in 1956 over Sinhala-Only, you also had riots in Tamil Nadu over “Hindi imposition”, with people protesting for days and throwing their shoes.
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
Reservation is still there in Tamil Nadu. Reservation is worse than the “standardization” you find in Sri Lanka. Because of reservation, people graduating from top schools in India generally go abroad. Such as the current CEO of Google, Pichai. Reservation has contributed to a brain drain in India, with serious economic implications. Indian economists agree that India will never be a superpower on the level of China.
Unfortunately, most Sri Lankan Tamils live in a bubble. But that is exactly why their fake freedom struggle ended in disaster.
Reservation policy
Tamil Nadu has 69 % reservation in education and government jobs (18 % SC, 1 % ST, 30 % BC, 20 % MBC, with various sub-quotas). It exceeds the Supreme Court’s 50 % cap, protected by placing it in the Ninth Schedule.
This was partly justified as a counterweight against perceived “North Indian/Brahmin/Aryan” dominance in central services and higher education, and partly as social justice for backward castes.
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
You seem to be obsessed with Brahmins and Aryans? Why are you one? If you are Sabarakum, you definitely dont look one. What is so special about Brahmins and Aryans, and this hatred for Tamil Nadu? I do not subscribe to the discrimination of Brahmins in Tamil Nadu, there as Tamil as the rest of the Tamils, with a little more steppe ancestry. However, other than a few of them, have you moved them? They generally have a superiority complex and are very caste-conscious, and they treated the rest of the Tamils like dirt. Even other upper caste Non-Brahmin Tamils. Despite being only around 2-3% of the Tamil population, they had a stranglehold on the state and would not allow any other non-Brahmin Tamil to come up. It was only after the Dravidian parties broke this Brahmin stranglehold in Tamil Nadu that Tamil Nadu and its population developed economically leaps and bounds, and now it is the second economically rich and vibrant state, have millions of North Indians migrating to the state.
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
Tamil Nadu is not against Brahmins, but against Brahminism and its ideology; otherwise, Tamil Brahmins like Jayalalitha would not have been a chief minister and much loved, or Tamil actors like Kamala Hassan, a Brahmin, very much respected and loved. The state poet Subramaniya Bhatarathiar is a Brahmin. Remember, Tamil Brahmins are also Tamils, irrespective of whether they are Aryan or Dravidian, and have contributed a lot to the Tamil language, culture and in all other spheres. As fellow Tamils, we love them, but if they start talking about Brahmin? Aryan superiority, we dont. Unfortunately, most of them still do.
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
“Tamil Nadu is not against Brahmins.”
Really?
Suspicion of the Brahmin was strong because of their role in social oppression.
The Brahmin elite played ball with the Brits and the Congress before independence.
The antagonism has lessened since the non-Brahmin elite became politically powerful.It was so strong that even the CPM was seen with suspicion by Dalits for the strong Brahmin presence in its leadership.
Do not making sweeping statements.
Caste antagonism still rides high in India.
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
Interesting that “SJ” is stealing my ideas. I was the first to point out that standardization is not as detrimental as the pro-LTTE people claim. SJ also agrees that Sunni (not Shia) Islam harbors dangerous tendencies that lean towards fascism. Unfortunately I had to block (filter) SJ for his use of foul language and intellectual dishonesty . I believe the individual in Germany is also incorporating my ideas, but that individual is clinically insane (by any measure) and has limited English capacity.
/
my nut is so itchy / December 7, 2025
My itchy darling Lester,
“Interesting that “SJ” is stealing my ideas.”. Ja Ja, your ideas are always the best, like the nuclear powered 300 psi pump. But how do you know that if you’ve filtered him out? Anyway, why this frenzy about Tamilnadu? Does it get under your foreskin that they sent a whole shipload of food yesterday?
“Tamil and English are both compulsory in schools. But Hindi is not” Well, isn’t that the reason their PCI is double ours? We should make Tamil compulsory too.
/
chiv / December 7, 2025
😅🤣😂😂🤣😅
To be precise more than 900 Tons of relief materials and medicines .
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
Lester, the nutless child, has returned to his customary occupation of badmouthing.
This person may be wired today since he is unable to generate money from tourists and is not experiencing any healing from his plastic surgery incursions.
–
Bugger should have been a minion, as he looked to be. He has now added our wonderful professor to his list of non-existing filters. All of this is to keep him above. Enjoy!
This idiot is an absolute curse. Perhaps recompense will no longer come from Rajaakshes’ stolen finances for his Rajapakshe-heroic propaganda.
/
leelagemalli / December 8, 2025
Those like Lester who are filled with racial notions all the time should be aware that disasters such as extreme flooding or cyclones do not discriminate; they effect everyone. No matter what religion, color, or ethnicity you are, you will face unforeseen challenges in this life. We are all the same. I despise racists of your sort… Tony is the other cancer in our forum. Valnacia, Spain, was similarly hit by heavy water without notice from its regional head and responsible autohriteis. Now, the regional head has resigned, unable to face the entire nation.
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Ew-rjkXqFkU
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
*only Tamil taught in schools
Tamil and English are both compulsory in schools. But Hindi is not offered as a third option, due to political opposition.
Anyway, the original point still stands. The 1956 Sinhala-Only act did not affect education (rural Sinhalese who went to university would now be at a disadvantage), it affected the civil service. Tamil Nadu follows a similar policy. Tamils who want to be politicians in Sri Lanka should learn Sinhala anyway, it makes sense. Can I really be a politician in Germany or Sweden without speaking German or Swedish?
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
*did not affect education in a “racist” sense
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
Rubbish standardisation was introduced to keep out many deserving Tamil students from higher education, especially from prestigious science and economics courses, in favour of far lower-qualified Sinhalese and Muslim students. When they found out that this had vastly reduced the number of Tamil students entering universities, but the numbers were still quite high, and not to their liking, they deliberately introduced district-based selection in addition to standardisation to reduce the number of Tamil students further, gaining entry to prestigious science and economic courses. There were 6 or 7 Tamil districts, and the rest were all predominantly Sinhalese. They further used the population of each district to allocate the number of students entering from these districts, which further restricted the number of Tamil students entering. In many Sinhalese majority districts like Colombo, Kandy, and other parts of the hill country, where there was a huge population of Tamils, they counted them. but hardly allocated any seats for the Tamils in these areas, but allocated them all to the Sinhalese and Muslims. Tamils were just counted like cattle to bloat the population to further increase the number of Sinhalese and Muslims entering from these districts. Just like the way did count then stateless estate Tamil population in
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
Standardization was a knee jerk reaction to an abnormal GCE AL result of 1970 leading to 80% of admissions to Engineering being from the Tamil medium.
Read some history and do not repeat stupid gossip.
/
Lester / December 7, 2025
Now you are admitting one group of Tamils (Brahmins) discriminated against the other group of Tamils. Why don’t you call it a genocide?
The next point to make is that only the Brahmins but the Vellalar discriminated against low castes.
If Tamils were discriminating against other Tamils, then you cannot justify the fake freedom struggle.
Why don’t you admit what really happened here was that the Vellalar wanted to keep all their privileges, so they convinced the low caste Tamils, like that idiot Velu, to do a fake freedom struggle against the Sri Lankan State? Velu was able to take the leadership from the Vellalar, mostly through assassination, but he could not win against the State.
I am not S Barakum. The only Muslim here is “Old Codger.” He is writing porno under various user names because I called out his fake Prophet who married a 6 year old. Religion of peaceful pedophiles!
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
Rubbish standardisation was introduced to keep out many deserving Tamil students from higher education, especially from prestigious science and economics courses, in favour of far lower-qualified Sinhalese and Muslim students. When they found out that this had vastly reduced the number of Tamil students entering universities, but the numbers were still quite high, and not to their liking, they deliberately introduced district-based selection in addition to standardisation to reduce the number of Tamil students further, gaining entry to prestigious science and economic courses. There were 6 or 7 Tamil districts, and the rest were all predominantly Sinhalese. They further used the population of each district to allocate the number of students entering from these districts, which further restricted the number of Tamil students entering. In many Sinhalese majority districts like Colombo, Kandy, and other parts of the hill country, where there was a huge population of Tamils, they counted them. but hardly allocated any seats for the Tamils in these areas, but allocated them all to the Sinhalese and Muslims.
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
Tamils were just counted like cattle to bloat the population to further increase the number of Sinhalese and Muslims entering from these districts. Just like the way the then stateless, voteless estate Tamil population in estate areas in the central, Uva and Sabaragamuwa provinces, like cattle, to create more Sinhalese electorates and members of Parliament from these areas. TO swell the number of Sinhalese MPS and representation in the parliament. They followed the same tactic. That a few Tamil students from remote and backward areas entered them did not bother them, and most of them were undeserving too, as these students entered with very minimal qualifications, like most Sinhalese and Muslims, but were not poor or economically backward.
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
“Tamils were just counted like cattle “
Did not Tamil leaders count the HCT and Muslims among their number (but like what I do not know) to boost their claims for representation?
/
Rohan25 / December 7, 2025
They went to all the elite schools in Colombo and Jaffna for their A levels and then returned and sat their exams using a school from these backward areas. The government was fully aware of this but did not care, as these 10 or 15were supposed to be economically deprived and poor students from backward Tamil areas( sic as there were far more economically poor and deprived Tamil students in Jaffna and Colombo), were used as propoganda tool, to show the world how king they were to the poor Tamils, when in reality thousands of poor and deserving Tamis students from backward and so called forward areas were shut out in favour of lots of rich and middle class undeserving Sinhalese and Muslims students. This is the actual story and the psychotic vicious snake and Sebastian, whoever are now trying to twist the truth.
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
How many backward disrtict Tamils “went to all the elite schools in Colombo and Jaffna for their A levels “.
The district quota system helped many deserving children who were denied good schools.
It also boosted confidence in local schools so that now there a excellent schools in Muthur, Kinniya and Vavuniya among others.
Even now many of the selfish Jaffna Vellala elite cannot accept others Tamils not from other regions alone but even Jaffna from the ‘wrong’ caste (what you gleefully call ‘low caste’) as deserving or intelligent.
Christianity contributed to elevating people of depressed castes (sometimes even without conversion) but within the limitations of the caste-ridden region.
Things got much better after the take over of schools in 1960.
/
Rohan25 / December 8, 2025
Really! A few token largely undeserving Tamil students, who were not backward or economically deprived but largely came from wealthy families, and had access to good education and used the district basis to their advantage, by having all their education and tuition from leading academies and schools in Jaffna and Colombo and then returning to their so called backward districts to sit from some school there and entering from these so-called backward Tamil areas, is helping poor backward schools? There were poor, economically backward schools and students in all areas and even in these so-called backward areas, there were good schools. Don’t try to bullshit, you know what really happened and are just an apologist and supporter of state-sponsored Sinhalese racism against the island’s Tamils and will defend and support it to the hilt. Especially since this racist diabolical scheme was hatched up by your racist heroine, Sri Amma and her extremely anti-Tamil Muslim Minister, who wanted to uplift the Muslims at the expense of the Tamils, not in the proper way, but by deliberately denying deserving, many poor and deserving Tamils from backward and forward areas, irrespective of religion or caste higher education in favour of far less deserving Sinhalese and Muslim students most of who were from wealthy, upper middle class families and not backward or poor.
/
Rohan25 / December 8, 2025
His own daughter from a prestigious Colombo school entered medicine with just 1 credit and three passes, so did many Sinhalese, and Muslims, whilst thousands of Tamil students, many from poor and middle-class families, were denied even a basic science course with far better results. Just look at the number of Tamil students who entered after standardisation, which severely dropped, and then the number dropped drastically further when entry was based on a district basis addition to standardisation. A double whammy for the Tamils and a big bonanza for the Sinhalese and Muslims. A few token undeserving economically rich Tamil students, who had all the advantages that even many Tamil students from Colombo and Jaffna did not have, entering and being used for political propaganda by racist Sinhalese and Tamil quislings like you does not fool anyone.
/
Rohan25 / December 8, 2025
What is this immense hatred for Vellalars, and constantly trying to use them as an excuse to justify state-sponsored Sinhalese racism against Tamils? You are the one who is cunningly and diabolically using caste as an excuse to justify state-sponsored Sinhalese terrorism and marginalisation of all Tamils, irrespective of origin, religion, region or caste. Vellalars make up half the ethnic Sri Lankan Tamil population, and they are rich Vellalars, but most are poor farmers from rural families, just like there are rich and powerful non-Vellalars and poor non-Vellalars. There are regional caste and religious differences amongst all people and even amongst the Sinhalese, English, French, Arabs, and North Indians. Even in Islamic Pakistan, there is caste and caste discrimination, and in the UK, there is class and regional discrimination. The Sinhalese, especially the Kandyans, discriminate far more than the Sri Lankan Tamils based on caste, you know it, but are very quiet about this. However, this does not justify state-sponsored discrimination, ethnic cleansing, marginalisation, war crimes and structural genocide against the island’s Tamils, and most of it was directed, and the victims of this were not the Vellalars but poor rural non-Vellalar Tamils in the north and east and the estate Tamils. Stop bullshitting and using caste as a red herring to justify genocide and ethnic cleansing, disgusting, nasty, evil man.
/
SJ / December 6, 2025
“‘Helping Hambantota’ project that made the Rajapaksas rich “
Are you sure that it didt?
The attempted theft was stopped and the culprit was left off the hook.
They made their money by other means foul not fair.
/
Douglas / December 6, 2025
Ajith: “……how to get rid of the barriers…?
The “Barriers” have already been identified. They are none other than the ‘Political Leadership’ of the present Opposition. Some of the front liners are Ranil Wickremesinghe of the UNP, Sajith Premadasa of the SJP, Namal Rajapaksa, the aspirant to the Presidency (who wants to topple the present Government by hook or crook), and their ‘Cohorts,’ who associate and advise them.
You might ask how we have identified them. Simple. Just assess what they have done as a responsible Opposition since the present Government was installed. Look at how they are handling the present crisis of devastation that the country is facing. Have you seen the official public announcement that the UNP issued a few days back? It mentions nothing other than the way the present President and the Government could be charged in the SC on violation of the Constitution and ‘Fundamental Rights’ of the citizens. This narrative is also followed by the SJB, as announced by MP Marikkar. Namal ‘Baby’ has also followed it.
Is that what the country needs and expects from a responsible ‘Opposition’ and its ‘Leaders’ at this moment? All of them must be ‘GOT RID OF’ Period!
/
Ajith / December 7, 2025
“The “Barriers” have already been identified.”
I don’t fully agree with that. You only talk about the corruption side of the past governments, political parties, and political leaders but nothing about the root causes. AKD said he identified them. In his speech at UN he identified them. “Religious extremism and racism have been major causes of wars and conflicts, bringing suffering to millions of people.” So far, he has not touched or afraid of Religious extremism and racism. I don’t keeping silence or delaying the actions will sometimes lead to negative results.
/
Douglas / December 6, 2025
This is for the attention of the ‘Erudite’ and the ‘Elite’ fake Sri Lankans living abroad, who nicknamed the President AKD as “Rnbandage Kolla’, ‘Thambuthegama Burampi’, “Tahmbuthegama Pachoris’, and with every comment on this page, dash out a ‘Fart from the mouth of what has been eaten from the Ass’. Open your heart (if you have one) and eyes to watch how we in Sri Lanka have been blessed to receive the attention of the International community at this moment of suffering. Do you see how a man whom you said did not even manage a ‘PETTY KADE’ is governing the country?
https://youtu.be/1yaKDg0UZtQ?si=usP4cqfxtssvQWMG
Please remain where you are. We will manage ourselves to emerge victorious. Have no doubts. Cheers!
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
Dear Readers,
.
Yes: there are solid, credible, verified reports and eyewitness accounts suggesting that many lives and homes in Gampola (and other areas) might have been saved — or at least suffering mitigated — if the government had been better prepared and more proactive.
–
The scale of destruction and the nature of failures (mudslide burying homes, lack of warning, delayed rescue) strongly support the public’s belief that the disaster was made worse by institutional failure and poor governance, not just by natural forces alone.
–
At the same time — because of incomplete data, ongoing rescue/cleanup, and chaotic conditions — it remains difficult to conclusively assign a precise “excess death” number due to negligence.
–
Tbd
/
LankaScot / December 7, 2025
Hello Leelagemalli,
We haven’t yet had the excess Deaths for Covid19 yet, so how are we to get the Gampola results – in 5 years time?
We had no warning here of possible dangerous conditions, despite the Grama Niladhari Office being only a few hundred metres down the road. Was anyone measuring the rise in the Mahawelli Ganga levels on an hourly schedule? Who was monitoring the downstream results of the Kotamale Dam Gate openings
/
LankaScot / December 7, 2025
Continued,
We continue to use Well Water and have seen only one Water Bowser make an appearance. We saw quite a few Government Relief Trucks in Gampola today and the cleaning is well underway. Haven’t seen much of cutting up the Fallen trees or Road edge repair where subsidence is taking place.
Best regards
/
SJ / December 7, 2025
LS
As long as the well was not polluted by muddied water, the risk is low.
Thanks for the briefing.
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
Thank you LS.
This country has a high crime rate. If you could please discuss this with your Lanken family, you will learn more about them. Not just northerners, but JVP-led southerners produced genuine terrorists. We have many instances from the Habaraduwa region, where commenter-Douglas, the NPP advocate, was one of the hotspot-killers during the JVP uprising from 1989 to 1992. I don’t have any doubts about what he’s explaining today. I assumed the person was normal, but he is no different than his Kadamandiya counterparts.
–
I lost my peers during that time, and my departure for Europe was the primary reason for this. They punished me just because I was an undergraduate at the time.
There were no legitimate reasons to murder youngsters arbitrarily; they are not saints. Some parents were sent bones and meat from their sons for their own eating. These are true.
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
Hello LS,
There is also abundant evidence of the theft squad from JVP rascals, which bothers the helpful distributors to flood victims. This is something we’ve never heard before since even genuine burglars would not steal rice packets or other eatables that were due to be delivered by volunteer organizations.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6OWXJq6uYvk&t=764s
In this nation, people traditionally invite anybody to eat during the Vesak and Poson months. However, it has since been shown to be a scam committed by the governing JVP-led government. Many people are disappointed nowadays because they are unable to express themselves. One minister, Manuwarana, is claimed to have taken rice packages from kind persons and distributed them to their party followers in Kandy.
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
cont.
1
Key media / investigative-report articles with (some) facts & witness-reports
–
Reuters — “Sri Lankans sift mud to unearth victims four days after deadly cyclone”: describes people in villages using spades to dig out bodies after a landslide flattened 13 homes; notes hundreds are still missing in Sri Lanka, the worst flooding in a decade, and shock at how many remain buried.
Reuters
Investing.com
–
Sky News — “‘No one helped us’: The Sri Lanka community left in a mass of mud and loss after cyclone Ditwah”: direct eyewitness reports from Gampola: “narrow, filthy streets … flooded with broken furniture, sodden toys and soiled mattresses”; many say they “had no time to escape,” and that there was no timely warning or evacuation order before floodwaters burst in.
Sky News
–
The Guardian — “We have to rebuild from scratch: Sri Lankans relive the devastation of Cyclone Ditwah”: documents sweeping devastation island-wide; reports flood and landslide-hurt central areas, critical infrastructure broken, emergency services overwhelmed, military deployed for rescue — and many survivors saying there was inadequate or no warning before disaster struck.
The Guardian
–
Malay Mail — “Clean-up hampered in Sri Lanka after floods and landslides leave nearly 500 dead”: describes the slow recovery in the central town of Gampola: huge mud damage, thousands of homes affected, massive clean-up efforts underway, and huge reconstruction costs — indicating that the damage was deep and recovery will be slow.
Tbd
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
2
Evidence pointing to serious failure or inadequate preparedness / response
–
Eyewitnesses in Gampola say many had no warning, no evacuation notice — floodwaters came fast in narrow streets, giving no time to escape.
Sky News
The Guardian
Rescue and recovery has been chaotic: locals digging with spades to recover bodies days later; some people reportedly buried without coffins; many missing, still unaccounted for.
Investing.com
http://www.ndtv.com
–
Relief efforts remain slow: cleanup in Gampola described as extremely labour-intensive; many houses need extensive restoration; infrastructure damage is large (homes, electricity, water, roads).
Malay Mail
The Guardian
–
The scale of devastation (homes destroyed, displaced populations, flooded roads, mudslides, rivers/ reservoirs overflowed) suggests that even with action, the disaster may have outstripped capacity — but critics argue the risk could have been mitigated.
The Guardian
World Socialist Web Site
TBC
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
3What remains unclear / contested
–
Official death-toll and casualty numbers remain disputed — e.g. there are conflicting claims about how many died in Gampola alone. One local official publicly rejected very high death-toll claims.
Newswire
–
It remains difficult to distinguish how much damage/fatalities come from sheer strength of the cyclone + landslide/flood magnitude vs. how much from human or institutional failure (e.g. lack of early warning, evacuation, water-release planning, disaster-management capacity).
–
Some of the institutions responsible (emergency services, rescue, relief centres) have been deployed — but given the scale, many survivors say aid came “too late” or insufficiently.
Tbc
/
leelagemalli / December 7, 2025
4
What we still need — and what to watch for
–
A full, independent, transparent investigation into what happened: when were warnings issued (if at all), whether water releases from reservoirs were managed responsibly, whether evacuation protocols worked, and if failures are due to natural disaster alone or institutional breakdown / mis-management.
–
Accurate, consolidated casualty and missing-persons data — covering remote villages, informal settlements, and accounting for unregistered residents.
–
A systematic review of whether existing legal/institutional frameworks (disaster-management laws, emergency preparedness, early-warning systems, infrastructure maintenance) were properly implemented — or neglected — before the disaster.
–
Long-term policy reforms: improved early-warning; better land-use, water-management and slope-stability regulation; disaster-resilient infrastructure; robust rescue & evacuation systems; community-level disaster risk reduction.
/
SebastianSR / December 7, 2025
“Helping Hambantota’ project that made the Rajapaksas rich
Good to look at theTsunami in hindsight. 2004 Tsunami disbursement went through various entities, but creating a mechanism involving the LTTE led to major contention with JVP leaving the govt. International donors contributed funds to GOSL, with no central authority or audit to managed funds. There was evidence that funds were siphoned off, both by LTTE and GOSL corruption. The TRO was accused by the US department of the treasury. Two Sri Lankan Australians were arrested for diverting tsunami aid to the Tigers. Two Canadian Hindu temples were fined by the Canada Revenue Agency for sending tsunami donations to the LTTE. Human rights groups claimed that LTTE extorted Tamil families and business owners who had received money for tsunami reconstruction. “Helping Hambantota” project, of PM Rajapaksa was accused of illegally siphoning over 82 million rupees by Sunday Leader. Rajapaksa officials claimed it was specifically for Hambantota relief, but they put back to the government fund when the matter was exposed. MP Kabir Hashim, filed a case with the Supreme Court in 2005. but was dismissed by the Court .
/