10 December, 2024

Blog

The New Political Culture, For A United Country

By Reverend PJ Fernando –

Reverend Dr PJ Fernando

All minorities: Tamils, Muslims, Malay, Burgers all to belong to one country and one people of Sri Lanka – Religious leaders a greater role to play.

Listening to the Songs of Mohideen Beg, it lifts up the spirits belonging to Sri Lanka, even though I myself live out of the country. It is even more striking that it is sung by a Sri Lankan Muslim, truly Sri Lankan. I suspect there must be such great people amongst the Tamils, Malays, Burgers etc. that celebrates the language, the culture and the heritage of their country. But could you spot any of them? hard to find, pardon me if I am ignorant.

I remember the young very talented Tamil girl not too long ago singing ‘me rata mage rate, ma ipaduna rata’ (මේ රට මගෙ රට මා  ඉපදුනු රට) and going to win a singing competition in one of the TV channels in Sri Lanka. She surely won for her sheer talent, but I would not doubt for a moment, that it also touched the heart of the nation.  I personally found it to be so inspiring and hope she knows she stands a great witness to the unity and integrity of this small Island Sri Lanka simply by her singing, what and how she did it and stood for. Rightly so, all peoples owe to such a great stand she took at her very young age and many those that encouraged and guided her. It is hard to find such an attitude or an approach amongst the leaders, not even among the religious leaders something for a nation and a country to regret and mourn about.

Sadly, we live in a time and era where such efforts to unite are not harnessed, but rather divisions are nurtured and polarised for one’s own gain and surely not for the best interest of a united Sri Lanka. The political leaders when they are keen for their own gain, or their parties’ and henchmen’s survival the country’s unity and integrity is always ransomed. The articles published today in leading magazines and papers locally and internationally talks about ‘fragmented ……political parties’ amongst the minority communities and longs for a united force towards reaching their goals and aspirations, not to mention the self-governance, separate state and identity. All minority communities have a right to coexist in Sri Lanka and so then if their argument is right, then a separate state for all notwithstanding what one fights for and lobbies for must be true. It then is a utopian having to give self-governance and a separate state for all minorities in this small Island. It is sad that this is not seen by the learned people, leaving alone the political leadership who are branded to be anything but literate. The religious leaders surely must have a moral obligation, but sadly that leadership is simply not there, but the contrary, the religious leaders and institutions in their subtlety has been the hidden hand and the voice for the force that promotes a divided country within the country and internationally.

Hatred against the Sinhalese people is nurtured in families

My experiences with the diaspora and their families sadly have seen how their children who probably never lived in Sri Lanka are brought up with a hatred towards the Sinhalese people and nation. Once they learn that I am Sinhalese, even though I am a catholic priest, I feel that I am not welcomed. I have known many a Tamil, Muslim, and Burgers from my childhood days. There are many who are family friends. Even otherwise after becoming a priest my experience has been especially in the villages and in Colombo, not in the North or East is that they are very welcoming to the Catholic Priest, and did not matter whether I was a Sinhalese or not. But sadly, once they are out of the country it is very different. This I believe is a serious problem we leave for the future if it is not addressed. Once a young child, who never lived in Sri Lanka was talking to me with great anger learning that I was a Sinhalese. He was accusing me that I have killed their people, taken their land and discriminated them. As a priest in Sri Lanka, I taught for ten years in two leading Catholic Schools. I have taught many a Tamil, Muslim, Burgers, others and Sinhalese alike. Never treated them differently depending on their religion, ethnicity or status. I was deeply saddened. I have the feeling that amongst the diaspora even those who would have lived in harmony, doing their learning and studying in our schools, speaking Sinhalese too, now suddenly become conscious of their community and avoid speaking with their Sinhalese friends, distancing themselves. This is clearly seen among the clergy too.

This youngster, and so this generation is not to be blamed but it is possibly the parents, the elders, the leaders who must bear the brunt. I as a religious leader would hold the religious leaders to account above else on their commitment and role in building peace and harmony in Sri Lanka. Sadly, I feel that the religious leaders by their polarised attitudes are responsible for this bleak future of our country.

Speaking Sinhalese is Taboo or looked down even within Sri Lanka

There is an increasing trend amongst the Tamil, Muslim and other communities an encouragement to speak other than the language of the country – Sinhalese. So much so that those who speak in Sinhalese are branded as ‘jathi wadiyo’ (ජා ති වා දියෝ. ). Once I walked into a bank in Dehiwela, and I spoke in Sinhalese. I was refused to be served by this young girl saying that she did not know Sinhalese. I was shocked.

On another occasion one of my students was facing an interview in the German embassy and when he finished his turn another student, a Tamil student wanting to know what was asked by the interviewer approached him, but when the Sinhalese student mentioned what was asked in Sinhalese, the Tamil student told him that he did not speak Sinhalese. Well, there was little choice for the Sinhalese student, other than to say that he did not speak anything else in Sri Lanka.

It is increasingly noticeable among the younger generation of the minority communities that they do not speak Sinhalese, as a reaction, embracing the divisions and the polarisations by their political and religious leaders. Sadly, there seems a stronger trend against learning and speaking Sinhalese, the language of the country even in the minority schools, even in those in Colombo and elsewhere, not only in the North and the East. A simple test would be to read the name boards of the schools. This goes without saying about the state of the institutions of higher education.

One would be surprised to hear that this is very true even amongst the religious too. Most of the religious leaders amongst the minorities would not speak Sinhalese nor show an interest to do so, let alone encouraging their people to do so. I have come across number of Tamil priests in Jaffna, Batticaloa and else where who would say they do not speak Sinhalese or simply avoid talking with me or any other whenever Sinhalese is spoken.

This reflects the attitude which I see even in the shops of Wellawatte, Nuwara Eliya and various other parts of the country, not just Jaffna, Mannar and Batticaloa. They would not serve you when you speak to them in Sinhalese, at best you are ignored, and the next customer is served. If you simply survey the name boards in these areas it is all there to see.   

The only identity for Sri Lanka as a country, a geographically defined island, with its own great history is the Sinhalese language and the historical artifacts which are protected by the culture and the religion of the land. As we all know throughout history this was challenged in various ways and continues to be so. Seeing our people living in various parts of the world, it amazes to see how quick and well they embrace the language, the culture and the way of life making their own in those countries they consider their home. This in no way have made them less of what or who they are. Their culture is celebrated, and language is spoken with great pride. But this small, island, with their people struggling to survive as an independent country in the region and of strategic importance to the rest of the world, are guaranteed to be a tear drop with the vested interests.

The Catholic Church was divided before the country Is divided

I think it is time we speak the truth. Unless and until truth is spoken in real honesty a thrust towards peace and reconciliation, creating a uniting force to define one country would not be possible.

There is a saying that is kept a secret amongst the priests in Sri Lanka, certainly during my time of training towards priesthood, but never dared spoken in public; ‘The church was divided before the country was divided’. There was a time, long before the separatist struggles, when the Tamil seminarians protested wearing black bands on their arms whilst going through the formation in the National Seminary in Kandy. With all the twists and turns, their power and force with the Catholic church in India-Tamil Nadu (the Sri Lankan church certainly a minority), they formed their own seminary in Jaffna with all the funding and blessing from India and Rome. Until then the National Seminary in Kandy with a long history and tradition going back to 1893 as the Papal Seminary established by Pope Leo xiii, formed priests not just for the whole of the country but for other countries in the region and elsewhere too. The National Seminary in Kandy now simply retains its title, but in fact it is no longer the National Seminary, and the Seminary in Jaffer remains the ‘separated’ major seminary. Here the teaching is done mainly in Tamil, and not a single non-Tamil priest is trained and so as a result there is not a single Tamil priest serving in the dioceses of Jaffna, Mannar and Batticaloa.

It must not be ignored that there were Sinhalese communities, villages in all these dioceses and they are now reduced to nothing except for a few pockets of families that live in the boarder villages. The families, villagers that were slaughtered in these areas long before the war started and during the war is no longer heard of and spoken of. No mother is there to hold the photos of their missing children. During the civil war it was no secret that the seminary and the dioceses playing their own role within the country and internationally promoting their cause.

One of my lecturers in the seminary at that time was one of those who was alleged to have had promoted and supported the terrorists. He was known to have been the spokes person internationally. There were many allegations against the Northa and East dioceses at that time. Whilst many lives were lost as victims or warriors, and many trials taken against the army personal that defended the country, there was little done to bring to justice those supported and encouraged such a struggle. I do not think even the authorities in Rome cared less either. The church seems to enjoy this impunity unjustly and unfairly all this while I feel.

I remember how warmly the elderly priests used to talk about the close friendships they had with the Tamil seminarians, and priests but that was something not known to our generations and thereafter since the separation of the major seminary. It is very sad indeed. There is hardly any brotherhood with the priests in the North. The truth is that there is not a single Sinhalese priest ordained for those dioceses even though there are Sinhalese villages and pockets just about surviving. Not a single Sinhalese priest is welcomed or requested by those bishops either to cater to the Sinhalese priests in the North and the East.

I was on a sabbatical in the English college in Rome. There were two Tamil seminarians from another religious house that came to the English college for a lecture they were attending. Hearing about them I stood outside to talk to them, but they had asked whether I was a Sinhalese or a Tamil, as I was a Sinhalese, they did not want to speak to me. These are the future religious leaders of the country.

Many of the religious congregations and orders are all overtaken by the Tamil community as it is a vehicle for their separatist agenda and working towards it within the country and internationally. The recent comments by the now nuncio attending the festival of Madhu at the invitation of the Bishop of Batticaloa was regrettable. It was insensitive to the burning issues of the Sinhalese people simple catering to an ill-informed agenda. A message that bears an invitation to the episcopate in the North and the East, especially the Tamil bishops to work in building peace and harmony and finding ways to work towards a united Sri Lanka, one country, would have been very timely and prophetic, especially after the war. But regrettably his address failed the test of the time.

It is also no secret that there is the longing and the move of the Tamil clergy to define the North and the East, the map of the LTTE land as a province of the Catholic church, defining a metropolitan Archdiocese as against the one in Colombo. This would be a sealing of the separatist agenda. Even though the Nuncio might be misled, hopefully such lobbying in Rome may not contribute towards such subtle division of this country along those lines making a lasting impact on this small Island nation that struggles to defend and survive as a country with its unique language and culture as the country of the Sinhalese Buddhist People, with a close proximity to India and Tamil Nadu, the traditional homeland of the Tamil people. It is a shame the church hierarchy as a whole does not seem to be able to embrace a stand uniting the country and its people.

The very bold courageous statement that the Cardinal made at a crucial time in Sri Lanka, that Sri Lanka is a Sinhalese, Buddhist Country have united the people and the country. Even though some condemned it.  It is remarkable to see how our Buddhist brothers and sisters embracing the Catholic church as their own brothers and sisters. The Buddhist monks and the people speak warmly of the Catholics in Sri Lanka as their own. I remember how one of the supreme court judges at a television interview praised the stand Cardinal took contributing to brining about unity and peace to Sri Lanka with such a bold statement. Even with the current political changes that has taken place and with the new president and the governance it is obvious that they see the role of the Cardinal and the Catholic Church in Colombo as one with the nation, brothers and sisters of one country that longs for the change they envisage.

When the cardinal has given such a lead, which makes me very proud that he has done so and is remarkable, what saddens me is as to why the other religious leaders did not and could not follow suite. I would wish all Tamil and Muslim leaders doing so too. Why would they not. What is so disheartening is to see none of the Tamil Catholic Bishops coming up to make such a statement or endorse it. Nor have the other bishops too. Why not? Here lies the one opportunity for the country’s religious leaders to join force standing a witness to a united Sri Lanka, one country, recognising its unique identity as a Sinhalese Buddhist Country and so work for peace, justice and reconciliation.

Minority consciousness has brought enormous suffering and pain

Minority consciousness, especially the Tamil, Muslim consciousness has brought enormous suffering and pain to the normal ordinary peace-loving people of this land throughout history. Besides the thirty years of a brutal war that littered the Island with suicide bombings and killings that came to an end there is little done to bring about peace, truth and justice, reconciling the people. It is always the scores of innocent people that become victims and suffer the consequences. Why did the people in border villages have to die living in their country. Why did normal ordinary people in their workplace, commuting or getting about in their normal life else where from the waring areas were blown off. Generations lost their opportunities in life and were hell bent in poverty. There must be an honest discussion on all sides of the spectrum of people.

The challenges and the issues, including discrimination the people of the country faces are far beyond the fact that they are a minority or not. Even amongst the Tamil, Muslim and other communities, their own people are discriminated, and this is true amongst the Sinhalese too. There are many Sinhalese where they are discriminated even against the Tamils and Muslims when they are from remote villages and from poorer, less affluent or lower cast, not the elite. It is a known fact that is purposefully oversighted, that the Sinhalese people were not given employment because they spoke Sinhalese, the language of the land and not English during the time of the British rule in Sri Lanka. This continued down the history. Even today in certain works of life and certain employments not only in the North and East, it is very unlikely that you would be given employment if you are Sinhalese and speak Sinhalese. There is always the demand and encouragement to speak English replacing Sinhalese. These must be heard.

The Tamils and the Muslims though consider themselves a minority in the country, in the wider region it is the Sinhalese that are a minority. It is the language of the Sinhalese, their cultural heritage that is struggling to survive and needs the care and the protection of the state. What a blessing it would be if all the other communities with the richness and diversity of language, religion and culture could give this assurance. Would it not be to become one with the people and the nation that we all long for.

Would this be the opportune time to change

When we are all glued tracing the political change and an exemplary political culture that is emerging in the country – the birth pangs of a new country, would this be a wonderful opportunity for all peoples to unite and bring about refinement and change in our own divisive and polarising ideologies. It is clear, that we have a political leadership that is longing to bring about just and true governance, at least in principle. It is our duty then to embrace it promoting it ourselves. There was a time in the very recent past where a very negative image was painted of Sri Lanka especially internationally affecting businesses, mainly tourism, by various interested parties bringing about economic and political downfall in the country not to mention the bankruptcy.  This may be seen as a political revenge but there were very good reasons for such too, not to mention the scale of nepotism and corruption that was licensed. Such an approach must not be warranted now.

Instead, this would be an opportunity for all forces, all communities to unite. Rather than thriving on negative and false propaganda it would be best to appreciate and embrace the change for good ourselves, uniting forces as one country. Can and will the religious leaders of our country too give this lead to our people. Should it be a million-dollar question to ask? This election would be a wonderful expression of our stand.

Latest comments

  • 3
    0

    Divisions are nurtured and polarised for one’s or party gain and surely not for the best interest of a united Sri Lanka.

    Dr. Shafi, who was accused in Sri Lanka, was ultimately proven innocent due to a lack of credible evidence against him. Wimal Weerawansa, and Udaya Gammanpila, who had led the accusations, allegedly to divert attention from their past failures. Critics argue that their divisive tactics served to mask their own mismanagement, which played a significant role in pushing the country toward economic crisis. Gamanpila come out on media about church bomb bringing documents without senders and asking question and want answer within 7 days and put them in jail what kind of judgement this cover up plan of their mismanagement

    • 1
      3

      Rev. Dr. Fernando, your discussion shows very clear divisions in the present world, but will be eliminated when the believers after death all become children of the one Father through his Son Jesus Christ, when filled and empowered with the Holy Spirit. Trying to unite human beings has to follow that pattern only. No other pattern can unite even though a one world leader called the Anti-Christ will arise to unite governmentally, militarily and religiously. Only the return of Jesus Christ to Jerusalem will finalize the unity.

      • 3
        0

        dtg
        Do you think that he will be with you in the same place after both of you finish life on this planet?

        • 0
          4

          SJ, Holy Spirit is in us since Pentecost. Jesus said “I will never leave you nor forsake you” to all believers. Eternal Life is forever, though life on earth is very short.

          • 3
            0

            So both of you will go to the same place— where no one knows.

      • 4
        1

        Hello DTG,
        “even though a one world leader called the Anti-Christ will arise to unite governmentally, militarily and religiously”.
        Sounds like Trump to me?
        Best regards

        • 0
          2

          LankaScot, you believe what you want to. As for me, Trump is a believing Christian and established Jerusalem for the return of Christ. The Anti-Christ is a non believer who wants to set up his image and be worshipped as god and will control with a cashless society. Will be associated with Iran (Persia) to whom will also flow China across the Belt and Road Initiative and also joined by Russia selling arms to Iran. Trump does not fit the biblical picture of the AC which has to connect with pro-Arab beliefs. Jehovah God not Allah

    • 9
      6

      This expat reverend seems to have a chip on his shoulder against Tamils and Muslims. Apart from his somewhat hilarious grammar, many of his claims are doubtful.
      “a Tamil student wanting to know what was asked by the interviewer approached him, but when the Sinhalese student mentioned what was asked in Sinhalese, ………”
      In what language did the Tamil student indicate his wishes?
      The story of the bank cashier in Wellawatta is totally incredible.
      “Besides the thirty years of a brutal war that littered the Island with suicide bombings and killings that came to an end there is little done to bring about peace, truth and justice, reconciling the people”
      Only suicide bombings? What about aerial bombings? I suspect that this “Rev Fernando ” is one of our regular commentators in disguise, the one who sees everything in terms of Calculus. I will say no more.

      • 9
        6

        “The only identity for Sri Lanka as a country, a geographically defined island, with its own great history is the Sinhalese language and the historical artifacts which are protected by the culture and the religion of the land. As we all know throughout history this was challenged in various ways and continues to be so. Seeing our people living in various parts of the world, it amazes to see how quick and well they embrace the language, the culture and the way of life”
        How patronising! This fake “reverend” obviously regards the minorities as immigrants who must take up the Sinhalese culture and language Of course he can’t be accused of being hypocritical, considering the history of his “Sinhala ” community.

      • 7
        0

        oc
        Donning a cassock does not make a person any more credible than holding a university degree.
        I think I have read him a few years ago, under this name..

        • 0
          0

          SJ,
          “Changing Tack” to suit the Times!!?? Same Name Makes it A BORE sometimes!!?? Name changing gives FRESH impetus!!??

      • 5
        2

        Hello OC,
        Having visited Nuwara Eliya and other places in the area including Hatton not so long ago I noted his comment “This reflects the attitude which I see even in the shops of Wellawatte, Nuwara Eliya and various other parts of the country”. We (my Sinhala relatives and me) have been to Nuwara Eliya and the surrounding Villages on many occasions and have never had any language issues. We ate in the small cafes and restaurants and were always well treated. We often buy Vegetables in the Wholesale Market in Nuwara Eliya with no problems.
        The Reverend does sound like Lester but a quick analysis of his English shows many differences, or maybe we have a genuine case of schizophrenia; but who is Dr Jekyll and who is Mr Hyde.
        Best regards

        • 4
          2

          LS,
          I don’t know about you, but this seems familiar:
          “Reverend Dr PJ Fernando – Currently Priest of the Archdiocese of Birmingham, UK. Besides his priestly studies he obtained his DPhil from University of Cambridge UK, in Computer Vision and Artificial Intelligent Systems in 2004, “
          Jekyll or Hyde?

          • 0
            0

            OC,
            May be apportionment of Both!!??

  • 10
    4

    Your article is oozing with anti-Tamil racism and there is nothing Christian about you. Constantly referring and alluding to the island belonging to the Sinhalese. Your own family name tells us the recent post 15th century South Indian Tamil immigrant origin, of your family, just like most coastal and low country Sinhalese. Yet so full of anti-Tamil prejudice, like most of them, both low and high born. People will only welcome you if they know that you are genuine, however pretending to be a good Christian but in reality, oozing with contempt and hatred for Tamils will not be welcomed and people know. Demanding Tamils to learn Sinhalese but have you and the most Sinhalese ever made any attempt to learn Tamil, which is the language of the ancestors of yours and most of the present-day Sinhalese and the first language of 25% of the island’s population. Tamils must learn Sinhalese no Tamil homeland or history. Looks like the same thing some so called Tamil Catholic living in the Sinhalese south is now advocating.

    • 10
      5

      In Switzerland most German Swiss who make around 70% of the population can speak French the mother tongue of 20% of the population fluently and many even Italian the mother tongue of around 5%. It is the same in Belgium the Walloon and Flemish Belgians are flued in Dutch and French. You are criticising the Tamil speakers for not the Sinhalese or the Sri Lankan state not taking any measures to see that Sinhalese also reciprocate and learn Tamil. Why? Because racist you, despite your recent Tamil origin, like most Sinhalese only thinks Sinhalese belongs to the island but not Tamil. This thought oozes out of your article. As a Christian priest and originating from the western/northwestern coast, that was once part of the Tamil homeland, have you learnt Tamil, that language of your grandparents? Before lecturing to others be a good Christian and follow what you preach.

      • 0
        0

        Parawar clan!!??

  • 4
    0

    Author:
    “Once I walked into a bank in Dehiwela, and I spoke in Sinhalese. I was refused to be served by this young girl saying that she did not know Sinhalese. I was shocked.”

    This is very surprising to read. One would have expected her to at least get another Sinhala-speaking employee to serve you. If that didn’t happen, then it WOULD be “shocking.” The mere fact that she wasn’t able to converse in Sinhalese I wouldn’t consider “shocking,” for how many Sinhalese are able to converse in Tamil? Did you try speaking to her in English?

    I lived in Dehiwala for over 50 years from birth and have never encountered a situation like this. Dehiwala had a large Tamil population to begin with, esp. in the area I lived, and their number (and that of Muslims) has considerably increased over the last few decades, esp. with the construction of apartments. I have noticed that even in Government offices the majority of employees now appear to be Tamil but usually they are able to converse in Sinhalese.

    Continued.

    • 4
      0

      Continued from above post.

      Actually, the only “language problem” I have had with Tamils as far I can recall is when spoke to a Tamil employee in a kade (boutique) in Vauxhall Street, Colombo, in English. He was annoyed that I had done so and asked me to speak in Sinhalese! Of course, he didn’t know English.

      • 5
        0

        LJ
        There are Tamils who are not sufficiently fluent in Sinhala living in the South.
        They do not need Sinhala to make a livelihood.
        This man is utterly prejudiced and his racism is not new to readers.

        • 7
          10

          SJ,

          “This man is utterly prejudiced and his racism is not new to readers.”

          I wonder what you think about the DMK and their language policies in TN.

          • 9
            6

            What about it? What has it got to do with this so-called Catholic priest’s open racism against the island’s Tamil speakers. DMK is in Tamil Nadu and has nothing to do with the island. It is only after the Dravidian parties started to rule Tamil Nadu, that Tamil Nadu became fast industrialized and the standard of living for everyone improved immensely, and it became one of the leading states in India. DMK only opposed the forcible imposition of Hindi in Tamil Nadu and were not against Hindi or any other language. If you want to learn Hindi you can learn it anywhere in Tamil Nadu, in schools, universities etc. The same for Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada. However, the same opportunity to learn other Indian languages are given in Hindi speaking states. No not only in Tamil Nadu but also in many other South Indian but also in North Indian non-Hindi speaking states, the forcible imposition of Hindi is being opposed. Tamil Nadu has thrived without Hindi on just two languages, English and Tamil. It is only in Tamil Nadu that non-Tamil immigrants are allowed to thrive come up and many are even in parliament and MGR a non-Tamil even became a Chief Minister. You will never see this magnanimity in other Indian states

            • 9
              6

              Strange all this anti Tamil diatribe against native Tamils, coming from this so-called Catholic Sinhalese priest, who comes from a community of recent South Indian ancestry. These recent Tamil South Indian origin assimilated Sinhalese, now make up around 30-50% of the present-day Sinhalese and they predominate along the western southern littorals and the low country plains. Many of the so-called Sinhalese upper castes and aristocrats both Kandyan and low country also belong to this category. Ironically it is from these recent South Indian origin assimilated Sinhalese, communities and castes that, you get the biggest anti Tamils and the biggest supporters of the Sinhalese Aryan myth. Most probably very vociferous and anti-Tamil to hide their own very recent Tamil origin from South India. He does not want to even acknowledge the ancient history of the Tamils and the Tamil language on the island and the rich contribution of Tamil to the Sinhalese language in all ways. Grammar, Alphabet, vocabulary. Take the Tamil out of Sinhalese and there will be no Sinhalese but just Sanskrit and Pali.

              • 10
                6

                With racist Sinhalese Christian clergy like this and the hierarchy that seems to support them or turn a blind eye to their openly racist diatribe instead of disciplining them and bringing them to task, no wonder the Tamil Christian clergy and laymen now are demanding for a separate diocese and seminaries for them. You cannot blame them. Unlike India, this island has only two languages 75% speak Sinhalese as their first language and 25% speak Tamil as their first language and both languages should be made equal official languages and taught compulsorily in all schools through the island and fluency in both languages should be made compulsory to get government employment and even in the private sector in addition to English the world language. What a nasty very un-Christian man.

            • 6
              12

              Tamil is the official language of Tamil Nadu. Only Tamil, not Tamil and Hindi, or Tamil and Hindi and English, or Tamil and English. Just like Sinhala became the official language following the “Sinhala-Only Act.” The Sinhala-Only act was repealed, but the DMK has kept only Tamil as the official language. All SL Tamils who complain about Sinhala-Only need to look in the mirror.

              • 8
                6

                Yes, Tamil is the only official language in Tamil Nadu so what is your problem, there are no native Hindi speakers there. Why should Hindi be the official language of Tamil Nadu? Telugu is the only official language of Andhra as native population is Telugu and Telugu and Urdu are the official languages of Telangana as the natives speak Telugu and Urdu. Bengali is the only official language of Bengal as the natives only speak Bengali and in UP, Bihar, MP, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand, Haryana, Rajasthan, Himachal and Uttaranchal Hindi is the official language and in UP it is Hindi and Urdu, as the natives speak various Hindi dialects or Hindi related languages. Understood. The official languages of India Hindi and English not just Hindi. Hindi in all Hindi speaking states and non-Hindi speaking states can opt to deal with the central government in Hindi or English and most non-Hindi speaking states, especially all five southern states have opted for English instead of Hindi and thrived. It is not just the DMK go and learn your history properly.

                • 8
                  5

                  Now coming to Sri Lanka, the native and indigenous languages are Sinhalese and Tamil not just Sinhalese only as you and other Sinhalese racists and fascists are falsely trying to portray. Nine out of the 25 districts on the island are predominantly Tamil or Tamil speaking. All the eight districts in the north and east, Nuwara Eliya district, add to these large parts of coastal Puttalam and the city of Colombo two other areas which are predominantly Tamil speaking. Tamil is the mother tongue of 25% of the island, therefore you cannot have just Sinhalese as the sole official language understood racist who has conveniently runaway to the UK for the good life. If you want Sinhalese only then divide or federate the island like India or Switzerland. Canada, into it predominantly Sinhalese and Tamil speaking parts and Sinhalese can be the sole official language in the Sinhalese speaking areas and Tamil in the Tamil speaking areas and in Colombo both languages. Otherwise, both Sinhalese and Tamil should be given equal status if it is unitary. You cannot have your cake and eat it. India is federated Sri Lanka is not.

                  • 9
                    6

                    Even before the Europeans arrived. There were three kingdoms, and the eastern Tamil Vannimai chiefdoms. Two of the kingdoms were nominally Sinhalese and one Tamil, however all the kings who ruled these three kingdoms, were closely related and were of South Indian origin. Both the sons of King Senarath of Kandy were married to two Tamil princesses from the kingdom of Jaffna. This was the reason he sent an army to Jaffna, when it was captured by the Portuguese the reasons to aid his close relative the king of Jaffna the father-in-law of both his sons and also to try and safeguard the sea access that the kingdom of Kandy had through the kingdom of Jaffna, seaports in Jaffna and Trincomalee. The court language of Kotte was Sinhalese. The court language of Jaffna and the easter Tamil Vannimai chiefdoms was Tamil and the court language of the kingdom of Kandy was both Sinhalese and Tamil not just Sinhalese

                  • 9
                    6

                    large areas of then Kandyan kingdom proper was Tamil speaking along the northwest area and later not only the king but many of the courtiers were far more fluent in Tamil than in Sinhala. In ancient times many Tamil poets were welcomed to the courts of Sinhalese Kings, who appreciated their poetry and rewarded them immensely, as these kings were very fluent in Tamil as their mothers and wives were largely from royal families from South India and most of their close relatives were Tamils. Learn and appreciate the real history of the island and not some racist lies and rubbish from a racist recent South Indian origin Sinhalese Catholic priest. Are you this priest?

              • 9
                6

                Lester,
                Why is the Indian national anthem in Bengali ?

                • 3
                  1

                  Hello OC,
                  On the balance of probabilities I am beginning to think that the Sri Lankan Sinhalese and Sri Lankan Tamils have more in common Genetically and Historically than either have with the people of Tamil Nadu. I think that the emphasis on the Tamil Language may be a bit of a Red Herring. Many Sinhalese relations and friends maintained that their Customs and Traditions were solely Sinhalese. Of course I have since found out that many of these are shared. For example the Rites of Passage for teenage girls are almost identical. The Patini Cult celebrations especially the 7 Milk Mothers are not Buddhist Celebrations, but seem to me to hark back to the Yamnaya or Vedic customs. Now I know this is from an outside perspective and I am quite willing to be persuaded of other opinions, preferably backed up with real evidence. What is very puzzling to me is how the Hindu Religion and Caste System managed to take root in the South. It would be interesting to compare the DNA of Balangoda Man with the oldest specimens of Humans in India, however trying to find a non partisan Geneticist/Archaeologist in any part of India and Sri Lanka is difficult.
                  Best regards

                  • 3
                    0

                    LS
                    The Patini cult among Tamils is virtually absent outside Batticaloa-Amparai. The source is Kerala I think. Tamilnadu has no significant Patini cult, despite the ‘story of the anklet’ (Silapathikaram) being a highly celebrated classic.
                    The Sinhalese wedding ritual is much closer to the Malayali ritual than to the Tamil ritual.
                    The caste system came with the immigrants and with each caste the gods, rituals and beliefs specific to the community. Buddhism could not destroy any.
                    Emphasis on language started with identity issues and suspicion of discrimination.
                    People have spoken each language for as long as two millennia, but that was no issue. Where they lived in close proximity there was bilingualism and linguistic exchanges.

                  • 5
                    3

                    LS,
                    I think the problem would be solved if one could find a “pure” Sinhalese or Tamil to check their genetics. But there ain’t any such animal. Look at this Reverend himself. His Portuguese surname gives him away as most likely from the Negombo to Chilaw coastal belt, populated by relatively recent arrivals from South India. There are still people in those areas who speak Tamil at home but identify as Sinhalese. Prof. Hoole will tell you that SJ isn’t quite as pure as he is .
                    The Pattini cult, unsurprisingly, is also of South Indian origin.
                    Since they don’t look any different, it’s probably a case of the same people speaking two different languages.
                    “however trying to find a non partisan Geneticist/Archaeologist in any part of India and Sri Lanka is difficult.” True.
                    But there are people who try, Try Raj Somadeva on YouTube. The only problem (for you) is that, though he usually avoids nationalist BS, his discourses are in Sinhala.

                  • 4
                    6

                    Hello Scot,

                    It may be difficult for a European to comprehend the magnitude of caste. Since you like stories, I will give you one. One of my friends studied in the UK. Her roommate was a Jain. The Jain imported her silverware specifically from India, because she was concerned that it would be tainted with meat. Meanwhile, my friend (who is an SB) occasionally went clubbing and got drunk. So if people like Old Vegetable tell you that caste has any value to SB’s, it is factually incorrect.

                    • 0
                      0

                      I suppose that story too, like the one about the Wellawatta bank teller, must be taken with a kilo of salt…..

                    • 5
                      3

                      Lester,
                      You are absolutely Right on the MONEY!!??
                      EXCEPT, WHEN THEY WANT TO GET MARRIED, (thru’ Matrimonial Advertisement or/and earnestly seeking the quest of the Magul KAPUWA) WANT TO ASCERTAIN THEIR STATUS WHETHER “THE SEAT AT THE WEDDING” – IS OF EQUAL STATUS!!?? NOTHING WRONG WITH THAT AT ALL, ASCERTAIN Marital Harmony and Progeny!!?? NOT ONLY “PORUWA SEATED” POSITION and “PARI PASU” and THEREAFTER DURING “COPULATION Position” too, which is of utmost Importance!?? What for the Telling?? As the
                      memorable Portuguese the 400-Year-old Colonisers of Sri Lanka would normally Lament at such ‘Impasse’!!? NEVER MIND, that’s all in the Pursuit of Happy contended Life INCLUSIVE of much coveted R&R and Happy Family Life unto eternity and Bliss!!??

                    • 5
                      3

                      Dear Rev .Lester,
                      “It may be difficult for a European to comprehend the magnitude of caste.”
                      “The Jain imported her silverware specifically from India, because she was concerned that it would be tainted with meat.”
                      What has this got to with caste?
                      Perhaps the good Rev. Lester is unaware that Jainism is a religion, not a caste.
                      Jews use only Kosher items. I suppose Rev. Lester thinks they are casteist too?
                      🤣🤣🤣🤣

                    • 1
                      0

                      Hello Lester,
                      My Sister is a Vegetarian and would not thole the idea of buying Utensils or Crockery that may have been tainted with Meat or Fish. When she goes into a Cafe or Restaurant she checks that if anything is fried, that they use different Oil, Containers and Utensils for Vegetarian Food. She will only purchase Tins, Jars or Packets of food items that have the Vegetarian Logo/Symbol.
                      This is typical Vegetarian behaviour and nothing to do with Caste. People like me (non Vegetarian) cannot see what the fuss is about, but for my Sister, and others of her ilk, it is extremely important.
                      Best regards

                    • 0
                      0

                      Scot,

                      “This is typical Vegetarian behaviour and nothing to do with Caste.”

                      Most Jains are vegetarians. The vegetarian aspect comes directly from “ahimsa” (non-violence). How strongly a Jain follows ahimsa depends on their caste. The caste directly impacts the diet.

                  • 0
                    0

                    // Sri Lankan Sinhalese and Sri Lankan Tamils have more in common Genetically and Historically //
                    Difficult to prove genetic similarity because stupidity is not an inherited trait.

                • 4
                  4

                  OC,
                  .
                  He will be at a loss for words. Or would that be available under ChatGPT?

                  Reverend Lester’s attitude I assume is rare these days. He does not think before leap.
                  Whatever Reverend Lester would do is contrary to the facts. Why? Is that because he is working for IT ? Does it have to do with “his self-proclaimed high IQ level”? Or the fact that he has Asperger’s syndrome?
                  Characteristics of Asperger’s Syndrome

                  Social difficulties
                  Inappropriate social interactions
                  Intense focus
                  Sensory sensitivities
                  Speech differences
                  Unusual body language
                  Very strong and particular interests
                  Hypersensitivity
                  Lack of adherence to social rules

                  Tbd

              • 9
                7

                Jester Aka Rev Dr. P J Fernando. Short and sweet. The language policy and other policies of the DMK brought in lots of peace, secularism and not the Hindutva or Islamic extremism that is found in many north Indian states and prosperity to the state of Tamil Nadu, where the standard of living has vastly improved for everyone and again unlike north India caste discrimination despite being there is vastly improved again. This is the same for the other four Southern states. They are mainly the engine drivers of India’s development. The standard of living in these 4 southern states is very similar now to Thailand or Vietnam. On the other hand, look at most of North India, especially the Hindi belt, the opposite with their Hindi only language policy. Standard of living largely like sub–Saharan Africa, other than is small industrial pockets, economy stagnated, caste and religious extremism rife and with huge population growth.

                • 7
                  5

                  It has been found out 94% of the population hardly leave Tamil Nadu to live elsewhere and if they leave 90% of the 6% largely move to the neighbouring South Indian states. As per 2011 statistics 94% live in Tamil Nadu/Puducherry. 3.06% in Karnataka mainly in Bangalore and around Kolar an ethnically Tamil predominating area of south Karnataka, 1.03% in Andhra and .74% in Kerala. Only around 1.22% of them have ventured further north to live and work. So why in the world do they have to be burdened with learning Hindi when 98.78% of them do not need to. The 1-2% of Tamils who need to learn Hindi for living and working out of South India will do so and the other 98.78% of them need not be burdened with learning a language that they will hardly use at all in their lives and can spend their time learning other more useful things that will help them. On the other hand, millions of North Indians, Bengali and other Northeast Indians are migrating into the five southern states for employment it is they who now have to learn the local Dravidian languages.

                • 4
                  8

                  Rohan aka Sharma,

                  I don’t know why you are spamming with two ID’s.

                  in India, the Brahmins were overrepresented in the civil service. In Sri Lanka, the Tamils were overrepresented. After the British left, the racist DMK chased the Brahmins, like the mother of Kamala Harris and the Google CEO, out of the country. In Sri Lanka, the Vellalar used the low caste LTTE to try to keep their privileges.

                  In Tamil Nadu, you have Tamil only language policy. In Sri Lanka, you had Sinhala-Only.

                  In Tamil Nadu, reservation. In Sri Lanka, standardization.

                  Everything that SL Tamils call “racist” happened in TN, except the race riots. But the SL Tamils (Vellalar) wanted a separate state in the 1930’s (GG Ponnambalam & others), so the race riot did not cause the civil war.

                  The reason for the civil war in Sri Lanka has nothing to do with Sinhala-Buddhism. Unlike in TN, the SB’s did not chase away minorities. The reason for the civil war has to do with RAW arming various Tamil militant groups and a stupid woman named CBK letting the war drag on for 20 years.

                  • 2
                    4

                    (Part I)
                    Lester,
                    A. “Everything that SL Tamils call “racist” happened in TN, except the race riots. But the SL Tamils (Vellala) wanted a separate state in the 1930’s (GG Ponnambalam & others), so the race riot did not cause the civil war.”
                    B. The reason for the civil war has to do with RAW arming various Tamil militant groups and a stupid woman named CBK letting the war drag on for 20 years.

                    Utter Falsehood, NO claim for any (2-State or 3- State federation GGP made in 1930’s except Equal representation in Parliament, ensure the Majority didn’t Playout the Minority without consent of all in Parliament!!?)
                    From where did you extract this fancy story!!??
                    I’m asking this question, because for you to enable this ‘DISBOLICAL LIE’, YOU HAVE CONVENIENTLY as material fact (to suit your framework for arguing YOUR case) FORGOTTEN or Suppressed an INTRINSIC PART of Sri Lankan History of the latter part of SL Colonial, Legislative Assembly History!!?? “THE MANUFACTURED HISTORY PROPOUNDED” doesn’t Latter-day British Colonial Rule, DONOUGHMORE COMMISSION ENACTMENTS and about the same time declaring the suggested implementation of a 3 (THREE) State CEYLONESE Federated STATE, either Dominion Status or otherwise within the British Commonwealth!!??
                    ((TBC)

                  • 2
                    2

                    (Part II)
                    (North Western and Eastern Province Enclave, – Tamils, KANDA-UDA Rata – Kandy, Matale, Badulla (UVA), Ruwanpura (‘South-western Slopes’) areas as Kandyan Sinhalese Enclave) and The Rest of the Island, South Western, Deep South and South-East as Sinhalese Enclave prior to Independence, by NONE other than SWRDB, the latter-day architect of Sinhala Only Policy to capture POWER and become Prime Minister, with the TACIT support of the “Sinhala Maha Sabha” and “Pancha Maha Balavegaya” – Ardent Sinhala Buddhist organisations!!??
                    Now you know and realise the architects SEEDING the DIVISION!!??
                    The SINGLE AND ONLY REASON THE PLOT FAILED WAS BECAUSE OF THE TAMILS, OF THE JAFFNA YMCA YOUTH Organisation, WHO THWARTED THAT EFFORT OF SWRDB 0 as they wanted a UNITED Sri Lanka – NOT DIVIDED!?
                    The ball SEEMS is back in ‘your court’, and you’re invited to CONTINUE the play, hopefully, without displaying you ignorance of relevant History!!!???
                    YOU ARE WELCOME!!??

                • 2
                  4

                  etable tell you that caste has any value to SB’s, it is factually incorrect.

                  Reply

                  Mahila / November 11, 2024
                  1 0
                  Lester,
                  You are absolutely Right on the MONEY!!??
                  EXCEPT, WHEN THEY WANT TO GET MARRIED, (thru’ Matrimonial Advertisement or/and earnestly seeking the quest of the Magul KAPUWA) WANT TO ASCERTAIN THEIR STATUS WHETHER “THE SEAT AT THE WEDDING” – IS OF EQUAL STATUS!!?? NOTHING WRONG WITH THAT AT ALL, ASCERTAIN Marital Harmony and Progeny!!?? NOT ONLY “PORUWA SEATED” POSITION and “PARI PASU” and THEREAFTER DURING “COPULATION Position” too, which is of utmost Importance!?? What for the Telling?? As the
                  memorable Portuguese the 400-Year-old Colonisers of Sri Lanka would normally Lament at such ‘Impasse’!!? NEVER MIND, that’s all in the Pursuit of Happy contended Life INCLUSIVE of much coveted R&R and Happy Family Life unto eternity and Bliss!!??

              • 3
                3

                “………the DMK has KEPT ONLY TAMIL AS the OFFICIAL LANGUAGE!!?? All SL Tamils who complain about ‘Sinhala-Only” need to look in the mirror.”!!
                Look in the mirror for what!!?? Utterly STUPID it seems!!?? Because what is happening in India need not be replicated in Sri Lanka and also TRUE, vice versa!?

          • 6
            6

            So, that’s your real name, is it?

            • 8
              4

              Does this ring a bell?
              “Reverend Dr PJ Fernando – Currently Priest of the Archdiocese of Birmingham, UK. Besides his priestly studies he obtained his DPhil from University of Cambridge UK, in Computer Vision and Artificial Intelligent Systems in 2004, “

              • 1
                1

                oc
                “his DPhil from University of Cambridge “
                Cambridge does not offer DPhil degrees.
                Oxford does.
                Also PhDs are not awarded in narrow areas. The PhD is at most identified by the department or more often the faculty in which work was conducted.

                • 2
                  4

                  SJ,
                  Maybe that’s fake. But the reverend does exist:
                  https://www.birminghamdiocese.org.uk/rev-fr-prem-jayalath-fernando

                  • 1
                    4

                    Hello OC/SJ,
                    The plot thickens! A very modern Church with the Manse next door, by the look of things. It’s much closer to Oxford than Cambridge.
                    From their EPSRC Website “Autonomous systems powered by artificial intelligence will have a transformative impact on economy, industry and society as a whole. Our mission is to train cohorts with both theoretical, practical and systems skills in autonomous systems – comprising machine learning, robotics, sensor systems and verification- and a deep understanding of the cross-disciplinary requirements of these domains”.
                    Lester could have written this.
                    Looks like he is the University Chaplain at Oxford Brookes University.
                    Best regards

                    • 0
                      0

                      LS,
                      Very good Investigative submission

                • 1
                  0

                  SJ,

                  You are trying to explain Oxbridge to a guy who likely didn’t finish secondary school. And another guy from a fishing village is backing him. GL.

                • 0
                  0

                  SJ,
                  Must be a Bl___y FAKE!!??
                  Cannot blame the Reverend, because, from Birmingham it’s too difficult to discern what is OFFERED and NOT on OFFER from OXFORD and CAMDRIDGE!!?? He must have thought, just like back home in Sri Lanka, ANY “GOO THEL” WOULD WORK to provide the MYSTIFICATION required to prove the point, beyond any reasonable doubt in Sri Lankan style!!?? He must be of the same Ilk as the MYNAH and DONALD J TRUMP!!?? DJT’s recent utterances and success must have given BOOST and Impetus!??

          • 7
            0

            L
            The DMK has come a long way.
            It was hostile to imposing Hindi on Tamils up to the 1960s.
            In fact linguistic nationalism is much stronger in Karnataka, where one has to learn Kannada as a mandatory subject in school.
            In Tamilnadu one can go through the whole educational system without any knowledge of Tamil.
            *
            Tamilnadu is not at all a land of Tamil language fanatics.
            I would say much the same for Sinhalese attitude towards Sinhala in this country. The emotional upsurge is long gone.
            Our real official and business language is English. Progress in Swabasha education of the professions is near zero.
            Sad but true.

            • 4
              3

              “In Tamilnadu one can go through the whole educational system without any knowledge of Tamil.”

              The same can be said of Sri Lanka, including the university. Even in 1956, the “swabasha” was limited to public schools and the civil service. But if one wants to join the civil service in Tamil Nadu, he/she has to be fluent in Tamil only.

              “It was hostile to imposing Hindi on Tamils up to the 1960s.”

              I would not call it imposition. For economic development, it is better if everyone can speak a common language. 43% of Indians speak Hindi. India is still lagging China because of the casteist mindset. The DMK became popular because it opposed Brahmin dominance. The Brahmins chased out of TN went to places like Silicon Valley and became very successful. Just like the LTTE chased the Tamil intellectuals out of Sri Lanka.

              • 4
                4

                “In Tamilnadu one can go through the whole educational system without any knowledge of Tamil.”
                The same can be said of Sri Lanka, including the university”
                Did anyone claim that a knowledge of Tamil is essential for education in Sri Lanka?

                • 0
                  1

                  OC, you are right. Back when I was in Pera (class of 86/87), classes for Tamils ​​were held in English, not Tamil. No matter what your knowledge of the Tamil language was, you were entitled to lectures in English.

              • 0
                1

                Dear Readers,
                India is a subcontinent full of different languages, lifestyles and cultures WHILE the People’s Republic of China is not. Anyone with lack of knowledge to compare these two huge countries should really be laughed at.
                And again, one should not compare China’s development with India’s because the demographics of these two countries are worlds apart.
                I also believe that China is more developed than India because people’s attitudes are not affected by different cultures and lifestyles as is the case in the Indian subcontinent where different main languages ​​are spoken depending on the region they are from.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.