19 April, 2025

Blog

Unreal Priorities – Pointless Endeavours

By Upatissa Pethiyagoda

Dr. Upatissa Pethiyagoda

Two matters which have recently, entered popular discourse, have been (i) The much-overdue local government elections and (ii) The measures proposed to deal with the disastrous losses of crops, and vandalism of houses and property by marauding pests – monkeys, flying squirrels, peacocks, and wild boar, and porcupines. Elephants are in a different class but causing spectacularly heavy losses of lives, crops and dwellings.

Much of the theatrics have been about dates for elections, symbols and party colours assigned, postal votes, and handling of deposits already made etc. Much of these are merely cosmetic matters of little concern or consequence for the voter. Much more relevant would have been, to assess how well these bodies have met the objectives that were expected of them. They have now been in operation for more than a decade. This gives ample time to determine how adequately they have met their expected responsibilities.

One must remember that the major justification for the introduction of the extra layers of power, created by the 13th Constitutional Amendment. This was to provide easier access to government agencies, and for a simpler and more efficient service delivery. This major change was for the so-called “decentralization of power”. Can anyone honestly deny failure in the hoped for change by bringing power closer to the periphery, thus leading to improved service in providing a faster, less exacting, and better delivery of State services to the public? Their colossal failure, has been a massive cost to the taxpayer.

What we regularly see on TV, are disgusting examples of gross irresponsibility. Expensive buildings, generally abandoned or left half done and unoccupied, pot- holed roads, broken bridges, blocked irrigation channels and much else, bear eloquent testimony to the utter failure of those inexcusable lapses. All that remains are weed-covered and cynically grandiose wrecks.       

The majority are appalled at this mere imposition of additional layers of corruption, crime and reckless expense. Many see this as an added burden of conspicuous extravagance, with no visible change for the better. Despite this, the last government, saw it proper to double the cadres of these useless bodies to some unconscionable 8,000, – nearly double the existing number. In nature too, pests generally can multiply at huge speed.

This extravagance can only be matched by the extraordinary speed of the “Jackpot payments,” to some 70 odd politicians, mostly as urgent “compensation” (revealed as totaling some Rs,1,300,000/=) to repair their vandalized mansions, by rightly angered mobs, swiftly assembled and readied as response for a brutal assault by the Armed Forces on the departing “Aragalaya” from Galle Face, with suspiciously synchronized speed.

The second abomination is the proposed “census” of monkeys, flying squirrels (dandu-lenas). More ridiculously, also peacocks and porcupines, all of whom it is presumed, will oblige by emerging from their abodes and burrows, to stay still to be counted, within the government’s stipulated five minutes.

We are told that already some of the required Forms, costing a cool seventy million or some such, have been distributed. But there are many more situations where more pitfalls are likely to dim any hopes of providing useful information.

The futility of this nonsense, particularly in the monkey and peacock sectors, is easy to see. It is astonishing to note that this futile exercise is claimed to be “Scientific”. Contrarily, the hugely obvious defects in this type of clowning, have been pointed out in many instances.

The very large numbers of variables impacting on reliability, would validly argue against the use of such shabby and false data for any useful purpose, without seriously compromising its value. Unfortunately, coming so soon after the ‘wasa visa caper’ will laughable, and so soon after the much c ting monkeys and the natural shy ‘dandulenas’ or the tunnel living and nocturnal porcupines.

How would we seem in the eyes of fellow scientists outside our country? We have a right and duty to place on record, to protest at the damage to our peer colleagues else by the desecration of our accepted stature. Coming so soon after the ‘Wasa-visa” caper, costing a virtual collapse of our agricultural system, we have this added mess to combat.

We must remember that the futile attempts to effect an acceptable population number, for the largest terrestrial inhabiting the planet, the elephant, it is unlikely that smaller and more agile monkeys and peacocks will present themselves for the planned five minute census. Even if they provide a perfectly accurate number, accurate to the last monkey, (exempting the hiding, legendary Hanuman) what precisely do we do with the number?

Food for thought, surely.

Latest comments

  • 4
    0

    ” Even if they provide a perfectly accurate number , accurate to the last
    Monkey…………..what precisely do we do with the number ? ” Just
    visualise A K D is in the opposition , you got the answer .Secondly ,
    Monkeys and peacocks have no votes , no need to give them anything
    back . Suppose the time spent on them is spent on helpless and
    abandoned aged people ? They will come and surround the parliament
    when nothing seen to be done ! Another very dangerous possibility is ,
    as everybody knows it , Monkeys are clever than RAJAS in stealing ,
    I M F and the W B got to be on day and night alert !

    • 6
      1

      I agree.

  • 7
    1

    I wonder whether the author could see the wider picture of the damage affecting almost a vast area and number of people in this country. While it should not be the #1 priority of the govt, damage to crops that give peasants and farmers their main income had been a major issue known for a long time only to the people living outside air conditioned rooms. Approximate estimates of one third of crops eaten by the animals surely is a top priority for those who depend 100% on their harvest. I have no knowledge about animal behaviour patterns but am not too sure how you do such a survey or one in five minutes either. However, I understand such a survey is quite important to find out a lasting solution for hundreds of thousands of people who struggle to put food on the table on a daily basis.

  • 9
    0

    Dr P, as someone with a PhD myself, it’s disappointing to see you mock the work of scientists outside of your field. This kind of thing is all too common in Lanka, where we saw people with political science degrees dispensing medical advice on the media and medical doctors (and only MBBS at that) running research institutions without a shred of wet lab experience or providing input on agrarian policy. I don’t mean for this to be an ad hominem attack, but even you must admit you’re not exactly young. We can’t just sit by forever foregoing scientific solutions to everything because the public doesn’t understand the process (and clearly neither do you). Have you paused to consider the complete lack of respect you appear to have for statisticians? Is sampling a totally alien concept to you? We draw conclusions about populations from limited samples all the time- we do it in every field. Even in my areas as a pharma scientist we run bench experiments on cells and tissue explants to make conclusions on a drug’s behaviour in a larger population. To write such things as “wild animals coming all coming out for five minutes” with a doctorate is way beneath you. Shame. If the issue here is a scientific one, spend some time understanding what methodology is being used to extrapolate the sample into a proper census and criticize that.

  • 4
    0

    JVP-NPP MUST COUNT THE NUMBER MONKEYS IN PARLIAMENT BEFORE COUNTING THE MONKEYS IN SRILANAKA.

    • 3
      0

      Well said paragon
      Monkeys will do a better job than some of the parasites sitting as MPs
      RN

      • 4
        0

        RN
        I thought that most of those parasites are not MPs anymore.

  • 1
    7

    I think the author is mistaken. It is not that difficult to find out these numbers. the Transgender monkeys and peacockhens will appear almost immediately . Then from that we can gather the rest are straight.

    There are no reason to abandon these endeavors. Its not like there is any more pressing issues in paradise.

    • 5
      1

      a14455, thanks for that information. Now I know, the monkey from Wilpattu, appearing immediately is a TG.
      In that case they should consider removing the other nut for a complete transformation. Okay, so it’s not infection but transformation. Explains the increase in libido minus a nut.

  • 4
    1

    Our new GoSL should act to prevent deforestation by preventing people trying to settle in areas where forests are being cleared. Encroachment of the
    wild animals areas by humans leads to unnecessary deaths and destruction.
    Should not the government promote VERTICAL FARMING in order to prevent further deforestation.
    GoSL should try to minimise agricultural wastage and food wastage by adopting the technical advances.
    I am not sure whether holding the Local Council elections are going to be beneficial to the public or to the CORRUPT politicians!
    Provincial Councils elections will only be of benefit if they have police and land powers and by reducing the number of Provincial Councils to FIVE and not NINE

    • 1
      1

      “Should not the government promote VERTICAL FARMING in order to prevent further deforestation.”
      It is at best good as an urban semi-urban strategy.
      It takes place inside, grows crops in stacked layers, and uses artificial growing systems such as hydroponics, aquaponics, or other methods of soilless agriculture.
      Will it suit us?
      Have you checked on performance? Not catching up either.
      [https://www.ars.usda.gov/oc/utm/vertical-farming-no-longer-a-futuristic-concept/#:~:text=However%2C%20vertical%20farming%20takes%20place,other%20methods%20of%20soilless%20agriculture.]

    • 2
      0

      Naman, I agree with you on the deforestation issue – the reason we are having such a lot of crop damage by wild animals is because of the destruction of their habitats. By committing to the 30 by 30 global call, i.e. to set aside 30% of land and sea as biodiverse, protected areas by 2030, Sri Lanka would not only commit itself to sustainable land/sea use and adequate habitat but also increase its value as a tourist destination.

      However accurate this monkey census might be, what is the point to it, as many on this forum have queried. Once they have the figures on the monkeys, is the government going to kill them, eat them or export them? Even though vertical farming would not be useful in rural Sri Lanka, the way forward would be protected agriculture – green houses, netting, electric fencing, etc. The money wasted on the census could have been better spent to provide loans/subsidies to farmers to invest in protected agriculture. The private sector could also pitch in as a CSR activity.

  • 4
    0

    One of my “Kadamandiya” comrades – Seelawathie visited me the day after the enumeration of “Monkeys”-(Rilavu) and told me what happened to her.

    The Grama Seva Niladhary visited in the evening and asked Seelawathie how many “Monkeys” (Rilavas) she counted on the previous day. Seelawathie’s answer was:

    “Yes. I counted and the number is one. I had only one “Monkey” a “Rilava” and two years back I sent him to a Middle East country. So, no more living on my property”.

    This is what happens when jokes are made freely available by our “Ministers”.

  • 2
    0

    In Thailand the coconut plantations are employing the monkeys to pluck the coconuts. Should the SL do the same?
    Monkeys are revered by Hindus and hence is a SENSITIVE topic to deal with. Our IMMEDIATE CLOSE
    big brother’s continuous WATCH.
    The conflict between Humans and wild life should be tackled thoughtfully by our GoSL. It is really sad to see unnecessary deaths of elephants and use of them on religious pretexts. In India the mechanical Elephants are being tried out during religious ceremonies. Temples and Viharas should not be keeping CHAINED elephants in their premises.
    In our new parliament we still have few crooked parasites/monkeys/donkeys/druggies/gold snatcher/dons!!!

    • 3
      0

      Naman,
      “In Thailand the coconut plantations are employing the monkeys to pluck the coconuts.”
      Yes, and in Indonesia too.There are many things that other countries do in agriculture that aren’t done here. For example, both Vietnam and India produce cooking oil from rice bran. It is cheaper than coconut oil. We must forget our 2500 year old farming systems. This is the 21st century.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.