
By Ajith De Silva and Sumith Doluweera –
Introduction
We would like to extend our gratitude to our colleagues for their well-argued piece on why Sri Lanka should not adopt nuclear energy. This is our opinion about the piece which was published in the Colombo Telegraph on January 27, 2025. Some of the authors we have had the pleasure to work with on other nationally important projects. As physicists, we have always been driven by the pursuit of new and reliable sources of energy, and we believe it is essential for us to consider all options, including nuclear energy, rather than ruling it out entirely.
Sri Lanka’s Energy Challenge
Sri Lanka faces a unique energy challenge. Unlike many other nations, we have no fossil fuel reserves such as petroleum products or no coal, oil, or natural gas of our own. While hydropower has been a crucial part of our energy mix, its potential is reaching its limits. Solar and wind energy, though promising, come with intermittency issues and cannot fully support a rapidly industrializing economy. If Sri Lanka is to realize its aspirations for economic growth and industrial advancement, we must ensure a stable, continuous power supply that can sustain large-scale manufacturing and technological progress. Nuclear energy is the only viable option to meet this demand while keeping emissions low.
Advancements in Nuclear Technology
The world’s energy landscape is evolving, and generating nuclear power has become safer and more efficient than ever before. Modern Small Modular Reactors (SMRs) with enhanced safety measures, significantly reduce the risks traditionally associated with nuclear energy. While concerns about costs, waste management, and the need for specialized expertise remain valid, ongoing technological advancements continue to address these challenges. Modern nuclear technologies, equipped with passive safety features, prevent catastrophic failures. In addition, advanced monitoring systems enhance operational efficiency. Moreover, SMRs offer more flexible and potentially cost-effective alternatives to traditional large-scale plants. With proper planning, international cooperation, and investment in local expertise, Sri Lanka can gradually build the foundation for a nuclear-ready future.
Addressing Public Concerns
The public should be informed about new nuclear energy technologies and safety measures through accurate scientific data and open public forums. Transparent communication fosters trust and provides a balanced understanding of both the potential benefits and risks of nuclear power.
While it is true that Sri Lanka currently lacks expertise in this field, this should not be a deterrent. Instead, it should motivate us to start building the necessary knowledge and skills to prepare for the future. By taking this proactive approach, Sri Lanka will be equipped with the expertise needed to implement nuclear energy safely and effectively when the time comes.
The Role of Nuclear Energy in a Balanced Energy Mix
The argument that renewable energy alone is sufficient overlooks a critical reality: an industrialized economy cannot function on solar and wind alone. Countries like France and the USA successfully integrate nuclear power with renewables to create a balanced, resilient energy mix. If Sri Lanka aspires to energy independence and economic progress, it must consider a diverse strategy that includes nuclear energy.
Rather than dismissing nuclear power outright, let us engage in an informed, science-driven discussion about how we can responsibly incorporate this technology into our energy portfolio. The future of energy is about adaptability and readiness. Should we not ensure that Sri Lanka is prepared?
Benefits of Nuclear Energy
Nuclear energy offers numerous advantages as a reliable, efficient, and environmentally friendly power source. It generates large amounts of electricity with a relatively small environmental footprint, producing minimal greenhouse gas emissions compared to fossil fuels. This makes nuclear power a key player in combating climate change and reducing air pollution.
Additionally, nuclear energy is highly efficient, as a small amount of uranium can produce vast amounts of energy through the process of nuclear fission. The underlying concept of this energy transformation is based on Einstein’s mass-energy equivalence equation which explains how a small amount of mass can be converted into a tremendous amount of energy.
Global Energy Trends and Historical Context
Global energy demands are projected to increase significantly in the coming decades. By 2050, experts predict that the world may need to produce two to three times more energy than it does today to support a growing population and expanding global economies. In this context, advanced nuclear technologies, such as Small Modular Reactors (SMRs), could play a crucial role in meeting these demands by providing a safe, efficient, and sustainable energy solution for the future.
Nuclear technology was first developed in the 1940s, and initially focused on weapon production during World War II. However, by the 1950s, attention shifted to the peaceful use of nuclear fission for power generation. On June 27, 1954, the world’s first nuclear power station, located in Obninsk, Russia, was connected to the Moscow grid, marking the beginning of nuclear energy’s role as a source of electricity for humanity.
Lessons from Past Incidents
Despite its many advantages, nuclear energy has faced challenges, particularly with major accidents. The most significant of these occurred in Japan at the Fukushima Daiichi plant following a natural disaster. A massive earthquake triggered a tsunami that disabled the power supply and cooling systems of three reactors, leading to a nuclear accident. This event underscored the need for robust safety measures, especially in regions prone to natural disasters, and highlighted the ongoing importance of improving nuclear technology and disaster preparedness.
Is It Time for Sri Lanka to Embrace Nuclear Energy?
Despite public concerns, modern nuclear technology has established a strong track record of safety and efficiency. Advances in reactor design, coupled with rigorous safety protocols, have significantly reduced risks, making nuclear power one of the safest forms of energy generation. Furthermore, continuous improvements in waste management and recycling techniques are effectively addressing longstanding concerns about radioactive waste.
With the goal of tripling global nuclear capacity by 2050, over 20 countries have committed to this ambitious target, recognizing the critical role nuclear energy plays in reducing carbon emissions and meeting the world’s growing energy demands. Nations across the world—including those with similar economic conditions and geographic constraints—are acknowledging the value of nuclear energy in achieving energy security and sustainability. Currently, 65 nuclear reactors are under construction worldwide, including two in Bangladesh, to meet future energy demands.
Given these global developments, shouldn’t Sri Lanka begin preparing for a nuclear-ready future as well?
Conclusion
In conclusion, while nuclear energy has long been a vital component of the global energy mix, ongoing advancements—such as the development of Small Modular Reactors (SMRs)—are positioning it as a key solution to meet the world’s growing energy demands. To fully realize its potential, it is crucial to continue enhancing safety protocols and driving technological innovations to maximize benefits while minimizing risks.
Ultimately, the decision to adopt nuclear energy should be rooted in informed, evidence-based discussions. By weighing the risks against the undeniable benefits, Sri Lanka can chart a path toward a secure, sustainable, and economically resilient energy future. This approach not only aligns with global trends but also ensures that Sri Lanka is not left behind in the pursuit of advanced, reliable energy solutions.
*Dr. Ajith DeSilva is an experimental physicist specializing in nanotechnology and renewable energy. A dedicated philanthropist and activist, he helps empower underserved communities in Sri Lanka through education and housing initiatives. Passionate about sustainability, he advocates for eco-friendly solutions to address environmental challenges.
*Dr. Sumith Doluweera is a computational physicist specializing in theoretical condensed matter physics. A dedicated educator committed to advancing science education and promoting equal access to learning. A data enthusiast passionate about sustainable, environmentally friendly solutions, leveraging data-driven decision-making and emerging technologies to tackle complex problems.
a14455 / February 15, 2025
lol a country that abandoned a windpower generation over a few birds will embrace Nuclear Energy ? pfft
/
SJ / February 15, 2025
It is not a few birds.
It is wrecking a bird sanctuary.
Will you respond similarly if a ‘beneficial’ project wrecking Yala is scrappped for such reason.
People are badly affected in Mannar by the wind power projects. Sadly the Tamil politicians do not care.
/
Mallaiyuran / February 15, 2025
“It is wrecking a bird sanctuary
Really?
Really Really?
You’re an Einstein in inventing lame duck excuses on other’s actions, but completely blind in the farts you are sitting and releasing, don’t you?
Is that anything worse than Rishard and Old Royal Rowdies swallowing more than 5,000 acres of land in that area?
How about Mattala Airport? The Evil Emperor dried paddy because pilots of international flights are fearing to bring their planes there, while the loss of conservation land and refuge birds’ lives are some other questions.
Can I talk with you about the Suriya Wewa – unwanted Stadium?
How about Colombo Pong Cing, which was not started after an environmental study, and it has affected the West side fishing families, already.
Didn’t the Evil Emperor end up writing off 5 villages’ land and giving the Hangbangtota Harbor to big bully brother China, because he promised to take back the Colombo Pong Cing Sea from China in the 2015 parliamentary election? Now they are both gone.
Did you ever write a question here that “Why does China have to build a refinery and pollute our air when it is building it for its export purpose”?
That is not all, but what is the use of writing the rest of it. Your dedicated Dhasanism (slavery) SLFP Gurus cannot accept your masters’ fart as fart, could you?
/
SJ / February 15, 2025
Read comment below by Mani.
It may tell you the limitations of the stuff between your ears.
/
Mallaiyuran / February 18, 2025
You say Old Rowdy’s projects were certified by the money (who seems to be a new Munthanai holder), for environmental compliance? We know your qualification, (in a mechanical school a “Karl Marx communism diploma” in the third century). Does your new Munthanai, money vouching include Mattala Airport too?
You’re an absolute dumb, aren’t you? Where do you find any connection between my comments and money’s comments? Could you reprint any of the money’s sentences that reply to any of the sentences in my comment? If you have understood his comment, and mine, start to correct him, picking points from mine.
If you have found anything wrong with my comment, bring it so we can talk. If you hide only in Munthanai, leave it, but you still wear Amude, we can discuss.
Rowdy Old carried out all the projects without calculating financial calculations (White Elephants), but now you are trying to escape, indicating he did perfect environmental costs too?
It is not unusual for small countries, who are weak in resource abundance, to be ready to take on higher environmental costs to reward their citizens to earn a minimum income.
How is it that you and Sinhala Buddhist are seeing environmental destruction only in the projects coming to the North East. But why didn’t you apply for a claim for the ship that brought Nitric acid and rated as the largest coastline damage in world history?
/
Mani / February 15, 2025
SJ, you are absolutely right. The wind power projects are not just wrecking any bird sanctuary but the most important flyway for migrant birds in and out of Sri Lanka. This includes flocks of hundreds of flamingoes – in a more enlightened country the economic potential for tourism based on these kinds of iconic species would have been properly assessed. These economic benefits far outweigh the energy produced by a few windmills! If the NPP regime lets the Chinese invest in an oil refinery in Hambantota, we can forget about Yala and Bundala as well. When will Sri Lanka realise that its greatest economic asset is its natural wealth?
As for these ‘eco-friendly” physicist authors here lobbying for nuclear reactors, sounds like the Russian or French nuclear interests are at work once again!!
/
SJ / February 15, 2025
M
Thanks
A one-man nuclear lobby was pretty aggressive in the late 1970s to early 1980s. Luckily a government appointed committee killed the suggestion. Among important considerations were the lack of industrial discipline and aversion for safety regulations.
That was also a time when moderately radioactive stainless steel cutlery was sold on the pavements of Bombay.
/
Mani / February 16, 2025
SJ, I met a French physicist who worked for a French nuclear company by chance in the early 1980s. That one-man nuclear lobby you mention was their poster boy. They were itching to get their hands on a Sri Lankan contract at that time. Bet they are back in business once again!
/
SJ / February 16, 2025
Small world!
/
a14455 / February 15, 2025
I am sorry but this is nonsense. There is already the Lankajiva and many other wind farms in the area. and this is the cost of living in a tropical country.
there are many animals everywhere. That does not mean the people should have to live with power cuts.
Any yes sure if Yala is a suitable place for power generation I would agree to it. We cant protect every gecko and bird that decides to fly or live in the island.
/
SJ / February 16, 2025
Your environmental concerns seem amazing to me!
Already there are protests by the people about the existing wind farms about the harm done by them to their livelihoods.
You may happily add person to gecko and bird in the closing sentence.
/
a14455 / February 17, 2025
So it turns out it was not the mannar bird but the Puttlam Donkeys who made sure the wind power generation project does not get done. The NPP clowns tried to renegotiate the already negotiated project and the Adanis called their bluff.
I hope this is not the future of the contry !!!
/
SJ / February 17, 2025
Do you seriously believe that Adani is not a swindler who finances the BJP?
A future without Adani is a blessing.
/
Lester / February 18, 2025
“A future without Adani is a blessing.”
Adani is definitely a criminal. But Old Rubbish Can wants Adani to finance the construction of a submarine cable between SL and TN.
/
Lester / February 18, 2025
*installation, not construction
/
a14455 / February 18, 2025
every business man is somewhat a swindler. it will be a long wait to find someone who is not. you can keep counting the blessings.
/
Mallaiyuran / February 18, 2025
Without any doubt, I am sure Sinhala Buddhism is angry with Modi because of a couple of issues. He made White Flag Murderer’s son-in-law get caught in the hotel parking lot with the commission he demanded and got. They watched and caught UNP-SLFP’s 4/21 Jihadi war. Even Ayman al-Zawahiri was caught because of the Jihadi War 4/21. Adani is bilinear, accounts are reasonably black and white. Old Rowdy is a billionaire. Only some media rating his position as between 30-50 billion. Modi’s government never known to pay Old Rowdy any commission, with many other donations, they paid a free hand $4.5B Loan to Gothapayal, when forced People’s Bankrupted by importing Chinese poop, without any study of environmental evaluation.
/
SJ / February 17, 2025
This is a nasty remark about a people.
The people in the vicinity of the wind turbine plants had been protesting and there was an extensive article in the Daily Mirror with evidence of harm.
You can be a little more civil in references to people I hope.
/
a14455 / February 18, 2025
The Puttlan donkey was a reference to the JVP not the people of Puttlam, lol
/
Mallaiyuran / February 18, 2025
This is a nasty remark about a people.
Who is that a people?
Got an opportunity to take a bath with soap and water? You were feeling your smell and wanted relief out of it? You won’t miss them because you want to survive without a single comment to communicate. Probably after this bath you may be feeling that you are awfully clean, shiny? But still your out-bursting fart is smelling though! The life of a paramilitary is not easy to wash, though Deva’s expiration date has long passed, and he needs to be ridden. So, the gentleman who rolls in the mud is still practicing the Siri Ma O, Old Rowdies’ election art!
/
old codger / February 15, 2025
I think some very clever authors should write an article about the effect of monkeys on nuclear reactors.
/
LankaScot / February 16, 2025
Hello OC,
One Contributor on Academia.edu suggested that the Hindus of Ramayana time wiped out the IVC with a Nuclear Bomb. Maybe it was Hanuman.
Best regards
/
old codger / February 16, 2025
LS,
“Hindus of Ramayana time wiped out the IVC with a Nuclear Bomb”
Would that be the famous Praveen Mohan?
/
LankaScot / February 16, 2025
Hell OC,
If I remember right yes, he has some very strange theories.Youtube abounds with them.
Best regards
/
SJ / February 17, 2025
LS
You accidentally stumble into something in archaeology or history, you have had it.
Tamil is steadily getting centuries more ancient to the joy of some Tamil fanatics.
/
Mallaiyuran / February 18, 2025
“Tamil is steadily getting centuries more ancient, to the joy of some Tamil fanatics. “
You are a chronic case, man.
Tamil fanatics?
Comedy Thamai! Whose dictionary you use? Badiyudeen or Siri Ma O”s? Even Solomon West Ridgeway Dias, the Christian Sinhala Buddhist said, after having introduced the Sinhala Only, “Tamils are proud of the ancient nature of their Language. We don’t have a problem of recognizing that. So we offer them Special usage rights”.
PM Modi named his Introduction of India with Thiruvaluvar’s name. He had told i parliament that Tamil is proud property of India and all Indian should try to learn it. There are some North Indian MPs took it as their propaganda topic. They kept persuading outside central government to request northerners to learn Tamils, insisting that is is not just another Language.
You, the CT clown only, may be having problem in accepting that.
/
Mani / February 16, 2025
Coal power plant in Norochcholai, wind farms in Mannar, oil refinery in Hambantota, oil refinery and nuclear plants in Trincomalee. Mining of mineral sands in Trincomalee, Batticaloa and Mannar. Is poor Jaffna missing out? Add the land bridge from India with trucks polluting the highway from Mannar to Colombo, compounding the already existing cross border pollution brought by the northeast monsoon winds every Nov-Feb from India and our very own domestic air pollution. Add also the garbage strewn by Indian truckers to the garbage already strewn by our wonderful citizens. Clean Sri Lanka, anyone? A rich country and a beautiful life? Why should people and animals in Mannar, Hambantota or Trincomalee districts have to pay for the over-consumption of energy in Colombo and Gampaha districts? When tourist revenues have fallen and the island unlivable, our ever resilient citizens will keep migrating abroad and sending remittances to their relatives dying of respiratory diseases, lung cancer and radiation here. Nobody seems to have heard of comparative economic advantage or the type of development that will make a difference to Sri Lanka, such as sustainable tourism and non-polluting industries. Who cares? In the long run we are all dead, right?
/
a14455 / February 17, 2025
Do you really want power generation in Jaffna? Why would you want it in such a populus area ?
/
SJ / February 17, 2025
Not all of Jaffna is populous. In fact it is overall less populous than it as 40 years ago.
Situation of power plants cannot be blind to matters of environmental and public well being.
/
SJ / February 17, 2025
M
“Is poor Jaffna missing out?”
You forgot that the first cement factory was in northern Jaffna. It exacted a price on pubic health.
/