By Mohamed Harees –

Lukman Harees
Israel has gone to the polls amid war, occupation, and international scrutiny. The election is being treated by many foreign commentators as a possible turning point: if Benjamin Netanyahu loses power, perhaps Israel will become more moderate, restrain its settler movement, ease its assault on Gaza, and return to some version of peace diplomacy. That assumption is foolhardy.
Netanyahu is responsible for grave crimes and must be held accountable. But it is a dangerous myth to believe that his removal alone would end the genocide in Gaza, dismantle the occupation, or restore Palestinian rights. The deeper problem is not merely one man. It is the normalization, across large parts of Israeli society and its media, of the idea that Palestinian life is expendable, Palestinian sovereignty is unnecessary, and overwhelming force against Palestinians is justified. A change of prime minister may change Israel’s tone. It will not, by itself, change Palestine.
The election is not a referendum on Palestinian rights. The campaign is dominated by questions that matter intensely to Israelis: Netanyahu’s corruption trial, judicial reform, military failures surrounding October 7, ultra-Orthodox conscription, the economy, and the future of Israeli democracy. These are serious issues. But Palestinian statehood, the occupation, settlement expansion, and the rights of Palestinians under Israeli control are not the central moral questions of the election.
This absence is revealing. Palestinians in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza do not vote in Israeli elections, even though Israeli governments control many of the conditions of their lives: movement, housing, land, water, security, and political freedom. Israelis can elect a new government without Palestinians having any meaningful say over the power that governs them. An election can therefore produce a new coalition while leaving the fundamental structure intact: military rule over Palestinians, expanding settlements, and the denial of Palestinian self-determination.
Netanyahu is guilty, but not alone
Netanyahu has led Israel through a war in Gaza marked by mass killing, displacement, destruction, and severe humanitarian deprivation. He has defended that campaign internationally, resisted meaningful limits, and led a coalition containing ministers who have openly promoted expulsion, annexation, and permanent domination. The International Criminal Court has issued an arrest warrant for him over alleged war crimes, and the International Court of Justice is considering genocide allegations brought by South Africa. None of this should be minimized. Netanyahu bears immense responsibility.
But the myth is that he alone authored the catastrophe. The occupation did not begin with him. Settlement expansion did not begin with him. The blockade of Gaza did not begin with him. The political assumption that Palestinians can be indefinitely denied equality and sovereignty did not begin with him. Netanyahu inherited a system built on domination, intensified it, and made it more extreme—but he did not create it alone.
Removing him may remove a uniquely polarizing and corrupt leader. It does not automatically remove the military doctrine, settlement bureaucracy, nationalist ideology, and public consent that sustain the system.
The opposition is not a liberation movement
Netanyahu’s leading challenger, Gadi Eisenkot, is often portrayed abroad as a moderate alternative. In some ways he is: he is less closely tied to the most extreme settler politicians and may be less chaotic in government. But on the central issue, the difference is narrow. Eisenkot rejects Palestinian statehood under his leadership. Like Netanyahu, he treats Israeli security as requiring continued military dominance and rejects the form of Palestinian sovereignty associated with a two-state solution. He has criticised some settlement projects, but he does not offer Palestinians equality, independence, or an end to occupation. That is why the election is unlikely to produce material change for Palestinians. The choice is not between occupation and freedom. It is between different forms of managing occupation.
Israeli society has normalised the unjustifiable
The most uncomfortable truth is that the war in Gaza has been sustained not only by Netanyahu’s government but by broad sections of Israeli society. Political leaders, media commentators, religious figures, military institutions, and many ordinary voters have not only defended it, but promoted it as well.
This does not mean every Israeli supports every act of the war, or that dissent does not exist. There are anti-occupation movements, human-rights organizations like BtSalem, Palestinian citizens of Israel, and Jewish Israelis who reject the war. But they remain politically marginal.Polling shows how deep the normalization runs. A majority of Jewish Israelis support keeping West Bank settlements under Israeli sovereignty. Support for a Palestinian state has fallen sharply, with recent polling finding that only about a third of centrist Jewish Israelis support Palestinian statehood.
The Jewish People Policy Institute found that 55 per cent of Jewish Israelis want all Jewish communities in the West Bank to remain under Israeli sovereignty, while support for strengthening control over Palestinians, expanding settlements, and possible annexation rose from 38 per cent in 2024 to 48 per cent in 2026. Support for a peace agreement and Palestinian statehood fell to 14 percent. These are not fringe views. They are mainstream positions. They show a society increasingly comfortable with permanent control over Palestinian land and people.
Dehumanisation makes genocide thinkable
Genocide does not become politically possible only through orders from above. It becomes possible when a society learns to see its victims as less human, less grievable, and less entitled to rights. In Israeli public discourse, Palestinians are often framed collectively as terrorists, security threats, human shields, or demographic dangers. This language allows Palestinian deaths to be treated as collateral damage, home destruction as military necessity, and starvation or displacement as unfortunate but unavoidable consequences of war.
Netanyahu has used and amplified such language. But it is bigger than him. It appears in political speeches, television coverage, social media, military briefings, and everyday conversations. It allows many Israelis to mourn Israeli victims passionately while treating Palestinian victims as abstractions. That moral asymmetry is the foundation on which the destruction of Gaza has been justified.
Israeli media reinforce the consensus
Israeli media play a central role in maintaining this consensus. Mainstream television and much of the Hebrew-language press have tended to center Israeli suffering, hostages, soldiers, and national unity, while demonising Palestinians, justifying civilian deaths, starvation, displacement, and destroyed communities.
This does not require formal censorship alone. It works through selection and framing: whose grief is shown, whose voices are heard, which experts are invited, and which criticisms are treated as legitimate. A Reuters Institute report found that mainstream Israeli TV largely ignored Palestinian suffering in Gaza, while smaller independent outlets that covered it reached far smaller audiences.
When Palestinian suffering is rarely seen, Israeli viewers can support policies whose human consequences they never fully confront. When criticism of the war is framed as disloyalty or propaganda, moral questioning becomes socially dangerous. This is how media normalize violence: not always by telling people what to think, but by repeatedly deciding what they do not need to see.
Why “Netanyahu is the problem” is comforting
The Netanyahu-only explanation is comforting because it simplifies a difficult reality. For foreign governments, it lets them condemn a leader while avoiding confrontation with the broader Israeli consensus. They can continue arms transfers, diplomatic protection, and trade relations while waiting for Israel to “choose moderation” at the ballot box. For many Israelis, it allows opposition to Netanyahu to be mistaken for opposition to occupation. One can despise his corruption and authoritarianism while still supporting settlements, military domination, and the denial of Palestinian statehood.
For international media, it creates a simple story: bad leader, good society, temporary crisis. But Gaza is not a temporary crisis caused by one man’s personality. It is the outcome of a political culture that has normalized Palestinian dispossession.
Accountability must go beyond one man
If genocide is real—and it is—then accountability cannot stop with Netanyahu. It must include the officials who planned policy, the commanders who ordered operations, the politicians who incited expulsion, and the institutions that enabled them. But accountability must also be political and social. It must challenge the consensus that made the policy possible. That means refusing to treat anti-Palestinian racism as a private Israeli matter. It means challenging media narratives that humanize Israeli grief while reducing Palestinians to numbers. It means supporting Palestinian voices, Israeli dissenters, and human-rights organizations rather than treating them as extremists.
It also means international consequences. Governments cannot claim to oppose genocide while continuing unconditional arms transfers, diplomatic shielding, and economic normalization with the state carrying it out. Human Rights Watch has argued that foreign governments should not suspend their legal and moral obligations while waiting for an Israeli election to change things.
What real change would require
A Netanyahu defeat might make Israel less corrupt, less chaotic, or less openly extremist. Those changes would matter to Israelis. But they would not end the genocide, reverse the occupation, halt settlement expansion, or restore Palestinian rights. Real change would require Israeli society to reject the idea that Palestinian life is expendable. It would require recognizing Palestinians as a people entitled to freedom, equality, sovereignty, and safety—not merely as a security problem to be managed. It would require dismantling military rule, ending settlement expansion, accepting accountability for crimes, and allowing Palestinians genuine self-determination. Above all, it would require Israelis to stop asking, “How can we make this occupation safer or more efficient?” and begin asking, “How can we end it?”
Israel’s election may change who governs Israel. It will not, on its own, change what Israel does to Palestinians. Netanyahu must be held accountable. But the myth that he alone is responsible allows too many people to avoid the harder truth: genocide in Gaza has been made possible by a broad social and political normalization of Palestinian dehumanisation. Whether Netanyahu wins or loses, nothing will change unless Israeli society changes its moral imagination and the world accepts that accountability goes beyond Netanyahu. Until then, Palestinians will continue to pay the price of Israeli oppression and global silence.
old codger / October 29, 2026
“This absence is revealing. Palestinians in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza do not vote in Israeli elections, even though Israeli governments control many of the conditions of their lives: “
It might actually be a good thing if the Palestinians in these areas stopped resistance, and allowed Israel to annex their lands. There are more than 3 million Arabs in these places. Israel cannot deny them a vote, as citizens, unless it wants to be exposed as an Apartheid state. Arab parties are already kingmakers in the Knesset, so inducting more Arab voters might turn Israel into the first Arab Democracy.
/
SJ / October 29, 2026
oc
Not so simple.
The Arab vote is not united and will not be united as long as Arab clients of Israel are in power in Arab countries and you have seen how it split when there was an election to the Palestinian authority.
Also Israel will first ethnically cleanse regions before they are brought under Israel control.
BTW
“Palestinians in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza do not vote in Israeli elections”
I think that this is irrelevant to the election to the Israeli Knesset.
/
old codger / October 30, 2026
SJ,
“Palestinians in the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza do not vote in Israeli elections”
Don’t you think Israe should shoot itself in the foot by annexing these and making the inhabitants voting citizens? Arabs are notoriously fractious, but it could make a difference if they can move their fights to the Knesset.
Did you read how Kushner has been caught taking money from all sides, and the UAE has been helping the Houthis? At this rate, can we trust the Vatican not to help ISIS?
/
SJ / October 30, 2026
I think that the Arab World has some way to go to achieve anything within this ‘Greater Israel’.
Remember what happened when Hamas won a massive majority in Gaza and showed potential to be partner in government of the Palestinian Authority.
Mahmoud Abbas would not have it and, even he would, his paymasters wouldn’t.
Egypt since Sadat’s time has long been Israel’s partner in choking Gaza.
The thieves who rule the Arab world have to go for anything good to happen.
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 30, 2026
Israel and Pakistan were created at the same time on the same principle. While Hindus accepted Pakistan for the sake of peace, Muslims did not accept Israel and went to destroy it. They fought three wars and lost all of them. This is the fourth attempt. Majority of Muslims in the world want Israel destroyed and Jews killed and driven out. Camp David accord gave entire Gaza and 90% of West Bank to Palestinians which was rejected by Muslims. Now they are crying foul. Pakistan is doing worst things to Hindus such as genocide, ethnic cleansing, destruction of Hindu temples and cultural annihilation. Writer of this article displays his Islamic bias in ignoring atrocities committed against Hindus in Pakistan. He has to be told in no uncertain terms that Israel will be protected by God and no matter Islamic racists try, Israel will not only survive, but also grow stronger.
/
SJ / October 30, 2026
“Israel and Pakistan were created at the same time on the same principle. “
The man who said this richly deserves the equivalent of the Nobel Prize for stupidity.
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Sivasegaram, do not display your stupidity. Pakistan was created in 1947 and Israel in 1948. Is this not the same time. Pakistan was created to give a homeland for Muslims and Israel was created to give a homeland for Jews. Is this not the same principle. It is Islamic propaganda that is distorting the truth. They are crying saying that creation of Israel had displaced thousands of Muslims, but are ignoring the fact that creation of Pakistan displaced millions of Hindus. Original people of Palestine are Cannans and not Arabs, but original people of Indus Valley are Dravidians and not Muslims. Jesus Christ is a Jew, which proves that Jews were in the land for more than 2000 years. Bible speaks of several ethnic groups inhabiting middle east, but no mention about Arabs. Muslims who got together first with Romans and then with Ottomans and drove Jews out. Jews have every right to come back to their ancestral land. Correct procedure is to do archeological survey and the lands which Jews prove to be the first inhabitants should be given to Jews. Muslims are not willing for it as if this fair method is adopted, their case is lost.
/
SJ / October 31, 2026
“Israel and Pakistan were created at the same time on the same principle. “
This utterance you called stupid was by you!
Pathetic creature, I was only citing it.
/
akismet1 / October 31, 2026
Doctor,
I fear to criticize someone of your eminence, but isn’t there something wrong with this:
“Original people of Palestine are Cannans and not Arabs, but original people of Indus Valley are Dravidians and not Muslims.”
Couldn’t “Cannans” and Arabs be the same people, the same way Cholas and Tamils are the same?
How could Indus Valley people be Muslims. There was no Islam then. However, the people in Indus Valley today are Muslims.
Kindly explain, I am confused.
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Cannans are still living in Lebanon. They are not Arabs. They have been displaced from their original lands by others. Archeologically they are the rightful owners of Palestine, Lebanon and Jordan. Similarly Assyrians are the owners of Syria and northern Iraq. As for Indus valley, it is coming to light that the original inhabitants were Dravidians sort of Proto-Tamils. Skeleton found in Rakhigari matched only with Irular tribe of Tamil Nadu. Artefacts emerging from Tamil Nadu have some resemblance to those in Indus valley. Anaikottai seal found in Jaffna has Indus valley symbols. Indus Valley was first taken over by Aryan immigrants and subsequently by Mugal Invaders, converting residents to Islam. Those who shout about Palestinians, must first hand over Indus valley to Dravidians.
/
akismet1 / November 1, 2026
Dear Eminent Doctor
You say, “Cannans are still living in Lebanon. They are not Arabs. They have been displaced from their original lands by others.”
If they were displaced , who displaced them? Don’t they have a right to go back to their homeland? Why only Jews are allowed a homeland?
Could “Cannans” be Dravidian? There is a Tamil name “Kannan”, identical. But Lebanese call themselves Arab, and speak Arabic not Kannada.
I am still confused.
/
LankaScot / November 1, 2026
Hello Akismet1
The “Canaanites: The indigenous urban and rural population of the southern Levant, (now the West Bank) established in city-states (such as Hazor, Megiddo, and Jericho) long before the emergence of Israel”. By the way the word Armageddon comes from Megiddo.
West of these were the Philistines (originally Peleset from where we derive Palestine) in ” Gaza, Ashkelon, and Ekron”. They were originally Sea Peoples from the Aegean, who migrated to the Levant from about the 12th Century BCE.
The Phoenicians occupied the North Central Coast (Tyre and Sidon).
The Ammonites, Moabites, Edomites lived to the South of the Dead Sea. The Amalekites were part of these Peoples. The Geonocide of the Amalekites is mentioned in the Bible 1 Samuel 15 and also by Netanyahu during the early stages of the Genocide of the Gazans.
The Arameans lived to the North (Damascus Aleppo and around the Tigris Euphrates area) and spoke Aramaic.
The Last peoples were what are now considered the forerunners of the Israelites – the Israelites and Judahites. They were split into two Kingdoms; the Kingdom of Israel (conquered by the Assyrians) and the Kingdom of Judea (exiled to Babylon 6th Century BCE).
Confused?
Best regards
/
SJ / October 31, 2026
a1
I can only wish you luck in your venture seeking clarity.
/
Rajash / November 1, 2026
“Israel and Pakistan were created at the same time on the same principle.”
====
on the same time – ok. one year apart – if that is same time for you.
====
but “…on the same principle”
=====
come on!
/
LankaScot / October 31, 2026
Hello Doctor,
There is a major flaw in your last sentence; there is no God.
Best regards
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Yes I agree because until now there has been no proof of existence of God. All religions are hypotheses, unproved and unlikely to be proved. God as omnipresent omnipotent entity does not exist, but concept of ultimate controlling power could be true. In science, everything is controlled by a central power. Biological cell and Chemical element have nucleus to control. Similarly brain is the centre for body, Captain controls the team and Prime minister controls the country. Controlling power of our universe is sun without which no living being can exist. But sun is only a star and there are millions of them. There should be a controlling power for the stars. In the same manner controlling power at infinity is God. However this entity has nom direct influence on lives of the world.
/
SJ / October 31, 2026
“In science, everything is controlled by a central power”
Who taught you “science”?
/
SJ / November 1, 2026
You are being kind to the science teachers guess.
After all, it was not their fault that some minds were immune to scientific reasoning.
/
SJ / November 1, 2026
You are being kind to the science teachers I guess.
/
LankaScot / November 1, 2026
Hello Doctor,
One of my Friends Daughters is a Neuroscientist who has written a number of Peer Reviewed Papers on Stochastic Processes in the Brain at the Neuron Level.
Many systems in the body act Autonomously –
Autonomous Cellular and Biochemical Processes
The Enteric Nervous System (The “Second Brain”)
Local Reflex Arcs (Spinal and Peripheral)
You said “Biological cell and Chemical element have nucleus to control”. Chemical Elements do not have a nucleus and a Major sub division of Life does not have a Nucleus – “Prokaryotes (Bacteria and Archaea)”
The Eukaryotes (which includes Humans) do have a Nucleus. This is O Level Biology.
Sounds like your last points are referring to the “Kalam Cosmological Argument”. Unless you can prove that the Universe began to exist, the Kalam falls to pieces. The majority of Cosmologists agree that the Big Bang Expansion says nothing about what came before it. I think Roger Penrose’s “Conformal Cyclic Cosmology” best describes an Eternal, Unending Universe that doesn’t need a God to create it.
Best regards
/
MongolianThroatSinger / October 29, 2026
OC, Israel and Zionist Israelis have no intention of making Palestinians “citizens”, capable of voting and doing all those things that ordinary Israelis of European extraction are allowed to do. At best, they want Palestinians to sod off somewhere else (why don’t other Muslim states take them, after all, they are Arabs ?) or better still, the much more Zionist-palatable “final solution” of “why don’t they just lay down and die ?” Israel does not care about being “exposed” as a Apartheid, Genocidal or Racist – they actually revel in it because they believe they ARE the Uber-Mensch, chosen by God and therefore, above such petty considerations.
/
old codger / October 30, 2026
MTS,
“Israel does not care about being “exposed” as a Apartheid, Genocidal or Racist – they actually revel in it because they believe they ARE the Uber-Mensch, “
But they do like their image as the only clean liberal democracy in the region.Even Bibi hasn’t convinced Israel’s admirers that it isn’t any different from old South Africa.
/
SJ / October 30, 2026
Apartheid South Africa has some redeeming features compared with Israel today.
/
SJ / October 30, 2026
Apartheid South Africa had some redeeming features….
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Sivasegaram, stop being stupid. What are the redeeming features of Apartheid South Africa. What Israel is fighting for its existence, and if they are left alone, problem will be solved. For your information, the worst apartheid in the world today is prevention of non-Muslims to enter Mecca. If Jews do the same thing preventing Muslims to enter Jerusalem, you cannot blame them. Al-Aqsa mosque was constructed in Jewish holy land during Islamic occupation, and to justify a canard is being said that Mohamed went to heaven in a chariot from that place. Can anyone with an iota of intelligence believe this. Very soon Al-Aqsa mosque will be demolished probably by a misguided missile from Iran and Jewish fourth temple will be built to fulfil Biblical prophesy.
/
SJ / October 31, 2026
GS
Calling others stupid cannot cover you champion stupidity.
You said something ridiculous and now deflect from it with irrelevancies.
CT had fairly long a break from your stupid utterances, but you are back to keep company for likes of ******, *** ***** and others (of late the list is fairly long).
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
I was busy with my project of Jaffna Metro as the prospective builders wanted a detail tracing of the routes using large scale drawing. It took me nearly one year to complete it in downloading maps at 10 cm to 100 meter scale and then work on them nearly 8 hours a day. During this period, I could not take my attention off to other things. Once project is completed, my name will be written in gold. Now I am back to take on educated fools like you.
/
SJ / November 1, 2026
CT
Do you have any golden letters on these pages?
Have some gold handy as there is a global gold rush on.
/
LankaScot / November 2, 2026
Hello SJ,
“Once project is completed, my name will be written in gold”.
Is the good Doctor an Avatar of Donald J Trump?
Best regards
/
SJ / November 2, 2026
LS
Perhaps, but with fewer loyal followers.
/
Agnos / October 31, 2026
Dr. GS,
Israel was created as a beachhead of Western imperialism in the Middle East. They developed their nuclear bomb early, in stealth, but with Western support, which gave the justification for Iran and other Middle Eastern countries to try to seek their own.
Regardless of the source of their initial exodus, Ashkenazi Jews had become Europeanized, and their return to the Middle East was ill-advised. Nor are their continuing illegal settlements and mass killings acceptable. Western guilt about the Holocaust must have been handled in better ways, without creating a settler colonial genocide. Tamils the Worldover should be known for advocating Human Rights and standing up for truth and justice, both at home and globally, without fear or favor, with Navi Pillay as the exemplar.
People like you are in the minority.
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Second generation of Tamils have become Europeanised, Do they have no right to return to their ancestral lands. Settling in lands which they could prove that they were the first nation cannot be called illegal. Best way out is archaeological survey on disputed lands assign them to rightful owners. Sadly, Muslims do not want anything like that for fear of evidence against their claims. As for killings, whoever does it is wrong and Jews will stop it if Muslims stop killing Jews. With the fall of Ottoman empire in the first world war, whole of middle east came under the rule of British. Mecca was under them from 1915 to 1922 and they did not do anything to destroy Kabah or build a Church in the vicinity and claim the land as theirs. British were mere decent than Muslim invaders who destroyed civilisations.
/
Lester / November 2, 2026
“Tamils the Worldover should be known for advocating Human Rights and standing up for truth and justice”
That’s a good one. Sri Lankan Tamils will only be known for suicide bombings, terrorism, and insider trading. Why are you afraid to take credit?
/
Native Vedda / November 2, 2026
Lester
–
“That’s a good one. Sri Lankan Tamils will only be known for suicide bombings, terrorism, and insider trading. Why are you afraid to take credit?”
–
Could you name those who involved in terrorism and insider trading.
–
Terrorism was first introduced to this island by Rohana Wijeweera, Somawansa, ….. followed by Sri Lankan armed forces, police, Green Tigers, …. They were not good teachers.
Ivan Boesky, Chris Collins, Du Jun, Simon Hannes, ….. Yoshiaki Tsutsumi and who else?
/
SJ / November 1, 2026
Do you know what redeeming means?
Do you understand in what context the word was used?
Do you realize that your stupidity is becoming increasingly transparent?
/
old codger / October 31, 2026
SJ,
Yes, you’re right, at least South Africa didn’t bomb its eequivalent of Gaza or bomb its neighbours to prevent them getting nuclear weapons.
/
Mohamed Marzook UK / October 30, 2026
Benjamin Netyanuon is only an employed agent of the Jewsih establishment that has wide influence all over the world, particularly in the West with powerful political and ecnonomic influence. Netyanu is only one of many such agents who have wide political influence in Israel. Netyanu is not easily going out even with losing his majority in the current election , and his foster-father Uncle Sam too will not let him go out of power that easily. The present could only a temporary set back for the Jewish establishment and it staging back its power cannot be fully ruled out.
/
Naman / October 30, 2026
” Jewish Establishment” is not the term that we need to use. ZIONISM is what rest of the world are against. Likewise in SL we should be against the Sinhala Buddhist SUPREMACY.
There are JEWS who are totally against Netanyhau’s genocidal activities.
/
SJ / October 30, 2026
MMUK
“the Jewsih establishment”
I think that you are mixing up Jewish and Zionist.
/
Dr. Gnana Sankaralingam / October 31, 2026
Zionism was formed to get back their lands occupied by Muslims. After they won their land, if they were allowed to live in peace, Zionism would have died a natural death. It is the action of Muslims who want to destroy it, which is keeping Zionism alive, to protect their lands. It is always that Muslims who create trouble and when others react to it, start crying out that they are victimised. According to old Testament, God will give divine help to protect Israel from their enemies.
/
SJ / October 31, 2026
“Zionism was formed to get back their lands occupied by Muslims”
One more from the gem pit.
/
LankaScot / November 1, 2026
Hello Doctor,
“According to old Testament, God will give divine help to protect Israel from their enemies”.
That obviously didn’t work in 587/586 BCE: “King Nebuchadnezzar II completely destroyed Jerusalem and Solomon’s Temple, resulting in a large-scale deportation of King Zedekiah and much of the population”.
Or the “fall of Jerusalem and the destruction of the Second Temple in AD 70”.
Were the Amalekites Muslims? In 1 Samuel 15 God tells the Israelites (500 or so years after he promised) to ““Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.”
Is that not Genocide?
Best regards
/
Native Vedda / November 2, 2026
LankaScot
–
From the above, don’t you think Tamils are also a very intelligent people, second only to Ashkenazi Jews, and spread across many countries? Once they have built enough temples in the holy city of Jaffna, their saviour, Velupillai Prabhakaran, will be born again and redeem all Tamils, granting them salvation.
–
Don’t ask me when the day of salvation will come. However, as another chosen people, if they live long enough, they too may experience redemption, salvation, and ultimate liberation.
–
I assure you that I am not insane.
/
old codger / November 2, 2026
Native,
“Once they have built enough temples in the holy city of Jaffna, their saviour, Velupillai Prabhakaran, will be born again”
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
/
LankaScot / November 2, 2026
Hello Native,
You can’t say that you are “not insane” until you have taken the same Cognitive Tests as Donald Trump – https://www.youtube.com/shorts/wuqQaxagj9g
I asked one of my 6 year old (Sinhala) Nieces a selection of the questions and she answered ( or drew) them all.
Best regards
/
Lester / November 2, 2026
Native,
He cannot say such a positive thing about Ashkenazim, even if you put the data in front of his face:
https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9781137414816_13
The antisemitism will not allow it. 😂
This is real racism, 1450 years of indoctrination, from Romans to Luther. Not the convert AD you like to quote from, who was anyway educated at missionary schools by Max Mueller types.
/
Jit / November 2, 2026
Judaism started around 1500 BCE and Islam in 600 CE. So Jews were there before Muslims, weren’t they? Or that fact does not connect to land occupations by the followers of each religion?
/
LankaScot / November 2, 2026
Hello Jit,
I and a few others retrieved an Outboard Motor for the Saudi Coastguard in the waters of Tarut Bay (Eastern Province). A short while later one of the Meteorologists told me about an Archaelogical Dig that uncovered Ubaid Sites in the Tarut Area.
These people were widespread across the Middle East and even extended to Tel Tsaf in the Jordan Valley. They originated in the Mesopotamian Area around 6500 BCE. The Iraqi Marsh Arabs are most likely their descendants – https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3215667/
Try to remember there is a difference between Ethnicity and Religion. The Ubaids, Sumerians and many other peoples occupied most of the Middle East long before the Abrahamic Religions took root. Much of the Babylonian Myths and God stories had an influence on the old Testament. The Epic of Gilgamesh (reigned 2800–2500 BCE) relates flood stories that “feature a deity warning a favored mortal to build a massive boat to survive a global deluge sent to wipe out humanity, followed by sending out birds to find dry land”.
That’s more than 1000 years before your date for Judaism (1500 BCE).
The Middle East has a Complex History
Best regards
/
old codger / November 2, 2026
LS,
Many people assume that Biblical stories actually were told by the Prophets, not based on previous tales. The Great Flood story is found in even Hindu mythology, complete with Ark.
Matsya instructs Manu to build a large ship and load it with the seeds of all plants, medicinal herbs, the seven sages (Saptarishis), and animal life.
/
LankaScot / November 2, 2026
Hello OC,
It looks like there are resemblances between some of the Hindu Gods and the Mesopotamian ones. Now did one influence the other or is there possibly a common source?
When you consider that the originators of the Vedas may have been the Yamnaya or related tribes from the Steppes around the Black Sea, then we have a possible source for the Flood Myths.
I read Walter Pitman and William Ryan’s book “Noah’s Flood: The New Scientific Discoveries about the Event that Changed History” way back in 1998 and have followed Robert Ballard’s Explorations as much as I can.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=irjJFuy3myk&t=170s
However although the Black Sea did suffer an inundation from the Mediterranean due to Sea Level rise due to the end of the Ice Age, it was not a catastrophic flood according to recent results –
https://www.whoi.edu/oceanus/feature/noahs-not-so-big-flood/
As an aside when we were drilling near the Dogger Bank we found Lignite (fossilised wood) in the Shale Shakers. This area once connected England to the Continent and is known as Doggerland.
Best regards
/
Jit / November 3, 2026
LS, the very reason why I do not get into this debate is the sheer obscurity of the historical facts. There are multi million different stories by the Jews and Arabs alike – and the factions support both sides. Some claim they are biblical myths, fables, yarns while some bring in modern science, some even stories from aliens. To be honest, I do not trust anyone’s story because they all start with vested interests. I am yet to read an honest, objective version. The question I raised was, if people claim the land on the basis of ‘religion’ – then Jews were the first settlers than the Muslims because Islam is the younger religion. If your argument is based on ethnicity and the claim that Arabs were there before, then before errrr…….whom, exactly? Because if you’re going to go that far back in history, there were no Arabs then either.
/
Naman / October 30, 2026
“It is the normalization, across large parts of Israeli society and its media, of the idea that Palestinian life is expendable,”
In Ceylon & later SL , the Lives of the Tamils in the country too were regarded as expendable by the majority race since the Independence from the colonial powers. During the sufferings of the Tamils the Muslims kept the SILENCE or sided with the oppressors. Before the Sri Lankans try to SORT OUT THE rest of the world, let us put our house in order. The WHATABOUTISM reasoning is not good enough. The outcome of the investigations the CHEMMANI excavations will determine the current Government’s sincerity & righteousness.
/
Naman / October 30, 2026
” nothing will change unless Israeli society changes its moral imagination”
INJUSTICES that is happening in and around Israel will continue as long as USA along with their special friends continue to ignore the Palestinians sufferings. The special friends include the oil rich Middle Eastern countries that ARE NOT practicing real DEMOCRACY but also keep on buying weapons from them.
Would the author compare the Palestinians sufferings to that of SL Tamils since Independence?
/
Lester / October 31, 2026
This is from Sahih al-Bukhari, the most authentic collection of hadith (sayings, actions, and approvals of Muhammad) in Sunni Islam, regarded as the most reliable book after the Qur’an.
Narrated Abu Huraira:
Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) said, “The Hour will not be established until you fight with the Jews, and the stone behind which a Jew will be hiding will say. “O Muslim! There is a Jew hiding behind me, so kill him.”
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:2926
If Allah’s Messenger has given such instructions, Israel doesn’t have many options.
The “Hour” refers to the Day of Judgment. So then we can conclude – according to Islamic belief – the world will not end until there is a great battle with Jews.
/