11 December, 2024

Blog

ICC Warrants & Netanyahu’s Digitus Impudicus

By Ameer Ali

Dr. Ameer Ali

After Israel’s genocidal rampage in Gaza since 7 October 2023, which killed so far nearly 44,000 “human animals” and “cockroaches” in the words of Benjamin Netanyahu and his former defence minister Yoav Gallant, and wounded around another 105,000 while turning that strip of land into an uninhabitable heap of brick and concrete rabble, Judges of the International Criminal Court have at last issued arrest warrants for these two war criminals and for the Hamas leader Mohammed Deif. Of the three wasn’t the last claimed to have been killed by IDF in an air strike in Gaza in July this year? Does that mean Deif is still alive according to ICC? Israel’s killings and destruction has now extended into Lebanon. According to one report, in both Gaza and Lebanon IDF has killed more than 17, 000 children and in Lebanon alone 400,000 children are displaced from their homes. In these two killing fields IDF has not spared even news reporters and aid workers.

Be that as it may, the tragedy about these warrants is that they are virtually ineffective, because ICC does not have a police force to chase and arrest international criminals and outlaws. ICC therefore needs to depend on the good offices of the 124 countries that are signatories to the Rome Statute. And the tragedy turns into comedy when one realizes that Israel and its backer US are not parties to that statute. Does this mean that these two countries are above the jurisdiction of international laws? Was that why when ICC initially requested those warrants be issued in July this year Joe Biden called it “outrageous”? And now the outgoing and physically wobbling lame duck president reaffirmed that position. That became even more evident when US singularly vetoed the last UN Security Council resolution for a ceasefire when all other 14 members supported it. One can be rest assured that US backing of Israel would be further strengthened when Donald Trump takes over the Presidency soon. And curiously, according to Trump America’s security seems to depend on the security of Israel. Didn’t he say during his election campaign that destruction of Israel would mean destruction of US? Enamoured and strengthened by that solid backing from US, Netanyahu, a protected outlaw, has reacted to ICC warrants by showing the Roman digitus impudicus or the insulting middle finger, which in obscene parlour is equivalent to saying “f— off”. His was a Roman salute to the Rome Statute.         

This is an insulting embarrassment not only to ICC but also to every other international institution operating under the auspices of UN to promote law and order, and peace and harmony among civilized nations. Worse, is the situation of the Arab Muslim world and all those 57 members of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). The entire organization has become a clique of impotent jokers with all their petroleum resources and financial assets, and none of them including Iran is militarily capable of challenging the might of Israel. To US on the other hand, Israel is the most dependable ally not only to take care of US imperial interest but also to take control on behalf US of the economic resources and markets in Muslim Middle East and prevent either Russia or China to set foot in that part of the world. Moreover, as far as US is concerned Arabs and Muslims are expendable creatures. According to a report by researchers at the US Brown University’s Watson Institute, US post-9/11 wars in Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, Syria, Somalia and Yemen have killed between 4.5 and 4.7 million Muslims including military personnel and civilians. (M. Reza Benham, “Retreat from Reason: Palestine in Times of Monsters”, Counterpunch, 22 Nov. 2024).       

According to a study published in 2019 by UNCTAD titled, “The Economic Cost of Occupation for the Palestinian People: The Unrealized Oil and Natural Gas Potential”, there is a deposit of 122 trillion cubic foot of oil and gas of which an estimated 1.7 billion oil worth $522 billion is recoverable. That was why Donald Trump during his first term as President successfully engineered the so-called Abraham Accord signed between Israel and UAE and between Israel and Bahrain in 2020 so that a joint commercial venture could be established to exploit this resource and promote friendly relations between Arab nations and Israel. Trump’s successor went along with that policy, and he was about to bring in Saudi Arabia into that Accord when Hamas spoilt everything by firing those deadly rockets on October 2023. What began as Gaza-Israel war has now turned into Gaza-Israel-US war drawing Lebanon, Iran and Syria into it. Joe Biden’s occasional calls for limited ceasefire was a charade while he continues supplying weapons and funds to Israel, and the so-called Qatari mediation efforts have ended in zero.  In fact, Netanyahu has been given carter blanche to accomplish what the ultra-orthodox Zionists want him to do i.e., to get rid of all Arabs from Gaza and annex it with Israel. Yet, despite all the killings and devastation of Gaza, Israel could not finish off Hamas and now Netanyahu is offering $5 million cash for every Israeli hostage returned by Hamas. There is no chance of that happening.

The incoming US President Trump promised during his campaign to end the war in one month. How is he going to do is not clear, but there are some indications that he would put an end to the so called two-state solution. His choice of appointing Mike Huckabee, a former governor of Arkansas and a former Evangelist as Ambassador to Israel would encourage Netanyahu and Co. to proceed with the total annexation of not only Gaza but also the West Bank. According to Huckabee there is “no such thing as the West Bank” and “no such thing as settlements”, but only Judea and Samarra as the ultra-orthodox Israelis would prefer to call. Not only he would do everything possible to make that become a reality but as a first step would reactivate Trump’s earlier call to shift Israel’s capital from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem.  Eventually, with or without Trump, the entire Palestine would become part of Israel, and the sacred mosque al-Aqsa would be eliminated to make way for the construction of David’s temple. Netanyahu’s Likud Party’s charter of 1977 says, “From the river to the sea”, which would mean between the Mediterranean Sea and the Jordan river there will only be Israel sovereignty.  In the meantime, Western leaders would go on repeating their empty promise of a two-state solution to the Palestine problem.  It is a historic betrayal to the Muslim world that the Arab countries have given up fighting for Palestine.

Outside the Middle East is another worrying development which should concern countries like Sri Lanka.  Orthodox Hasidic Jews are putting up Chabad Houses all over the world and they are particularly very active in the universities in America. In Sri Lanka too Chabad Houses are mushrooming. The recent suspected terror threat in Arugam Bay and before that the fire that consumed the students hostel of a Muslim Girls school in Weligama, were all rumoured to have had Jewish links. In the absence of a notable Jewish community in Sri Lanka it is claimed that Chabad houses are providing services to Jewish tourists, but what type of services apart from supplying kosher food are they providing is not clear. There are reports that tourists from Israel are staying for months and illegally engaging in business activities. It appears that the lure of employment in Israel for local artisans and skilled workers seems to have allowed bankrupt Sri Lankan governments to tolerate the activities of law-breaking tourists. However, with Sri Lanka’s increasing importance in the geo-strategic rivalry among China, India and US in the Indian Ocean whether the Chabad houses are becoming intelligence gathering workshops for Mossad needs to be closely monitored especially by the left leaning NPP government, which has committed for system change.    

*Dr. Ameer Ali, Business School, Murdoch University, W. Australia

Latest comments

  • 1
    4

    AA, The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court has not been signed by both US and Israel and hence does not apply to their citizens.

    • 2
      0

      Hello DTG,
      In a previous post you said –
      “Mark Salter, ICJ works with those who have signed the Rome Statute. US and Israel both have not signed the Rome Statute and are not under ICJ”.
      This is wrong –
      “The International Court of Justice shall be the principal judicial organ of the United Nations. It shall function in accordance with the annexed Statute, which is based upon the Statute of the Permanent Court of International Justice and forms an integral part of the present Charter”. https://legal.un.org/avl/ha/sicj/sicj.html
      Please don’t mix them up, there is an ICC (International Criminal Court) and the ICJ (International Court of Justice).
      On the ICC you are correct, The US and Israel have not signed, however the ICC and most of the World’s Nations have agreed that it does apply to Israel.
      Can you imagine a Criminal appearing in Court for Arson and telling the Judge that he never signed up to a Law on not setting fire to Buildings?
      Best regards

      • 5
        3

        DTG,
        “The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court has not been signed by both US and Israel “
        If you go read your non-biblical History Book, you will find that Goering and 11 others were sentenced to death in 1946, even though they hadn’t signed anything. I believe they were all good Christians, not a single Muslim.

    • 7
      0

      DTG:
      Israel and USA did not sign the Rome Statute because they knew intuitively that they will be the first to be charged and found guilty under its provisions.

      • 2
        4

        Captain Morgan, do you really think Israel and US will extend their necks to the UN which is full of Middle-east Islam population.

        • 0
          0

          Tell me clearly, davidthegood, do you approve, or disapprove?
          .
          It is true that when we read about what the Nazis did to the Jews, we are horrified. My Belgian neighbour was a posthumous child, born in what is now the Czech Republic. He has told nobody (not even his children) what his biological father’s name was.
          .
          I’m therefore personally conscious of the horror of what they suffered.
          .
          Many Jews themselves are unhappy, and all sensitive persons:
          .
          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rqyf1E5u0Gk&t=171s
          .
          It is responses like yours which make me reject all religions (including Islam!) However, I will never want religions banned.
          .
          There’s something within humans which impels us towards religions; but why can’t religions live and let live.
          .
          The question is just too complex, but I just don’t approve of your over-zealous posturing.

    • 6
      1

      david the good bad and the ugly theocratic hypocrite

      “The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court has not been signed by both US and Israel and hence does not apply to their citizens.”

      It didn’t stop both countries from assassinating people whom they considered enemies, including their own citizens, Palestinians, Iraqis, Syrians, Afghanis, Vietnamese, Laotians, Saudis, Jordanians, …………….. South Americans, Africans, Japanese, ……………………..?

  • 4
    5

    US can easily give the oil areas to Hamas and the Palestinian people so they can work with the Arab countries, become self-contained, and be happy on the little land left to them. We hope and pray that Trump will use his wisdom, rationality, and the kindly spirit that he possesses to help these people out. World will have a greater respect for America and have hearts full of gratitude to work with this super-power. Trump himself would have created an enduring legacy excelling all other presidents.

    As for Arugam Bay, if 2-4 million Israelis are looking for places all around the world to settle in, this is a good thing. They too are quite desperate and have suffered discrimination and persecution in Europe for millennia. Their smaller communities do well and are treated relatively well in other lands like US, and even in Iran. They will bring much needed money to Sri Lanka and boost up business opportunity, even with the Lankan Muslims, and bring in a healthy diversity to our land. They will then free up the lands they occupy in Palestine, and return these lands to these original people of the Bible, the suffering Palestinians.

    • 7
      3

      Ramona,
      “They will then free up the lands they occupy in Palestine, and return these lands to these original people of the Bible, the suffering Palestinians.”
      You are asking for Big Trouble from DTG. Be careful.

    • 1
      7

      rtf, you say Israel can free up land they occupy in Palestine. Where is this Palestine land. When Noah came out of the Ark after the flood and built an altar to God Almighty, Noah’s son Ham’s son Canaan in Gen.10,6, were dispersed in Gen.10,19 their borders being towards Gaza as well as Sodom and Gomorrah. Then God brought Abram back from Ur of the Chaldeans back to the land of Canaan in Gen.11,31. Then the Lord said to Abram in Gen.12,7 “To you and your descendants I give this land” and Abram built an altar to the Lord between Bethel and Ai and called on the name of the Lord. Abram went down to Egypt in a famine and came up from Egypt up to Bethel in Gen. 13,1. God said to Abram that he was giving the land to Abram and his descendants for-ever. Gen.13,15. The eternal covenant is Gen.17,8.

      • 5
        1

        DTG,
        “Where is this Palestine land.”
        Why do you keep repeating this endlessly? How many times do you need to be shown the partition map of Palestine passed by the UN in 1948?
        Is Sri Lanka mentioned as such in the Bible? Does it mean that this country and its citizens, including you, don’t exist?

      • 3
        1

        Dtg…..all the Palestinian people are 75-100% Abram’s descendants. Israeli’s are mostly only 15% of Abram’s blood. They need to find other places to go to.

        • 3
          1

          Jews have to move on and find a new day.
          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8DDHulO485k

        • 0
          1

          rtf, if Palestinian people accept themselves as being Abram’s descendants, why on earth are they trying to be separate from the Jews in Israel which land was promised to them not for folly or fun, but to bring Jesus into the world. Jesus is coming again to Jerusalem and that is what this is all about. Most do not know the truth of God’s plan for his creation and are cooking up their own lofty wrong thoughts of what it should be. They are all wrong.

          • 2
            0

            DTG…..No, they are not trying to be separate from Jews in Israel. They are trying to be separate from the Europeans of 15-0% Jewish blood from Europe…..4-million of which encroached and stole their ancient lands that God Almighty declared was theirs.

            • 0
              0

              ……ancient lands that God Almighty declared was for the people of Judah who are the Palestinians.

      • 1
        1

        davidthegood!
        .
        I was zealous
        in my study of the Bible as a kid, and as a teenager; I now regard most of it as make-believe, but admit that there are very worthy moral teachings encapsulated in them.
        .
        I have mixed feelings towards you, and I have told you so. There is evil 🐍within you, and I tell you that it is because of unnatural devotion to religion.
        .
        When I think of human civilization, I recognize how religion has inspired the 🏛️Arts:
        .
        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sistine_Chapel_ceiling
        .
        I recently spent four hours gazing at all that; inspiring,💯 but not literally true.
        .
        How was Michelangelo himself treated? Wasn’t all this to pander to the vanity of Pope Sixtus?
        .
        I have no literal belief in a Day of Judgement (or even after-life), but remember this: you are constantly driving people away from religion‼️
        .
        As always, Ramona talks sense; you’d actually be a good man if you listened to her.

        • 3
          0

          Hello SM.
          First of all there is no way that an Atheist can drive people away from Religion. People leave Religion either because of its irrelevance or they recognise that its fundamental premises cannot be proven. The concept of Evil is a religious construction in the sense that you use it for me. I can defend myself (Physically and Literally) but I have never caused unnecessary harm to anyone, I have always tried to live by the premise “if you are not going to eat it, don’t kill it”.
          Yes Ramona talks a form of sense (its negation) called (non)sense.
          I have seen magnificent Architecture in many parts of the World. The Parthenon and the Coliseum (neither are Christian). I have walked through the Arc de Triomphe many times, built to celebrate Napoleon’s victories. I have sat on Napoleons bed in Ajaccio. Its size reminds you that he really was short and that you don’t need to be tall or strong to achieve success in battles. But don’t mention Elba or St Helena.
          I have visited Kolossi Castle in Cyprus, a Crusader stronghold. Read some history of the atrocities committed by Christians in Jerusalem.
          And your point is?
          Best regards

          • 3
            0

            Hello SM,
            Instead of “The concept of Evil is a religious construction in the sense that you use it for me”, I should have said “The concept of Evil is a religious construction in the sense that you use it for him” That would take away the ambiguity, I hope.

            DTG is like many of the Jehovah’s Witnesses that I have known and cannot conceive of the Notion that the Bible is written by Humans (predominately men). For him it is the Gospel Truth and anyone that gets in the way of its Predictions is anathema to him.
            Best regards

          • 2
            2

            Hello LS,
            “I went to Kolossi Castle in Cyprus, a Crusader fortress. Read the history of the atrocities committed by Christians in Jerusalem.
            And your opinion?”

            I wonder what self-proclaimed pundits like SM would say about some of the commentators on this forum about his judgments.
            .
            I always agree with LS, OC or the kind of individuals who have seen the world or judge based on facts. I often find it funny when people parrot the Bible or other religious texts, including my good Sinhala-Buddhist Jataka stories.
            To be honest, when I was there last November, some relatives forced me to disagree with them for the “Kathinai Pingkama” they organized. I didn’t join them like I did when I was younger.

          • 0
            0

            Scot,

            “The Parthenon and the Coliseum (neither are Christian).”

            The Romans had many gods. The difference was the lack of any organized religion. Mostly there were cults and festivals to honor the gods. There are many similarities between “Jesus” and “Dionysus”, whom the Romans called “Bacchus.” Virgin birth, drinking wine, crown of thorns, etc.
            Anyway, if you look closely, Buddhism is the religion closest to atheism. There is a suggested code of conduct (dharma), but no obligation to follow it. Reincarnation exists, but science is neutral on this one. As well as karma. One can be a “Buddhist” without any formal conversion or knowledge of the Buddha. This is not true of other religions. Buddhists do not persecute others on the basis of religion alone. In fact, the opposite is true. The Marxist Chinese illegally occupied Tibet, causing genocide. That is a real genocide, as the Tibetans did not initiate anarchy using suicide bombs or other extreme measures. They were in their own land.

            • 0
              0

              Hello Lester,
              “Reincarnation exists, but science is neutral on this one”. “As well as karma”. Where is your evidence or is it Magic Mushroom time again in England? Have a look at these other Supernatural Powers of Buddhists – https://sanmateobuddhisttemple.org/the-six-superhuman-powers/
              And another oxymoron ‘Marxist Chinese”.
              The Hindus have more gods than anyone else, is Hinduism not a Religion. Have you not seen Roman Temples (Temple of Augustus, Temple of Saturn etc.). I have even been in one in England, Temple of Sulis Minerva in Bath. I have stood inside the small room at the edge of the Chester Amphitheatre where Romans, including Gladiators, performed their Ablutions. The actual Altar to Nemesis which once stood there is round the corner in the Grosvenor Museum.
              The Pope has his Ecumenical Councils, the Romans had the Collegium pontificum: A college of priests that controlled state religion.
              Best regards

        • 0
          3

          Sinhala_Man, you are in for severe trouble as the Holy Spirit is in me, having accepted Jesus as my Savior, and you say that what is in me is evil. Mat.12,31 says that all sins can be forgiven, but blasphemy against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven. That means that you cannot go to heaven but definitely have chosen to go to hell, defying judgement. Rev.19, 11 says Jesus judges and makes war. Rev.20,12 says that dead stand before God and judged.

          • 0
            0

            OK. So, I’m headed for Hell!
            .
            Wish me luck there, David.

        • 2
          2

          “As always, Ramona talks sense; you’d actually be a good man if you listened to her”

          Oh, what judgment from a man who has nothing but hero worship and spreading lies.

          If Ramona talks sense, all what AKD droped down his pre-election rallies should be the truths. is not that so ?
          .
          Yet Today, nothing like miraculous from AKD deyyo… Remember? PEOPLE are stupid and they would not give a damn looking back.

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d95whMa_0-M

          None of the followings are in their ongoing agenda after grabbing the power.
          Renegotiate with IMF as promised before
          Introduce a new DSA based on “AKD” policies…
          Reduce fuel prices by at least Rs. 150 – promised
          Behead rice mafia thugs such as Dudley Sirisena and Ranawaga – promised
          Dismiss Mahinda Siriwardena, Central Bank of Sri Lanka Chief Dr. Weerasinghe and others who worked with Mr. Wickremesinghe (the most powerful and intelligent president in terms of handling the IMF).
          Serious criminal acts mentioned in their pre-election meetings, however, they are now looking for excuses.

          This list is cealess….. What do our NPP promoters utter today ?

    • 4
      0

      Hello Ramona,
      I always thought that you had a sense of Humour, now you have just proved it.
      “Trump will use his wisdom, rationality, and the kindly spirit that he possesses to help these people out”.
      Trump has just admitted that he will implement much of Project 2025.
      His Vice President JD Vance has the following heroes, Patrick Deneen, Peter Thiel, Curtis Yarvin, and René Girard.
      All these so-called Intellectuals share a far-right Philosophy that wants to impose a Technocratic or Theocratic Rule in the USA/World.
      Take Curtis Yarvin, “He expresses the belief that white people are genetically endowed with higher IQs than black people”.
      Peter Thiel and his puppet Mark Zuckenberg are part of the reason that I intensely dislike Facebook.
      Patrick Deneen wants to replace liberalism with a regime that enables the “promotion of conservative and religious values rather than the protection of individual rights”.
      All of the above people represent the Ideological Land that Lester and many other right wing pseudo-Intellectuals would like to inhabit.
      Trump and Vance will prepare the ground for their march to erase Democracy, first in the US and then elsewhere. The United Nations will be one of their first targets.
      Best regards

      • 6
        1

        LS,

        The pro-Trump people have an inversion of reality in their heads, so it is no use talking to them.

        That includes many Sri Lankan Americans. I have told the Trump supporters in my circles that they have permanently marked themselves as idiots, with an ‘I’ on their foreheads for the rest of their lives.

        By the way, Einstein was against Zionism and referred to “Zionist thugs” in his writings. Also, despite the U.S. and Israel not being signatories to the Rome treaty, the Palestinian Authority signed it, so the ICC has jurisdiction. Canada, Belgium, Ireland, Netherlands, the UK, etc., have explicitly said Netanyahu will be arrested if he tries to visit their countries. Moreover, even before the ICC warrant on Netanyahu and Gallant, Israeli President Herzog was denied the right to Turkey’s airspace when he wanted to attend a conference in Azerbaijan. Such isolation of Israeli war criminals is even more likely now, even if they may be able to evade arrest.

      • 2
        2

        LS,
        Trump and his wisdom?

        God, many in Europe more or less know that if it weren’t for him, a million innocent people who could have survived COVID-19 would not have died. Paradoxically, stupid republicans allowed the clown to return as their leader.

        Ramona, a Sri Lankan immigrant living in the United States, may be completely blind to the stupidity, but she seems to have the audacity to make absurd statements about god fathers of crimes. I really dont know how I could control my anger……… my dear LS, please help me.

      • 1
        0

        Hello Scot,

        “All of the above people represent the Ideological Land that Lester and many other right wing pseudo-Intellectuals would like to inhabit.”

        Trump will be gone (permanently) after 4 years. That is the strength of a democracy; the system has in-built mechanisms to combat redundancies and other efficiencies. Unlike Putin or Ji Xinping, Trump is not “Dear Leader”, he is “Elected Leader.” Also, you need people like Trump every once in a while to test the resiliency of the system. Without identifying the weak points, the system will stagnate. That is my opinion of a “democracy”. It is not one person, but a system with strong checks and balances that can absorb shocks.
        What to expect from Trump? Create your classes here. He will promote fossil fuels, give Ukraine to Russia, and likely initiate a war with Iran. With a strong stand on immigration and trade. It’s not good for the developing world and people who can’t figure out their gender, but they have bigger (internal) issues to take care of anyway.

        • 0
          0

          *inefficiencies

          • 0
            0

            Hello Lester,
            “Also, you need people like Trump every once in a while to test the resiliency of the system”. So that was what Trump was doing on 6th January 2021, testing the resiliency?
            And I suppose the workers in Italy were testing the Resilience of the Lamposts in the Piazzale Loreto using Mussolini and other dead Fascists?
            Fascism didn’t arrive in Germany from overseas, there was a slow but deliberate takeover of the Democratic Institutions, and the Military, that reached a point where the Nazis were able to coerce the Politicians, Judiciary and the Clergy to follow their orders. The rest is History.
            Read about the people that are behind JD Vance and what they want to achieve with the Trump Presidency.
            Best regards

  • 0
    1

    ICC Warrants & Netanyahu’s Digitus Impudicus

    The Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court has not been signed that means any contry not signed they can do anything they want why did the ICC says like this.

  • 6
    9

    davidthegood is correct. Israel and the US are not signatories to the Rome Statue or ICC. It is unlikely any Western country will arrest Netanyahu, regardless of the recent remarks of Keir Starmer. With that said, the best course of action for the Palestinians is to distance themselves from Hamas. If they did this, it would increase international pressure on Israel. On another note, smart minds are often able to predict the future (dumb minds get mired in the past). There is a story about Feynman: “We were at a physics conference in Rochester, New York in September 1967, three months after the Six-Day War, something shook him out of his customary neutrality. He spent the whole evening dispensing astute advice based on his analysis of the situation. He predicted, for example, that because the Arabs could not defeat us in an ordinary war, they would now concentrate mainly on terrorism, and Israel would do well to prepare itself accordingly.” Preparing yourself to deal with terrorism is never easy. In my opinion, we are at the peak of the cycle. Israel will ensure another attack similar 7th Oct does not re-occur. Trump will assist.

    • 3
      3

      *statute

    • 8
      0

      Hello Lester,
      How many times did Richard Feynman visit Israel?
      Why did Albert Einstein refuse the Presidency of Israel and was against a Jewish State?
      Einstein visited Israel once, in February 1923, before the formation of the Jewish State, and never went back.
      Best regards

      • 5
        0

        Hello Lester,
        Strange that you didn’t mention where your quote on Feynman came from. Just for everyone it came from Yuval Ne’eman. He was an Israeli theoretical physicist, military scientist, and politician. He was Minister of Science and Development in the 1980s and early 1990s. He was the President of Tel Aviv University from 1971 to 1977. Richard Feynman died in 1988. I believe Ne’eman gave this quote in 1999 (but I may be wrong).
        Best regards

        • 2
          2

          Hello Scot,

          Both Einstein and Feynman were extreme rationalists. Einstein even doubted QM, given its heavy reliance on probability. They would not support any cause blindly, particularly a religion. Although Einstein did express his support for Zionism and Feynman admired the Torah. Here is a quote from Einstein:

          “Long before the emergence of Hitler I made the cause of Zionism mine because through it I saw a means of correcting a flagrant wrong….The Jewish people alone has for centuries been in the anomalous position of being victimized and hounded as a people, though bereft of all the rights and protections which even the smallest people normally has…Zionism offered the means of ending this discrimination. Through the return to the land to which they were bound by close historic ties…Jews sought to abolish their pariah status among peoples… The advent of Hitler underscored with a savage logic all the disastrous implications contained in the abnormal situation in which Jews found themselves. Millions of Jews perished… because there was no spot on the globe where they could find sanctuary…The Jewish survivors demand the right to dwell amid brothers, on the ancient soil of their fathers.”

          • 0
            0

            Hello Lester,
            You missed out Einsteins opposition to a Jewish State.
            “I should much rather see reasonable agreement with the Arabs on the basis of living together in peace than the creation of a Jewish state. My awareness of the essential nature of Judaism resists the idea of a Jewish state with borders, an army, and a measure of temporal power, no matter how modest”.
            Best regards

            • 1
              0

              Hello Lester,
              I never agreed with Neils Bohr’s Copenhagen Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics. Like Schrodinger I found the instantaneous Quantum Jumps difficult to reconcile. Do a Fourier Analysis of a Square Wave and you will see the problem. It should be easy for you (Lester) to explain why the square wave is composed only of odd harmonics.
              I had no problem with the Probabilistic Nature of Quantum Mechanics. Tunnel Diodes supplied the answer that you could hold in your hand. I used them many times in Circuits.
              For a modern analysis of the positions read Adam Becker’s book “What is Real”. I thought that David Bohm had some of the best ideas at that time – “David Bohm argued that particles in quantum systems existed whether observed or not, and that they have predictable positions and motions determined by pilot waves. John Bell then showed that Einstein’s concerns about locality and incompleteness in the Copenhagen interpretation were valid. It was he who refuted von Neumann’s proof by revealing that it ruled out only a narrow class of hidden-variables theories”.
              Now try to explain Feynman’s “Sum over Histories” Path Integral theory.
              Best regards

              • 2
                0

                My apologies for the bold, slip of the Word Processor.
                Best regards

              • 0
                1

                Let me affirm my opposition to Zionism in my effort to undo Scot’s bold!
                .
                Panini Edirisinhe

            • 0
              1

              Hello Scot,

              Don’t forget the Six Day War. Had Israel lost, there would be no Jews in Israel/Palestine. A “reasonable” agreement with the Arabs? The Hamas Charter says otherwise. Even when you take “Jews” out of the picture, there is no such thing as an Arab “democracy.” Turkey might be the closest thing, but Turkey did not have free elections and sponsors jihad all over the globe. The point being that Arab countries are generally governed by a “strongman”, very often a dictator. This dictator operates outside the law. Whether Saddam Hussein, Assad, or Erdogan. The US could not implement any kind of “democracy” in either Iraq or Afghanistan (not Arab but Islamic). Once Saddam Hussein was removed from power in Iraq, ISIS flourished. In Afghanistan, the Taliban burned down schools for girls. Democracy does not work for Arab/Islamic countries. Some other system, based on autocracy, is needed. Thomas Guthrie had good insight, regardless of his mental state.

  • 0
    2

    “I used them many times in Circuits.”

    Solid-state physics makes free use of QM.

    Regarding John Bell, his findings actually support the Copenhagen Interpretation. Because in many of the experiments he carried out, the so-called Bell Inequalities was violated. This does not favor the “local realism” that Einstein supported. Local realism rests on two fundamental assumptions: (1) nothing travels faster than the speed of light, and (2) physical properties exist independently of observation. The first assumption may be proven wrong in the future: (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XlJrw6VLECw&ab_channel=GuardianNews). The second assumption contradicts Heisenberg’s Uncertainty Principle.

    It seems that many professional researchers still support the Copenhagen Interpretation:

    “After 1925 Bohr and his associates introduced a new and unprecedented lowering of critical standards for scientific theories. This led to a defeat of reason within modern physics and to an anarchist cult of incomprehensible chaos.”

    http://claesjohnson.blogspot.com/2018/06/time-for-real-quantum-mechanics.html

    • 0
      1

      *were violated

      • 0
        2

        Sorry, I gave the wrong link. It is a complex subject, well beyond my comprehension as an amateur, so I am deferring to greater minds. Here are some very interesting tidbits from Lubos Motl. Motl, a researcher in String Theory, got in a lot of “trouble” at Harvard for his right-wing political views.

        ” One may discuss what exactly “counts” as a condition for a view to be called the Copenhagen interpretation but to refuse the Copenhagen interpretation in the more inclusive sense means to deny all of quantum mechanics and all the insights for which Heisenberg, Born, Dirac, and others got their Nobel prizes.” (Clever!)

        “The people favoring “different interpretations” are actually denying quantum mechanics per se. The term “different interpretations of quantum mechanics” is just a euphemism for “crackpottery of denying quantum mechanics.” (Motl likes to use this word, “crackpot”)

        “*This* is quantum mechanics as a framework. Calling it an “interpretation” to make it look more disputable is a pure demagogy – these are still the key foundations of quantum mechanics that every good physics undergraduate student simply has to learn and be able to reproduce or use at 3 am.”

        https://infoproc.blogspot.com/2015/11/the-measure-problem-in-many-worlds.html

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.