21 June, 2024

Blog

JR’s ‘Men And Memories’: A Personification Of Aloofness: A Review

By Palitha Pelpola

Palitha Pelpola

“Read no history: nothing but biography, for that is life without theory.” ~ Benjamin Disraeli

Legacies are not created out of thin air. They are the sum of one’s lifetime’s successes and failures, of achievements and unfulfillments, victories and defeats and above all, one’s commitment to a cause and his lamentable vacillation from it. ‘Men and Memories-Autobiographical Recollections and Reflections by JR Jayewardene is no ordinary book penned by the subject himself. A lifetime of commitment to the panorama of local politics that spanned over five decades, from pre-indipendent Ceylon to the outer edge of the twentieth century, is drawn in the pages with an eldritch sense of detachment. Its richness in facts, clarity of mind that presented them and the detachment with which the the story is told is extraordinary. In the annals of political biographies, ‘Men and Memories’ stands out as one that captures the reader’s attention to the minutest detail of a chaotic time between 1987 and 1989, but also to the macro picture of Ceylon’s development and ripening from a subject people to a sovereign family of men and women of the new world.

JR Jayewardene was no ordinary politician. His method of governance, his strategic planning, the ultimate achievement of its goals set upon that planning and the unmatched patience displayed by him throughout his life, could be an ideal subject matter for any postgraduate student to study and write a thesis on.

Divided into ten chapters, JR begins, as he writes, ‘at the beginning’. And at the end of the preface to his autobiography JR writes thus: ‘In the account of Men and Memories, which is not strictly an autobiography, I seek to present some autobiographical recollections and reflections which were inseparable  from my life, and for over more than half a century of work. This I do in the hope that the contemporary and future generations would be enabled to understand the Agony and Ecstasy of Sri Lanka and her people with more insight, understanding and compassion.’ Then he paints the story of Ceylon from 1505, invasion of coastal Ceylon by the Portuguese. A remarkable account of Ceylon’s political evolution from 1505 to 1948, is  so succinctly written as an amateur historian, JR is more elaborate than some history textbooks we have read in our schools.

Yet the evaluation of the book must be as objective as is possible. JR has not told any ‘untruths‘. On the contrary, he has told ‘nothing but the truth’; yet in the same vein, he has not told the ‘whole truth’. Obvious omissions are glaring, may be for a reason. If JR’s purpose was to present the changing historical drama in one hundred and ninety two pages, he has certainly accomplished the task. But for a student of contemporary times and its his immediate past, it is lacking in some personal underachievements and failures.

Narration of the Jayewardene-Gandhi Accord and its aftermath yearns for yet unknown details this writer has been privy to. His understatements regarding Prime Minister Premadasa’s unequivocal opposition, certain preconditions demanded by India as per Indian High Commissioner JN Dixit’s account as penned in ‘Assignment Colombo’ and the founding of the failed JVP-revolution in the ’87-’89 period solely on Indo-Sri Lanka relationships cannot be disregarded as a matter of forgetfulness by JR. It was a deliberate skip.

JR’s critics would undoubtedly be harsher in their final assessment of his regimes and his overall political life given the consummate aloofness of demeanor JR always projected. This aloofness, unfortunately for JR himself, gave credence to the appraisal of his character as one who did not possess that one singular quality which all politicians should possess- empathy. However, in my own assessment, as a one who had the privilege of being associated with him in official work, I challenge that view. JR was one politician whose empathy was second to none in Sri Lanka’s political leaders. Yet he never displayed that in a normal way; nor did he resort to cheap demeanor of some politicians who held others’ babies in their arms for the benefit of photographers. 

Simply put, J R Jayewardene was the most misunderstood politician in Sri Lanka. He was misunderstood from the time he entered politics to the time he retired. Men and Memories is devoid of his personal likes and dislikes of a certain caliber of men and women. His remoteness was total and absolute. Allow me to give one single example of this quality of the man. I met him soon after his mammoth victory in 1977 elections. Thereafter, I met him after the assassination of my close friend Harsha Abheywardana, the then Chairman of the UNP and also during Gamini Dissanayake’s funeral. J R portrayed the same face, same countenance and the same equanimity. He was touched by the loss but never rattled or distressed. Such stoic equanimity does not belong to ordinary men. That composure won him the ’77 election victory, such stoicism won him many lifelong friends and disciples. 

JR the Indophile

Inclusion of his correspondence with Jawaharlal Nehru and other Indian leaders of the nineteen forties, his famous speeches in the SAARC meetings in the nineteen eighties and his devotion to the ideals pursued by Gandhi and other Indian leaders give a glimpse of depth and breadth of his understanding of the geopolitical contexts of a forgotten era. The profuseness of his knowledge, comprehension of contemporary issues with a geopolitical connect and personal relationships with the Indian leaders add to a subtle and profound mindset of a leader whose unfortunate legacy happens to be his failure to tackle the 1983 Tamil riots and its immediate aftermath. The only time he tends to be emotional, if it was emotional at all, was when he mentions the names of Nehru and Gandhi and one other local politician, D S Senanayake. Being the only locally educated member of Ceylon’s first Cabinet, except D S himself, all others educated abroad, either at Oxbridge  or other prestigious university in the United Kingdom (UK), JR held the most pivotal portfolio, Finance. Yet, that subtle empathetic feel never found expression in JR’s speeches, action or personal conduct.           

I have personally met J R many a time. Allow me to mention below one incidents that would live long, until my last breath: In the context of recent history of Sri Lanka, it is quite significant. After the election defeat in 1994, being the leader of the Kandy district (only, Kandy, Nuwara Eliya and Badulla districts were secured by the UNP), Gamini Dissanayake (GD) decided to contest Ranil Wickremesinghe, the outgoing Prime Minster, for the position of the Leader of the Opposition. Gamini and I came down to Colombo and we had a hurried meeting at his residence. Those who attended the meeting were Gamini, Dr. Wickema Weerasooria, Rohan Pethiyagoda (GD’s other brother in law), Srima Dissanayake (Gamini’s wife) and myself. It was the consensus of all of us that GD should contest Ranil for the Leader of the Opposition position. It was also decided that GD should immediately inform Ranil personally by calling on him wherever he was at the time.

After some difficulty I managed to locate where Ranil was. He was at the Temple Trees. GD and I got into GD’s bullet-proof Volvo and started going towards the Temple Trees. For a minute it occurred to me to look who was there with us that day. The driver was Piyasena and the personal security guard was Mahatung and the other was me. All three had joined GD when he was an ordinary MP in 1970 Parliament, a way before GD became a Minister. The original team was there in that car. On our way, when we turned our car to the 5th Lane on the way to Galle Road, I received a call on my cellular. It was Pradeep Jayewardene, JR’s grandson. He told me thus: ‘Palitha, ‘Seeya’ (grandfather) wants to meet GD asap’. When I said that to GD, he said that would see him after meeting Ranil.

When we visited JR, he was fresh from a bath, emanating a lovely scent of the soap he used; he asked us to sit down and what he began to relate to us was no ordinary stuff. It was like a superior professor teaching to a class of keen students. I give below in a nutshell of what he said: ‘Gamini, when Dudley passed away I was holidaying in Mirissa (a town in the Deep South in Sri Lanka). On hearing of the news, I immediately took off for Colombo and dropped my wife at Braemar and headed straight for ‘Sirikotha’ (UNP headquarters). The meeting had started but the head-chair was vacant. That was the chair which was usually occupied by Dudley as the leader of the party. I did not ask anybody; went straight to that seat and sat down. I started to conduct the meeting. After that they accepted me as the leader of the Party. No one dared contest me; no one challenged my position. Gamini, JR said, this Party is yours. Go and take it over. Nobody is going to give it to you on a platter. You assume leadership and bring back the honor that we have lost in the recent past’. No mention of the outgoing Prime Minister, Ranil Wickremasinghe, his mother’s niece’s son.

JR, at the time in 1994, was 89 years ‘young’; he was never clearer than on that occasion. In those few minutes, not exceeding twelve or thirteen in all, he gave us a free lesson on the ups and downs of politics; how to attain leadership of one of the two leading political parties in Sri Lanka. His profile while delivering these unforgettable words was devoid of emotion; devoid of laughter or sadness; it was clear, cold, calm and above all else, aloof and detached. It was quintessential JR! It is with that same coldness, same clarity, same calmness and same detached and aloof manner he has written his autobiographical story. 

*The writer can be reached at palithapelpola@gmail.com   

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 10
    0

    Hey Pelpola,

    “1983 Tamil riots.” Anti-Tamil mob violence instigated by JRJ’s own supporters. And it would be his legacy. No amount of perfumes can change that.

    • 4
      2

      Thanks, Palitha.
      .
      I say that despite deepthi silva’s excoriation of what you say. You were not Prince Hamlet, nor was meant to be; I’m even more obscure. But at least we don’t mislead.
      .
      Agnos is right; we still have more to pay for those July 1983 riots, which were so meticulously prepared for by JR’s lackey, Cyril Mathew.
      .
      We exchanged many emails in 2015, when you attempted to guide Maithripala. We tried, and failed. In the run-up to those elections, Colombo Telegraph and the like were not accessible to us in Lanka. The legacy of Yahapalanaya included allowing us to know what others were saying about us.
      .
      Anonymous commenters are a huge problem; not when they’re consistent, as deepthi silva, and nimal fernando are. No comments on this article from old codger and “leelagemalli”, who boast that they were pre-2015 comenters here. They specialise in misleading. I’m making this comment because I realise that there campaigns based on half-truths may succeed.
      .
      I hope that you will write more articles. Our society needs these insights.
      .
      Panini Edirisinhe of Bandarawela (NIC 483111444V)

      • 1
        0

        SM the NIC Hunter of CT@
        .
        Even if you have not yet been able to respond constructively to our long-awaited questions, what are you saying about us again? how shameless you should be ?

        I will come with my comment later to the current article, however, I will add something else, before that, I was quick to come with the following comment based on Canada and India conflict.

        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E3tpwyvSqhk
        .
        Today we the srilankens can learn more from Canada.
        .
        Leaders of Trudeau’s (51 years) nature have lost complete credibility to be called the most disliked leader in the entire world. Mouth is a good organ of people that should be used very carefully on the international stage, however if they abuse it in public, it can be like a powerful bomb.
        . Young leaders don’t seem to care. 12 days ago, Trudeau publicly criticized India saying “Death to Indians”. Now that same man comes to India as if he was born yesterday and gets kissed by Modi joker.
        :
        We have a JVP-NPP leader who dreams of becoming the leader of Sri Lanka from next year, however he needs to learn more in addressing issues with international allies. A person cannot be made a leader just by making accusations. AKD’s specialty is pointing the finger at others only.

      • 0
        0

        Sinhala Man and his behaviour is no different to a worker for FREEMANSONRY.
        .
        https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O30ufWni5UU

        He is talented at persecuting annonymous CT commenters.

  • 7
    0

    This kind of nonsense is what passes for history/intellectual writing in Sri Lanka !

    An obvious political lackey , waiting for crumbs to fall from his corrupt masters table, writing about his social superiors in hero worshipping terms.

    It is clear our education system has failed miserably , giving these half-baked characters professional certificates to pose off as lawyers, PhDs and to come forward as political activists ( to ruin and rob the country further )

    The writer takes pains to show how close he was the characters like JR and Gamini Dissanayake. How can a lackey understand what happens in the superiors mind ! It like a driver writing about his master ! A servants inferior opinion !

    Was JR, a wise capable man or a confused old man who ruined everything he dabbled in ?

    Was Gamini inherently corrupt and violent ( Jaffna library ) , while posing off as a good man in national costume ?
    Our history will condemn them as among those who ruined this country

  • 9
    0

    “The one who blows his own trumpet also farts the loudest” ……… Dabali.

    • 9
      0

      The Megalomaniac grabbed the empty chair claiming sole ownership ,telling others with that smug smirk , ” no one dare or challenge me ” . He later went on to do the same with PM / President’s chairs. Remember the empty / undated resignation letters. Advised a kleptomaniac to follow the same (most probably told the same to nephew before telling Gamini). And Palitha calls it ” an ultimate achievement “.

  • 10
    0

    “JR was one politician whose empathy was second to none in Sri Lanka’s political leaders. “

    You must be joking. Having gleefully nestling with an out and out racist like Gamini Dissanayake, you might have your own definition for “empathy” . 1983 riots would have been totally avoided if JRJ had an iota of empathy towards the minority Tamils. The whole country was destroyed and country was put into war path and economic disaster by this single act. Your minister the precursor to the Rajapakse looters was another culprit.(Jaffna library burning)

  • 9
    0

    “It is with that same coldness, same clarity, same calmness and same detached and aloof manner he has written his autobiographical story.”
    He did it the same way with the July 1983 pogrom he unleashed against the Tamil people.

    • 4
      0

      Captain Morgan,
      Isn’t that ‘autobiographical story’ a clear sign of experience!

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.