1 July, 2022

Blog

People’s Preamble To IMF Technical Report

By Hema Senanayake

Hema Senanayake

I, including many concerned people, requested Dr. Nandalal Weerasinghe and the government to reveal the technical report submitted to the IMF. This is important because, given the country’s current political situation, the IMF needs the political and social consensuses on any IMF support program. Since, it is not forthcoming from responsible government agencies, I decided to write a preamble for a possible IMF technical report with an objective to get wider political and social consensus. Here it is.

Sri Lanka understands that it had done many macroeconomic mistakes in economic governance, in recent past. It further understands that setting proper macroeconomic fundamentals means nothing other than setting the causes in the cause-and-effect relationship of the whole economic system. In this cause-and-effect relationship we cannot get the desired effect or outcome without setting the causes, which means without setting the proper macroeconomic fundamentals. It is these fundamentals that only a government can change either for good or bad. Sri Lanka did it wrongly and the outcome is the present unprecedented economic crisis with having scarcities of many essentials including lifesaving medications.

Sri Lanka determines to change the course by setting new set of macroeconomic reforms in the economy by obtaining wider political and social consensus for reforms. Such general consensus about economic reform is vital to ensure that the set macroeconomic approach would remain as it is even though political power switches among political parties when decent democratic elections are held. Sri Lanka understands such guarantee for sticking to the economic reforms is important not only to the IMF but also to the existing creditors of foreign currency denominated loans and any possible investors who wishes to invest in dollar denominated fixed rate bond issues ignoring credit ratings in near future.

Sri Lanka further understands that far reaching successful economic reforms beyond regular monetary and fiscal reforms are not possible without proper philosophical understanding of how money based economic system works. This is a time that whole Sri Lankan society is awakened to hear and to understand the structure of the economic system and how it works and what are the economic variables that the government could and should maneuver to have a sound and resilient economy.

Sri Lanka understands that the economy is and should be based on market exchange of goods and services (call market mechanism) which is dependent upon a sound monetary infrastructure. Market mechanism in general set the prices or the relative value of any produce which even helps to produce common interests (public services) such as general administration, law and order, education, health etc., by the government. Sri Lanka understands that market mechanism is not a tool for pure exploitation but a tool an efficient mechanism or tool for the validation of the use of social resources in any production of goods and services efficiently.

The market mechanism simply doesn’t work if there is no instrument that penetrates each cell of produce to reveal its relative value so as to exchange the produce in the market. The money does this job. Without a stable currency it is not possible to reveal any produce’s relative value, and in the event that will lead to a significant market failure and continued economic crisis. Therefore, Sri Lanka understands the need to strengthen market mechanism and to have a near perfect stable currency.

Further, Sri Lanka understands that the economy will grow if the capital allocation and the consumption allocation are increased on continuing basis. It further understands that these allocations are originated from the total proceeds (not GDP) or from the total sellable output which means that the only option to ensure economic growth is to increase the total sellable output and in turn this is possible by expanding the entrepreneurial base. Sri Lanka understands that the expansion of entrepreneurial base is not possible without increasing the “business confidence’ among entrepreneurs. This is where entrepreneurs -local and international, look at real economic parameters rather than political promises. Business confidence increases if market forces determined current account balance is positive or at least steady if deficit is reported. If the domestic currency depreciates or if currency is fakely stable while foreign reserves depreciate, it is highly unlikely that there could exist a good business confidence. Sri Lanka further understands that the increased business confidence may significantly contribute to expand the country’s total sellable output while contributes to positively change the country’s current account when entrepreneurs invest in businesses that would increase net inflow of foreign currencies. This situation may further improve the balances in capital account through non-credit based inflow of foreign currencies such as FDIs and foreign grants etc. ultimately contributing to ease the Balance of Payment situation.

Therefore, Sri Lanka understands that IMF support program is essential in easing balance of payment crisis, stabilizing the domestic currency, which would ultimately increase business confidence. Along with such stabilization of domestic currency which helps in increasing inward remittances, increase tourist arrivals, streamlining exports and regaining lost export quotas etc. will increase the confidence of international community on the country which waiting to kick off the inflow of foreign investments to Port City Project.

In view of above Sri Lanka understands its massive responsibilities towards the changing and strengthening of fiscal and monetary policies including the short term use of administrative tools to take care of the current account balance in the short run. However, Sri Lanka further understands that finding a lasting solution to the economic crisis is not possible without reforming the entire economy by changing the entire macroeconomic approach.

As mentioned before Sri Lanka understands that the increase of total sellable output would increase the capital allocation and allocation for the consumption. The capital allocation is a society’s decision and hence entrepreneurial holders of capital reserve are obligated to use those resources for useful investments including investments that might possibly change the country’s national current account. Accordingly, taxation policy of the profit reserve of entrepreneurial entities would not be ad-hoc. instead, the policy would be based on to optimize the capital accumulation and the application of the same for the country’s economic growth and especially job creation. On the other hand Sri Lanka understands that it is the consumption allocation which should be taxed to collect money for the government which is obligated to produce common interest (public services) for the society hence taxation policy on the consumption allocation would be designed to achieve two basic objectives, one is to optimize the general wellbeing of the members of the society and the other is to support the increase of total sellable output focusing on having positive impact on the current account.

Thus, Sri Lanka having understood the macroeconomic implications of taxation policy, it further understands the necessity of continuing increase of country’s total proceeds which is in turn linked to the rational optimization of public sector and its expenditure. However, Sri Lanka understands that this objective of optimizing public sector cannot be achieved without ensuring the free flow of labor between public sector and entrepreneurial sector which in turn cannot be achieved without having universal pension reforms enabling the auto adjustment of productivity increases and inflation in calculating pension (retirement) benefits.

Further Sri Lanka understands that administrative price-system does not work in the long run hence it determines to ensure that the value of almost every produce be reflected based on market forces and Sri Lanka is mindful that ensuring such process is an integral part of proper taxation mechanism to remove unjust distribution of distributable output.

Sri Lanka further understands that in order to function efficient market mechanism and economy needs to ensure that everybody should be reflect its true cost not any administrative price. Using this economic principle in regard to state owned enterprises (SOEs) is vital in restructuring them to perform an important role in the country’s economy. However while ensuring to reflect true value of output, it is necessary to ensure that their services such as electricity, water etc., are accessible to low income groups of the society. Proper taxation mechanism instituted can be used in ensuring accessibility to vital services for low income groups. In that respect, taxation mechanism is not only a tool to collect income for the government, but also an efficient mechanism of the delivery of social benefits to low income groups.

Sri Lanka further understands that that rationalization of government expenditure must arise from the fact that the government is the largest institutional consumer and for its operations it must mainly find funds from the general allocation of consumption money mentioned above and not from deficit financing or from heavy borrowings either from domestic or foreign loans. Sri Lanka understands that the government should be prevented borrowing dollar denominated loans from foreign capital markets but should be able to raise money to roll over the existing foreign currency denominated loans subject to that such operation will last only up to the time of paying such loans in full.

Sri Lanka further understands that understand that the government should not undertake any infrastructure project either if it is not able to finance from its income or domestic loans taken subject to the debt limit set by the macroeconomic fundamentals and approved by parliament. However, the government undertakes strategically important infrastructure projects that are justified by the increased economic output or increase wellbeing of the society subject to the proven debt sustainability. Sri Lanka understands that the government its agencies do not enter into any venture or project that are partly or fully funded by foreign currency denominated short to medium term loans borrowed from commercial capital market including any Exim bank of a foreign country.

Further Sri Lanka understands that given the massive money printing spree undertaken by the central bank under government’s persuasion, the bank will not have enough policy tools to contain credit growth, in the case of the economy started to grow. Therefore, Sri Lanka further understands the need of acquiring new policy tools or need to plan ahead to contain credit growth not increasing interest rates.

In view of the above, this preamble explains the necessary macroeconomic principles that Sri Lanka should adhere to, immaterial of the change of political power in democratically contested national elections.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 0
    1

    Mr Hema Senanayake,
    Morning.
    Thanks for that all enveloping ‘People’s Preamble to IMF Technical Report’.
    We are committed, bring Sri Lanka out of the ‘Doldrums’, we got into by Design, Accident, experimenting with ‘NEW ECONOMIC THEORY’!
    Whatever, now, we need CHANGE of attitude and direction, which is the important element!
    My request is, our country, though claims 80 – 85% literacy and numeracy rate, sadly but surely lacks comprehension of the Queens’ Language – perhaps we have an inherent hate due to past Colonial Rule and our natural love of the native tongue – Sinhala & Tamil, which is enriched by long Sri Lankan heritage nestled with near 2500 years of culture.
    The “Kaduwa” is second place of importance in studies, with no special effort to study, comprehend the English Language well enough!!
    Past President (2018), who was under oath, to uphold the constitution instead, sacked incumbent PM and sadly,claimed ignorance of constitutional provision!! Laughing stock
    So help the people at large, to understand implications of this resolution, sought for this complex problem, translate this fantastic piece of “PREAMBLE” into Sinhala and Tamil, in easy to understand (LUCID) terminology ”NEED FOR CHANGE OF ATTITUDE AND CULTURE”!
    Enables voters and government understand commitment!

    • 2
      6

      Hema: Please don’t talk rubbish! Sri Lanka needs Debt Cancellation after the biowar Covid-19 project. Sri Lanka should buy oil and gas from Russia and take Chinese loans tell the IMF to go to hell! Look at what IMF did to Greece, Argentina etc. Have you heard of Stiglitz?
      Why is the IMF report not available??!. The Data is Fake! The bottom line is that there is NO Transparency when it comes to the IMF and Washington Consensus which pumped and dumped Sri Lanka into an Upper Middle Income County (MIC) in 2019, making it hard to borrow at concessionary rates and forced it into an ISB Debt trap and default in 2022!. What sort of nutcase economist are you?!
      Washington’s game with the UNP/SJB and SLFP/PP is Heads I win, tails you lose” Ranil or Basil, makes no difference and either way the IMF and Washington wins! All political parties are corrupt -bought by USAID and work for it. Parliament is a Puppet Show.
      Sri Lanka understands that IMF support program is essential in easing balance of payment crisis – What tosh is this!

      • 0
        0

        Dinuk,

        What nonsense! Who cares about the debt. Nobody is asking for their money back….they have only lost on Sri Lanka. Even China and Russia have lost on Sri Lanka. It is even difficult to ask Russia for a credit line on their oil. China has to save face in the midst of the accusations of being a debt trap. Sri Lanka can’t even feed or her people with her own produce at the present time. Even MMT won’t work.

    • 0
      1

      “The market mechanism simply doesn’t work if there is no instrument that penetrates each cell of produce to reveal its relative value so as to exchange the produce in the market. The money does this job. Without a stable currency it is not possible to reveal any produce’s relative value,”
      The SL rupee is not a stable currency. Some countries have adopted the USD, which itself depreciates, but not as much as the LKR.
      For us the best solution is to adopt the Indian Rupee, which, at 5.50, is still affordable and convenient. Sovereignty isn’t much use if we are reduced Ed to beggary.

      • 0
        1

        (Part I)
        OC,
        That is blasphemy! This country, with 2500+ years of Great Culture and History, with great Men and Women of yore, being in the forefront of leading this world, will never agree to compromising in any Way, Manner or Shape the ‘SOVEREIGNTY’ of this Resplendent country!!!
        Sovereignty is one that has been safely guarded from being eroded over the past 100’s of Years and is not negotiable, so say the Sangha, People and Rulers!!??
        They guard it so much, it is more important to be intact, than even the ‘Spick and Span’ white sarong worn to depict their national feeling of belonging to the Sri Lankan culture!!!
        As much as they feel emancipated and would not ‘Barter’ their White Sarong, for any reason whatsoever, instead of Trouser, Shirt, Tie and Coat, worn by western aspiring non-patriots around!!
        May dare say, (worst case Scenario) they may let go of the ‘White Sarong’, if the holding belt buckle comes loose but never the SOVEREIGNTY, under any circumstances , whatsoever, even if much in demand, ‘THORA’ Malu or Bairaha Chicken becomes unavailable for the ‘Alms Giving’ Ceremony, because of this Crisis??!!

      • 0
        0

        (Part II)
        SMACKS OF WESTERN ELITIST COUP OR AN INDIAN PLOT, TO CIRCUMVENT THE IMPENDING ABOLISHMENT OF 13TH AMENDMENT??!!
        Are you sure this crisis has been caused by the, “TIGER RUMP OF THE WW DIASPORA”???! They (Tigers) are trying their best to ‘WIN’, which eluded them in the armed struggle???!!!!!
        We didn’t have any of these problems, surprisingly for the 75 years since Independence and even during the 30years of war with ’Clandestine Tiger outfit’?! Did we let the Guard down post war??!
        They may be trying a Fast tracked proposition to become the 23rd state bartering the 13th??!!

      • 0
        0

        Error in (Part II)
        Instead of, “Are you sure this crisis has been caused”, should read as “Are you sure this crisis has NOT been caused “

  • 0
    0

    The causes were for the Monarchial cause; the effects were for the people to bear the burden of, and still worship them for a generation or two till the Monarchial system eventually adjusted for the better. It was implemented through the executive presidency. That was their Market Mechanism. Wider political and social consensus of democracy went down to a zero.

    Producing instruments to penetrate each cell of produce to reveal its relative value so as to exchange the produce in the market, as you say, is something beyond the scope of these incumbent rulers. Only a socialist party like the JVP will be able to implement these instruments.

    As such, current government is dictating to these foreign lenders in inflated terms. The foreign lenders, are so embarrassed, and are saying a big no, no! China thought they could do a fast upheaval of global economic conditions. To their horror, they too are stuck in a horrific catch 22 -situation. Removal of these leaders is the only way to remove the tool of pure exploitation – the only way IMF,ADB, WB, China, Russia, Japan, are ever going to give us funds and loans in the future.

    • 0
      0

      The Market Mechanism of the current rulers are mostly now about sending the Lankan worker abroad to bring in the much-needed dollars. That’s their only solution. Indeed, there isn’t any other at this time. The anger and resentment of the people is insatiable, for that is exactly what they have been doing for so many decades and had it all stolen from them.

      Whilst consumption allocation was increasing on a continuing basis, capital allocation was placed on credit for a long time. So, we are back to square minus one: We are deeply in unpayable debt, and entrepreneurial base cannot be expanded without the foreign lenders.

      But they did try to do some kind of entrepreneurship with Port City and Volks Wagon plants. PC is a dud…. crypto currency blockchain vanished in a jiff. The other parts of PC, like global Billionaires placing laundered money on PC, is just too obvious to pursue any further…won’t be allowed by institutions ensuring global money works in democratic fashion.

      • 0
        0

        State-Owned-Enterprise are directly related to foreign worker remittances. SOE’s give in-country employment to those who have worked abroad, or have family who work abroad. We can sit worrying about and blaming the SOE’s, and try to remove them to ease the debt burden. While they must be restructured, they hold the monetary value of the masses who go to places like the Middle East. Instead of dabbling in printing of money, better that those employed in SOE’s keep their jobs so they can pay for their essentials and not become low-income groups that will depend on hand-outs. At least they do some work at SOE.

        Only the JVP (maybe with some SJB), will be able to remove government expenditure. The other parties live in arrogance over the struggling masses.

        As per failing infrastructure projects, even COPE was bought up by incumbent rulers. Not a chance for Motherland if SLPP and UNP hang around any longer. Removal and dire Prosecution are the Keywords!

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.