25 April, 2024

Blog

Sinhala Only, Tamil Also — And Also (?) English?

By Manel Fonseka –

Manel Fonseka

We have just learnt that the NMSJ’s “proposal on language is to declare Sinhala and Tamil as official languages and to recognise English as the link language.

On Colombo Telegraph, the first response to this was from Sri Krish: “Why not declare Sinhala, Tamil and English as Official Languages?” to which I replied: “Why not?”

A Sinhala scholar (plus Sanskrit, Pali, Latin, Greek, English, etc.), my father was dead against the “Sinhala Only” Act, anticipating many problems to which it would give rise. Extremely pessimistic, despite the fact that his own professional life had always been in Sinhala. From 1942, he had broadcast a regular Sinhala “letter” from the BBC in London, and later founded the Sandesaya program, which he ran until 1955. He then returned here, to the country he had left “for ever” 23 years earlier, to take up the job of Deputy Editor on the Sinhala Encyclopaedia, which is what he was working on when the Sinhala Only Act was passed.

L to R: Me, my father, mother (now 102 in London) with her arms around the “baby” Sirima, the only one born here (1956), brother Amal (2 years younger than me,) Leela & behind her, her best friend Devika, Doric de Souza’s daughter.

Unfortunately, I fell foul of the act as I struggled with a language I was hearing and seeing for the first time, even more daunting in its “duality” – having spoken and written forms. Even Sinhala classmates (one of them now a well-known, confirmed and vocal nationalist), used to tell me how difficult it was for them to master the written language. Unable to obtain a Sinhala O-Level pass, despite nine O-levels (incl. Latin and French), I was not eligible to enter university here. We lived on the Peradeniya campus at the time and knew of certain undergrads, born and bred in SL, who had managed to deal with language requisite by “influence”. Alas, despite having friends in high places, my father was never one to ask for favours.

So, traumatised when torn away from England in 1955, I had scarcely recovered when another wrench came a few years later. I had to return to London, leaving my family and the place and people I had come to love. No option. It was decided that I join a grammar school in England and prepare for the A-Level exam there.

A photo taken by the Evening Standard, when I was a children’s librarian in London.

However, yet another obstacle was planted in my way. The Sri Lankan government ruled against my parents sending money to support me abroad. Why? Because I wanted to study English for my degree, and English was a subject available in the university here! Crazy!

So my mother decided to take all four children back to England, put us in school, find a job to support us until I had sat the A-Level exam and been accepted by a university. She would then return to SL with the younger children.

Rev Narada, JV Fonseka (My father), MB Ariyapala @ BBC 2 June 1949

Soon after arriving in England, we discovered that though I was still a British citizen, entitled to a university grant in Britain, three years’ continuous residence again were necessary to qualify. So I had to get a job to support myself, meanwhile. Birkbeck College in London offered part-time degree courses for working people. Lectures from 6pm till 9pm. I was just 19 when I began working full-time at the British Council and attending lectures after work. The academic year began in September, autumn. After several winter months working, studying and arriving home late at night, by tube, I gave up. It was only years later, at the urging of a SL friend, with an honours degree in English from an English university, that I re-applied to university. The friend coached me for the interviews and I was accepted by my first choice and obtained a grant. Not enough to support me totally, of course, so vacation jobs were necessary.

I can’t resist sharing, all these years later, my answer to the first question at the interview: “Why have you chosen this College first?” (Out of six choices.) I lived in Hampstead at the time, right by the Heath, and a bus started near the bottom of my road, going straight to the college. (Every morning I sat upstairs a few rows behind the Labour MP, Michael Foot, who always beat me to the front seats.) So, without stopping to think of an answer that would impress the panel with my great intelligence, I replied: “Because you’re on the 24 Bus route from home!”

Upon graduating, amazingly, after all this trouble, provoked, in a way, by unyielding, short-sighted language policies, I actually decided to return to the “source”. Once again, my parents were not allowed to buy me a ticket to come back, so I had to work again, at the BC, to earn a sea passage. However, too many problems faced me back in Ceylon and, despite being offered an assistant lectureship at Colombo University, I returned once again to England where I studied librarianship and worked for a few more years.

By the mid ‘70s I had become certain that Sri Lanka, despite so many drawbacks, was where I would settle down, and returned overland with three friends in a VW Beetle, taking in all sorts of extraordinary places on the way – five months – including climbing to the top of the great Bamiyan Buddha. Once here, I was urgently in need of a job and was offered one as the librarian in the regional office of an international organization. But! Of course, there is always a “but”. The post counted as “local staff”, so one had to be a Ceylon (still) citizen and I was only a Brit. Further, dual nationality/citizenship was still not permitted here. So – to be or not to be? That was the question. Commit or keep a loophole? After over 30 years of the privileges of a British passport?

What to do?

I decided to commit to this country, and so renounced Brit. Cit. in a ceremony at the High Commission — even had to pay a fee for doing so. I became a Ceylon Citizen. And that is all I am to this day.

To get back to what I started out to say (!) — I sincerely hope that serious attention be given to bring back English as an official language, with sufficient resources to train competent teachers. I think that Prof. Laksiri Fernando has somewhat spoken for me in his: “Just ‘recognition of English as the link language’ does not make any difference and sense. However, recognition…as an official language would be simple and effective. Making it the language of higher education and teaching English as a language in schools in addition to Sinhala and/or Tamil can revolutionize the country both in terms of education, development, and reconciliation.”

However, I also defer to the immense experience of Sinhala man in this regard & realize my opinion here is very subjective.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 13
    3

    This article is great news. Manel Fonseka knows English better than anybody else in Lanka. Her commitment to Justice, decency and egalitarianism, is total.
    .
    There are many possibilities to
    get this subject discussed in the next five days. I had been making comments here:
    .
    https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/nmsj-proposals-on-the-judiciary-fundamental-rights/
    .
    The inadequate comments there may have persuaded Manel, the writer of this article to give us something more complete.
    .
    Pay attention to what this writer I saying.

    • 9
      4

      Thank u Ms Fonseka/ for this article. I ll read it later. A wonderful day to u all from central Europe 😎😎😎😎

      • 0
        2

        LM,
        .
        Keep the thanks to yourself. Read the bloody article.
        .
        The problem with you is that you spend all your time listening to Sepal Amarsinghe.

        • 2
          0

          Beg to differ Mr. I am against SA so as you and the few. Dont compare me with and reitired men and women, we in europe keep working like workoholic ( 50 to 60 hours/week). There are times, I add mine to CT articles of my choice while me in waiting lounge in EU airports. Mostly at DUS and Heathrow.

          Please watch the video below
          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J8OKH3xJYpc
          .
          And honestly saying, I listen to various other sources in the same time. Please dont underestimate my mission. I was heading to north germany and held hours on high way, so that I could not get back to Manel s timely.
          :
          But I am glad to have added mine last evening. I think Manel should come with lot more articles since her writing style is the best.

    • 5
      1

      Sinhala_Man

      Please watch this FB clip:

      Dr. Paikiasothy Saravanamuttu’s speech at the Human Rights Day-2021 event about the challenges that human rights defenders will face in the country:
      https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=1120961385309085&extid=NS-UNK-UNK-UNK-IOS_GK0T-GK1C&ref=sharing

      Dr. Paikiasothy Saravanamuttu has raised a number of age old pertinent questions about Sangha and the chattering classes.

      • 3
        0

        Thanks, NV, I listened to it all.
        .
        Yes, that was a justifiably hard-hitting speech by Paikiasothy, whom I don’t personally know, but like most Lankans, know about.
        .
        You may be surprised to be told that I have not met nor spoken to; however, she and I I know each other well, and I’m not surprised to see most readers being fascinated by the Manel Fonseka story.
        .
        However, I know that Manel will be disappointed even if we don’t go beyond it and use it to find answers to the language problems that we

        • 1
          0

          . . . the problems that we are faced with.
          .
          I’ve got a few computer problems. Diagnosed now! This laptop has no battery, and I shouldn’t be using it like that. Don’t worry too much about it. See what a cry baby I turn into!
          [edited out]
          .
          Manel is right when she says that I have had experiences as strange and varied as hers, but confined mainly to Asia, mainly Lanka. All this talk won’t be much use unless we work out solutions for our people. I had already made a start with comments on Dr Jayampathy Wickremaratne’s article. You have the link from my first comment. Their arrangement is a bit of a mess. I will go there and continue. When comments cease there, I will come here.
          .
          I’ll try to make my comments more disciplined. My apologies for the mess!
          .
          My contribution will be to tell you in prosaic terms, the situation as it now is. Most unsatisfactory, but clearly, we can’t just say that and give up!
          .
          Panini Edirisinhe, now in Mahargama.
          .

  • 20
    3

    Sri Lanka will do well with English as an official language.

    But will the Sinhalese who have immense power over the rest of us because theirs is the official language, ever agree to giving it up?

    I doubt it.

  • 6
    13

    Almost all developed countries have one official language. Not many. Just one. The language of the majority.

    This must be the case within the island too if its nations must achieve development. All 3 nations.

    However, the problem is elsewhere. There are 3 nations within the island. One nation for each tribe. If the island is divided into 3 mono ethnic nations with relocation of people, all problems will be history.

    Until then tweaking language, this policy and that policy will not bring peace. Just plaster solutions.

    • 19
      1

      Gatam, re “Almost all developed countries have one official language….. The language of the majority,.” I wonder where this is not the case. Switzerland, for instance, has four “national” languages. I must look into how this is implemented.

      • 10
        1

        Don’t worry about Gatam he advocates the same thing at all forums. [edited out]

      • 1
        0

        This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy.

        For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

      • 0
        2

        Manel Fonseka,
        “Switzerland, for instance, has four “national” languages. I must look into how this is implemented.”

        What you are trying to do is like comparing apples and oranges.

      • 1
        0

        What about Canada, Belgium and India’s official state languages?

        • 0
          0

          According to Wimal Weerawansa, the Indian National Anthem is sung only in Hindi.

          • 1
            0

            S.M,
            It’s actually sung in Bengali, a minority language. How ignorant are our purported leaders! Probably a result of monolingual education.

            • 0
              0

              OC,
              supporting your thoughts.
              .
              Which language is used in national anthem of India?
              Bengali
              The song Jana-gana-mana, composed originally in Bengali by Rabindranath Tagore, was adopted in its Hindi version by the Constituent Assembly as the national anthem of India on 24 January 1950. It was first sung on 27 December 1911 at the Calcutta Session of the Indian National Congress.

    • 2
      5

      GATAM,
      “If the island is divided into 3 mono ethnic nations with relocation of people, all problems will be history.”
      —-
      Three mono ethnic nations should be:
      • Sinhala nation that includes Sinhala speaking people irrespective of their religion.
      • Tamil nation that includes all Tamil speaking people irrespective of their religion.
      • Adiwasi (Vedda) nation consisting of real indigenous minority community in Sinhale who speak Vedda language.

      If you want to bring religion into this, there should be separate areas for Sinhala Christians/Catholics, Hindu Tamils, Catholic Tamils and Muslim Tamils. Best thing is to divide on the basis of the language. All Tamil speaking people will be relocated to North. Adiwasi (Vedda) people will be given an area in the East which is their ‘Traditional Homeland’.

  • 12
    0

    Nice photographs …… a different era: all are dressed in long skirts. ……. Ramona also put up a photograph …… everyone is in micro mini skirts ……… horses couldn’t drag Old Codger away.

    I notice you all have Sinhala names. …….. Like many in their time, my parents were educated in English: couldn’t read or write Sinhala. But wanted to go nativist in a big way …… the first thing they did was give me Sinhala names. Their knowledge of Sinhala was so poor I ended up with 2 girls’ names! There are similar Sinhala boys’ names but you change a letter here and there they become girls’ names. It’s A Boy Named Sue all over again. But it hasn’t affected me that much: I was shipped out at an early age and out here they don’t know one name from another.

    • 9
      0

      continued

      It has its advantages though ……… when I was a kid, I was sent by my father to his bank – Bank of Ceylon, I think – to withdraw or deposit money …….. they give you a “token” and have to wait in a long queue. I saw people getting up from their desks and gathering at one desk …… they were looking down at the documents and then looking at me seated on the bench ….. after a several of these looks they waved me to come in ……. it was a mystery to them how a strapping boy – I was over 6 feet by 12/13 – had girls’ names. ……… I gave them one of my usual cock and bull stories, about a girl trapped in a boy’s body …….. they had their mouths open and the jaws were hitting the ground ……. after a while, of my sad story, all had empathy, sympathy and all the rest pasted all over their faces. …….. Upshot of all that was, I didn’t have to wait in the long queue, as I had been already called in, they did my work and sent me on my way ………….

      • 8
        0


        Recently I was stopped by a comely lady cop ……. checked my licence and burst out laughing: I couldn’t stop but laugh with her. That would’ve been the opening/ice-breaker for Old Codger for a date. …… I’m past my heydays of courting ……with a scalpel hanging over my head ………

        Although I studied in the Sinhala medium ……..strangely enough, I didn’t formally study English or Sinhala ……. sure, I was in classrooms but my mind wasn’t there. Only thing I studied formally was Sinhalese Literature – My parents wanted my Sinhala to be a lot better than theirs – from a Buddhist priest no less: a young Sinhala scholar and a good laugh. He would visit home and tech me during the vacations.

        I can still remember the books I studied …… Salalihini Sandeshaya, Guttila Kavaya, and a book by Madawela S Ratnayake (The name I’ve forgotten, but the beginning I still remember ……. Goda Mada dekema saru saraya ……)

        • 7
          0

          continued

          As my luck would have it, all the books were in verse …… and the Buddhist priest insisted on singing them to me ….. not from a few feet away but 6 inches from my right ear! ……. and the bastard couldn’t sing to save his life! ……. Still, when I hear the nasal drawl of Ameredeva, Victor Ratnayake, the hair on the back of my neck stand up.

          And Native thinks he has problems! ……… reading EE, Soma, Ramona …………

          • 2
            0

            nimal fernando

            “Still, when I hear the nasal drawl of Ameredeva, Victor Ratnayake,”

            W. D. Amaradeva was born on 5 December 1927 and was active between 1947 and 2016.

            He must have been lot younger than you were.

            Victor Rathnayake was born on 18 February 1942 and was active since 1958.

            It appears that Victor is lot younger than you are.

            Did it take you two or more years in each class?

            • 2
              0

              “It appears that Victor is lot younger than you are.”

              Geeze Native! ……I thought you were one of the least insecure …….. sorry, I’m not as old as you want me to be. ……..Most Lankans want to imagine me with a handicap …… either I’m missing a leg or I’m older than Santa Clause ………

              Visitors from SL, give us CDs of Ameradeva and Victor Rathnayake and I’ve tried to listen to them and they remind me of the Buddhist priest, my Sinhala Lit. teacher. He sang the same way …. with the lilting nasal drawl …….

              But one of my most treasured gifts ……. a cassette of Anton Jones also given by a visitor …….. I listen to it on a vintage Nakamichi RX505 which pops the cassette out and automatically turns it at the end of the first side …….. I don’t miss a beat on my dance routine …….

            • 0
              0

              nimal,
              .
              Connoisseurs of oriental music revere both Amaradeva and Victor. We should respect that.
              .
              However, if it is a different sort of music that you respond to, it is good for you to acknowledge that; without, however, hurting the feelings of the fans of A&V.
              .
              This honesty could be stretched out to many other fields.

        • 3
          0

          Nimal,
          “That would’ve been the opening/ice-breaker for Old Codger for a date. …”
          What was this lady cop’s badge number, please? It’s so wicked of you to keep it to yourself.

          • 2
            0

            Nimal,
            Apropos these nativist names, Portuguese /Dutch names and all sorts of permutations were popular till the late 19th century. Don Carolis (Portuguese/Dutch), Juwanis, Andiris (Dutch) ..etc.
            The Brits have us names like Solomon West Ridgeway Dias Bandaranaike. After that, Indian names like Ranjit, Sunil, Padma,. became fashionable. Nowadays many Sinhala children’s names are chosen by astrologers, and generally are randomly unpronounceable, besides making it difficult to figure out if the bearer is male or female.

            • 5
              0

              OC,

              My parents used to talk about a Lankan journalist, a friend of theirs …… I think his name was Darcy Vittachhi …… who had written a piece about Lankan names ……. one guy was named Sextus by his parents ….. and as Lankan traditions go, the main house is named after the youngest son who inherits the house …….. So this guy’s house was named “Sexville.” ……….The guy used to sit alone at home wondering why no one visits him!

              Is EE’s real name Sextus?

              • 3
                0

                nimal fernando,
                Tarzie Vittachi wrote the book, ‘Emergency 58. It was about the Government’s role in the country’s race riots.

                • 2
                  0

                  “Emergency 58”

                  Nathan,

                  That time, my grandparents had given refuge to a Tamil family they didn’t know, in their coconut estate in a very Catholic area …… where there was no rioting.

                  An old uncle who was a doctor in the public service and worked all over the island had known the gent who was a civil engineer who also had worked all over the island. The uncle had called and asked my grandparents if they can help the family.

                  Later on they moved to Canada and were very successful (both grandsons are cardiothoracic surgeons) but they never forgot ……. every time my parents visited Canada they would come to see them with gifts. They would have stayed with my grandparents 2 or 3 weeks max ………

                  I wouldn’t give anyone a can of baked beans ……… but my grandparent and parents have helped a lot of Sinhalese much more ……… bought all the servants lands and helped to build houses …….. taken some overseas and helped them to establish ……. but all see us as the enemy. Not a drop of gratitude.

                  Strange but true!

                  When I have to help, I help anonymously ………. they see kindness as weakness.

              • 0
                0

                Bah, nimal, Darcy, indeed!
                .
                Well done, Nathan.
                .
                nimal can think only of the “superior” characters in “Pride and Prejudice. Poor Elizabeth Bennet. One imagines that she had to call her husband Mr Darcy even in bed.
                .
                Well, in fact his mother had bestowed the first name Fitzwilliam on him. nimal ought to consult his kinswoman, Professor Yasmine Gooneratne, who is an authority on Austen.

                • 2
                  0

                  Tsk tsk …. give me a good Lankan name like Sunil, Nimal, Soma, Velupillay, Nathan, Native Vedda, …….. any day!

                  Who the bloody hell names a Lankan Tarzie? ………. Tarzan?

                  You blooming Lankan English scholars can keep your Fitzwilliam, Elizabeth Bennet, Austen …….

  • 7
    0

    Thanks for the interesting narrative of your early life in Ceylon and the UK. Enjoyed it.
    *
    Whether as a link language or official language, the use of English in Sri Lanka depends to a large extent on the competency of our English teachers. The better international and private schools may have competent English teachers, but, at most government schools, the English teachers themselves are barely able to handle the English language. They may be able to speak, and read and understand the language, at a basic level, but, when it comes to writing, most of them are abysmally incompetent.
    *
    The question is, how do we enhance the English of our English teachers?

    • 1
      0

      SarathP,
      Q: How do we enhance the English of our English teachers?
      A: Stop looking for excuses.
      Start teaching with whatever resources we have!

      • 1
        0

        I have an anecdote to share.
        .
        The School Inspection was on.
        An Inspector was assessing a teacher of English, in a primary class.
        Teacher: Children, repeat after me. G-R-I-L – Girl.
        The students dutifully repeated it.
        The dismayed Inspector quietly took the teacher aside, and said, “What you just taught is shameful. Girl is G-I-R-L, not G-R-I-L.”
        With a nonchalant shrug, the teacher said, “Sir, it will be, when you pay me enough. For what I get paid now, G-R-I-L is good enough!”.

    • 0
      0

      Dear SarathP,
      .
      You’ve identified one of the main constraints, but the moment you speak of it being the “better” schools being the only ones that have competent English teachers, the entire argument turns tautological, doesn’t it?
      .
      I wish nimal and Nathan, two of my favorite commenters because of their wit, would occasionally get a bit more serious in their analyses. I’m going to the bottom of the next page grateful that Manel has given us this opportunity to explore this terribly important subject relating to languages within Lanka.

  • 7
    0

    We’re entering a new world in which data is machine language is in English and important, we have to interact with the world so English is vital globally numerous communications networks that all speak the same digital language. Sinhala is within sri lanka Tamil within sri lanka and India English globa Most travel to other country universities and and the language wanted is english.

  • 16
    1

    Manel Fonseka,
    Thanks for a very interesting autobiographical sketch, please continue your narrative.

    We shall have English as an Official language along with Sinhalese and Tamil, English will never replace our own native languages, we will continue to cherish our own native languages, our religions, our cultures and all our glorious traditions and our way of life and English will be only a language of utility.

    Why fear?

  • 14
    1

    Making English a national language is an excellent idea. It is a rational and enlightened step that will democratize English by making it available to the children of the poor, the vast majority of the country’s school-going population. It will broaden perspectives, and help achieve the inner development necessary for the achievement of true economic and social development.

    • 6
      1

      Prof HL Seneviratne

      I completely agree with you.
      Now the problem is we do not seem to have enough professional English teachers among Tamil and Sinhala speaking people. The reason being we have invested too much in Nationalism and empty theatrics.

      Even at this 11th hour the rulers and saintly monks are after something that they seem to have no clue, or do not know what it is. Everyone has opinion to stir up the situation while the Sangha keeps a deafening silence.

      Those English speaking middle classes have no concern for the ordinary people. They sit on the fence until the situation get worst. Rather people want them to do something to stop the rot.

      • 5
        1

        Native Vedda,
        Shortfall of English teachers will continue to remain when there is no learning in the classrooms.
        We have to grow out of this conundrum by teaching English with the number of teachers we have.
        .
        Introducing Sinhala/Tamil instructions without considering the impact of abandoning English was like throwing out the baby with the bathwater!
        .
        Good to begin teaching with the number of teachers available now.
        .
        If anybody is listening, I am willing to Teach English for free.
        .
        I may not be a professional English teacher; but, I am a good teacher

        • 3
          0

          Nathan,
          .
          I gave your comment a LIKE, because I know that was sincerely meant. However, at least two conditions must be met.
          .

          1. We must, in some way, enjoy financial stability.
          .
          2. We must have “satisfactory” students.
          .
          I do freely give advice, but I’m old now, and if I had to give lots of basic instructions to scores of students, I’d be soon be sick of it.
          .
          There is an important third consideration. I must know that the knowledge tha I give out is to those who will use it to benefit others. This is particularly true of teaching English
          .
          In our society, English is too often used to keep others down. I know a fine teacher who stopped teaching in the local (Bandarawela) International
          School only two years ago
          He’s now 94. Such rare people exist.

          • 0
            0

            Just to assert that I know English:
            .
            Typo:
            .
            “basic instruction” NOT “basic instructions!
            .
            Putting the above line in, I realised that a mistake has crept into Android.
            .
            I know only two languages.
            .
            This may be a good time to make this observation.
            .
            English has become THE World Language owing to historical reasons. I use Lankan English. However, when I need to check usage, I go to Standard British English.
            .
            That’s a losing battle; American English will inexorably take over.
            .
            Never mind whether it is the American or the British version. It’s a messy language. Spanish would have been better.
            .
            But American English reigns supreme. That it was the Brits who colonised us, gave us an advantage over (let’s say) Vietnam.
            .
            Another blessing we didn’t appreciate.

          • 2
            0

            Dear Sinhala_Man,
            You are a genuine Language teacher. I was teaching Mathematics. (I was even called a MatheMagician!)
            .
            I faced setbacks as a Language teacher. My students did not even take the trouble to sit down and go thru the day’s lesson. They had nothing to lose, because they were attending for free!

            • 1
              0

              Thanks, Nathan.
              .
              Yours has been a very honest answer. I’m sure that you, and all other readers who were reading with a serious purpose, would realise that your efforts to teach did not really fail because the help was given free. There has to be professionalism, and unless there is respect for that, nothing will succeed.
              .
              I’m sure that you’re an excellent Maths teacher. I would seriously say that second language English teaching is very difficult.
              .
              I’m genuine, but not a particularly effective teacher. My strengths are a fairly solid knowledge of the language, and also of its Literature. After one has got those, it is pretty hard work. With really keen students, I know that I was among the best.
              .
              In most contexts, one can stop congratulating oneself on knowledge of Literature. Few are really interested in that now. What you have is silly veneration of it by those who rarely read anything.

        • 4
          0

          Nathan,
          .
          If you know all the facts about my career, you would realise that I have been exploited. However, there is a point at which I stop when it’s clear that some unscrupulous people are using me.
          .
          As I’ve told you, this guy, HCR, almost fits the bill. I have immense respect for him. I’m not as saintly!
          .
          But surely, you can’t be serious! Almost all Lankans desire to know English. Please tell me why you feel that they don’t flock to you. Once you tell me that, I’m sure that I’d be able to identify some fallacy in your thinking.
          .
          I’ve seen many intelligent comments by you. I respect you, that’s why I ask. Your comment starts with you talking sense!!
          .
          Panini Edirisinhe

  • 11
    1

    Manel Fonseka,

    Sinhala Only, Tamil Also — And Also (?) English?
    Not at all?
    It gives a distorted meaning that Sinhala is the only official language and Tamil and English is accepted and tolerated as a concession to the minority by the majority, it gives an impression of majoritarianism.
    It is far better to have Sinhala, Tamil and English as official languages without any qualifying adjectives

    • 8
      1

      Sorry Srikrish, obviously my title wasnt clear. I meant the final ? to refer both separately, to each individual element — as well as collectively, sweeping up all 3 lingos. Late-night, lazy rambling.

  • 3
    0

    Even in sri lank if a beggar begs in Sinhala or Tamil he gets one rupees But when he begs in English he get 10 rupees, I seen this in Sinhala films Predi silva acts

  • 5
    2

    Excellent narrative of a hectic personal experience (with nice photographs) touching on the bungled official language policy in Sri Lanka with sarcasm. Ambiguous policies both in the UK and Ceylon/Sri Lanka appear to have affected young Manel badly. Her courage has been marvelous facing the odds. I know for sure she had an excellent career and life. Her message is the most important: ‘go for English without neglecting Sinhala and Tamil. Young people will have great opportunities here and abroad.’

    • 6
      0

      Laksiri Fernando

      “Her courage has been marvelous facing the odds.”

      If ever South Asia offers a poor man’s Nobel Prize Manel and few others deserve it rather than brutal brothers who were awarded Honourary DSc and LLD. Those who proposed and seconded for the honorary doctorates for these thieving brothers should be ashamed of themselves. The Colombo Uni now has a Chancellor who is being ignored and insulted by graduating students at the graduation ceremony.

      See how the Uni is being destroyed by excessive patriotism of a few so called intellectuals.

  • 6
    1

    Manel, what caught my attention is the impact of “Sinhala Only” act, had on your family and your self. Even after going through adversity you decided to return back,shows that you are genuine. I wonder if a person of Sinhala origin had gone through such ordeal , what would have been the impact on the rest?? Hats off to your mom’s persistence and determination in ensuring her child complete education. Thank you , for sharing your personal experience with us.

    • 0
      1

      This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn’t abide by our Comment policy.

      For more detail see our Comment policy https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/comments-policy-2

      • 1
        0

        A moderator’s job isn’ easy. That wasn’t just a valid response, it was a necessary one.
        .
        I’d be surprised to find Manel NOT making a similar comment within the next two daýs.

  • 3
    2

    There is a confusion between national and official language. If we do not understand the problem then it is difficult to resolve this issue. Official language means that it should be used to official purposes (formal) to communicate with public by government and institutions. For example, government circulars, police reports etc. The national languages of this country are Sinhala and Tamil. Since the “Suyabasa” policy introduced the use of English language is neglected and the Sinhala only act Tamil as a National language ignored for political opportunism. This created unnecessary problems to this country including a war. It is important to recognise that sufficient knowledge of all three languages will benefit to the country. At least professionals and civil societies must get together for a common policy of educating children from all three languages.

    • 1
      0

      Amen!

  • 4
    2

    Racist Buddhist Monks pushed SWRD/Mrs. Bandaranike to bring the Sinhala Only theory to Sri Lanka. Not only now, even then the Buddhist Monks are the architects of spreading doom to Sri Lanka. The power of the Buddhist Monks has to be taken away first not by the Government but by the Buddhists themselves. These Monks must be allowed to only practice religion and only in a Vihara compound and not outside.

  • 3
    0

    Wot’s in a name, Nimal?
    My father was quite involved with the Indian independence movement in London, & knew Krishna Menon.  So my first name, Indra, which I never use, may have something to do with Nehru’s daughter. But “Manel” was decided by the group of SL friends (of every community – I can only remember the names of Crossette Thambiah & Rahman Hathy) who shared a house with my parents those days.  My mother had no say in it!  “Amal” was chosen by my father from Tagore’s play “The Post Office.”  And “Sirima” emerged from the Sinhala Encyclopaedia staff where one of the editorial assistants was also an astrologer.  He insisted on a name starting with “Si”.  It was ’56, so what else…?

    Amal decided to come when the bombs were falling & the ambulance couldnt get through.  Emergency!  He was delivered by a medical student (who later failed his finals & ended up running a pharmacy on the Galle Road, Bambalapitiya – Sittam’s) and placed in a drawer. Cont/
     

  • 4
    0

    Cont./
    Though growing up as a little English girl, I was always aware & quite proud of the SL part & of my father — unlike my brother, who suffered at school on account of his “funny” name.  He always said he was Ian or Cliff (after Richards) & when expecting friends home forbade us to call him by his name while they were there.  I had no hang-ups about being half-black even though I was taunted by children in some of the streets I walked through on the way to school, over a mile away.  Somewhere in early 1950s, I was waylaid & intimidated by group of Teddy Boys…on a patch of rather secluded abandoned land, still full of bomb debris, that I had to cross between main roads on the way home. I burst into tears & one said: “Oh, let the little bitch go!”
    ___
    The earliest memory of my name being problematic was on my first day at infants’ school.  All the children were seated in the hall while their names were called out. Girls had to join one line, boys another.  When I heard “May-nel” called, I got up to join the girls’ line.  Imagine my horror when the teacher called out from the stage: “Oh! It’s a little girl!”
    And the hall burst into laughter!

    • 0
      5

      Manel…..Aww, poor you! What a suffering with the British people. I do so sympathize.

      All Motherland had to do was re-structure the Sinhala language courses to incorporate the many mixed-lot people with other brain waves to enter into the sacred portals of the Sinhala psyche. That’s what is called Evolution, for the honor of the Motherland. Instead, I hear they are making the language more and more complicated, in an attempt to appease the shame and anger they felt when the British came and ridiculed the language. (And now they are putting in more ancient Bengali words into it also, instead of incorporating it with Tamil and English).

      (on another story to make you feel a bit better……living in S.E. Asia, the Malays and Chinese used to laugh and mock our “Indian-ness.” “Kaling” was the racist word for us S. Asians. “Go home, Kalings.” You couldn’t walk the streets before being called “Anderey-Punderey,” and mocked in Indian dancing ways because the fellows were actually hooked on Hindi films. This was in the 70’s and 80’s, but things have changed since then I think. Childhood memories, but in the end we have fond memories and love the people of the place.)

      • 9
        0

        Dear Ramona, thank you for your sympathy. But, forgive me for saying so, I think I have suffered rather more here than in my years in Britain. This country has gone through so much trauma and even if I wasnt one of the unhappy targeted victims, I was never able to close my eyes or block my ears to what others were experiencing. And from 1980, when I joined the Civil Rights Movement, I could rarely switch off from the more negative aspects of life here.

        • 0
          0

          Humans with different looks and culture are strange to others at first, but everybody soon gets used to each other after a few decades. The S.E. Asian region was prosperous (with oil and gas), and people were therefore more amiable. The Malays are genetically a very calm and peaceful race of people. If those guys didn’t like the S. Asian darker skin and big features, they got used to it eventually. Most of the Malays and Chinese were very kind and hospitable, and didn’t mind us around actually, although once in a while they liked to have a bit of fun with the strange S. Asian culture and look. It took some time for them to realize that in some parts of the world, they too looked strange, behaved in odd ways, and had funny accents. All is the result of globalization, till mindsets adjust. It takes a strong leader to stop racism. In S.E. Asia, Lee Kwan Yew made it a criminal offence with jail and fine if an Indian was called “Kaling.” Its effect gradually spread to the rest of the region.

          In Sri Lanka however, millennia of interaction and assimilation hasn’t done much to help Lankans (who almost look the same) enter the globalized world. I believe the racism is on both sides. Current leaders are making the situation far worse. A strong leader needs to emerge.

          • 0
            0

            Ramona,
            “while they ((Malays) liked to have a bit of fun with the strange S. Asian culture “
            Perhaps you don’t know that, from Angkor to Borobudur, the culture is heavily Indian-influenced, and the languages contain much Sanskrit. And I must remind you that oil became valuable only recently. So, were the Malays less amiable before that?😳😳😳

    • 2
      0

      Manel,

      I had a couple of years schooling in England …….. quite a pleasant experience.

      The English are a strange lot …….. some of them are the worst when it comes to racism and discrimination. Strangely enough, my best friend is an English boy I worked with long ago; we hit it off from day one. He is one of those people who are casually brilliant without even knowing or making an effort. I used to look at his coding and marvel …….. it had a beauty similar to Michelangelo’s sculptures. Now he is back in England …… struck down with MS at quite a young age. A very good tennis player: had grown up near Wimbledon and used to sneak in and play on the courts as kids. Now walks with difficulty ….. we still talk for hours on the phone. He is so talented in many things, I feel he has never felt insecure.

      • 1
        0

        continued

        I have met people all over the world ……… and people who have to resort to racism are the most insecure.

        Some time ago, I had an expat English neighbour who pretended he couldn’t pronounce my name ………. he used to call me “Hey there.” His name was Peter, a very difficult name for me to pronounce as well, so I also called him “Hey there.” He was like 5′ 6″ tall ……. I was on to his insecurity from the get-go. Around him I walked on my toes to gain an additional 3″ …… my wife used to come from behind and kick me. We are trained to be nice and polite …… but it’s a game two can play.

        Nowadays you hardly hear an English accent in London ………. we’ll be spending some time in England soon (and Ireland; one of our favourite places to tour) ……. one of our kids is going to Moorfields (sorta Mecca for eye surgeons) for a couple of months to work on a project.

  • 3
    1

    Hear! Hear! Hear!

    Manel Fonseka has argued her case convincingly.
    Lets reverse the foolhardiness of the previous decades and make English also as an official Language.
    This would bring back the communal amity that prevailed in the good old days.
    A half-English daughter of a Sinhala scholar has led the way on these pages.
    je Sius……[.We salute you].

    • 2
      0

      Plato

      “This would bring back the communal amity that prevailed in the good old days.”

      Communal amity?
      How do you propose to deal with 6.9 million smart patriots, particularly Weerawansa, Gaman, ……..Kamala Gunaratne, H L D M, Geventhu, … ?

  • 2
    3

    I mean,….our Sinhala scholars are still hung up on that old Colonial rivalry on whose language was more superior : English or Sinhala! Buddhist priests held their heads in horror at the contortion of the Lankan psyche, evolved for many millennia under Buddhist precepts, with the funny sounding foreign language of the British. And it was never against the Tamil language of course, but rather against the Tamils who were more proficient in English.

    (Well….. those were only the elite Colombo Tamils…..our Sinhalese Elite knew English of course, but trying to incorporate English with the Masses was an impossibility. The Tamils were about controlling the country via the Elite; the Sinhalese being more naturally Egalitarian, were more into Democratic rights for the Struggling Masses. The unrest that ensued is……Anthropological.)
    _
    But we have to evolve with the times, the main issue being that Motherland wants to join up, and in-fact, overtake the U.S. hegemony over the world (unbelievable!). Via China, and this means the Lankan brain will have another century of restructuring to assimilate into the Chinese language. Motherland-fail, yet again!

    • 3
      1

      ramona grandma therese fernando


      “English or Sinhala! Buddhist priests held their heads in horror at the contortion of the Lankan psyche, evolved for many millennia under Buddhist precepts, with the funny sounding foreign language of the British. “

      I assume Pirith (Pariththa) is chanted in Sinhala.
      And your name is a pure Sinhala name?

  • 4
    0

    Manel,
    We know that what gives value to your writings is that they are true to your feelings.

  • 1
    0

    Manel – you have not heard ChiChi?
    He is proposing that even business language should be Sinhala

    anyhow What is Link language

    • 1
      0

      Rajash

      “you have not heard Chi Chi?”

      It must be the space scientist Rohitha Rajapaksa.

      “He is proposing that even business language should be Sinhala anyhow”

      Good idea. Let him fire toy foot pump rocket from his back garden.
      The LTTE diaspora is going to have a field day.
      Congratulation Chi Chi.

    • 1
      0

      Rajash, you can’t be serious!
      .
      Why the devil didn’t that horrible trio attend Walasmulla Central instead of S.Thomas’?
      .
      And why are they all Yankees now? That’s simpler! The loot can be accessed from there.
      .
      I’ll make a certain observation about what may have happened to the trio – but you’ll have to wait two days for that.
      .
      .
      Right now I must qualify that reference to Walasmulla Central. It’s the sort of sentence I associate with “deepthi silva” on this site.
      .
      Absolute equality is something we will never have, but nasty snobbery has to be forcefully countered.
      .

  • 5
    0

    Let us leave sentiments aside for a second and let us keep our false sense of idiotic over-bloated conceitedness also aside and let us the reason for a second.
    .
    We all know that language ability sets humans apart from animals.
    .
    Similarly, we know that the more we can communicate with other people the more effective we could be at a global level. Presently an average Sri Lankan can opt mainly for menial jobs because of this barrier.
    .
    English is the universal language in this world.
    .
    While English is spoken by 1.5 billion people in the world, Sinhala is only spoken by 15 million people tops. Hence if you can speak English you could communicate with 100 times more people than if you could speak only Sinhala.
    .
    So, what is wrong with learning English as a first language? It opens up endless opportunities at a global level.
    Why deceive ourselves and continue to operate like frogs in a well?
    .
    If we as Sri Lankans can learn English to a high standard and learn Sinhala and Tamil also equally well, we would be at a much better advantage than sticking to Sinhala only.
    .
    Only idiots will take the Sinhala only option.
    .
    It is an example of how conceited and vain we truly are.

    • 1
      0

      Easier said than done, HT. How many of these languages do you currently know?

      To appreciate the worth of a given language you must know many other languages? How many do you know?

      My grandchildren say that Chinese is easy to learn. When I say that I find it difficult, they tell me that it is because I’m mentally retarded.
      .
      Children nowadays are rude

      • 1
        0

        Dear Sinhala_Man ,
        Your verdict, ‘Children nowadays are rude’, interests me!
        .
        Didn’t our parents say the same thing about us.
        This accusation is generational in character.
        .
        Our children are not as polite as we expect them to be!

    • 1
      0

      It’s not the sheer numbers, dear HT. It’s the spread. Look at this bar chart:
      .
      https://www.statista.com/statistics/266808/the-most-spoken-languages-worldwide/
      .
      That will not surprise. However, look more closely. It includes second language users – you and me. That gets even clearer if you look at this:
      .
      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_number_of_speakers
      .
      You see, how far Mandarin Chinese outstrips English for first language speakers. Let others comment on that.
      .
      I’d like to add what I’ve already touched on once: Spanish is a language far better suited to be THE world language. I don’t know Spanish, but I can back up that statement with sound reasoning.

  • 5
    1

    For interested readers, this is an extract from O.L. de Kretser’s 1964 judgment in the Kodeesaran case:

    At the time it was passed one has to presume that those voting for [Sinhala Only] were aware of the numbers literate in Sinhala among the Sinhalese and among the non-Sinhalese communities. They must be presumed to know that those literate in Sinhala were going to have a tremendous advantage in at least the matter of appointments and promotions in the public service over those who were not. They had to know that overnight the hitherto efficient non-Sinhalese officer would lose his value while even the otherwise inefficient Sinhalese officer would have his utility value doubled.

  • 1
    0

    Manel,
    It is highly interesting & charming to read discussions and essays skillfully embedded with compassion and personal endeavors and endurance of writer’s life. Many commentators are reflecting it in their comments, about your approach. But my concern is the Sinhala Buddhist attitude, rather than Sinhala’s anything else. When Buddhism was sharpened into Sinhala Buddhism to throw at Tamils, it was turned into “Sinhala Only”. When the spear edge was replaced to throw at Muslims, it became “One country One Law”. I don’t want to go too deep that side, but some of you may remember activists have been pushing Aanduwa & ICs like EU only to improve Muslim women and girls rights by reforming MMDA. Sinhala Buddhist opportunism twisted it as “one country one law”. You may remember what happened to ICCPR. This human right convention of the UN is used in Lankawe to oppress minorities who protest against force feeding of toxic Sinhala Buddhism. You remember who opposed in parliament CTA which was requested in Resolution 30/1 to replace PTA. It was TNA members, Mano Ganesan, Hakeem, and other minorities. Because the tabled CTA was more draconian than PTA.

  • 1
    0

    I can remind you that it was the same case with Anti-Hate Speech Bill. I have been writing here that the Lankawe’s free education is to spread Sinhala Buddhism’s unscientific SinhaLE bestiality story, but not to teach children science, History, Math, Economics, etc. Siri Ma o brought Shobasha, Sinhala Only & Standardization & was claiming she is resurrecting the lost Sinhala Buddhism’s glory. But her children studied English in London and Paris.
    The constitution Dr. Jeyampathy’s proposal is nothing different from the Soulbury’s constitution, a basic democratic constitution – Nothing special. Just, let us say this may work; Then why didn’t 19A work? Didn’t it give back all the power parliament needed. The biggest deficiency in Jeyampathy’s talk is he didn’t explain how the democratic components that were in Soulbury Constitution and 19A vanished through the Parliament’s back door. If so, how is he going to save his constitution from another ⅔ majority from the next election changing it completely? The Soulbury Constitution had the S 29, the minority protection clause. It had the Privy Council Appeal. It had adopted all fairly enacted earlier British laws, Ceylon’s Legislative Council, State Council, and earlier other European colonialists & Tamil-Sinhala Kings’ Customs-codified. Did any of them protect Tamils when Don Stephen disenfranchised Up Country Tamils’ because they spoke Tamil?

  • 1
    0

    Indian – Pakistani Citizenship Act proved that any law can be made targeted at minorities, irrelevant of any kind of constitutional protection they have through constitutions. Further, there is a question. What was the mistake in Section 29, so which was not adopted in the First Republican constitution? It only said not to make laws oppressing minorities, but they still made the citizenship Acts. Why did they get rid of it? It did not prevent them making amendments to the constitution, did it? It is the same case with 13A. It was a fake devolution to fool Indian governments (, but not Tamils). Is it after 13A they started to say ‘The law is an ass’? There are many 13A asses in Dr. Jeyampathy’s proposals. But we have no interest in a new Sinhala Constitution so no detailed discussion on them (I wrote them all in the 20 Pages comments I made over 4 days in CT, when the first proposal of Secret Solution was presented in Parliament. They are still in CT).

  • 1
    0

    Dr. Jayampathy has circumvented and covered fully the PCs if they made any laws which the Sinhala Rulers would not like. For Example, Sinhala Buddhist Aanduwa can sell Northern Eastern Lands to China, but if North tries to take loan from IMF or ADB to their developments, that becomes ultra vires to the Constitutional Court. It is the Sinhala COA will be the Provincial Supreme Court and its job will be lazily sitting and reversing NEPC passing laws & NEPC courts’ rulings.
    Now Tamil is an Official language. But many times, Sinhala and Chinese used or even Sinhala and Arabic used, but no Tamils used. Last week Sridharan, one northern MP, walked out of a Northern Development Council meeting because they refused to use Tamil in Jaffna. In the last government, Mano Ganesan was Tamil Official Language implementation minister. He refused to go for a witness call because the summon was issued to him in Sinhala Only. English is used as a gateway to science and international relations in many dominant, but not English-speaking countries. It is absolute basic for all developing countries. So why are these Modayas showing so much hate against English? It is because of the ill-founded theory that British rulers supported Tamils. Then why are the French speaking, Italian speaking, German speaking……… countries accepting Tamil refugees?

  • 1
    0

    The answer to that is simple; that is, even from Norway or Sweden, they are all Neo Colonialist, want to rule the SinhaLE Lankawe. One can make English as a coordinating language, official Language or even English Only, but none of them will solve any problem in Lankawe. Under the current constitution (1978) English should the one practically be used for any conflict resolving between the constitutional versions of the three languages. During the Coup 2018 proceeding, Sumanthiran, PC explained that there are many UN conventions adopted (as whole lines from UN Documents); the constitution is saying when there is a procedural vacuum, Westminster is the one needed to be used to fill the gaps. And the lawyers debate and communicate in English during constitution making. But it is always the Sinhala Hegemony used, even if those lines are wrong in the Sinhala version of the constitution. So Old King’s defense lawyers used the Sinhala wrong version to justify his coup and run the parliament as its PM.

    • 3
      0

      Stop referring to that scumbag thief and traitor as “old king”, we don’t have kings in a democratic republic.
      You all are so used to the slave mentality that you keep referring to your oppressors as kings and queens. What a shame.

      • 1
        0

        Dear HT,
        .
        Mallai always does that, and half the time I’m not sure whom he’s writing about.
        .
        He doesn’t break his responses into paragraphs, so it’s difficult to understand what he’s writing. Also each comment consists of many parts.
        .
        My comments are also multi part, but then I’m a better writer.
        .
        Since nobody usually praises me, I’m praising myself!
        .
        Panini Edirisinhe

  • 2
    1

    I know that Manel, you like to look at things from the soft side. But, two years ago, the Norwegian envoy who facilitated the LTTE- Appe Aanduwa negotiations said that without a hard diplomatic fight, Tamil will get nothing from the Sinhala Government. There is a saying in Tamils that :“it doesn’t matter whether the unwanted wife let her hand fall on the gentleman or leg fall on the gentleman, it is a serious crime she committed against her husband”. Language of the Tamils is not the crime, nor the religion of the Tamils is the crime. It is being a minority, who are with their own 3,000 years old Mother land and magnificent culture, under the Sinhala Rulers’ constitutions, is the fault of Tamils. Closing that loophole is the only one can bring dawn for Tamils Not any dubious constitutions.

    • 2
      0

      Dear Mallaiyuran
      I wonder what you mean by this: “I know that, you like to look at things from the soft side.”

      I was just attempting a response to you, but then saw Jit’s post & hastened to respond to that. With the result that what I had begun to you got waylaid & went to him instead! And it probably doesn’t answer him, either. And now I’m too tired to begin again.
      ___

      But let me just say this. I know you say “Language of the Tamils is not the crime,” but, still, I originally hoped to become basically proficient in both Sinhala & Tamil, & joined a course for the latter at the BCIS. (There was also a young Buddhist monk in the class). Sadly, living in Dehiwela, & having to bus up & down, I gave up after a few months. But I learnt to read & write & still keep all sorts of Tamil books nearby, including a small dictionary & several poetry books, including “Sivaramani Kavithaikal”. I also presented some of Sivaramani’s poems at a recital in Colombo, & an article I wrote about her, “Hope and Despair” was published in the Sunday Observer, 21 May 2000, p. 7. But I am losing what little I knew of the language now.

      • 1
        0

        “Dear Mallaiyuran
        I wonder what you mean by this: “I know that, you like to look at things from the soft side.”

        You worry too much about hurting the feeling of the opponents. You want to go only for “handle with care”. I do not think murderous, rowdy, Appe Aanduwa deserve that much manners or would show any response to that way.

        (Do worry about replying to me. Take a good rest)
        Best!

  • 2
    2

    Reply to the writer & the commenters from someone who studied in the Sinhala medium
    .
    We are no longer colonized by the British, but it is clear that the BRAINWASHING that started during the colonization of Sinhaladvipa, where the Sinhalese were forced to take on Western ways of life, religion, language, classism, etc still persists to this day.
    There is no need to be ashamed of our native Sinhala language.
    You need to ask yourself why English, the native language of Sri Lanka’s predominant colonizer, is this important to you.
    The Western countries, desperate for resources, built their empires on the backbones and riches of the countries they colonized, such as Sinhaladvipa.
    My hope for you and anyone else that carries this MENTALITY is to release the shame you have for our native language and appreciate the fact that even after being colonized by so many Western countries for so many centuries, we are still keeping our native Sinhala language alive.
    Oh, and fun fact:
    Although Sinhala is a minority language, unlike English which originated only in the 5th Century-AD, there is archaeological, epigraphical, historical, speleological & documentary evidence to prove that the Sinhala alphabet is the world’s oldest scientific writing system.

    • 3
      1

      Champass

      “There is no need to be ashamed of our native Sinhala language.”

      No one should be ashamed of their own language. However how many quality research papers on science, technology, ….. have you published in Sinhala Language that is read and understood by the rest of the world. Why do you have to wait 50 years or more the catch up with latest inventions and changes in science and technology?

      International trade is conducted in English not in Sinhala.

      Being a dumb ass smart patriot please do not attempt to stop the state creating a level playing field for all citizen of this island and deny opportunity for youth whose future depends on learning, learning languages, learning science, … accumulating knowledge, …………………

      If you want to sit on your head, please feel free to do so, it is your prerogative.

  • 3
    0

    What’s interesting is over 90 per cent of the comments here are concerned with the subject matter. Not many have pivoted to name-calling and balderdash. There’s a lesson here: Stick with the subject. Then you will be read. Otherwise you make a fool of yourself.

    • 1
      0

      Sarath

      “Not many have pivoted to name-calling and balderdash.”

      I am sorry, I have just done exactly that above.
      As far as I am concerned, “Stupid is as stupid does”.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.