19 June, 2026

Blog

Standing By Harini

By Ashanthi Ekanayake

Asanthi Ekanayake

Harini Amarasuriya was one of the professors teaching a course on the Philosophy of Education I was following in the 2022/2023 academic year. She taught the course with Professor Harshana Rambukwella. Those hours we spent with her and Professor Rambukwella opened our eyes to the many injustices which prevail our systems as well as those aspects which worked well for us. They never taught us preaching from the pulpit as it were, they encouraged us to examine questions of equality and equity while reading and examining theories put forward by Pierre Bourdieu and Paulo Freire among others while examining our language and educational policies and teaching practices during discussions where we debated with each other and agreed to disagree. I distinctly remember one occasion when Professor Amarasuriya was a few minutes late to class. She was delayed at parliament that day. I think she wore a yellow sari that day. I remember watching her in parliament speaking with some emotion against some injustice and less than half an hour later she was teaching us, effortlessly, that anger and emotion she had kept in check while she spoke at the parliament was still palpably emanating from her as she began the lecture. Well prepared as always leading us through notions of cultural and linguistic capital making us give examples from our own experiences both in schools and in the tertiary level institutions of education, she set an example for us. She made us aware of how certain injustices manifest themselves in seemingly innocuous systemic issues causing immense harm to our children and the country as a whole.

I am sure my fellow students as do I can assure anyone wondering that she never spoke unnecessarily of sex, sexuality nor the need to incorporate LGBTQIA+ rights or sex education in our sessions. Even when a student wanted to bring in a discussion on gender issues, she shut that discussion down quickly highlighting the fact that though it would be an enticing enough topic it was not on the agenda for that day. She never spoke of sexuality nor the need for sex education in class. She was one of those rare professors who encouraged discussion and down-to-earth conversations about privilege and entitlement and the many issues which riddle the Sri Lankan education system. She contrasted the privileges enjoyed by some while others lacked the basic needs and her passion was contagious.

There should be no question that her knowledge and expertise is in an area which will necessarily contribute to the betterment of the system of education in Sri Lanka. I have seen folks giving media briefings to the contrary. Well, The Philosophy of Education is in fact one of her areas of expertise. I wonder how many of our school and university teachers have actually read the now easily available Sinhala and I hope Tamil translations of The Pedagogy of the Oppressed and from what I know the yet to be translated Pedagogy of Hope freely available online just like gay pornography as many appear to clamor.

Let us now look at those who are clamoring that she should resign and their arguments. The opposition is led by a man whose father notoriously said that chairs would need to be cleaned every month if the country had a woman prime minister, unless my memory is playing tricks. The accusations that the opposition, trade unions and the clergy are throwing at her are ad hominem or mulierem as it were as they attack the person and not an argument. If you have not been pilloried and slandered you are missing the full scope of the feminine experience in Sri Lanka. If it is felt that you are too outspoken by the patriarchies and patriarchal institutions, including the clergy, you will be dragged through the mud and challenged. What do a person’s sexual proclivities have to do with anything. Is it not a distasteful subject? Have we not had finer examples of leaders who did not ascribe to the accepted sexual norms who have held high positions in the political sphere and caused scandal? Watching the antics in the parliament one can only feel cheated and insulted. Throwing abuse and insults at fellow female parliamentarians has been the accepted norm. We would expect better from those who watch and laugh, notably the lady members of the opposition. Is this what your constituents expected of you? When some of you were insulted, she stood by you and you now choose to watch and laugh openly. Shame!

Which is precisely why we should want to empower our young children. They should know when to say no to unwanted advances. They should know when to question. They should learn what might be used against a person. They should be privy to what makes some special and others not. Let us take for an example those who do well in the Arts subjects such as English Literature at the advanced levels. Almost always they come from the upper middle class with access to cultural and linguistic capital that most of us have no access to, such as a father who read Shakespeare or a mother who listened to Ella Fitzgerald. Those who know the correct use of the definite article and the pronunciation of the word meringue already have an advantage over 99% of the population. This disparity is an issue that must be remedied. I find the inclusion of racial and gender stereotypes as troublesome as the inclusion, if accidental, of a web site with smut. Some school children from certain schools are aware that Nigeria is not the poor country we imagine it to be and that the depiction found in many of our textbooks is a racial stereotype and that the Japanese mother who can only work two days a week is a gender stereotype. These aspects should have been carefully examined when the syllabi and texts were whetted. Has anyone asked the children about what they want to read in English? They are the subalterns in this matter and everyone is shouting over their heads. Not all the stakeholders have been consulted. What is their reality? What will empower them? What will help them talk to children, of their own age in other countries? For as long as I can remember our textbooks have dealt with English folk, the Japanese and Nigerians. Why are we so disingenuous? I have been part of the Flat Stanley project in Sri Lanka for some American children. Is it not something we ourselves can adopt? Those who are actually manning the project to overhaul the system need to think of these aspects. The minister should also make sure that capable people who are in the know are put in charge of these activities at least in the future. To overhaul an entire system within a year or two is an impossible task, this should have been more paced and more thoughtful.

Sexuality and sexual politics have played an integral part in education since its inception as a separate system. Since the time of Socrates aspects such as pederasty, fortunately for our school children criminalized as of present, are known to have existed. Simone du Beauvoir had her teaching license revoked because of just such an accusation. Yet the current President of France’s love story which began when he was but fifteen years old and his drama teacher, and his present wife was thirty-nine is sensationalized. Norms and standards change and patriarchies wield much power. Our children deserve to know of how to keep themselves safe and those who are to assist them should be better equipped and we should support them. Then pedophilia and abuse will be prevented through and because of our pedagogical practices.

Another group refusing to stand by Harini are her trade unionist comrades. They are feeling churlish ad cheated that she has not stood by her assurance of 6% GDP and due to what they see as interference in the administration. I distinctly remember one such comrade saying that their role was to open the dialogue and that they did not have all the answers regarding the 6%. Well, they should know shouldn’t they? And they should also show how the allocation might be made by being proactive? It is common knowledge that misallocation and misuse of funds is an issue riddling the system as is abuse of power.     

Latest comments

  • 8
    1

    J.C. Lately

    It was not only a former UNP president who publicly made a licentious remark, but also a former PA president, Mahinda Rajapaksa, who made a lewd remark concerning a homosexual act at a public meeting when he said in regard to a rock in the sea at the Hambantota harbour which had to be blasted to allow ships in “Gala kaepuwe kawdha danne nae.”. Here, ‘gala’ is the boy victim and ‘kapuwe’ refers to the sexual act of the male predator. This was said to the utter delight of the male audience.

    When presidents made these bawdy remarks in public shouldn’t our 12 year old boys be taught in schools about homosexuality so they could identify teacher predators in schools and monk/priest exploiters in temples and churches so that students will not succumb? I don’t know the highest rank of priests from other religions found guilty of homosexual offences, but in the Catholic church it is cardinal (not ours, of course).

    I am of the view that it was wrong for the government to admit there was wrongdoing in inserting a homosexual link in one module in an English workbook for 12 year olds. It should be there and children taught why it is there, namely, children could guard against sexual exploit

    • 9
      0

      J.C,
      “It should be there and children taught why it is there, namely, children could guard against sexual exploit”
      It seems that you have fallen into the same groove that the sanctimonious priests and politicians are in.
      People who abuse children are paedophiles, not homosexuals.
      It is increasingly obvious that these attacks on the PM stem from the fact that she is an unmarried female with independent views in a position of power. This is anathema to the geriatric male clergy who are the real government in this unfortunate country. How can these characters claim to be protecting children while they themselves exploit children on a mass scale as novices?
      That said, this issue exposes the amateurish functioning of this government. Aren’t school text books supposed to be reviewed by an expert committee before printing? Is the expert committee still composed of old fossils who don’t know how to check a Web link?

      • 4
        1

        OC

        “How can these characters (geriatric male clergy) claim to be protecting children while they themselves exploit children on a mass scale as novices?”

        You only buttress my argument. It’s from these paedophiles that children must be protected. The “old fossils” couldn’t think of obliterating the website with black marker pens, still retaining the page with non-offensive contents. This is sad.

      • 6
        0

        Hello OC,
        At School in Scotland we knew at an early age quite a bit about sex. In the Primary School playground we were aged from 5 to 12 and heard from older children most of what we knew. As I said before my Grandmother warned me at an early age never to be alone with Priests/Ministers.
        As Teenagers we were highly suspicious of the Police. However one of the few times that we ever reported someone to the Police, it was to report that we knew the identity of a Paedophile (we used a different word) Man that had tied up and abused a young boy in our area. They arrested him; he was found Guilty and sent to Prison, where he was kept in solitary for his own safety.
        We knew all about the abuse of our Catholic friends in Nazareth House by Nuns (Physical) and Priests (Sexual).
        If the Teachers back then had provided suitable Sex Education then possibly some Children would have been able to talk freely and report their abuse.
        Best regards

        • 4
          4

          Dear LS and all other rational thinkers,
          A group of Buddhist monks in the US are embarking on a 3000 km trek to promote compassion, which is becoming increasingly rare in today’s world.

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ckMAqjxuh7U

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P418wwtG9K0

          I believe Sri Lanka has somewhat more than 20,000 Buddhist monks spread around the country in Buddhist temples and monasteries.
          As AKD and his vicious men under his leadership sow hatreds and make Sri Lanka a darker country filled with hate mongering, we also need such Buddhist monks to come forward and do such walks for peace, sending a message across the country to the nation and the majority who have been abusing their mouths only with sinhlaa filth….. negative thoughts can only lead us deeper… that should be avoided sooner rather than later.

          • 3
            0

            Hello Leelagemalli,
            “A group of Buddhist monks in the US are embarking on a 3000 km trek to promote compassion, which is becoming increasingly rare in today’s world”.
            Their intentions may be heartfelt, however in Trump’s US they are probably flogging a dead horse.
            Best regards

        • 3
          3

          Dear LS,
          You have visited almost every continent and studied vibrant cultures, religions, and traditions in Europe, Asia, North America, and Africa in at least some countries around the world, and you now live in a country where sinhala-buddhism (another practice of Buddhism, but more similar to jainism and hinduism) is practiced.
          Even if you do not speak Sinhala, do you believe that hate is on the increase in Sri Lanka today than it was four years ago?
          Isn’t that a paradox in a country where over 70% are believed to be born Buddhists (really Sinhala Buddhists)? Buddhism, as I learned, was founded on nonviolence, peace, and harmony, yet nowadays, most Sri Lankans behave like hyna-dogs on this forum and elsewhere. Most youtubers, even “so-called Buddhist monks,” behave like hyna-dogs.

          People are more influenced by class and hatred than by caste; what are your thoughts on people’s psyches, especially certain NPP advocates in CT?

          • 5
            0

            Hello Leelagemalli,
            I may be wrong, but I believe that the practice of Sinhala Buddhism by most Sinhalese is completely ritualised. They all pray to non-existent Gods and even when I point out that the Buddha either didn’t believe in them or thought that they were irrelevant, I am met with blank stares.
            It’s like the two Jehovah’s Witness Geologists that I met and worked alongside in the Oil Industry. They were able to compartmentalise their Work and Religion. They could hold the idea that the Earth was 5000 years old and the fact that they were dealing with Shale Samples from the Jurassic 200 Million years ago, with not a shred of Cognitive Dissonance.
            Anagarika Dharmapala was not exactly a peace loving man calling for “Compassion” for others. He set the tone, which some see as “a foundational element of the ethnic tensions and subsequent conflicts in Sri Lanka”.
            Best regards

            • 18
              8

              “Anagarika Dharmapala was not exactly a peace loving man”

              He was more peaceful than the rogue Wallace who was tried for war crimes related to the sacking of Northumbria.

              There was a strong attempt by the British to convert the natives to Christianity, using various of bribery. AD joined up with Blavatasky and others to counter these attempts (Theosophical Society).

              Dharmapala, though being blunt was correct. For example, “alien Mohammedans” is on point. Islam is not native to South Asia. The roots are in the Middle East.

              Dharmapala also converted many Dalits to Buddhism.

              • 18
                5

                *various forms of bribery

            • 8
              0

              LS,
              Buddhism, like other religions, takes on local characteristics depending on the country. For example, Thailand is as Theravada as Sri Lanka, but Thais are far less squeamish about meat-eating (and sexual shenanigans as you probably know).
              “Thai gods are a blend of indigenous beliefs and powerful Hindu deities, prominent in the epic Ramakien (Thai version of Ramayana), featuring figures like Phra Narai (Vishnu), Phra Isuan (Shiva), and Phra In (Indra), alongside popular household spirits like Kuman Thong and revered figures from folklore such as the monkey hero Hanuman, all integrated into the Buddhist framework of Thailand. “
              Here too, there is heavy Indian (Hindu) influence mixed with local animism.
              In the midst of all this, there are idiots who claim that Buddhism originated in Sri Lanka.

              • 1
                0

                Hello OC,
                As for “and sexual shenanigans as you probably know”, I plead the 5th Amendment, however one of my Colleagues got a big (or not so big) shock when his beautiful Thai Escort turned out to be a “Man”.
                Best regards

              • 3
                1

                cont.
                If you listen to what your wife reads in local YouTuber comments, you’ll wonder why people are so nasty these days.
                Most of them are promoted by the ruling party, the JVP. They reflect on their violent background, no matter how whitewashed they are now. Hatred is the smoke that they use to breathe according to their so-called JVP-ideology.

                https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=McVrhgW3riY&list=RDMcVrhgW3riY&start_radio=1

                Domestic/stray pets such as dogs and cats act like the “ALOKA dog” whose publicity was sparked by the continuous walking monks for peace. However, YouTubers and other reporters for their own advantage create biased tales about him.

              • 3
                0

                Hello OC,
                As Teenagers we read Margaret Mead’s “The Coming of Age in Samoa” and found it hilarious that the young girls in Samoa were hoaxing her. Ever since then I have always been sceptical of Social Anthropologist’s claims that there is NO commonality across cultures. “Margaret Mead had not written an ethnographic account, but had published a work of social science fiction” Christopher Badcock Ph.D. “The Imprinted Brain”
                Derek Freeman visited Samoa in the 1960s and subsequently (1999) debunked the vast majority of Mead’s claims. As one of the girls said “As you know, Samoan girls are terrific liars when it comes to joking. But Margaret accepted our trumped up stories as though they were true”.
                I sincerely hope that Harini Amarasuriya is not a Social Anthropologist of the Margaret Mead/Franz Boas ilk.
                Best regards

                • 1
                  0

                  Hello LS,
                  The current government’s double standards are evident, even among schoolchildren.
                  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5MsKUHYthMo

                  NPP politicians, who are essentially JVP criminals, act like teens in front of today’s teenagers. So how many more talks would it take to persuade the gallery that Jeppos is unqualified to lead this country?

                  • 3
                    0

                    LS,
                    Got it. Looks like it would be interesting reading for for our sanctimonious clergy.
                    “Psychology suggesfed-that much
                    might be gained by a knowledge of the way in which
                    children developed, of the stages through which they
                    passed, of what the adult world might reasonably expect
                    of the baby of two months or the child of two years.
                    And the fulminations of the pulpit, the loudly voiced
                    laments of the conservative social philosopher, the rec- ords of juvenile courts and social agencies all suggested
                    that something must be done with the period which
                    science had named adolescence.”
                    Given that the above was written in 1928, I wonder what year our holy men are stuck in?

                    • 1
                      0

                      Hello OC,
                      The next lines of your quote really frightened them – “The spectacle of a younger generation diverging ever more widely from the standards and ideals of the past, cut adrift without the anchorage of respected home standards or group religious values, terrified the cautious reactionary”
                      But even in 1928 Margaret Mead was stuck with the idea that the peoples that she was observing were “Primitive”.
                      Even at the age of 14 I was uncomfortable with this analysis. I was quite familiar with the caricatures made by the English Newspapers of “Primitive Highlanders” and knew that they were not true e.g. “Sawney in the Boghouse (1745)”
                      The Netflix Series “Outlander” is one of the most accurate portrayals of Highland Life from that period that I have seen (despite the Fantasy Aspect). Of course I am biased, in part due to my Fraser Relatives,
                      I am sure that the actress (Caitríona Balfe) that plays Claire will be much to your taste or possibly Nimals😉.
                      Best regards

                • 2
                  0

                  LS,
                  I must look up this Margaret Mead book. Sounds interesting 🤒

            • 3
              1

              You are absolutely correct, LS. Lanken Buddhists are ritualized and simply followers.
              Most of them have no idea if priests explain things in Pali or Sankrit. The majority of them are based on fictional Jathaka tales.
              This is not unlike the behavior of Hindus that I observed on the island of Bali few years ago.
              And, as usual, our OC is correct in stating that, like all other bilind adherents of all religions, Sinhala Buddhism is revered by more than 70% of Sri Lankans simply as a way of life. Also, when they are about to commit the next contract killing act or any other major crime, they shout “Budusarnayi”. They don’t utilize their intellect at all. The thicker their wristbands are, the more criminal I detect.
              Every Sinhala-Buddhist I’ve encountered from the Gallery has used the most offensive trash Sinhala, “UMBE AMMATA, pointing at,” as no other nation would.

          • 0
            0

            Hate has not increased in Sri Lanka, but decreased after the war. Even during the war, during the Tsunami, peopled helped each other irrespective of Ehnic and religious differences. The intense hate rhetoric of the 1975-1980s period (leading to periodic communal riots), and later with Theleepan and other human scarifices, as well as the internecine killing among “liberation groups” in the North that ended up in the survival of the most ruthless (the tigers) etc., are now gone. Caste hate is less intense. People travel freely all over the island, and there is increasing signs of the emergence of ALL_Island poltical parties instead of ethnically exclusive parties. We now even have a person of Estate-Tamil origin as as well as persons of Northern Tamil origin as MPs in the NPP!

      • 10
        0

        old codger

        Thanks for expressing your independent considered view. However you know those ar*****es are attempting to “Making a mountain out of a molehill” .

        Mummy’s boy Sajith is now ready to run the country (when offered he refused to take over the job), Namal Baby has vouched to defend/protect Buddhism (forgetting Buddhism being destroyed by themselves the Sinhala/Buddhists), Wimal Sangili Karuppan Weerawansa is now on fasting (plenty of Lemon Puffs a available).

        If anything the last person(s) who can be relied upon for sound advice are the Saffronistas.

  • 0
    0

    J.C. Lately

    (Contd.). Sexual exploitation of sick minds.

    • 1
      0

      “Sexual exploitation of sick minds.”
      Not ‘by’?

      • 1
        0

        SJ

        You’re right. Thanks. Wrong preposition. Maybe I need to get a grade 6 English textbook with page 51 intact into my hands.

        If grade 6 students venture out into the said website despite the hurdle placed in the website itself and parental oversight they do it at their own peril. This is something the Ulapane robe hanger and all who made a big hullabaloo fail to realise.

  • 10
    1

    Obviously how our Prime Minister is treated by some politicians, clergy and many idiots in FB is unacceptable in a civilized society. However, except few most in her own government are keeping quiet. That is sad

  • 4
    0

    A government which is reluctant to honour its pledges on various matters rushes into something that is potentially explosive in our context.
    There is much need to educate the public and the educators on matters of sex and sexuality before jumping the gun.
    Surely, there could have been some discussion with interest groups and cabinet colleagues before rushing into action.
    Was she sure of the backing that she has in the government ranks? They are mostly not the revolutionary kind.

    • 2
      1

      SJ says “Was she sure of the backing that she has in the government ranks? They are mostly not the revolutionary kind
      If they had been “revolutionary” would it have been better? Pol Pot and Kim Il Sung labled thmeselves as “revolutionaries”. Wijeweera had formulated his 5 lessons for JVP cadre.
      What does “revolutinary” in the present context mean?
      One of the (few) goods that had happened when parties with Marixist leanings came to power was the investment in education and investment in Health. Thus Cuba has a better public health system and free education in proportion to its per capita income, unlike USA ins spite of its larger per Capita income. The JVP-NPP when in opposition (and previously the Samasajists etc) politicized the Universties and ruined them, In power they have not voted in the 6% GDP for education that they were clamouring for.

      • 0
        0

        “If they had been “revolutionary” would it have been better? “
        Yes, very probably.
        *
        You go on thoughtlessly with your anti-left harangue.
        *
        If the quality of public health and education in Cuba, despite sanctions and blockades, is still streets ahead of those in the US, you should meditate on it for a moment.

    • 4
      1

      “BBS was correct after all………You cannot deny the monks have good foresight. The Easter Attacks could have been prevented.
      Does BBS have “monks”? These pretend-monks behave like thugs. So, they have no credibility. Ganasara (invited to a Nordic country and then to USA) is funded by Western NGOs?
      Why should a government rely on the “foresight of the monks:? Govt has intellegence agencies collecting info from ALL sources including from even hypocrite monks of the BBS. Regarding Easter attacks, the govt. was fore-warned, Sirisena’s defence secy ignored it. An MPs father knew of it warned the son to avoid church! The ever so wise Cardinal or St. Peter’s representative on Earth didn’t know what Gnanasara & the MP knew? ArchAngel Gabrial give no inkling to the Cardinal? God’s will has been done!!!! Can “things” happen without God’s knowledge?

      • 18
        10

        BBS was the first organization to call out the radicalization that was happening in the East. They asked why women were wearing niqab, which is a Middle Eastern dress. They asked why signboards were going up in Arabic. They questioned the ethics of halal </b. Niqab was banned in France, minarets were banned in Switzerland, most halal was banned in Germany and Poland. Unlike these countries, the Sri Lankan Government did not take any concrete steps to halt (Islamic) radicalization. Ranil gave land in the East to Muslim ministers in exchange for votes. Some of this land was used to construct Saudi-funded mosques which the Easter Sunday attackers attended. That is another point; GOSL did not notice (or chose to ignore) the flow of Saudi money.

        There were intelligence warnings (from India and others) about pending attacks, but at that point, the window to prevent the attacks was closing. The bombs were already constructed, the targets selected, the bombers in place. The exact targets were likely unknown, so now it's a guessing game. Had GOSL listened to Gnanasara from the start, the intelligence warnings would have been unnecessary .

        • 3
          0

          “Had GOSL listened to Gnanasara from the start, the intelligence warnings would have been unnecessary “

          Ghanaasara and other fake- monks entered monastic life not for any other reason than to fulfill their latent desires as XYY-men.

          They are sluggish and thugish individuals whom their mothers and dads could not manage. The majority of like-minded offenders and high-level criminals may be found in Gunathamnbo Prison.

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p6azAEg3fV4

          This bugger-nutless lester dares to brag about Ghanarasara’s cautions. My foot!
          We must not forget how Ghanasara-led racists organized and caused Muslim riots in the Aluthgama area a few years ago. Ghanasara leads a hypocritical lifestyle. All of his strong pronouncements about bringing day light turned out to be mild recitals at the end of the day, fooling the “thanakola-eating” majority of people in the country, particularly Sinhala Buddhists.

        • 1
          0

      • 17
        5

        concrete steps

  • 0
    2

    Nothing happens without God’s knowledge. So, God sent messangers warnig about the Easter attack, via the Indian agency to Sirisena’s Secy, and via secret messenger to the son of a Catholic MP, but NOT to the ArchBishop? Possibly, Were Luther and Kelvin correct, and the Catholic Church out with the Almighty? We need someone like Prof. Ratnajeevan Hoole! He knows all the shady deals of all churches, and even what is happening behind the Pearly Gates. Harini should consult the good professor on the morality of LGBTQIA+, aka Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, Queer/Questioning, Intersex, Asexual, and others (the “+”), with variations like 2SLGBTQI+ (adding Two-Spirit) or just LGBT+, all diverse sexual/gender identities of God’s creations. Harini to internet links to all of them in the Grade VI textbook.

    • 1
      0

      Sebastian

      Were Luther and Kelvin correct, and the Catholic Church out with the Almighty?

      Today there isn’t much difference amongst Lutherans, Calvinists AA new d

      • 1
        0

        Sebastian
        (Contd). Lutherans, Calvinists and catholics. They are all united by ecumenism. Papacy is an integral part of catholicism whereas Ls and C’s are against papacy. So for unity’s sake what Francis did was to say that papacy is the biggest stumbling block for unity. In other words, abandon Peter’s succession to be united with those who don’t believe in that succession and are implacably opposed to it. Since you are no doubt a catholic and have written much on that I thought of explaining this.

        Will you still wonder why god abandoned the church on Easter Sunday?

        • 1
          0

          (Since you are no doubt a catholic and have written much on that I thought of explaining this)
          I was born a Catholic but by the time I was in hig-school I gave up belief in such hogwash. Later at University I liked a series of lectures that Shanmugathasan selling Chinese Communism. It was very attractive, but I was repelled by his talk of “capturing power by the bullet if not by the ballot”. Still I remined a fellow-traveller of Marxist parties until I realized that Marxism was just a secularized version of Catholicism, with members of the Party being the papmpered priesthood. Writer Eric Voegelin argue that communism and fascism borrow from Christianity replacing divine myths with secular myths.”Salvation” (entry into heaven) is replaced by classless utopia (the communist state or the Reich) to be reached via immense violence to unbelievers (class enemeys).

          • 0
            0

            Have you seen what happened to power won by the ballot in many a country?
            The American bullet had its way.
            *
            A Marxist is not an armed thug, but one cannot fight the armed thug of a state without taking to arms.
            Check it out based on historical experience.

            • 0
              0

              I humbly invite SJ with his pro-Mraxist claims to give reasoned arguments. “A Marxist is not an armed thug, but one cannot fight the armed thug of a state without taking to arms. Check it out based on historical experience.”. Indeed, in the Soviet Union, in China, in Cam,bodia, in Sri Lanka, Marxists taking arms become armed thugs – that is the historical experience. Same with the French revolution – begins with fine words of Liberte, egalite, Fraternite, and end in a reign oif terror. Cuba’s “revolution” was nationalist but it would have done EVEN better with its education and health, and in other spheres too, sans its ideology. Cuban Marxist authorities effectively abolished private property and business for 50 to 60 years, aborting any devlopment.

            • 0
              0

              one cannot fight the armed thug of a state without taking to arms. This claim by SJ is exactly one of the arguments that the ultra-right wing American Rifle Society (NRS) uses for justifyiong the “right to Arms” by Americans. So, from SJ’s argument we see how the hidden face of Fascist logic emerges as an essential component of Marxist ideolgy

    • 13
      6

      BBS never invoked a divine authority, so your point is moot. The more interesting point is that you referred to monks as “thugs.” Where is your evidence to support this claim? On the other hand, your Tamil Christian priests, such as Rayappu Joseph, openly supported the LTTE (banned by 32 countries).

      “There is nothing wrong in the Tamil nation raising its national flag. The Tamil national flag is not the Tigers’ flag but it is the Tamil people’s flag. Hoisting it is not against peace`”

      “I praise the Tigers for being patient despite such provocations. Tamil civilians hoist the Tiger flag in Tamil areas on Great Heroes Day. But the military responds to this peaceful act by sending troops with heavy weapons to assault unarmed civilians who are peacefully hoisting the flag” [TamilNet 15.2.05]

      Joseph was in awe of the Tigers’ patience. By his reckoning, enough suicide bombs, drug trafficking, forcible child recruitment, and ethnic cleansing could yield a positive outcome called “Tamil Eelam.” Looks like Joseph was gobbling roti happily on “Heroes Day” (heroes including suicide bombers), while waving a Tiger flag that totally represents the aspirations of the Tamil people.

      • 2
        3

        “On the other hand, your Tamil Christian priests, such as Rayappu Joseph, openly supported the LTTE (banned by 32 countries)”
        Being a Christian Priest (or a Buddhist monk) does not give you any moral direction. Many Marxists mistkenely supported the LTTE, regarding it as a “revolutionary striggle”. During WorldWar-II, most German priests supported Hitler. In the 1977 election, the TULF received 421,500 votes, the UNP received 3,179,000 votes, and the total number of valid votes cast was 6,244,000. So, 6.7% of the population (including Tamil priests!) voted for the Vaddukkoddai resolution and took up arms against some 80% of the Nation; Tamils committed political hara-kiri. When I say this, Rohan25 comes out claiming that 33% of the population were Tamil speaking and implies that 33% supported the LTTE. Absolutely NO. I grant that state terror produced grudging support to the LTTE but not even all 7% in the North and East supported the tigers but no dissent was possible. The disapora (about 2% of Tamil population of the N&E), safe from the cross-fire was more supportive and funded a distant war.

        • 7
          2

          The Catholic priests did not support Hitler, although a large segment of Protestants did. So your assertion is only partially true.

          Anyway, you are mixing up issues here. The Germans had a concrete plan to wipe out the Jews. Look it up, it’s called the “Final Solution.” GOSL, under CBK and Ranil W, nearly signed away 33% of the island to the Tamils:

          https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcTHJ_CkpicSPPj4Ppei32maKUEAHxEv-ap09A&s

          Monks have been serving as advisors to kings and locals for 2000 years. BBS was no different. They warned about Islamic radicalization and that is exactly what manifested. You can make excuses about “state terror” and other nonsense, but as I said before, the monks were correct in their assessment.

          No sane, rational person wears a suicide vest and walks into a public space full of unarmed civilians.Your excuses such as “human rights abuses”, “state terror”, and “monks are thugs”, fail here. The US had slavery and then racial discrimination until the 1960’s, did you see people turn into suicide bombers?

          • 1
            0

            Lessie dear,
            You say monks are not thugs?
            Last week the Mihintale monk used obscene language in public. Not long ago, a monk was sentenced to prison for insulting the court by using obscene language. Another time he entered a meeting at a Colombo hotel and physically assaulted a monk who was holding opposing views. That monk is currently out on bail after being convicted for a second time on charges of racial incitement. A political monk who was participating in a protest movement slapped a police officer on the cheek, causing the senior officer’s official cap to fly into the air. Another monk in the group was caught on camera getting a tattoo on his arm, in violation of the monastic discipline. The late Minister Mangala Samaraweera referred to them not as true monks but as a ‘sect of yellow-colored monks’
            Obsessed as you are with Muslims, suicide bombers, mathematics, fake AI, apart from being on the run from disgusting pedo allegations in the US, you probably have no time to do your research.

        • 7
          2

          “Being a Christian Priest (or a Buddhist monk) does not give you any moral direction. “

          Yes it does. Priests are supposed to be an elite class of people.

          Lastly, Jaffna Tamils are not an elite group. They learned English at a higher rate than other groups and took up a disproportionate number of positions in the civil service. So what? Where are the scientists, Fortune 500 CEO’s, Nobel Prize winners etc? Count of zero . What are you so proud of?

          “not even all 7% in the North and East supported the tigers but no dissent was possible.”

          Yet another poor excuse, which is also false. You should take full moral responsibility for suicide bombings and reject the Tigers. The way that Germans reject the Nazis.

        • 1
          0

          ““On the other hand, your Tamil Christian priests, such as Rayappu Joseph, openly supported the LTTE (banned by 32 countries)”.”
          We are diverting the real issue of the island of Sri Lanka by blaming LTTE and diaspora Tamils without why Sri Lanka failed under Sinhala Buddhist Governments between 1948 and 2026? You can put some figures for your satisfaction but that is no matter. It is not about the LTTE or any other militant group or any other political party, it is about Tamils and Sinhalese. Can you tell us when did Sinhalese rule out of the past 500 years? Why they couldn’t rule? What is the religion of Sinhalese before Buddhism was brought by Indians?

    • 17
      7

      Joseph is not the only priest who supported the LTTE. There are many. A prominent one is Father Emmanuel in Australia.

      “Father Emmanuel created the Global Tamil Forum, the premier LTTE international organisation to project Sri Lanka as a human rights violator and white wash the LTTE. To promote the LTTE message in Geneva, Father Emmanuel worked with Gary Anandasangari of the Canadian Tamil Congress that came up with the idea that there was ‘genocide’ in Sri Lanka.”

      • 3
        1

        While the extreme wing of Tamil nationalism in the Disapora, together with local politicians like Wigneswarna talked of a “Genocide of Lankan Tamils”, more balanced politicians have explictly rejected it. The UN high commissioner for Human Rights has also rejected it. See Tamil Net, Saturday, 19 September 2015. The Leaders of major Tamil political parties in Sri Lanka, e.g.,Mr. Sumanthiran of the TNA, and Mr. Sangaree of the TULF had rejected the Genocide claim, already in 2015, when Mr. Wigneswaran of the Northern Provincial Council Sri Lanka in 2015 called for an investigation alleging a genocide of Tamils. But all this simply the continuation of the Eelam war on a morfe soft scale. So, while the Genocide claim is very unlikely to hold, there is no question that there were reprehensible HR violations.

        • 1
          0

          SSR
          Genocide is not readily established based on a few events.
          If a few mass killings and mass displacements alone will establish it, the LTTE will equally be guilty of it.
          There have been willful killing of non-combatants and other offences by the state’s forces that need looking into so that willful perpetrators of the crime are punished and victims or families are compensated.
          Sadly many people are selective in picking out offenders. And that is a serious obstacle.

          • 0
            1

            There have been willful killing of non-combatants and other offences by the state’s forces that need looking into so that willful perpetrators of the crime are punished and victims or families are compensated“. That is right, but not limited to perpetrators of “state’s forces”. Also claims of “Genocide” requires establishing willful and deliberate policy to destroy an ethnic group, acts of ethnic cleansing etc. The Tigers with their “exclusive homelands” and ethnic cleansing of Muslims and Sinhalese in the North acted Genocidally; the GOSL far less so, in spite of its state terror (copied from Israeli advisors used by Athulathmudali). The Tigers probabaly killed more Tamils than even the GOSL. The Sinhalese Marxists (JVP) and the GOSL conterattack together probabaly killed more Sinhalese than the Tigers did. </b?

            • 7
              1

              In a zero-sum game , the loser does not gain anything. So Tamils should not expect a political solution of any kind. The best option for them would be to emigrate.

              • 0
                0

                It is NOT a zero sum game. The loser of a war does not gain anything, and ALSO, he stands to loose everything. Zero-sum game, Prisoner’s dialemma and other concepts that came from grame theory are being loosely misued in public parlance to give the impression of erudition but they end up conveying the wrong idea. The LTTE, and the Tamil people in Sri Lanka LOST very badly due to the foolish misdaveture of a mere 7% of the population taking on 80% of the population in a protracted war that they were bound to loose very badly. They carried on under heavy loses due to the malignant support of the diaspora. .

                • 0
                  0

                  The point, which many observers fail to grasp: If the Sri Lankan Government had lost the war, the land it lost would be gone indefinitely. This is precisely why we can classify it as zero-sum. The island would very likely resemble something like the Korean Peninsula, with a clear demarcation between the North and the South. The North (Eelam) would be a mess, as trade sanctions, embargoes, and other restrictions prevented economic development. The designation of “terrorist” or “terror state” does not go away because you are independent. Afghanistan is now under the control of the Taliban, and likewise Syria is under ISIS control. Companies are not running to do business.

                  By assassinating Rajiv Gandhi, as well as resorting to suicide attacks , Prabhakaran ensured that any “Tamil homeland” would not gain international legitimacy. This is not something Diaspora money can fix. Ask Russia.

                • 0
                  0

                  The issue is not that Tamils waged an armed struggle. The issue is that they waged an armed struggle and lost . It is no different than the gambler going all-in. The Casino does not have an insurance policy. Given the high stakes, losing is surely unpleasant. That is why I suggested emigration. Ideally to T Nadu. With the T Nadu government’s 69% reservation policy that has chased the Brahmins out, there is plenty of wealth re-distribution to go around.

          • 0
            0

            If a few mass killings and mass displacements alone will establish it, the LTTE will equally be guilty of it“. The track record of the LTTE in attacking civilians is arguably worse than that of the GOSL. But it was the Northern Provincial Council under Wigneswaran, and the Ontario provincial government that made direct or inderct claims of Genocide by the Giovernment, WITHOUT setting up mechanisms to nail it down factually in confromity with the IJC specifications. Wigenswaran, an Ex-Justice knew the law but ignore it for doubious politcal gains with the hawkish diaspora. In the end his standing among the people of the North did not improve. They are, as far as I can see, looking for going forward, and not back to the now outdated confrontations of the pre-Vaddukkodai days.

  • 2
    0

    Readers,
    People all throughout the world have become more sensitive as a result of nearly two dozen Vietnamese monks marching across the United States with their cherished dog, ALOKA (the light).
    Without a doubt, the dog-ALOKA is kinder than the current NPP leaders.
    -https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pTG4fvAvmSs
    If nothing else, the leaders ought to make strong public declarations that take into account people from different backgrounds. AKD-like prevarications alone do not constitute leadership quality. AKD, the president of Sri Lanka, and his cabinet members were devoid of this trait from the beginning. He can learn a lot from the dog-ALOKA, who was formerly a stray but became a kind dog as a result of the monks’ kinder treatment of him.

  • 2
    0

    Almost every day, the president’s appointments have sparked widespread criticism.
    Manoj Nanayakkara, an attorney, has been appointed as the Chief Scout Commissioner of the Sri Lanka Scout Association (source: https://www.presidentsoffice.gov.lk/).
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jguEGvj9IkQ
    The position of Chief Scout Commissioner for SCOUTing has been cherry-picked for a candidate close to the President, disregarding traditions and qualifications. The way the newly elected would approach the music is comparable to their educational qualifications.
    This demonstrates the growing inadequacy of his leadership. Prior to AKD’s election, we thought SIRISENA was the worst president.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.