20 November, 2026

Blog

The Presidential Pardon In Sri Lanka: Institutional Value & Organisational Failure

By Dinesh Dodamgoda –

Dinesh Dodamgoda

Minister Lal Kantha has called for the abolition of the presidential pardon, apparently in response to recent controversies over its use. Although those concerns merit serious consideration, abolishing the power would remove an important constitutional safeguard. A better response is to identify why the pardon process has failed and how its administration can be strengthened.

This article explores the importance of the executive pardon as a democratic “institution”. It examines the failures of the political “organisations”—including politicians and public officials—that have developed around it in Sri Lanka. To address these failures, I recommend strengthening these organisations through education to shift attitudes and behavioural norms regarding the presidential pardon, thereby improving “informal institutional frameworks”.

The Executive Pardon

The executive power to grant pardons traces back to the monarch’s historic prerogative of mercy. Over time, democratic constitutional systems have shaped this power, creating a more thoughtful balance between executive discretion and the rule of law. No judicial system is perfect: human error, investigative overreach, and unreliable evidence can sometimes lead to unjust outcomes. By helping correct judicial mistakes, extending mercy and fairness, offering political amnesty, and serving as a check within the system of checks and balances, the power to grant pardons can make a meaningful contribution to justice and democracy.

The scope of executive pardon powers varies across democracies. Under the United States’ plenary model, the President may grant reprieves and pardons for federal offences, except in cases of impeachment. By contrast, the United Kingdom’s Westminster model places the royal prerogative of mercy within a framework of established constitutional conventions, ministerial advice and procedural limits. In Commonwealth and hybrid models, such as those of India and Sri Lanka, written constitutions expressly define the pardon power, and these systems combine the Westminster tradition of ministerial advice with formal safeguards to uphold the rule of law.

Article II, Section 2 of the U.S. Constitution gives the President broad discretion to grant reprieves and pardons for federal offences, but not for state offences. This authority does not extend to cases of impeachment and may be exercised at any stage of the legal process, even before formal charges are filed. For example, President Ford pardoned President Nixon in 1974, intending to bring an end to the “American tragedy” of the Watergate scandal.

In the U.K.’s Westminster model, the Sovereign grants pardons on the advice of the justice minister or the Cabinet. Procedural frameworks govern this power and are subject to judicial review and political accountability to Parliament. The courts have held that, while they would not second-guess the wisdom of a pardon, they can review whether a minister failed to properly consider the relevant legal criteria or acted unlawfully by refusing to assess the evidence.

In India’s codified Commonwealth and hybrid system, Articles 72 and 161 of the Constitution, respectively concerning the President and the Governors, provide that the power to grant pardons rests with the President and the Governors. Although pardon decisions are generally subject to limited judicial review, the Supreme Court of India has held that the President or the Governor acts on the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers. Courts may review these decisions on limited public law grounds, including arbitrary decision-making, mala fides (bad faith), reliance on irrelevant material, or political, caste, or religious bias.

In Sri Lanka, Article 34 of the Constitution authorises the President to grant pardons, respites, or commutations, but only through separate formal processes. For example, in death penalty cases, the President receives reports from the trial judge who heard the case, the Attorney-General, and the Minister of Justice, who submits a recommendation. The Supreme Court may also review the matter in a fundamental rights case to ensure compliance with Article 12(1) of the Constitution (right to equality).

Compared with the less restrictive US model, courts in the United Kingdom, India and Sri Lanka subject executive pardons to judicial scrutiny. Under established Commonwealth jurisprudence, courts do not assess the wisdom or merits of a pardon. Instead, they examine whether the decision-making process was lawful: whether the required constitutional procedures were followed; whether the decision was arbitrary; whether the relevant facts were properly considered; whether it involved mala fides or irrelevant considerations, such as personal or political favouritism; and whether it infringed fundamental or victims’ rights.

Failures in Sri Lanka

Recent public criticism, including Minister Lal Kantha’s remarks, reflects growing concern about the exercise of the presidential pardon in Sri Lanka. This concern has intensified following Supreme Court decisions in 2024 on the pardon in the Royal Park murder case, the pardon granted to Gnanasara Thero in 2026, and the 2026 clemency case under President Wickremesinghe’s administration.

In these cases, the Supreme Court found that the executive had failed to follow the procedure under Article 34 of the Constitution: that pardoning individuals convicted of contempt without reasoned justification was impermissible; and that the executive had failed to demonstrate a rational assessment or adherence to proper procedure. Taken together, these rulings demonstrate how arbitrary clemency can undermine the rule of law and the aggrieved parties’ right to equality under Article 12(1) of the Constitution.

Commenting on the 2026 Gnanasara Thero decision, former President Maithripala Sirisena said that officials at the Presidential Secretariat had misled him and that a technical error had contributed to the outcome. The explanation highlights possible administrative weaknesses but does not challenge the constitutional responsibility attached to the exercise of presidential power. Because the relevant constitutional and procedural requirements were violated in the cases discussed above (despite differing opinions), the shortcomings do not appear to stem from “institutions” (the constitutional provisions) or the “rules of the game,” as the Nobel Prize-winning scholar Douglass C. North defines “institutions” in his 1990 work on Institutions. Rather, they seem to lie with “organisations” or the “players”—the political bodies or individual actors who hold executive and administrative powers. I therefore find North’s theoretical framework of “institutions” and “organisations” a helpful way to understand and address shortcomings in Sri Lanka’s use of the presidential pardon power.

Institutions and Organisations

“Institutions” are the “rules of the game” in a society: humanly devised constraints that shape how people interact. They can be formal, such as constitutions, laws, and property rights, or informal, such as sanctions, customs, traditions, codes of conduct, and shared mental models. In this context, Article 34 of the Sri Lankan Constitution is a “formal institution”. By contrast, unwritten constraints—such as the customary obligation to protect loyalists and signals that they will be rewarded; norms around the use of pardons, political reciprocity, and elite bargaining; selective enforcement and the use of the law as a weapon; and religious, cultural, and commemorative traditions such as ‘Wesak Poya Day prisoner release’—are “informal institutions”, conventions, or codes of behaviour that govern how people interact on this issue.

Formal and informal institutions operate together. Article 34 establishes the constitutional authority and, in relevant cases, the procedure for granting pardons. Informal norms shape how political and administrative actors interpret and exercise that authority, while judicial review provides an enforcement mechanism against arbitrary, discriminatory or procedurally unlawful decisions.

The principal “organisations” or “players of the game” include the President, the Presidential Secretariat, the Ministry of Justice, the Attorney-General’s Department, political parties and Parliament. Their effectiveness depends on whether they understand their responsibilities, provide independent advice, maintain accurate records and comply with the constitutional process.

An organisation’s governance structure, the skills of its people, and the lessons it learns through experience all contribute to its long-term success. In practice, some organisations thrive while others face challenges. In the Gnanasara Thero case (2026), the Royal Park murder case (2024), and the Wickremesinghe clemency case (2026), the organisations failed to exercise the pardon power lawfully, and the enforcement mechanism—the Supreme Court’s judicial review—ultimately invalidated the presidential pardons.

Minister Lal Kantha’s opinion

Minister Lal Kantha’s proposal treats the constitutional power or the “institution” itself as the source of the problem. However, recent cases support a more nuanced conclusion: the danger arises when weak procedures, inadequate advice, political influence and harmful informal norms shape the exercise of that power. Thus, abolishing the institution will remove not only the risk of abuse but also the power’s legitimate capacity to correct injustice, extend mercy and respond to exceptional circumstances.

As North (1990) explains, institutions and organisations influence one another, shaping outcomes towards either success or persistent inefficiency. When they succeed, both direct and indirect demand for educational investment can encourage further development. This investment helps players or “organisations” strengthen their strategies and skills, increasing their chances of winning the “game” (granting the pardon). In contrast, North observes that limited investment in education can reduce productivity and lower the chances of winning the game.

Two Presidents granted these pardons. It is reasonable to assume that, as players, both may have been misled and lacked the necessary understanding of the pardon procedures. The administrative staff and other players may also have lacked the relevant knowledge or failed to advise the Presidents appropriately. Minister Lal Kantha may also have been misled or failed to fully understand that presidential pardons are a vital safeguard for justice and democracy.

Conclusion

Minister Lal Kantha’s call to abolish the presidential pardon therefore goes beyond the evidence. A more constructive response would preserve the constitutional power while strengthening the organisations responsible for its exercise. Reforms should include written procedural guidelines, specialist legal advice, complete records of the material considered, reasoned recommendations, conflict-of-interest safeguards, and appropriate public reporting, subject to legitimate confidentiality requirements.

Furthermore, education and professional training investment should form part of this reform, particularly for political office-holders and officials involved in the pardon process. Over time, clearer procedures and stronger accountability could also reshape the informal norms surrounding executive clemency. The presidential pardon should be understood not as an unrestricted personal privilege but as an important democratic constitutional responsibility that must be exercised lawfully, transparently and in the public interest.

*Dinesh Dodamgoda, a former Member of Parliament and Attorney-at-Law, holds an MSc in Global Security from Cranfield University in the United Kingdom. He has also conducted research at Newcastle University and at the Centre for the Study of Terrorism and Political Violence at the University of St Andrews. He was a Fulbright Scholar in U.S. National Security at the University of Delaware in the United States. 

Latest comments

  • 6
    0

    But, surely, no mere President can ignore the call of a Mahanayaka to pardon one of his sidekicks?
    What is this country coming to?

    • 0
      3

      Why? The pardon is reduced from a constitutional safeguard to an instrument of patronage, reflecting the tension between informal institutions—shaped by cultural pressures—and formal institutions grounded in the rule of law.

      Therefore, informal institutions must be strengthened, and education is one way to achieve this.

  • 10
    0

    “This article explores the importance of the executive pardon as a democratic “institution”.
    So far excutive pardon failed since 1948. You cannot have an executive pardon in this island as long as the constitution and the rulers failed or biased towards different religious, different language speaking people. The system should be changed and the constitution should be changed.

    • 0
      3

      Rather than giving up the pardon’s value as a safeguard, we can preserve it while helping organisations/players improve through education and training, and encouraging them to follow the ‘rules of the game ’ closely.

      • 2
        0

        You are saying that 78 years of education, training and encouraging is not enough to follow the rules of the governance? Pathetic Executive Power of pardon for criminals?

  • 5
    0

    “The executive power to grant pardons traces back to the monarch’s historic prerogative of mercy.”
    We have long passed the time of monarchies.
    Cannot there be a democratic mechanism to address the concerns raised.
    A President can abuse his powers and that has often happened.

    • 0
      4

      Democratic governance and Commonwealth legal traditions constrain monarchical power through the rule of law and judicial review.
      Better procedural compliance by the presidency and its secretariat ensures executive actions follow established processes and limits unilateral decisions.
      The article finds that investment in education and training improves outcomes.

      • 0
        0

        Thank you, but this is a bit of a malle pol response to the point made by me.

  • 9
    4

    “….No judicial system is perfect: human error, investigative overreach, and unreliable evidence can sometimes lead to unjust outcomes…..”

    So Dinesh, there was a ‘human error’ when the judiciary gave a jail term to Gonawala Sunil for raping a minor? And the judiciary is guilty of “human error, investigative overreach, and unreliable evidence” when Duminda Silva was sentenced? Gnasara, Jude Fernando??

    I thought human pitifulness had limits, but you show none!

    • 0
      3

      The article neither calls every controversial conviction a judicial error nor defends pardons overturned by the judiciary.
      Instead, it urges strengthening the country’s ‘informal institutions’ by educating and training ‘the players’ of ‘the game’ or ‘organisations’, including political actors and relevant officials.
      That’s how things improve.

      • 0
        0

        Are you majoring in moving the goalposts, or did you just minor in throwing up smokescreens? Or are you simply too confused to comprehend what you wrote a few days ago?

        “…..Minister Lal Kantha may also have been misled or failed to fully understand that presidential pardons are a vital safeguard for justice and democracy…..”

        You clearly indicated in your article that you wish to keep the presidential pardons. I clearly said – no we don’t need it!

        What ‘apanbrnsha’ are you talking now??

  • 11
    1

    No one should be above the law, the principle must apply to everyone equally. Any rule that places itself above the Supreme Court undermines our justice system and destroys public trust in the judiciary. When a president uses a pardon to bail out political allies or well-connected criminals, it completely undermines the rule of law and only proves there’s a double standard for the powerful. Allowing a single politician to wipe away a valid conviction with the stroke of a pen is an insult to the entire judicial system and the victims involved. That is exactly what has happened with presidential pardons in Sri Lanka – no exceptions!!

    Only those who benefit from corruption or serve as cogs in the wheels of a rotten legal system need an exclusive band of law above Supreme Court rulings. We have seen this movie plot before, and we already know exactly how it ends!

    • 0
      3

      The debate isn’t about empowering rulers. It’s about whether to fix the system’s corrupt execution or give up a safeguard that protects the genuinely innocent.
      The article suggests reforming ‘informal institutions’ by educating and training ‘players’ or ‘organisations’ to respect the rule of law.

      • 0
        0

        When the Supreme court gives a ruling why the heck you are worried about any blinking ‘informal institutions or other players’ ??

        Do you really know what you are talking about!!

  • 10
    0

    One of the most shameful episodes in Sri Lanka’s political history was the controversial presidential pardon granted by President J. R. Jayewardene to Gonawala Sunil, a convicted rapist with close connections to the ruling United National Party (UNP).
    Sunil had been convicted of rape and sentenced to imprisonment. However, he was subsequently released through the exercise of presidential powers. Allegations have long persisted that Ranil Wickremesinghe, then Minister of Youth Affairs, intervened on his behalf, although his precise role in securing the pardon remains unverified.
    The controversy deepened when Sunil was reportedly appointed an All-Island Justice of the Peace, despite his criminal conviction. Such political patronage represented a disturbing disregard for judicial integrity, public morality and the dignity of victims.
    Presidential pardons are intended to uphold justice and compassion, not to reward political loyalty or protect criminals with influential connections.
    This disgraceful episode raises fundamental questions about political accountability, executive abuse and the erosion of democratic values.
    No president or minister should ever place political interests above justice. The rule of law must prevail equally, irrespective of political affiliations, personal relationships or positions of power.

    • 4
      1

      PK
      Thank you.
      Well said.

      • 4
        1

        Paramanathan K
        –
        If these failures to investigate, prosecute and punish those responsible were not, in practice, a guarantee of future impunity, then what were they?
        –
        Impunity does not require an explicit promise of pardon. A deliberate failure to investigate and prosecute perpetrators can serve exactly the same purpose.

    • 3
      1

      Paramanathan K
      –
      “One of the most shameful episodes in Sri Lanka’s political history was the controversial presidential pardon granted by President J. R. Jayewardene to Gonawala Sunil, a convicted rapist with close connections to the ruling United National Party (UNP).”
      –
      This cannot be compared with the numerous crimes committed by police officers, politicians, members of the armed forces, political henchmen and those saffronistas extremists who promoted racism, communal hatred and violence against innocent people.
      –
      Many of those responsible escaped proper police investigations, while charges were deliberately never brought against the perpetrators and instigators.
      –
      For example, consider the thugs who were incited to attack innocent civilians and subsequently escaped scot-free, never having been charged for their involvement in the riots of 1958, 1977, 1983 and 2013. Consider also the burning of the Jaffna Public Library in 1981 and the killing of innocent civilians by members of the armed forces, their dead squads and party’s own dead squad between 1971 and 2009.

    • 0
      3

      That historic case shows why trust in Sri Lanka’s executive clemency remains fractured.
      When political patronage frees a convicted person and later secures appointments such as Justice of the Peace, pardons can seem less like constitutional safeguards than shields for allies.
      Powerful ‘organisations’ can undermine the rule of law, abandon victims, and erode confidence in justice.
      Strengthening ‘organisations’ is essential.

  • 7
    3

    “Minister Lal Kantha’s call to abolish the presidential pardon therefore goes beyond the evidence.”
    Presidential system itself brought bankruptcy to the country. A special status to Buddhism in the constitution destroyed not only destroyed Buddhism but also rule of equality.

    • 0
      3

      Your comment points to a deeper frustration: when people feel the presidential system and structural inequalities have kept them from being treated equally, it’s understandable that they may distrust unchecked executive power.
      Systemic reforms remain essential.
      At the same time, a fair legal system needs a carefully limited, transparent safeguard to address rare, genuine miscarriages of justice, not a loophole for the powerful.

  • 4
    6

    Readers,
    Unlike in the past, the current President seems preoccupied with responding to even the simplest criticism of his government. Why?
    –
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aYRO1rdGg-4
    –
    Some argue that AKD lacks the stature expected of a national leader, while his recent public speech reportedly contained several inaccuracies about his own political journey. Nevertheless, his supporters applaud his so-called bravery, despite allegations of misleading the public. At a time when ordinary people are struggling with soaring prices, the government appears to have prioritised political rallies over addressing their daily hardships. Promised VAT reductions remain unfulfilled, while concerns over fuel, cooking gas and the cost of living continue to grow. People still remember how Ranil Wickremesinghe brought inflation down from unprecedented levels and stabilised the rupee after Gotabaya Rajapaksa’s departure. Today, however, public confidence is being tested by unfulfilled promises, questionable statements and growing economic uncertainty. Ultimately, a nation cannot be governed by rhetoric and applause; people need tangible results, accountability and relief.

  • 4
    8

    The power to pardon is with the elected President.

    The judges are not elected and work for a salary and promotions.

    On a future date what if the president as a result of an agreement pardons all the LTTE guys now in jail and later it is discovered that there was a bureaucratic blunder in the procedure.

    Will all the thousands pardoned be put in jail again ?

    • 5
      4

      The Fake Truth
      –
      “On a future date what if the president as a result of an agreement pardons all the LTTE guys now in jail and later it is discovered that there was a bureaucratic blunder in the procedure.”
      –
      I would like to have the full details of all LTTE members currently in detention or serving prison sentences, including their legal status and the charges, if any, brought against them.
      –
      Those who have been detained for years, in some cases for more than 25 years, without ever being formally charged in a court of law are living in a state of legal limbo. This is unacceptable in a country supposed to be governed by the rule of law.
      –
      First, the State must establish their guilt through due process of law. Only after a person has been convicted by a court of law can the President consider granting a pardon.
      –
      Furthermore, decisions on pardons should be made only after an independent review by an impartial parole or pardon committee, rather than being left to the discretion of corrupt politicians who may have personal or political interests.

    • 5
      5

      The Fake Truth
      –
      We should also remember the controversial pardons granted during President Maithripala Sirisena’s presidency, including the pardon of a wealthy young man who was serving a prison sentence for murder and the pardon of a notorious saffron-clad thug.
      –
      The power to grant a presidential pardon must never become a political tool for rewarding friends, protecting the powerful, or securing political agreements. It must be exercised transparently, fairly and in accordance with the rule of law.
      –
      You should start at the very beginning, a very good place to start, …….. A B C D, ..Z, අ, ආ, ….. அ, ஆ, 1,2,3, …….

      • 3
        7

        Vedda ,you cannot rise above your hatred of this Ganasara guy and sinhala politicians ( according to you all corrupt unlike the Tamils),

        Interesting you don’t mention the convicts pardoned by JR,Chandrika and of course Ranil’

        You are off on a tangent about people in remand without trial ( Namal too ?)

        I was only raising a theoretical issue. If a judge says there is a procedural lapse, should the pardoned prisoner go back to jail ?

        In every country the head of state can pardon. Typically Sri Lanka is trying to take away this necessary discretion ( from Sinhalese heads of State.)

        Is it OK if the head of state can pardon a person after seeking your approval ?

        Vedda approves !

        Will you pardon Mahendran and LTTE but not a chaps like Ranjan Ramanayake or Sarath Fonseka or those various Sinhala terrorists as defined by you ?

        • 3
          7

          The Truth,

          Vedda thinks every minority is a victim of injustice. This is how the media has conditioned people for the past 20 odd years. Now you are seeing the backlash in Western Europe. Germans just elected a far right politician. France may follow. If elected, Le Pen will be like Trump, when it comes to immigration.

          Regarding the media conditioning, it may get worse with AI. As people continue to use it for the purposes of confirmation bias.

          • 5
            4

            Lester the court jester
            –
            “Vedda thinks every minority is a victim of injustice.”
            –
            Not exactly.
            –
            Even the majority community has been a victim of injustice since 1948.
            –
            AKD and his family were targeted by the armed forces and party- and army-backed death squads. Banda was assassinated by a saffron clad thug.
            –
            If the majority community has not been a victim of injustice, why have so many of its own people left this island, either in search of a livelihood or to settle permanently elsewhere?
            –
            Victimhood is not determined by whether one belongs to a majority or a minority. Injustice does not discriminate along ethnic or religious lines.
            –
            Be a man. Stop sending women and children to medieval Middle Eastern kingdoms

        • 4
          5

          The Fake Truth

          “Will you pardon Mahendran and LTTE but not a chaps like Ranjan Ramanayake or Sarath Fonseka or those various Sinhala terrorists as defined by you ?”
          –
          In Mahendran’s case, AKD must first ensure that he is brought back to Sri Lanka to face justice. If found guilty, he should be sentenced to prison. If, at a later date, a judge finds him innocent, then he should be released. And if his mates want him released before then, Mahendran should write to the Parole Board!
          –
          It was much, much easier to deal with militants and terrorists. The approach was simple: let the Army find a solution by searching for them, arresting them or, if necessary, killing them. That way, there would be no need to answer questions about the people who went missing, no accountability and no explanations demanded. Was that really justice, or simply a way of making people disappear without having to account for their fate?

    • 3
      3

      The Fake Truth
      –
      “Will all the thousands pardoned be put in jail again ?”
      –
      If certain high-profile individuals have been granted presidential pardons, the relevant authorities should investigate the entire process surrounding those pardons. The Bribery Commission should also examine whether any favours, financial benefits or other advantages were exchanged between the convicted individuals and the politicians responsible for granting the pardons.
      –
      Any evidence of bribery, corruption or abuse of presidential powers must be thoroughly investigated, and those found responsible should be held accountable.

    • 3
      3

      This scenario highlights the dangers of unchecked executive power and the need for due process.
      Sri Lankan Supreme Court rulings show that mass pardons issued without required safeguards can be overturned, potentially exposing released people to renewed legal jeopardy.
      Strong oversight, transparent advisory boards, and adherence to the rule of law can prevent political deals from triggering a crisis.

  • 3
    4

    Vedda, that is a job for you-“thoroughly investigate high profile pardons !”

    The world will be treated to a first class comedy !

    The tragedy is why you think of yourself any better than the rest of the rascals there.

    Is it because you know a bit of English ?

    • 4
      3

      The Fake Truth
      –
      “Is it because you know a bit of English ?”
      –
      I must confess, I’ve never formally studied English. I’ve just picked it up along the way.
      –
      “The world will be treated to a first-class comedy!”
      –
      Really? I do enjoy comedy!
      –
      The history of Sri Lanka, too, has been one long-running family comedy show, with a rich cast of characters: fathers, mothers, sons, daughters, uncles, grandfathers, mothers-in-law, astrologers, huniya men and women, gun-wielding saffron clad thugs, rent a mob, and so on…
      –
      Life is hard, however, we still get to enjoy these family serials.
      –
      How could I possibly resist watching every episode?
      –
      Thanks for reminding me how fortunate I am to enjoy these shows in real time.
      –
      After all, why settle for historical drama when you can watch the next episode unfold before your very eyes?

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.