4 March, 2024

Blog

What Is The Character Of The Chinese State?

By Kumar David

Prof. Kumar David

Scholars write learned theses and simple folks like you and I wonder “Is China now some new kind of capitalist state?” Remember that every example of a state is a particular version or variant of a general class; so China may, or may not, be a particular version of capitalism at this point in time. Take the many manifestations of state forms as examples of variance. Slavery manifested itself in numerous forms spread across the world and in various ages – ancient China, ancient Greece, the African Continent (different in the Sahel, Nigeria, the Congo Basin and Eastern and Southern Africa). The economy of most recent great power, the USA remained a slave state till Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation of 1763. Southern US was built on the labour of four million slaves.

The question “What is China?” is an intriguing one. I will argue here that it is an unfinished story. The character of the state in China despite its enormous size is an unfinished story, prone to be pushed this way and that, changeable and fluctuating in the face of greater events on a planetary scale. I first advanced this thesis in a paper entitled “Socialist Market Economy: Oxymoron or valid Concept” at the Hector Abhayavardhana Symposium in 1999 backed by detailed economic data. The thesis remains valid today. A quarter of a century is but the blink of an eye on a scale of historical time. See also Colombo Telegraph for comments on Hector.

The post-WW2, post Brittan Woods world order remained intact despite Nixon pulling the US out of the Gold Standard in 1973, the Stagflation crisis of the Regan period, and Moron Bush and despicable SIR (Shame on you QE2) Tony Blair, flogging wild lies in their rush to conquer Iraq. To come up to date,  a dramatic shift in the structure global power is unfolding at this time. The post-WW2 world order, dominated by the United States and its Western European alies is unravelling, superficially as a consequence of a catastrophe in the Middle East (Palestine/Israel) and defeat in the Ukraine. At a deeper level the unravelling if because the post-WW2 epoch of expansion of global capitalism has run its course. The phase of expansion of global capitalism has, objectively, run its course and the economic and political balances have, of their own, evolved to a new stage. If you like fancy terminology you may call it the dialectic, or if you prefer analogies you may recall how Mercantilism evolved into Empire, Colonialism and Imperialism like a Darwinian progression. What I am labouring to say is that the familiar economic, strategic and social order of about the last 75 years is over; now it’s the start of a new world order. The emerging and still not final state form in China is trapped within this ‘problématique’ (sorry for using a fancy French word but the luminaire are familiar with the usage). 

Before speculating (which is all one can do) on the big question of what the world will be like after the now disintegrating world order has run its course, let me recount how difficult this is to do even on a national scale for a small country. Allow me to use constitutions as my mileposts. When the Dunmore Constitution was enacted in 1931 who predicted the socio-positional conflicts and changes in economic landscape during the period up the Soulbury Constitution of 1947? Who saw the trajectory of the short-lived Sirima-Colvin Republican Constitution of 1972, or the blood-soaked trail of JR’s brutal 1977 instrument? No one really in his mind’s eye saw it all. Even NM only alerted the nation to dangers inherent in JR’s constitution; he could not predict the future step by step.

Predicting the global future is best left to soothsays, astrologers and charlatans. When Queen Victoria died in 1901 to be succeeded by Edward VII till 1910, who on earth foresaw impending war? And after the Great Imperialist War (the War to end all Wars!), came the Wall Street Crash, the Great Depression, Hitler-Nazism and WW-II. This was followed by a Britten Woods defined, US dominated world. Yes it was foreseeable that post WW-II capitalist boom would last for about half a century. Tell me what’s next? A global Socialist Market Economy, or the end free-markets, or a new dose of liberalism. Who knows?

There is one point that is pertinent. Experience across the world over the last century has proved that leaders must not remain in power for too long. A decade is enough. Lenin a genuine revolutionary, had he not died in January 1924, would surely have stepped-down as head of the Soviet State after about a decade. Mao no doubt felt that his work was unfinished but he would have been wise to step aside for about ten years and let Liu Sao Chi and Chou en Lai have a go. Mao’s overreach contributed to the horrors of the Cultural Revolution. In my view it will be good if President Xi Ping steps aside for five to ten years while state power remains in the hands of the CCP for reasons that I will explain now. 

The structural stability that CCP hegemony has provided, despite shortcomings, was essential. China has pulled about 500 or 600 million people out of poverty, the country has not fallen apart into warlord states, it has prospered into an economic great power. Deng Xiao Ping pulled of an economic miracle within two decades thanks to solid Party backing. This could not have happened if the CCP had been ousted. House construction was the domain of private capital leading to disaster. Finance and baking a sophisticated challenge and needs leadership by the Government supported by a Planning Commission not Party directives.

I grant that there has been many a downside; absence of formal electoral democracy except at the county or local (village) level anabhorrence and suppression of other influential ideologies – Confucianism, Fulan Gong and Islam in Xinjiang. Some of these excesses could have been avoided but if the CCP had been overthrown, the country would have descended into chaos (and America’s dreams fulfilled!).   

I like to finish off my essays on international topics with a short comment on how what effect they may have on Sri Lanka. I have often commented in these pages that I am of view that the NPP-JVP is likely to win a large number of seats, maybe up to 30 or 40 percent in the next parliamentary election and that the two leading contenders in a presidential election in 2024 would be Anura Kumara and the main UNP contender. The latter may be Ranil, or Sajith as the candidate put up by some consortium his own UNPers also known as the SJB, in alliance with the formal UNP. The poinht I want to make about the newly developing global situation and in particular the topic of this essay which is how things may pan out in China is this. In relation to the JVP it will be very comfortable if China comes out “winner” in the global context. The JVP has had a relationship with China from the Wijeweera days, it had fraternal relations with Shan and the JVP’s mentality is what I will call “orientalist” (with apologies to Edward Saied) for want of a better term.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 4
    0

    “What Is the Character Of the Chinese State”?

    We question others “Character” and are “Experts” in raising that question.

    Why are we not QUESTIONING our CHARACTER?

    If as a NATION and a COUNTRY, we got involved in questioning our “Character” and MOULDED it to suit us and shape it in relation to others, our destiny would have been far different, in excellence than we are today. That is what all other countries, including China, did and still doing (even recognizing failures and adjusting to suit the time and environment) to achieve SUCCESS.

    In contrast, what we did and still doing is to QUESTION others “CHARACTER”. No wonder we are FAILED STATE. It is time to CHANGE.

    • 6
      1

      We never had a political Leader who was able to see beyond his nose.
      End of chapter. End of story. End of our future!

      • 6
        0

        My dear Nathan Uncle,
        .
        we know that our people are not that developed in their human and social evolution, how dare you expect such a leader be formed ? can you expect a mango tree to produce apples ?

        So-called political analysts (e.g Dayan Jayathilaka) and even law professors (once upon a time, Rajapakshe Goebells GLP) – high court judges and chief justices (e.g Sarath N Silva) behave like immature youths, so how can we expect good leaders to emerge?

        • 3
          0

          Dear leelagemalli, Addressing me as ‘uncle’, you have made my day. I truly wish you well.

      • 3
        0

        “I grant that there has been many a downside; absence of formal electoral democracy except at the county or local (village) level anabhorrence and suppression of other influential ideologies “
        True, and that is what we must consider in this country amid the cacophony of anarchic voices calling for “free speech”, “regular elections “, and whatnot.
        These are Weatern things superimposed on what is basically a tribal society. There will never be free speech here as long as there are religious sacred cows, and there will never be real rule of law as long as the sacred cows have veto power.
        It is safe also to assume that even a Sinhala Christian will never be Head of State.

        • 2
          0

          Chinese seem to do quite well when they are left to themselves as a majority, like Hong Kong, Singapore, Macau, Taiwan, and China itself.
          But, strangely, as individuals they lag behind in earning capacity as immigrants in the West. Even Sri Lankans do better than Chinese, and Indians outdo all by a good margin.
          https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ethnic_groups_in_the_United_States_by_household_income
          Should we conclude that a Chiese style state is better for the population as a whole, while an Indian style state is better for motivated individuals?

          • 2
            3

            “But, strangely, as individuals they lag behind in earning capacity as immigrants in the West. Even Sri Lankans do better than Chinese, and Indians outdo all by a good margin.”
            It has little to do with race and more to do with class.
            The bulk of the Chinese immigrants to the US were coolies on par with African slaves.
            The more middle class types that immigrated since the 1980s have fared very well in the professions.
            Also an anti-China prejudice has played a role since 1950.

    • 1
      0

      “It is time to CHANGE”
      The damage is done not only by Politicians but also by majority people. The question is who should CHANGE? What limits them to change. Some thought the people changed in 2022 in the name of Aragalaya’ but it looks the People have not Changed. Where are they gone now the Country is sold once again by Ranil to India, USA and China.?

  • 5
    2

    Let us all hold our breath. “Freedom & democracy” will in 2024 gift us a new US president. Polls tell us who is the leading conntender. And as with all US presients, he will have the key to nuclear armageddon.

    • 3
      3

      Sonali
      The next President will sleepwalk the US into whatever it is in store for it, as a result of decades of mishandling of world affairs based on American exceptionalism.
      There is no chance of its electing a person who will critically analyse the past and put the US on track for survival in a multi-polar world.

  • 4
    1

    “I will argue here that it is an unfinished story.”
    Kindly tell me of any story that is finished in political history.

  • 3
    0

    “Who saw the trajectory of the short-lived Sirima-Colvin Republican Constitution of 1972, or the blood-soaked trail of JR’s brutal 1977 instrument?”
    Many saw where we were heading in both instances.
    Colvin cannot say that he was not warned.
    Key aspects ofg JRJ’s instrument, really of 1978, was foreseen by many;
    and what was in store for the Tamils and the opposition was pretty much clear to many within months of the UNP getting elected.

  • 1
    3

    Why is QE2 being blamed for the blunders that Blair made? She had no say in his decisions. I thought it was well known that she didn’t approve of Blair dragging the UK into the Iraq war.
    .
    The same way the US led capitalist neoliberal world is losing its power and relevance, one wonders if the time is ripe for China to ascend into a more democratic state in order to fully realize its economic and social potential.
    .
    While touching upon a number of key historical milestones, current major global trends and trying to pose the question of how the world is going to be in the future, the author has left out the greatest challenge of our time and perhaps in the history of human kind.
    .
    The Global Question of Climate Change. Whatever happen to the US and China, the future of the world will depend on how we face this challenge of climate crisis. The solutions for which may require greater corporation across countries.
    .
    There’s a growing sense among some people that the future course of the world would be shaped by abandoning capitalism, that depends on perpetual economic growth, thereby entering in to a post growth era that would enable us to successfully face the challenges upon us. Broadly speaking both to address, the perils of capitalism and, sustainable and a liveable planet.
    .

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.