14 April, 2024


Who Will Protect Us ?

By Ranil Senanayake

Dr Ranil Senanayake

We are held hostage to a group of of greedy politicians and corrupt businessmen willing to sacrifice our health and our heritage to the purveyors of energy addiction. It is universally accepted that Coal is one of the most toxic sources of power and contributes volumes of climate changing Carbon Dioxide gas.

On all International Platforms the dangers of using Coal for energy generation has been made patently clear. The negative impact of of Coal on human health, to biodiversity and to Ecosystem Services has been demonstrated time and again. Yet, the sad argument “The developed countries used Coal and got developed, so we have an equal right to use Coal for our development”, is oft repeated by some ill-educated and greedy people, ignoring the reality as to what its use is doing, to our health to our wellbeing and to the planet. Today, the argument on coal is being craftily modified to state that there is a mythical substance called ‘clean coal’ and using this myth they try to foist coal burning plants, rejected by the populace of their own countries, on some poor, gullible, ‘developing’ nation.

It was not so long ago that a great number of Sri Lankans who are experts in their fields provided information to the Ministry of Environment on the massive negative impact of using Coal. This presentation was based on scientific research and was it amassed a massive body of evidence, it was then decided to cancel the proposed Coal fired power plant. But now, suddenly some politicians within the system have seen it profitable to jump at the bait offered by Japan, “Clean Coal “ fired power plants ! There is no such substance as ‘Clean Coal’. To make such a move, while the President himself is the minister, bespeaks of dark doings behind his back, for we know that the President will never go against his own words at international fora. The plotters who conspired with the Japanese should be outed, the public has a right to know. The public needs to know ‘What is Clean Coal ?’

However we should bear in mind that in a lop sided vision of ‘development’ the public will be coerced to consume more and more as ‘development’. Compound this with unplanned constructions with their profligate use of power and we move into a future with greater demand for power and thereby a call for more power generation. This is the tragedy of a government policy whose concepts of ‘development’ are still rooted in the consumerist/growth models 1970’s, and whose awareness of power generation stops at coal. Coal is an environmentally destructive substance, it degrades human health. But none of that is important to the purveyors of coal who want us ‘hooked’ on their product to give as power.

“In a port city in France, goes a story; there lived some of the most unscrupulous criminals. There were the drug traffickers who dealt in the cruel drug heroin.  Heroin is addictive, it creates a sense of well-being; but one requires increasingly large doses to maintain this sense of well-being. The victim who begins to take it becomes ever more dependent on the drug and freedom from it becomes increasingly difficult. The traffickers, it is alleged, give free doses to children in the 11, 12 age group knowing well that the gullible, naïve, children will soon become addicted. When they become addicted they have to pay and the price they have to pay increases with the addiction. They are trapped in a vicious dependency cycle and there is no way out. They end up being the chattel of the criminals.” Is development to be spelled out as dependency on fossil fuels? If this is the energy source that powers development and if our hopes and sense of well-being is tied to the oil, coal and gas purveyors, how safe are we as an independent nation?

Politicians of every colour has pushed us along this path, until today we are ready to accept any poison, any compromise of our future as long as our increasingly profligate fossil energy  dependent lifestyle is not affected. It is the level of consumption by a household that is the measure of development today, a far cry from the vision of our founding father D.S. Senanayake who said that development should be measured by the larder of the poorest of our homes. But under the guidance of the ‘new’ leaders, the worship of GDP and international monetary metrics, is more important than the well-being of the citizenry.

So burning coal, is considered good because it give us more energy and thus adds to the GDP. The myth of ‘clean coal’ is now being developed, the public, are told that; The will be no problems, do not be concerned’, the same mantra we heard when Norochcholai was being promoted and the same set of crooked EIA writers will probably be commissioned again. The reality of Norochcholai

was very different to the EIA that was given. The cost that the populace is paying through the increase of non-communicable diseases in the operation of this power plant, is painfully evident.

The danger was clear to our first president J.R. Jayewardene, when as a young politician, he wrote; “The environment which the State provides today, for building up the character of its citizens, tends not to the establishment of the ideal but to its destruction. The majority of States, including Sri Lanka, stand for “the purely industrial and utilitarian view of life, the cult of power and machinery and national comfort”.

Today, this cult of power and machinery, with those subscribing to it, is pushing us to accept the purely industrial and utilitarian view of life as development. The current crop of the BBP (Businessman-Bureaucrat-Politician) nexus, sees consumerist growth as the only valid goal.

Is the present deal to push the Japanese coal fired power plants on a nation whose leaders have rejected coal power a sign of some crooked BBP elements once again attempting to subvert his excellency the President by going against his international undertakings ?

Sri Lanka was a foremost nation speaking on Japans defense after the war. Using the ignorance of our politicians, to foist a substance that undermines our international stance is not a reciprocal gesture.

To have a cabinet that issues a cabinet paper promoting a mythical substance called ‘Clean Coal’, is shameful.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 1

    Ranil Senanayake. Coal use may have been abandoned because of cheap Nuclear energy. I think, coal may be used if the universities were asked to fine tune it and make it clean. for example, if the smoke goes through a water pool or oil or something which absorbs all the particles. In Sri lanka, cabinet ministers, state ministers are the experts and decisions are taken depending how much the businessman is pushing it and how much they are getting paid. I have herd, some times politicians (namal Rajapakse) did not push clearing of used cars through the hambanthota because the payment was poor. It is a completed situation in Sri lanka, it looks Sri lanka is bankrupt and beyond repair because, every thing is politics.
    Western countries go to new technology such as wind, tide, solar power etc.,,

    • 0

      Ranil thanks! the whole model of development in Sri Lanka is corrupt and intellectually bankrupt. Sri Lanka is a “Development Disaster” today. That is, an environmental and social and Financial (debt) disaster caused in the name of development because it is pursing the wrong development model for a small island nation that is climate change vulnerable.
      Lanka also does not need to ape the Singapore Asian Haze and pollution story of development as it has an agriculture base and lots of unpolluted ocean.
      Japan has been building super expensive highways to sell its Toyota cars here for year with the Asian Development Bank that it owns an operates. No interest in PUBLIC TRANSPORT by ADB!
      Short answer to Geopolitics and energy question now, is that Sri Lanka should ask China to help explore and develop LNG reserves and build an extraction plat in Mannar Basin.

  • 0

    Ranil Senanayaka again cautions us.
    No doubt coal fired power generation causes global warming. There are the skeptics like Idi Amin Trump.
    Equally emissions from cars, trucks, trains, planes and other means of transport is comparable to the coal fired outfits. Today’s Daily Mirror (27 Dec ‘170 carries a warning by the Central Environment Trust Director Sajeewa Chamikara that Colombo will face Delhi-type pollution soon.

  • 1

    Cost of solar and wind power is now in parity with coal. But the best option for base load is gas. Gas is cheap, abundant and clean. North America is floating in gas from the Artic to the Gulf of Mexico, and it’s really cheap there. Russia just opened the LNG plants in the North to Rival Qatar. With their off shore fields in the north, Australia too going to be a huge producers of gas. Iran too developing their Pars field next to Qatar’s field. The huge new gas field in Mozambique is coming on stream also Israel’s new field in the Mediterranean sea. Why Sri Lanka not making an effort to develop the gas field off Mannar. World’s major oil companies gave very poor offers to Malaysia to develop their off shore gas fields but they tied with energy hungry Japanese and now they are the forth largest gas producer in the world. It’s really worth, if we do something like it for the good of the country.

  • 0

    The whole concept of westernisation is wrong for us. Studies done of the cultural gene has confirmed that Europeans believe in individualism and might is right and Asians believe in collectivism. The philosophy of might is right is alien to all Asians. This is why our society has been disrupted by the open economy. Ranil W lacks the intelligence to understand it. Forcing SL to adapt western solutions to our economic problems will cause more disruptions probably worse than what JRJ did to our country.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.