13 April, 2024

Blog

A Tale Of Two Addendums & Ekwa Negitimu Miscarriage

By Rajan Philips

Rajan Philips

Parliament had one of its rare, better moments last week. It also had one of its routine bad moments. On Thursday (October 20), 179 MPs voted resoundingly to pass the 22nd Amendment (subsequently renamed 21st Amendment) to the Constitution. On Tuesday (October 18), not even 100 MPs showed up for the vote on the Petroleum Products (Special Provisions) Amendment Bill that too was passed but rather quietly with 77 government MPs voting for and only 17 opposition MPs voting against. It is disquieting, however, that only 94 MPs would show up in parliament for a legislation on petroleum products, the mismanagement of which turned the country upside down in a matter of months this year. 

Neither the 22nd Amendment nor the Petroleum Products Amendment Bill are masterpieces of legislations. The 22nd Amendment is not a significant constitutional improvement. It rescinds the 20th Amendment but does not fully restore the 19th Amendment, let alone address 19A’s shortcomings. It is not the content of 22A that is significant but the implications of the vote divisions for the unfolding Wickremesinghe presidency and the folding down of Rajapaksa politics. The Petroleum Bill will do nothing to foster proper management of the petroleum sector, but underscores the point that in the absence of real infrastructure and supporting policy regime, there is no legislative, regulatory or constitutional way out of the crisis in the petroleum sector or any other economic sector. 

Tragically, however, for all the political tumults about the supply and delivery crisis of petroleum products there has not been any corresponding ‘agitation’ in parliament either at the level of soliciting and securing up-to-date information on the supply and delivery status of petroleum products, or at the level of having some serious discussion about the petroleum crisis, its causes and potential solutions. With no one in parliament showing any serious interest in these matters, and the executive running around like a headless chicken, it is left to the Supreme Court to step in to fill the void. 

But filling voids is not solving the crisis and it is not the business of the Supreme Court to solve anything. Nonetheless, the Court’s ruling on the amending bill provides a good summary account of the “existing legal framework” for the regulation (I would add ‘and deregulation’) of the petroleum sector, beginning with the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation Act, No. 28 of 1961. The ruling also lays down the obvious markers to indicate where things could easily go wrong and slide into the opaque world of corruption and kickbacks with half-baked privatization attempts. 

Petroleum Saga

The current Minister who is now claiming that his new law will eliminate the monopoly of the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation, should know from the Supreme Court ruling (if he is not directly familiar with the CPC Act) that the 1961 law that nationalized the petroleum industry has always included provisions permitting the supply or distribution of petrol, kerosene, diesel oil or furnace oil by non-CPC entities with the approval of the Minister  or CPC Board of Directors. 

These provisions were not utilized by governments not because, as was suggested during the Court hearing, the CPC Act did not ‘contemplate’ regulatory measures for their application but because no government before 1977 contemplated using them for the import, supply or distribution by non-CPC entities. This included both the governments of the Left and the Right. In fact, it was the UNP government of Dudley Senanayake that entrenched the monopoly of the CPC by building a new refinery in Sapugaskanda with the capacity to meet virtually the entire domestic demand for petroleum products by importing and refining crude oil from Iran. 

Contemplations to use non-CPC sources for the import, supply and distribution of petroleum products began after 1977 with the changes in economic direction and philosophy, under a different UNP government led by PM turned President, JR Jayewardene. His government enacted the Petroleum Products (Regulation and Control of Supplies) Act No. 34 of 1979 to provide for the regulation and control of the distribution and use of petroleum products. Nothing much came out of it, and the JRJ government baulked from making a serious and considered decision about the petroleum sector (and the electricity sector) – whether to continue the CPC monopoly, ‘liberalize’ the whole sector, or selectively ‘unbundle’ it to create a healthy blend of both public and private sector involvement. 

The next set of laws came after more than 20 years, in 2002, when Ranil Wickremesinghe was Prime Minister, co-habiting with President Chandrika Kumaratunga. There were three pieces of Legislation – the Energy Supply Act, the Petroleum Products Act and the Public Utilities Commission of Sri Lanka Act, all enacted in 2002. The Energy Supply Act was enacted to purportedly deal with the emerging energy crisis in the country, and the Act enabled the creation of a new Committee, the Energy Supply Committee, but it also  provided for the of regulation of “activities  of  persons  engaged  in  the  importation, exportation, storage, distribution and supply of petroleum and petroleum products.” 

The Court ruling suggests that the Petroleum Products Act (PPA) “sought to regulate the downstream petroleum sector by removing the monopoly of the CPC and providing for the issue of licences subject to prescribed conditions.” With respect, I would say that in policy parlance the PPA legislation actually sought to achieve the opposite: to deregulate the petroleum sector! Pertinent to the new amendment to the PPA legislation, the latter provided for the licences for the import, export, sale, supply or distribution of petroleum products to be issued by the Minister on the recommendations of the Energy Supply Committee. The new Amendment is replacing the Energy Supply Committee by a new Committee. 

The question now is what difference is the new amendment going to make to the operation of the petroleum sector? The Minister might think that he now has a freer hand to break the monopoly of the Ceylon Petroleum Corporation and get non-CPC entities to import and supply petroleum products for local distribution. If the Minister, or the government, wants to really end the monopoly of the CPC, even though there is no monopoly now anyway, it must bite the bullet and privatize the CPC. That way whoever is willing to take over the CPC can use its infrastructure the same way the CPC used the infrastructure of the multinational oil companies after their nationalization. In trying to create a parallel system besides the CPC, the government is only leading the country into the worst of both (public and private) worlds. The same way the JRJ government destroyed the bus industry and the school system. Very soon there might be an international university on climate change headed by a new Jennings from Norway! 

As for falling into the worst of both worlds, the Supreme Court ruling has laid down the markers to indicate where things could easily go wrong. The most important marker by the Court is striking down the whole Bill as inconsistent with the Constitution insofar as (original) Bill provided for the new Committee to be kept outside the purview of the Bribery Act. The Court directed the Bill to be changed to include the Committee as a Scheduled Institution under the meaning of the Bribery Act. Why was it excluded from the purview of the Bribery Act in the first place? 

The answer is because the real intent behind half-baked attempts at licensing is to create the path of least obstacles to local importers and their foreign suppliers. Even with privatization, it is the responsibility of the government to ensure that proper processes are in place for setting criteria and standards, for competitive bidding, and for the granting of licenses and contracts. That has not been the case at all in Sri Lanka, starting from 1977 and made worse after 2010. That will continue to be the case so long as the current Wickremesinghe presidency continues to be under the shadow of the Rajapaksas. 

22A Vote and Ekwa Negitimu 

After their sneaky attempts to keep lurking in the shadows, the Rajapaksas would seem to have got emboldened to extend their shadows more openly, thanks to the security crackdowns that President Wickremesinghe has been enforcing on their behalf. Their most blatant attempt to make a comeback is the Ekwa Negitimu (let us rise together) campaign. It really is an attempt to rise together with Ranil Wickremesinghe but on their terms. The evidence of collaboration came in the reported long distance conversations between Ranil Wickremesinghe and Basil Rajapaksa to consummate a no-contest electoral marriage between the UNP and the SLPP for future elections. That it will have to be on their terms again became evident with Basil Rajapaksa’s insistence on changes to the 22nd Amendment in return for SLPP’s support for its passage in parliament.

Not surprisingly, nothing seems to be over for the Rajapaksas even after everything is over for everyone else. Ekwa Negitimu is no where near the Mahinda sulanga that sprang in Nugegoda in 2005. The architects of Nugegoda are now dead set against the Rajapaksas. Even with them and with the mood the country is in, it is highly unlikely that Ekwa Negitimu will find any political traction. The vote on the 22nd Amendment shows that Basi Rajapaksa might also be losing his clout in parliament. After inspiring political foretelling last Sunday that Basil Rajapaksa is all set to decide the fate of the 22nd Amendment (either change it, have it withdrawn, or defeat it), the Rajapaksas were reduced to a pathetic no show on Thursday, when parliament passed the 22nd Amendment with 179 votes for and a solitary vote against. 

The solitary vote of course was that of Sarath Weerasekera, still standing by his “sapatha kara kiyanawa” pledge to put an end to Provincial Councils. With or without the President’s blessing, Foreign Minister Ali Sabry played the smart IMF card that without 22A, Sri Lanka can forget about any international bailout to help with its debt obligations. That certainly would explain the Rajapaksas choosing to stay away from the vote rather than voting against 22A. Even the usually patriotic Justice Minister Wijeyadasa Rajapakshe seemed constrained to go along with his creative cabinet colleague. Where does all this leave President Wickremesinghe?

The clever man he is, Ranil Wickremesinghe has been trying to keep the Rajapaksa insurance in parliament, and even extend it electorally in the country, while being constrained, and potentially pretending, to pursue a legislative agenda  that would be anathema to the Rajapaksas, but utterly necessary (though not sufficient) for the country. The President is still not open about his legislative agenda except in generalities and his mantra about an all party government. For all his talk about all-party government, not to mention the ‘national council non-starter, the President has not seriously engaged any of the opposition parties, either individually or collectively, to reach some agreement over what could be done by the current parliament working with an interim president. 

The reason for this ‘stalemate’ is that no opposition party will talk with the President without a commitment from him to have an early parliamentary election and about the future of the presidency itself. The President cannot do either without reconciling himself to being an interim President on a crucial but limited agenda. As a self-acknowledged crisis president Ranil Wickremesinghe should not have an electoral agenda beyond the current terms of the legislature and the executive. At 73, and given the state of his Party, he can easily do without one and commit himself totally and exclusively to laying down the groundwork for a new parliament to build on for Sri Lanka’s economic recovery. The vote on 22A should liberate the President from Rajapaksa clutches and let him focus solely on his mission as a crisis president without electoral distractions or ambitions. 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 6
    0

    If it is not a distraction let me pick,
    ‘thanks to the security crackdowns that President Wickremesinghe has been enforcing on their (read, Rajapaksas) behalf’.
    The ‘crackdowns’ of Ranil is a true setback to the liberation of the people of our country.
    (Economy should not be exploited as an excuse.)

  • 1
    24

    Under duress signed 13th amendment and Indu-Lanka accord are illegal. Sri Lankan leaders are being threatened by India behind closed doors.

    Kudos to naval soldier who told Rajive with rifle butt touch that what he was trying to do is illegal.

    Mr Weerasekara, another patriotic naval officer should be the next foreign minister and tell India to stop meddling in Sri Lanka’s politics and sort out so called Tamil problem in the only Tamil homeland Tamil Nadu.

    • 20
      2

      Tony,
      With so much access, even to know what happens behind closed doors, your willingness to let Weerasekara be the next foreign minister speaks volumes of your big heart. Keep it up!

      • 10
        1

        Nathan,
        Your praise is wasted on the likes of Tony.
        You can see where the great Admiral gets his votes.

    • 3
      0

      Weera’s theory Ravana dosent existed in this pride/bleesed land

      • 7
        0

        cugan

        “Weera’s theory Ravana dosent existed in this pride/bleesed land”

        Please forget the unhappy man, prince of darkness Weerasekera for a minute or so,
        do you think Ravana ever lived or existed in this part of the world? Please cite evidence.

        • 2
          0

          Natie
          Just now we celebrated the Deepawali

    • 9
      0

      Tony
–
“Under duress signed 13th amendment and Indu-Lanka accord are illegal.”
–
The accord was signed in 1987.
Most of the anti democratic/racist laws were passed in the previous 40 or so years and enforced until then.
There had been numerous anti minorities riots, arsonists went scot-free after setting fire to magnificent library and 95,000 books and and ancient ola manuscript although the then prime minister accused two of his senior party men and holding important ministerial portfolios, thousands of people were killed in 1956, 1958, 1961, …1977, 1981, 1983,… . Numerous properties were burnt down.
–
Can you tell us how do you think the above acts became legal, and nonpunishable by law? Could you cite the Act which gave the racists, rapists, arsonists, murderers, …. rioters, the relevant legal authority to claim impunity.
–
Where were your brave naval rating and Prince of Darkness Weerasekera when five An-32s and two Mirage 2000 roared over this island? Were they hiding behind their women folks’ back or Vellupillai Prabaharan’s fat bum?
–
“Mr Weerasekara, another patriotic naval officer should be the next foreign minister and tell India to stop meddling in Sri Lanka’s politics “
–
If you treat your women folks well strangers and neighbours won’t dare to grope them.

    • 6
      2

      That is attempted murder of Rajiv Gandhi that you approve of!
      .
      We didn’t like Indian interference in our affairs, but it is up to us to question why such interference arose.
      .
      The State must observe high standards of rectitude and responsibility.
      .
      Having double standards for them and us is very wrong.

      • 0
        5

        Oh, sorry.
        .
        It’ after a long time that I lost control of bold.

      • 7
        0

        Sinhala_Man

        “We didn’t like Indian interference in our affairs, but it is up to us to question why such interference arose.”

        As far as Hindians are concerned this island is part of their Akhand Barath, another state.

        You may call it interference however as far as Hindians are concerned it was mother India’s tough love.

        • 2
          0

          This Sinhala_Man or Panini Edirisighe, the peanut brain is never to be taken seriously. He tries to inform sophisticated readers of CT of things he has got no clue of. Like he was explaining what is a ROBOT himself not knowing the meaning of it.

          • 5
            0

            That is called ” intelligence” according to SM.
            .
            LM

          • 2
            2

            The time is 23:01. The updates today have not come in yet. But an email from LM has come to me at 22:42, and now another at 23:10.
            .
            At 14.19 (it says 8 hours ago, when I look at it), I sent a fairly long email to “leelagemalli”. His response to that had come in come in at 22.42. Discrepancy? I could explain it, if anybody wants me to.
            .
            Quite the contrary! You must be cursing us both if we are the reason for this delay. We can’t be sure, so please desist from cursing!
            .
            The email that I sent to LM, I forwarded to Colombo Telegraph (with introductory explanation) at 15:03 (also described as eight hours). I asked for my “RIGHT to Reply”. And I shall reply to the point.
            .
            However, I shall submit this now, apologising to all readers for allowing our personal differences of perspectives on politics to spill on to CT. Basically, he’s had bad experiences inflicted (so he says) by the JVP from 1988 to 1920, and still hates them. He thinks that they are still bad. And he thinks now that Ranil Wickremasinghe is our saviour.
            .
            Panini Edirisinhe

  • 7
    0

    RANIL SHOULD NOT DEPEND ON WIJEDASA RAJAPAKSE TOO MUCH ITS LOOKS LIKE WIJEDASA HAS HIS OWN PLAN EITHER TO BECOME NEXT PRESIDENT OR PRIME MINISTER.ALL HIS RECENT ACTIONS ARE MOVING ON THAT DIRECTION.

  • 8
    0

    With passage of 22nd Amendment, I do hope that Basil R keeps out of the SL politics.
    Superficially Colombo seems to be trouble free. SL citizens with money are able to carry on their lives. Hopefully charity organisations are looking after poor.
    Food banks and community kitchens are needed in various parts of the country. School kids should get a wholesome meal which can be breakfast or lunch.
    Government should not waste money on too many ministers and should not let ministers taking commissions or Bribes. Previous such cases should be investigated

  • 7
    0

    “In fact, it was the UNP government of Dudley Senanayake that entrenched the monopoly of the CPC by building a new refinery in Sapugaskanda with the capacity to meet virtually the entire domestic demand for petroleum products by importing and refining crude oil from Iran. “
    The UNP government may have built the refinery, but it was actually planned by the oil companies, way back in 1955, when Iran was safely under their control. The oil companies put their plans on hold when SWRD was elected and started nationalizing. Eventually his wife nationalized oil distribution too.
    Interestingly, the unions (some JVP-led) which loudly oppose privatization did absolutely nothing but fatten themselves with ludicrous salary agreements while politicians were stuffing the CPC with ten times the number of employees it really needed. These unions have a lot to answer for.

  • 6
    1

    A Tale Of Two Addendums & Ekwa Negitimu Miscarriage

    The President is involving the public saying we will rise together, He know that he is not from the people and people are daily rejecting him due to imposing of tax and covering up his supporters who assemble him is in the Miscarriage period, and no time for the healing

  • 10
    1

    Tony,
    Keep the racial issues burning for another few decades, until you all go back to eat….

  • 4
    0

    BASIL Was Behind the move to bring WERASEKARA To colombo district from Ampara district to contest in order to cut down the size of WIMAL VEERAYA and as BASIL Expected WERASEKARA GOT MORE VOTES THAN WERAWANSE IN COLOMBO DISTRICT.THIS WAS THE START OF TUG OF WAR BETWEEN BASIL AND WEERAWANSE AS A RESULT WEERASEKERA VOTED AGAINST 21 1/2 AMENDMENT.

  • 1
    0

    From Pothuwa to Ekwa (its total new brand they knows the art of sell/buy)

  • 9
    0

    Whatever we think about Rajapaksas and Ranil, Sinhalese people only depend on them because it is they who can take through the racism and Buddhist Fundamentalism against Tamils,Muslims and Christians. Even we thought that after “Aragalaya” people turn against them but they finally turned back to the same system that is followed by over seven deacdes with the help of super powers. Even though Sri Lanka has high level of education when it comes to Buddhism and Racism they are very low level of understanding.

  • 3
    0

    Amendments to the constitution alone would not solve the impending problems the country now faces. First and foremost, the power-hungry and dishonest Rajapaksa clan should be brought to face justice as all others. Young educated, trustworthy, and respectable people should be elected to parliament and thereby prevent thugs and criminals from politics as is happening now.

  • 5
    0

    Aji
    We Lankans have high proportion of can read and write that doesnt make us to be educated people

    • 6
      0

      cugan,
      you are right that education at school, colleges, universities does not enough to make people are knowledgable or human beings unless they understand or differentiate with what is good and what is bad. Unfortunately, they only listen what is our politicians and Religious leaders shout loudly in their speeches and in the medias. For examples, when the Monks and people like Sarath Weerasekara tells in media that a Muslim doctor carried out thousands of operation in Sinhalese women sterilization forcefully in Kurunagala hospital those Sinhalese people who trust their Monks and Politicians they just took it as a god saying without thinking that how can a Muslim doctor can do that operation in Sinhala majority hospital which has almost 90% Sinhalese doctors, nurses etc.

  • 2
    1

    Forgive my ignorance. What happened when the UK Labour Party elected Starmer as leader? Corbyn has given his version, a month ago; 88 minutes:
    .
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PSTmjY5rV1w
    .
    Two days earlier, these 84 minutes had come from Al Jazeera:
    .
    https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2022/9/25/what-really-happened-during-labours-anti-semitism-crisis
    .
    I’ve listened to Prime Minister’s Question time yesterday.
    .
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QG2H_n8Mddc
    .
    Hear Sunak at 42 minutes into that.
    .

    They fear winter, but we’re in a greater mess, facing starvation. They gave us independence 74 years ago; we, and we alone, are to blame for the mess we’re in. It’s up to us to extricate ourselves from it, instead of flooding Britain with immigrants.
    .
    Those YouTubes are long. Tell me how much has Corbyn been sinned against?
    .
    But here’s something for readers who fear the JVP:
    .
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rFTX3hyjrg0&t=611s
    .
    AKD for less than 12 minutes. A clear apology at 9’.30”
    .
    Given when AKD was born on 24 November 1968, work out how old he was at each point of their history. In any case they no longer contest elections. It is as the NPP. True, mostly JVP, but remember that Dr Harini Amarasuriya is not a member of the JVP.
    .
    Panini Edirisinhe

    • 0
      0

      They just abbomden the Ceylon, did we asked for …..Gandhi the great

  • 1
    0

    Punni Selvam see around see in Bandarawela how we sells our tea leaves It’s all picked by hand and the living conditions

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.