23 November, 2026

Blog

Americans Fought For Freedom; Sri Lanka Inherited Its Rulers

By Firdous MHM –

Firdous MHM

Part 1 showed that the American people made their own constitution, while Sri Lanka’s was made for its people by those in power. Part 2 asks why. The answer lies in history. Each country arrived at its constitution by a very different road, and that road shaped what “freedom” came to mean.

In the United States, freedom was demanded from below. Ordinary people fought for it, first against the British Crown and then against slavery and racial discrimination built into their own laws. In Sri Lanka, the relationship between those who rule and those who serve carried on, almost unbroken, from the Kandyan kingdom through British rule and into the independent state. The language of freedom was written into its constitution from above, but freedom itself was never won from below.

United States: freedom as a claim against power

The American Revolution was fought on one big idea: a government is legitimate only if the governed consent to it. Yet the same Constitution that claimed to speak for “the People” also protected slavery. Closing that gap took nearly two centuries of struggle, and much of it was a fight against the Constitution’s own compromises.

The key moments show how slowly and painfully freedom was extended:

1857: In Dred Scott v Sandford, the Supreme Court ruled that people of African descent, whether enslaved or free, could never be US citizens.

1863–1865: A civil war, President Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation and the Thirteenth Amendment ended slavery in law.

1896: In Plessy v Ferguson, the Court allowed states to keep Black and white Americans legally separate, so long as facilities were supposedly “equal.”

1954: In Brown v Board of Education, the Court reversed course and ruled that separate schools for Black and white children were unconstitutional.

1964–1965: After years of marches, court cases and peaceful law-breaking, Congress passed the Civil Rights Act and the Voting Rights Act.

Notice what these moments have in common. Each time, the people who had been left out, enslaved people, Black Americans, their allies, did not reject the Constitution. Instead, they held it up and said: you promised liberty and equality to “the People,” and we are the People too. They used the country’s own founding words as their strongest argument. In other words, the promise of freedom in 1787 was not yet true for millions of Americans. It became true, step by step, only because those who were excluded fought to make the country live up to it.

Sri Lanka: a hierarchy that kept going

Sri Lanka’s story is different. Instead of a struggle that broke the old order, there was a long chain of continuity. Three periods show how the same basic relationship, a ruler above, people below who owe service, survived each change of government.

Before the British: the Kandyan kingdom. In the Kandyan kingdom, land was not owned outright by ordinary people. It was held in return for service. Under a system called rājakāriya, meaning “the king’s work,” the king was in principle the owner of all land. He granted plots to people who, in return, owed him labour on public works or services linked to their caste. Temples, shrines and noble families also held large estates, and the families farming those lands owed them services too. Power belonged to the king personally. There was no separation between those who made the rules, those who enforced them and those who judged disputes.

Under the British: the old order reshaped, not removed. British rule changed parts of this system, but it kept the hierarchy behind it.

In 1815, by the Kandyan Convention, the British promised to protect Buddhism and its places of worship.

In 1832–33, reforms ended compulsory service to the government.

But in 1870, a new law, the Service Tenures Ordinance, recorded and protected the services that tenants still owed to temples, shrines and landlords. In short, people no longer had to work for the state, but their duty to work for the temple and the landlord was now written into law.

In 1840, another law allowed the government to treat unoccupied land as Crown property, so it could be sold for coffee and later tea plantations.

In 1848, forced road-building labour and new taxes sparked a rebellion in Matale, which the British crushed under martial law.

The plantations were worked by labourers brought from South India. By the end of British rule they numbered several hundred thousand, and they sat at the very bottom of the new colonial economy.

After independence: the same structure, new managers. Sri Lanka’s independence was negotiated, not fought for. The right of every adult to vote was granted by a British commission in 1931; before that, only about four per cent of men could vote. Independence itself, in 1948, was negotiated by a small, English-educated elite who had already served in colonial institutions. Outside that small circle, the great majority of the people, of every community, had little real say in the process.

The new government’s early laws kept the old hierarchy in place:

In 1948, the Ceylon Citizenship Act left most Tamil plantation workers of Indian origin without citizenship of any country, and a 1949 law took away their right to vote.

In 1972, the Land Reform Law limited how much land a private owner could hold, but it exempted temple lands. Temple estates, and the service duties attached to them, survived even the most radical land reform in the country’s history.

What this meant for the idea of freedom

This history does not mean Sri Lankans simply accepted their rulers. They resisted, and sometimes fiercely. The risings of 1818 and 1848 were serious challenges to British rule. But it matters what those risings were fighting for. Their aim was to drive out a foreign ruler and bring back a Sri Lankan king. In 1848 the rebels even crowned their own king, Gongalegoda Banda, at Dambulla. They wanted to change who sat on the throne. They did not demand that the throne itself be limited, or that ordinary people should have rights the ruler could not take away.

That is the difference between a revolt and a constitutional demand. A revolt asks, “Who should rule us?” A constitutional demand asks, “On what terms may anyone rule us, and what can we do if they break those terms?” The American struggles described above asked the second question. Sri Lanka’s risings asked the first.

The twentieth century brought new movements, but they did not break this pattern. The Youth Leagues of the 1920s and 1930s, including the Jaffna Youth Congress, demanded complete independence from Britain; the Jaffna Youth Congress even boycotted the 1931 elections in protest. The left parties that grew out of this movement, starting with the Lanka Sama Samaja Party in 1935, campaigned against economic exploitation: for fair wages, decent working conditions, the right to organise and a socialist economy.

These were reactions against exploitation by the rulers of the day, not demands to limit rule itself. The movements wanted a different ruler, Sri Lankans instead of the British, working people instead of a privileged few, but they did not question the dominating state. They did not fight for constitutional rights: rights that protect every citizen against the government itself, and that a citizen can enforce in court even against Parliament. Instead, they looked to a powerful state, placed in new hands, to deliver justice. When the left finally helped write a constitution, in 1972, it gave supreme power to the elected Parliament and did not allow the courts to strike down a law once it had been passed. The ruler changed; the dominating state remained.

Just as importantly, these movements did not challenge the deeper structure that ranked people into different levels: the hierarchies of caste, of service owed to temples and landlords, and of plantation workers at the bottom of the colonial economy. They may have opposed particular injustices, but they did not set out to dismantle the laws and institutions that kept those hierarchies in place. The clearest sign is the Land Reform Law of 1972, passed by a government in which the left parties were partners: it left temple lands, and the service duties attached to them, untouched. This is the sharpest contrast with the United States. There, the struggle against slavery was a struggle against the legal recognition of some people as lesser than others, and it ended with that recognition written out of the Constitution. In Sri Lanka, no comparable struggle took place, and even today the question of how the law itself sustains these hierarchies has never become a central part of the country’s constitutional debate.

Nor did these movements shape the settlement at independence. The vote was granted by a British commission, and independence was negotiated by the elite. At no point did ordinary people force their leaders to accept that power must be held on the people’s terms and limited by rights they can enforce, the way American citizens forced their leaders to add a Bill of Rights.

This is the main point of Part 2. In the United States, freedom became part of the constitution because people who were denied it fought to have it recognised. In Sri Lanka, the words of freedom were placed in the constitution by those at the top, while the old relationship between rulers and ruled stayed in place underneath. The 1978 preamble shows this clearly. It says the people “entrusted” power to their Representatives, and that the Representatives “adopt and enact” the Constitution. The people hand power over; those in power decide. The American Preamble, by contrast, became the very text that excluded people held up to claim their freedom.

Part 3 asks what this difference means in practice: when a citizen’s rights are violated, what can a court actually do about it?

Next: Part 3: Right Without A Remedy Is Just A Promise.

No comments

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.

leave a comment