11 December, 2024

Blog

Continuing Need For Inclusivity & Representation 

By Jehan Perera

Jehan Perera

Delivering his inaugural policy statement to parliament, President Anura Kumara Dissanayake dealt mostly with the economy and in particular the IMF agreement. The problem he faces is that the former government agreed to terms with the IMF that did not consider the impact on the people, but gave priority to meeting fiscal targets. The president acknowledged that the government had no alternative but to continue with it as the country had gone too far down the road to change direction. He said, “The negotiations had already been ongoing for more than two years. If we were to restart discussions on the restructuring programme for an extended period it will be impossible for us to move the economy forward…”

Due to the straitjacket that the previous government has put the country into, the government cannot follow its election time pledges to renegotiate the IMF agreement and get a more pro-poor outcome. With the poverty level having doubled over the past two years,” bringing increased hardships to the people it is necessary for the government to continue with the IMF agreement without jeopardising economic stability. The fact that the country is in dire straits in terms of the economy, and the government is a new one, would orient the government to take its decisions in a centralised manner.

The fact that the core group in the government consists of the JVP component has a Marxist ideology that would add to this centralising tendency.

Accordingly, the government would give priority to addressing economic issues from a centralising perspective rather than giving space to ethnicity, religion or region. This centralising and uniform feature can be seen in the choice of government ministers. The government has given more importance to membership in the party to other qualities such as ethnicity, religion or region. Indeed, the president pledged to create a racism-free society. He said, “I assure you with full responsibility that we will not allow a resurgence of divisive racist politics in our country. Similarly, no form of religious extremism will be permitted to take root. Our nation has endured immense suffering due to ethnic conflicts.” But the danger is that one-size-fits-all policies can fail to take into account the specific problems that people of different ethnicities, religions and living in different regions may face.

Mannar Disclosures 

In Mannar in the north, the issues that most concern the people at this time, and which they wish to have addressed on a priority basis, are the economic ones. Three issues that were highlighted during discussions in Mannar last week were the windmill project by the Adani Group, a sand mining for minerals project by a company based in Australia and the upgrade of the Puttalam-Mannar road, which has been a matter of concern to them for some time now. At the meeting, civil society members took the position that both the Adani and Australian projects are harmful to the people of the area and even threatening their very existence on the island with sea levels rising. They also highlighted that tourism potential and fishing would be affected as a result of the windmill project. They called for an independent environmental assessment, including foreign professionals, to be carried out to assess the long-term negative outcomes of the two projects.

There is frustration that the permits for these projects to be done has been secured by the Government with minimal contribution from the people of the area regarding what can be done. Both the Adani and Australian projects are seen as potentially harmful to the people of the area and endangering their fisheries and agricultural potential in the longer term. They claim that due to these projects there is flooding of their land. However, there is nothing that can be done to stop this as the permits for construction and digging are issued in Colombo. They feel that the benefits of these projects, the employment opportunities at the higher levels and profits go outside of Mannar while they are saddled with the environmental costs of the project. There is frustration that the approvals are given from Colombo without input from the affected people.

In addition, the participants at the discussion spoke about long standing issues of land, entire villages, that have been taken over by the military during the period of war, and continue to be held by them. The people of these villages live outside the village which is now a military camp, and they can see the military personnel who occupy their homes, while they live in temporary shelters outside. There are several such villages under full or partial military occupation, even though more than 15 years have elapsed since the end of the war. The new government has promised to deal with these problems. But to deal with them better there needs to be those within the cabinet of ministers who can articulate these problems.

Internal Representation

In its selection of the cabinet of ministers, the NPP has given priority to its members who have worked for the party as loyal cadres over a long period of time. The party has taken the stand that they will govern the country with their members and not form a coalition with other parties in which compromise will be necessary. The cabinet has also those who are more recent members but with requisite academic and managerial qualifications. The cabinet has many academics and doctors in it with good reputations. However, in a plural society like Sri Lanka, where ethnicity and religion have contributed towards creating major conflicts, the importance of a balanced representation needs to be borne in mind. It cannot be forgotten that often academics have been the part of the problem facing the country rather than contributing to resolving them.

 The relatively small size of the NPP cabinet of 21 has come in for commendation. Previous governments had more than double that number which led to high expenditures on overhead costs as well as creating incoherent and un-cohesive governance. As a consequence of restricting the number of ministers, the government seems to have given less priority to ensuring the representativeness of its cabinet. In particular, the absence of a Muslim in the cabinet of ministers has become highlighted and has caused a measure of heartburn among members of the community. They have noted that this is the first time ever that such a situation has arisen. Although the cabinet has two Tamil ministers, both of them are from outside the north and east, although they may work there.

At the parliamentary elections, the NPP won in all parts of the country including the north and east where the Tamil and Muslim people constitute the majority. It even won in Jaffna in the north which is a first time for a national political party. Therefore, all ethnic and religious communities have voted for it and, as such, they need to be represented in the cabinet of ministers where the most important discussions about the future path of the government will take place. In Sri Lanka’s plural society, it is very important that all communities should be represented in the cabinet so that they can represent the needs and aspirations of those communities, which might otherwise be neglected like Mannar currently is. The NPP government has an opportunity to chart a new course for Sri Lanka, one that balances economic imperatives with the need for inclusivity and representation. By addressing these challenges proactively, it can lay the groundwork for a more equitable and cohesive society.

Latest comments

  • 6
    10

    JP, you have stressed the need for inclusivity and representation when governing. Since there are MPs voted in from all areas, they can be approached for any additional voicing of concerns and issues. Even the President himself can be informed I am sure, if any issues become major.

    • 7
      2

      davidthegood
      The issues faced by Tamils have been there all along, and are known to all.

      • 0
        0

        Nathan, If President knows the issues faced by Tamils, surely he will do what he can to be trouble free as best as he can.

  • 7
    0

    Continuing Need For Inclusivity & Representation

    NPP see that the direction using IMF funds responsibly has curbed corruption, promoting transparency and better fiscal discipline. This enhances investor confidence, supports sustainable economic growth, and restores public trust. Continuing inclusivity and representation further builds confidence, avoids misunderstandings, and strengthens public support.

  • 10
    2

    “It cannot be forgotten that often academics have been the part of the problem facing the country rather than contributing to resolving them.”
    Very true. Being a so-called Academic doesn’t always make one wiser.C.Suntheralingam was a rabid casteist. Nalin de Silva and Channa Jayasumana used their status to promote racism and mythology. There are too many more to mention.

    • 1
      0

      It cannot be forgotten that often academics have been the part of the problem facing the country rather than contributing to resolving them.
      It cannot also be forgotten that many NGOs, funded from abroad and unaccountable to anyone, leave aside the electorate, have also skewed the polticis of the country for a long time. At one time Kumar Rupasinghe’s NGO topped the list. Then there is the “policy alternatives” people that this writer whould know about in detail. The Berghoff foundation, the funds from the US John Kerry boasted as having been used to lever the Lankan elections thorugh their NGOs, etc., are unknown to the public or anyone elese. This has led to the origin of a whole lot of conspiracy theories. As for academics, Nalin de Silva and his student Channa Jayasumana are totally unrepresentative and they were zealots who should not be used to tar brush the vast majority of Sri lankan academics, e.g., scientists, medics, engineers and literary men who have done good to this country. For example, the challange of feeding the rapidly increased population was met by unassuming Lankan scientists who created world-renowned high-yielding rice varieties. But the name of not one of them is known to the public or any MPs.

  • 6
    2

    Mr. Jehan Perera, I fully agree with you on inclusivity in the cabinet. This is not about appointing people who are not qualified for the job but that the NPP should have taken more care in ensuring ethnic and female representation, accounting for the person’s knowledge of the sector. If the NPP could show that there was a match between the portfolio and the person selected, that would be fine but this is not the case. For example, why appoint a doctor with no background in environment as Environment Minister when there are so many qualified lawyers among the NPP MPs? As the author’s discussion on his recent Mannar visit reveals, negative impacts on people’s livelihoods there and the environment are linked, with expertise needed in both environment and human rights. A lawyer, such as Dr. Kaushalya Ariyaratne, would have been far more qualified for this portfolio. The Fisheries Minister, Ramalingam Chandrasekar, is an up-country Tamil from Bandarawela with no knowledge of fisheries. There are competent Tamil MPs from Jaffna and Vanni and a Muslim MP from Puttalam, all coastal districts, who would have been more suitable. Meanwhile, Mr. Chandrasekar might have made a better Labour Minister.

  • 8
    1

    And also can anyone tell me what kind of qualifications Lal Kantha has for the portfolio of Agriculture Minister? The last I heard him at a press briefing, he was uttering a lot of nonsense – including setting up a monkey unit!!

    • 4
      1

      M
      A minister need not be an expert in any field.
      Willingness to learn and humility to listen to informed advice are far better qualifications than any formal training.
      *
      It will be safe to avoid taking comments out of context.

      • 1
        0

        SJ, Agree entirely with you – willingness to learn and humility to listen are essential qualities of good leadership, which Cabinet ministers need to have. But are you saying Lal Kantha has been listening, learning or showing any humility recently? Or any mediocre academic for that matter? One of the reasons they are mediocre is because they lack those qualities.

        • 1
          0

          Also wanted to say that in addition to the leadership qualities discussed above, basic knoweldge of the sector is helpful if the minister does not want to be taken for a ride by bureaucrats or industry stakeholders who do not have the public interest in mind.

  • 8
    8

    NPP doesn’t need any financial support for making some laws or regulations or for making changes to the constitution. They can easily pass them using the members of parliament within a week or month.
    Removal of PTA;
    Removal of ban on LTTE and other Tamil organisations or Tamils.
    Removal of special status for Buddhism and the ministry of Buddha Sasana.

    • 3
      6

      Ajith, you are joking no doubt. Removal of ban on LTTE. Ha ha ha it will never happen.
      Removal of special status for Buddhism? In your dreams buddy. You have been taken for a ride yet again.

      • 3
        0

        Svenson

        “Removal of ban on LTTE. Ha ha ha it will never happen.”

        Removal of ban on LTTR is not pie in the sky. It could happen sooner or later. Watch out you may one day end up eating humble pie depending on changing international circumstances.

        Who would have thought Tiger slayer Gota would escape from his country (6.9 Million) not once but twice.

        By the way there is a line
        “In the garden, growth has its seasons. First comes spring and summer, but then we have fall and winter. And then we get spring and summer again”.
        the Gardener says in the film “BEING THERE”

        Watch that film if you get a chance, you will learn something of course from the illiterate Gardener.

        “Removal of special status for Buddhism?”

        You too have been taken for a ride by the crooks who brought that clause into the constitution while you were priding yourself being citizen of Sinhala/Buddhist country. Did your Sinhala/Buddhism protect you lot from tsunami, Covid 19, bankruptcy, .bombs bullet, 1971, between 1987 and 1991, 30 years, … especially from crooks who made billions out of wars, contracts, … ….

        Could you use the special status for Buddhism to recover billions that crooks looted from the country and bring back crooks and murderers who escaped from justice?

        Forget the LTTE for a second try and save those asses who made you believe they saved you from LTTE, a few of your war heroes have been banned from travelling to your favorite destination USA.

    • 0
      0

      Ajith, what is the reason to exalt Buddhism above other religions, knowing that the robbers and corrupt Buddhist majority in this nation, even preached to by their monks, cannot get to nirvana wherever it is, but only path they tread is to hell, unable to come out from there.

    • 1
      0

      In spite of the enormous political cloute of the Eelamist Tamils in Canada and the USA, they have not been able to get the ban on the LTTE removed. Furthermore, Tamils will NOT advance until they recognize the enormous harm the LTTE and tamil nationalsim did to the Tamil community, killing off one whole new young generation, as well as assasinating some of the best Tamil people or making them exiles. The LTTE won the sympathy and support of the Tamils as a reaction to state terror, and this must be understood if we are to go forward.
      Noting the special status given to the Anglican Church in England (resulting from Henry VIII wanting to get rid of one queen and marrying another woman), and consequently special even in the minds of many Lankans, or the “In God we Trust” stuff in the US, I would opt for Buddhism rather than any Abrahamic Religion or the Hinduthva dominance that Narendra Modi has imposed in Sri Lanka. Mind you, some of the defeted and elected leaders of the TNA have their not-so-hidden Hinduthva agenda for us to worry about.

  • 4
    4

    Divesity, and demand for diversity, along religeous and ethinc lines is meaningless. Token representations do not achieve much. But then, Sri Lanka has a President who comes from humble backgrounds and not from the elite political class, and has far better understanding and vision than anyone who came before him. What better diversity do you need?

    • 5
      4

      SAV
      We seem too addicted to personalities and ethnic identities.
      So far AKD has avoided acting based on SB ideology. That deserves encouragement and not petty nitpicking.

  • 12
    5

    Jehan, buddy …… Cut this old-world inclusivity claptrap ……. now it’s the modern world.

    The appointments should be purely on merit: people who can do the job.

    If it’s 22 Tamils ministers so be it. If it’s 22 Muslims so be it. If it’s 22 ladies so be it. If it’s 22 LGBTQ so be it. If it’s 22 hermaphrodites so be it.

    As long as they don’t eat millions worth of cashews …… and don’t take trillions worth of vitamins ……. to do nothing ……. what does it matter?

    Man, even my grandma …… is more modern than you!

    • 6
      10

      The election was held on proportional basis Can you please explain what was the criteria used in the selection of ministers. Was any interview?

      • 5
        2

        In which country are ministers elected or appointed based on selection criteria?
        I am not sure if VP used such criterial too appoint his administrators.

        • 1
          0

          SJ,
          “I am not sure if VP used such criterial too appoint his administrators.”
          You still use VP to cover up your face from Srimavo BSF advisor.
          Even today, Tamils are behind their leader even after your master BSF slavery. Are you not ashamed of your behaviour?

      • 5
        0

        “The election was held on proportional basis Can you please explain what was the criteria used in the selection of ministers.”


        Ajith.

        I feel you have a wrong understanding of proportional representation in Lanka’s electoral process.

        It’s not like admission to universities/higher-education (if it’s still practiced.)

        I may be wrong …. but I’ve read somewhere …… that when the UNP lost an election by a landslide, in the early 70s, and was left with only 5 or 6 seats ….. JR realised, although they lost by such a big margin of seats, in a ‘first past the post’ electoral system ….. their loss in %s was only a few point ….. i.e. 52% to 48%

        So JR’s rationale for the proportional system is …… that 48% – a large number – of citizens were left without representation.

        I think, proportional representation is practiced in few places around the world.

        Proportional representation in Lankan electoral process …… is not based on race/ethnicity/religion ……. or what-have-you ……….


        Native, You should be explaining these ……. without wasting time picking fights with hapless ladies ……… who are in variance with your distorted view of reality!

    • 4
      2

      nimal fernando

      “Man, even my grandma …… is more modern than you!”

      Also they are more benevolent and kinder than all of us who talk about humanity.

      By the way did you participate in Tiruvengadam Velupillai Prabaharan’s birthday party yesterday? Today Tamils in the North East and abroad are remembering fallen heroes.

      • 5
        0

        Native,

        If your brain is mature enough to handle the truth ……… It’s the Sinhalese who should be celebrating Prabakaran’s Birthday …….. even more than the Tamils!

        If not for Prabakaran’s great act of patriotism …… SL today would be de facto partitioned state like Cyprus ……. and you’ll be standing in the queue to get your boss Ranil’s visa to visit Jaffna!

        What I write might sound like comedy …….. but if you can face it …… it’s closer to the truth than ……. the serious distorted crap you guys write because your inability to handle the truth …… or face reality.

        Good ol’ Sigmund would’ve hit the exosphere in renown ……. if he was born in Lanka …… and analysed Lankan minds ……

    • 1
      2

      nimal fernando

      “The appointments should be purely on merit: people who can do the job.”

      Are you suggesting Tiruvengadam Velu Prabaharan would have been a better choice than AKD, Ranil, Gota Mahinda, Sirisena, ………..? Being in possession of an efficient killing machine T V P would have halved the population in no time and sent all his competitors and opponents to grave, no parliament, no election expenses, halved sate expenses ….. . … no bankruptcy, …. what a great patriot he was, …

      • 3
        0

        Ranil, Gota Mahinda, Sirisena …….. collectively and individually have done more damage to the country ……… more than Prabakaran could ever dream of!

        Think about it. The truth is stranger than fiction!

        Strange but true!! :))))


        Man Native, you’re woeful as Ranil’s propaganda chief ……. no wonder he lost!

        Time to hand over to OC.

        Or better still …… hand it over to the guy in Bandarawela. His team won!

        He has surpassed you in the craft! :))))

  • 1
    2

    PTA was used properly in the past. It was targeted by the previous governments to suppress voices against them. The NPP government needs it to get at the people who brought economic turmoil as well as those who aim at promoting ethnic and religious animosities… be it LAY or CLERGY. PTA can be used judiciously for the benefit of all the residents of the country.
    The immediate aim of the new government should be bringing in the new constitution that is acceptable to EVERYONE.
    RW and others were champions of starting lots of commissions and inquiries and wasn’t following it’s conclusions

  • 2
    1

    SL embassies and high commissions should aim to bring the diverse diaspora together in order that they can be of use in the development of their motherland.
    These should be very be spending money very carefully and economically. This wasn’t in the past.
    Hope that GoSL has brought back all the political appointees and new ones appointed on merit basis

    • 4
      1

      It is time for the diaspora to go along with the new government and NOT TO REKINDLE racial issues in the various countries they live in.
      Please fold the LTTE flags and lock them away and help make the lives of the people left in their motherland

      • 5
        6

        “Please fold the LTTE flags and lock them away and help make the lives of the people left in their motherland.”
        It is absurd to ask the diaspora to fold the LTTE flags now. LTTE fought for Tamils rights of the people and gave up their arms in 2009. LTTE is no different JVP in terms of armed struggle for the discrimination of their people by the past 76 years of BSF. LTTE was believed by Tamil People and they are not against Sinhalese people. LTTE flags are not Bombs or Shells. They represent Tamil Peoples rights. If NPP understands clearly this fact and the Sinhalese People understands the fact that the past 76 years are against to human rights, against to oppressed groups they should not have any opposition to do right things. It is the challenge that to prove racism and Religious Fundamentalism is no more. There should not be any excuses.

        • 4
          1

          Ajith
          // fought for Tamils rights of the people //
          Don’t you think several Tamils who were killed by the LTTE, and their relatives, might have a slightly different view? And does fighting for rights include the stupidity of killing the Prime Minister of India?

          • 0
            1

            “Don’t you think several Tamils who were killed by the LTTE, and their relatives, might have a slightly different view? “
            Singar A Velan,
            Can you tell me any of the Sinhalese leaders including JVP Anura did not kill Sinhalese people over the seven decades? His JVP is now President and Government. Do you know how many Tamil People were killed by Former Indian Prime Minister? Have you heard of the killing of Hospital staff by Indian military?
            Yes every one has a different view. You have your view. I have my view. Tamil People still looking for their justice. That is why they still remember their love ones who were dead in the fight against Tamil rights.

            • 1
              0

              Ajith: The question is not the cruelty of others, yes others killed, maybe more so, I know full well. But the question here is confusing the cruelty by our own people on our own people as a fight for our rights.

        • 2
          0

          “LTTE flags are not Bombs or Shells. “
          True. So were flags bearing the Swastika some 80 years ago..

      • 5
        1

        N
        It is not the diaspora as a whole.
        There are swindlers who still make money by denying the death of VP.
        Their likes can induce poorly informed people by appealing to sentiment.
        These and other such people have money to throw and politicians to buy here.
        We cannot educate them. They are best ignored, but for exposing their shady deals.

  • 1
    1

    Disappointed that Harvard educated Jehan Perera is talking about ethnicity based ministerial positions which have contributed in a significant way to the downfall of this country over the last several decades.

    People have not forgotten how smaller parties offered their allegiance to whoever offered them the larger number of cabinet portfolios, and the corruption and fraud that ensued with total impunity.

    What would Dr.JP advocate next appointments based on caste? What about indigenous Sri Lankans, should they be represented in Cabinet as well on the basis of inclusivity?

  • 3
    3

    ‘LTTE fought for Tamils rights of the people and gave up their arms in 2009. ‘
    .
    Rubbish. The LTTE fought for power over the Tamil people. Dissent was instantly punished. Members of other Tamil organisations were massacred until the LTTE was the only organisation left. They lost the war in 2009. They are still banned in the West.

    • 1
      1

      Svenson, some who comment here twist the truth to their advantage. All know LTTE killed other groups to take control over Tamil people here as Eelam with flag and symbols.

    • 1
      1

      “They are still banned in the West.”
      The same west says you Sinhalese Government killed unlawfully thousands of Tamils. Why?

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.