18 November, 2026

Blog

Controversy At Chemmani Burial Site Is Not The First

By Jehan Perera –

Jehan Perera

The Chemmani mass grave site has today become a focus of public concern in the North and a challenge to the government’s credibility among the Tamil people. After months of excavation and the recovery of more than 580 human skeletons, a report by Sri Lanka’s leading forensic archaeologist, Prof Raj Somadeva, has concluded that the site bears greater similarities to a formal burial ground than to clandestine burial sites with signs of criminal activity and non-conventional burial. The report acknowledges that the available evidence is insufficient to establish conclusively the nature and circumstances of the burials. Its findings, which are markedly different from two previous interim reports by Prof Somadeva have caused dismay among Tamil political parties, civil society organisations and families of the disappeared. Establishing the scientific truth is essential, but so is ensuring that the investigation is seen to be fair, independent and transparent.

The controversy recalls the still inconclusive investigation into the Mannar mass grave, discovered in March 2018 at a construction site in the heart of the town. Radiocarbon dating of some samples at a laboratory in Florida indicated that they were approximately 600 years old. The legal teams representing the families of the disappeared argued that this finding could not establish the age of all the remains, pointing to untested sections of the site and relatively recent objects recovered during excavation. These reportedly included a biscuit wrapper from the 1980s and a skeleton found with its hands chained and manacled. The controversy demonstrated the dangers of drawing conclusions about an entire burial site from limited scientific evidence. The same danger exists at Chemmani. A finding that some remains resemble those in a conventional burial ground cannot establish that all the people buried there died naturally.

The mass grave discovered at the Matale District General Hospital in 2013 provides another troubling example of the difficulties Sri Lanka has faced in establishing the truth about suspected mass graves. The recovery of 154 skeletal remains was followed by conflicting forensic interpretations concerning the period of burial, including findings that reportedly pointed to the late 1980s and later radiocarbon results suggesting an earlier historical period. Questions were also raised about the selection and handling of samples and the adequacy of the investigation. These unresolved issues reinforce the need for independent scrutiny of forensic evidence, transparent procedures and a credible explanation of discrepancies between competing findings. The lessons from Matale, Mannar and Chemmani should inform a national framework for investigating all suspected mass graves.

No Follow-up

More than 15,000 disappearances during the war have been registered with the Office on Missing Persons (OMP) and the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), and many more are believed to have gone unreported. Identifying those responsible remains an even greater challenge. There are many documented cases in which witnesses identified those who took people away before they disappeared, but the authorities have failed to follow up by questioning those who are alleged to have caused the disappearances. One such incident occurred at the refugee camp at Eastern University in September 1990, when people who had sought refuge were taken away. Witness accounts have identified those responsible. Similar incidents occurred in May 2009, when the war ended and many people who surrendered to the military in the presence of others were never seen again. Disappearances also occurred at other times during the conflict, including the period surrounding the military recapture of Jaffna in 1995.

Chemmani came to public attention following the rape and murder of schoolgirl Krishanthi Kumaraswamy in September 1996, nine months after the government regained control over Jaffna. Her mother, brother and a family friend who went searching for her were also killed. The soldiers responsible were prosecuted, and six people were sentenced to death in 1998. One of the convicted soldiers, Lance Corporal Somaratne Rajapakse, alleged that hundreds of Tamil civilians who had been arrested and forcibly disappeared during the mid-1990s had been executed and buried in the Chemmani area. Exhumations at that time recovered 15 skeletons. Successive governments, however, failed to pursue these allegations adequately. The convicted soldier’s evidence could now prove important in resolving the present controversy, as is being done successfully today with others in custody in regard to the Easter bombing. His allegations should be investigated alongside the archaeological findings, forensic evidence, witness accounts and historical records.

Prof Somadeva’s report points to the positioning of some skeletons, possible coffin fittings and the concentration of children’s remains. It suggests that the burials may be associated with formal burial practices and raises the possibility of an epidemic or natural catastrophe. Yet it identifies no specific epidemic or disaster, neither the Covid epidemic of 2020 nor the Tsunami of 2004, establishes neither the date of death nor the cause of death, and does not rule out unlawful killings. In a court case filed last week, families of the disappeared challenged the report’s conclusions and called for the evidence to be examined more comprehensively. Personal belongings, including school bags and children’s items, have been recovered with some remains. Allegations that certain skeletons were found with their hands bound must also be assessed against excavation records and forensic observations. The objective of investigations must be to establish the truth through rigorous investigation and to pursue accountability wherever the evidence leads.

HRCSL Framework

The findings of the Human Rights Commission of Sri Lanka (HRCSL) provide an important framework for addressing these questions. In its report, the HRCSL identified weaknesses that threaten both the quality of the investigation and public confidence in its outcome. These included inadequate forensic expertise, limited access to scientific dating and DNA analysis, funding difficulties and the absence of an adopted standard operating procedure for mass grave investigations. These recommendations need to be implemented. Independent international expertise should be obtained where necessary to undertake scientific dating, including carbon-14 testing, and credible DNA analysis. A DNA bank should be established so that relatives can voluntarily provide samples for comparison. Ground-penetrating radar surveys should be extended to determine whether further remains lie beyond the excavated area. A formal procedure for mass grave investigations, developed in consultation with experts, lawyers and civil society, should ensure the preservation of evidence and regular public updates.

The Human Rights Commission also recommended an independent institution empowered to investigate and prosecute serious crimes by state officials. This is particularly important where allegations concern institutions whose own conduct may come under scrutiny. Investigations must be sufficiently independent to ensure that evidence is neither overlooked nor suppressed and that responsibility is established wherever the evidence leads. At Chemmani, as at Mannar and Matale, competing explanations must be tested through independent scientific examination. An inquiry into missing persons must be non-partisan, empathetic and attentive to the historical context. Families who have spent decades seeking answers must be kept informed and given meaningful opportunities to participate in the search for truth.

People of all communities who lost their loved ones in the past need to trust that the investigation seeks to uncover what happened to their loved ones and not be yet another government cover up as in the past. Their frustration also arises from decades of institutional failure. A credible process must address that history rather than simply ask them to trust a new investigation. For many families, the central question remains not only what happened to those who disappeared, but who was responsible and why those responsible have not been held accountable. Their demand for answers deserves to be treated as a legitimate claim of justice, not merely as a challenge to government credibility. Sri Lanka cannot build lasting reconciliation by asking families to move on while the fate of their loved ones remains unknown.

Latest comments

  • 10
    3

    “A credible process must address that history rather than simply ask them to trust a new investigation.”
    None of the governments or political leaders are prepared to solve the problems of this country or island, The only solution is to this problem is that all other religions should convert to Buddhism that is practised in this island and convert all the hindu, christian and muslim mosques or move to other countries those who can accept you. Let the monks and Buddhist political leaders to whatever they do.

    • 6
      0

      Fault lies with Tamil politicians who have been caught napping. They should have objected from the start about involvement of Prof. Raj Somadeva in Chemmani mass grave investigation after his role in the cover up of Mannar mass graves. Chemmani cemetery (Chithupathi mayanam) is a Hindu cemetery where they cremate dead bodies and not bury them. To pass judgement on bones, you need an in depth knowledge of skeletal remains. In medical school bones are taught in detail as to the size, shape and muscle attachments. Archaeologists are no experts in this field. Correctly a forensic medicine expert should have been present at the excavation and the archaeologist should only be used to carbon date the age of the bones. Prof Raj Somadeva is displaying his ignorance due to ethnic bias and should be removed forthwith to maintain sense of impartiality.

  • 8
    2

    Hello Jehan,
    It sounds like this comment “Sri Lanka cannot build lasting reconciliation by asking families to move on while the fate of their loved ones remains unknown”. could have been addressed to a former Diplomat who currently writes effusively on CT.
    Best regards

    • 3
      8

      Hello LS, Do you have a basic understanding of Jehan Perera’s writings during the height of the MaRa and Gota administrations? https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/president-gotabaya-can-achieve-where-other-leaders-failed/ The same Jehan now appears somewhat biased towards the current government. I believe we should refrain from criticism when we do not fully understand the background and origins of an issue. Likewise, I kindly ask LS to think twice before attacking diplomats. I may be wrong, but I do not think SD was as closely aligned with former governments as Dr DJ and several others were. If all diplomats are to be criticised on these grounds, then public servants in varied fields should also be held to the same standard. I believe such attacks are unfair, especially when SD has recently contributed several valuable articles while many others remain silent. Even university academics with relevant expertise rarely come forward to write on Sri Lankan affairs.
      Tbc

      • 7
        5

        Hello Leelagemalli,
        I asked Sarath Disanayake, as an insider, in a post why doesn’t he tell the Truth about what he knows about the MR Government’s Criminal Acts; he ignored me. I and others have criticised Sarath for his Evasions, Hubris, Circumlocution, Prolixity, Verbosity and veiled Sarcasm. His Articles on Buddhism etc. are an exercise in Apologetics. I am critical of all Religions and that includes Buddhism. There are no Gods, no Demons, no Ghosts, no Afterlife, no Future Rebirths, no Supernatural etc. If you, or anyone else ,have concrete Evidence of any of the preceding then show the World.
        Best regards

        • 0
          1

          ” I am critical of all Religions and that includes Buddhism.”

          But I will never criticize “Prophet” Muhammad, only Jesus and Lord Buddha. 😂

    • 7
      3

      Cont.
      To the best of my understanding, Sri Lanka’s reconciliation remains elusive as hatred and impunity continue to grow. Rising poverty and political extremism will only deepen the crisis, while law and order risk becoming words confined to books. If police officers commit crimes and kill citizens in broad daylight, we must not remain silent. We must unite against police brutality and demand justice, accountability, and respect for every human life.

      • 8
        1

        Hello Leelagemalli,
        I worked at the Foreign & Commonwealth Office and was privy to much information.
        I signed the Official Secrets Act and had a Security Clearance.
        I know how much (and the level) Information Diplomats are cognisant of. I also recognise the language that they are trained to use in Public Communications etc. Behind the scenes it is much more to the point.
        Sri Lanka has a Postgraduate Diploma in Diplomacy & World Affairs, 18 months if you have a relevant Degree. Maybe Sarath has a similar Qualification, if so good on him.
        As an Ambassador to Cuba, Turkey and with his UN experience, he knows as much as anyone about Sri Lanka Affairs, past and present.
        Have a read of his “The Geneva Witch Hunt: Why Sri Lanka Remains In The UNHRC Crosshairs” 12th September 2026 Article to see how biased his position is.
        Best regards

        • 3
          0

          LankaScot
          –
          I am glad to have found the interim report on the Chemmani mass grave, titled:
          –
          “Forensic Archaeological Excavation in Chemmani, Jaffna – 2025/2026: A Summary Report on Findings”
          By Raj Somadeva, PhD, and Anusha Wanninayake, MSc.
          –
          Please click on the link below to read the report:
          https://drive.google.com/file/d/18V3rUkaregXC2T-vhqMDCeagcPsVcoZ3/view

          • 3
            0

            Who is this Anusha Wanninayake. What credential does this person has to take part in the proceedings. Why no medico-legal officer a part of this investigation. Everything smells foul.

  • 7
    1

    All inquiries into mass killings go to one big mass grave never to return.

  • 7
    1

    The famous diplomat apparently reads only his own articles, and doesn’t have the nerve to get into a real debate.

  • 14
    11

    They used to brag about their military victories. Now all they have left is the HR canard. Keeping in mind, NGO’s and other interested parties are also in on the game. See this bit…. ” Independent international expertise should be obtained…” Jehan’s career depends on such statements. Jehan is not alone. Check social media, with Gaza being the catchphrase.

    Foreign “expertise” is not cheap. The country is struggling under austerity, no need to waste money on something of no benefit. Somadeva has done excellent work with his report.

    • 5
      3

      Lester
      –
      “NGOs and other interested parties are also in on the game.”

      —
      Sorry, are they working as prostitutes?
      –
      “Foreign ‘expertise’ is not cheap.”

      —
      Neither was the war. That does not mean the innocent victims and their kith and kin should be ignored. All mass graves should be excavated, and everything recovered during the excavations should be catalogued, examined using appropriate forensic techniques, and documented. All findings should be published on a publicly accessible website for everyone to scrutinise.
      –
      Don’t worry about the cost. AKD will soon recover the loot from the looters!

    • 6
      1

      Lester / June 2, 2024
      8 4
      The Chemmani mass grave is fake. Only 2 bodies were found, not a mass grave.
      I made $ 3.45 yesterday on MSFT. Yeah, I’m rich!

    • 4
      4

      Lester
      –
      By the way, have you ever attempted to guesstimate how much the country has lost in the past 78 years due to electing the wrong party and persons to govern and inapt members of the functionaries, in terms of actual theft, bribery, nepotism, inefficiency, foregone development resulting from poor management, and unnecessary government extravagance?
      –
      Please let me know the methodology you would use and provide the actual calculations.

      • 7
        5

        Ask Depinder Singh where he buried the bodies.

        https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jaffna_hospital_massacre

        • 4
          0

          Lester Ji
          –
          As far as I know, there is no accusation or evidence that Depinder Singh buried the victims and then built a vihara on top of each mass graves. His men did not even bother to dig graves and bury the bodies. The Indian soldiers left the bodies wherever they were killed, only for them to be discovered later by builders or exposed by members of the Sri Lankan armed forces.
          –
          Those killed by Depinder Singh’s men were all citizens of Sri Lanka. Why didn’t Sri Lanka challenge the Indian armed forces sent by the Government of India? Were they scared? When will the Sinhala/Buddhists grow their b**ls?

          • 6
            2

            “In all documented cases, Amnesty International has sworn statements from
            witnesses that IPKF personnel were responsible for the arrest of these people and
            that, despite repeated attempts by relatives to trace them in custody, their fate
            or whereabouts remain unknown.”

            https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/asa37/030/1990/en/

            More than 1K disappearances. Enough to fill Chemmani.

            “Disappearances and Extrajudicial Killings: Organizations like Amnesty International documented dozens of specific cases of forced disappearances, and human rights bodies note that thousands of detained individuals were held outside legal frameworks, with cumulative civilian deaths estimated by various regional monitors in the hundreds to low thousands.”

            • 3
              0

              Lester Ji
              –
              I thought you never trusted international non-governmental organisations (NGOs), as you seem to believe that they are intent on harming Sri Lanka and damaging its image abroad.
              –
              How, then, have you now chosen to trust these bloody foreigners?
              –
              Could you provide us with the details of the disappeared so that the facts can be independently verified?
              –
              By the way, why did the sovereign state of Sri Lanka not question the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF), demand accountability, and have those responsible arrested and charged in Sri Lankan courts? – The various Tamil militant groups opposed to the LTTE went on a spree of forced recruitment during the IPKF’s occupation of the North and East. Several groups emerged during this period of lawlessness, allegedly with the blessing and at the direction of the IPKF. Some even adopted names such as the Two-Star and Four-Star groups. One cannot help but wonder whether these groups were, in effect, serving as the IPKF’s auxiliary forces or expeditionary scouts.
              –
              I wonder why the noisy Tamil community did not make a bigger issue of your selective killings and enforced disappearances.

            • 4
              0

              Native,
              But isn’t this Lester the same Lester who swore that there is no mass grave in Chemmani? Or is this a fake Lester?
              Are we seeing double?
              On the other hand,:
              Lester / September 17, 2025
              12 11
              Native,
              “BTW, most Indians support Israel and, of course, most Indians are “extra-devout” evangelical Christians.”
              The statement is correct. If you listen to the Indian media on YT, they are major supporters of Israel. Unlike LieZeera, the Indian media generally refers to Hamas as “terrorists.”
              Native, your opinion?

              • 3
                0

                old codger
                –
                “Unlike LieZeera, the Indian media generally refers to Hamas as “terrorists.”
                Native, your opinion?”
                –
                If it is a terror group why did the Israeli Military intelligence and Natanyahu created Hamas in the first place and continue to support it until its attack in October 2023, even though the Egypt’s top Intelligent Chief was in Israel briefing the Mossad about the attack?
                –

                https://www.timesofisrael.com/for-years-netanyahu-propped-up-hamas-now-its-blown-up-in-our-faces/
                –
                As far as I am concerned if a person or an organisation attacks an individual or a group of innocent civilian to maximise damage and sufferings to the people then that person or the organisation should be listed as of Terrorists.

            • 2
              0

              “More than 1K disappearances. Enough to fill Chemmani.”
              “This report documents 43 cases of “disappearance” reported from the northeast of Sri Lanka from mid-1987 to early 1990”
              Who killed the other 500?
              Nice try, bro.

              • 2
                0

                Hello OC, Here is a short quote from Lester’s AI –
                “The report provides only preliminary field age estimates and basic positional data; full biological profiles (sex, stature, trauma inventory, pathology), detailed taphonomic scoring, and any trauma analysis are absent. No mention is made of DNA sampling, isotopic analysis, histology, or radiological imaging. Identification efforts and family liaison (a core Protocol component) are not addressed”
                In short the Interim Report has Significant Departures from Best Practice as per “Minnesota Protocol on the Investigation of Potentially Unlawful Death (2016, revised UN Manual)”
                The Report also says that there is Evidence of many more Burials as yet to be exhumed.
                Best regards

                • 2
                  0

                  LS,
                  We all know Lester is a habitual liar. Onr of his tricks is to make fake quote or figures from real reports, hoping that no one will read the real one.
                  I am afraid he is a disgrace to our common father.

  • 8
    2

    It’s a very high price to pay for the country.
    –
    –
    Prabakaran is the greatest patriot to ever emerge from Lanka.
    –
    Lanka needed Prabakaran more than the Tamils!
    –
    The political incorrect way: The Sinhalese needed Prabakaran more than the Tamils!!
    –
    –
    It’s strange but true!!!
    –
    None of you will get it …….. cause you don’t think afresh ……….. everything is already prejudged and stored in your minds ……. and you just bring them out. :)))

  • 5
    0

    Some events/acts shape history …….. motives don’t matter much.

    –

    –

    The Sinhalese have annual celebrations to celebrate great brave heroes.

    –

    There are great battalions of Sinhala-Buddhist monks marching up and down proclaiming ……. they are ever willing to sacrifice their lives.

    –

    So this should be easy.

    –

    Name one among the self-proclaimed brave heroic Sinhalese who would have fought India?

    –

    Just one!

    –

    –

    Since the first question is so difficult/easy …… I won’t tax your overworked brains by asking why someone had to fight India. …….. Not just yet.

  • 4
    2

    nimal fernando
    –
    “Name one among the self-proclaimed brave heroic Sinhalese who would have fought India?”
    –
    We can trace the history of the enduring stupidity of both Sinhala/Buddhists and Tamils. However, neither is so stupid as to take on India for and on behalf of Premadasa and the West. He forced his own people to sacrifice their wealth, health, and lives in order to enrich foreign arms merchants, Sinhala/Buddhist interests, and some of his own loyalists, both inside and outside the island.
    –
    Look at the so-called Sinhala/Buddhists and their own saffronistas. How low can they go? If it works, why didn’t all the war leaders and the armed forces choose Huniya instead of engaging in a very expensive war? They could have used a black-magic woman or man to bring the enemy to their knees.
    –
    There is a lesson to be learned: humanity should prevail, survive, and thrive above all parochial and nasty forces.
    –
    I can’t understand why you are so inspired by a psychopath.

  • 5
    5

    Imagine the scenario where the Tigers were successful in obtaining a separate state. Would their supporters in the Diaspora, such as NV, Scot, and Leela, call for any investigation? This is the approach GOSL should also follow.

    • 0
      2

      “Imagine the scenario where the Tigers were successful in obtaining a separate state. “
      Such an interesting scenario!!
      1. All captured ranaviruwas would be put to work growing rice.
      2. All ranaviruwo rapists would be chemically castrated.
      3.All families of suicide bombers would be given pensions.
      4. Mullaitivu turns into the submarine factory of Asia.
      5. Iranamadu becomes biggest aircraft factory in Asia.
      6. Full employment in Tamil Eelam.Sinhala workers return from Middle East to work in TE.
      7. Six car factories move in from ToiletNadu. Eelam Rupee double of LKR.
      8. TE GDP rises above TN GDP, which is already above LK GDP.
      9. Mahanayakas demand union with TE.
      10 Lester swallows grenade.

    • 2
      1

      “Imagine the scenario where the Tigers were successful in obtaining a separate state. Would their supporters in the Diaspora, such as NV, Scot, and Leela, call for any investigation?”
      Imagination brought bankruptcy to this nation. LTTE was not in the seen until 1980s for imagination. But the imaginatition started long before you all play this game even independence. Tamils did not ask you or your gomernment for investigation. The investigation so far is lead only corruption by your Buddhist Sinhalese by another Buddhist sinhala government. If you imagine if the investigation started with the muder of SWRD and the masscre of civilians in 1958 by your Buddhist Sinhala government?

      • 1
        2

        “LTTE was not in the seen until 1980s for imagination.”
        Check it out.

  • 3
    1

    Native,
    –
    For chrissakes man ……. keep things simple. You are getting worse than Diplomat Sarath!
    –
    –
    “Some events/acts shape history …….. motives don’t matter much.”
    –
    I’m talking about actions of people: what people did ………. not admiration/inspiration.
    –
    –
    “During the presence of the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF) in Sri Lanka from 1987 to 1990, the provincial government established for the region was the North-Eastern Provincial Council.”
    –
    “Headed by Chief Minister Varatharaja Perumal, leader of the Eelam People’s Revolutionary Liberation Front (EPRLF), which was backed by India.”
    –
    “The provincial administration attempted to form the Tamil National Army (TNA). The administration collapsed following the withdrawal of the IPKF in 1990.”
    –
    Ever heard of Cyprus?
    –
    –
    Who prevented the partition of Lanka?
    –
    –

    Keep it simple ……. for you make it multiple choice. ……. 1. Hero Fonseka? 2. Hero Mahinda? 3. All- capable Ranil? 4. Brave well-trained Navel Cadet Yoshitha? 5. Brave heroic Buddhist monks? 6. Any other Sinhalese? 7. None of the above?
    –
    –
    Please please please keep it simple ……… let Diplomat Sarath do Diplomat Sarath. We don’t need any more of them!

  • 5
    5

    I asked an AI (not GPT) to critique Somadeva’s report. I will not name the AI, since someone in Germany will use it to spam this website. You can see the results of the critique here:

    https://sharetext.io/er7zmvt6

    These are the questions I asked:

    1. Critique the report. Highlight the strong points, weak points, and suggest improvements. Comment on whether the investigation meets international standards.

    2. How does this report compare to international standards?

    3. Would you classify this report as good, fair, or bad?

    No alteration of the response occurred. The final verdict seems to be, the report does not fully meet “international standards”, however, “as an interim archaeological summary rather than a final forensic report, many of its gaps are expected; it still supplies usable baseline data on distribution, associations, and site history.”

    The response is superior to Jehan’s verdict or anything from the LiaSpora.

    • 1
      0

      “No alteration of the response occurred. “
      Sez who? The same guy who turned 40 in an Amnesty Intl report into 1200. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • 1
      0

      AI can be programmed to get the result you want.

  • 4
    0

    This is what the truth:
    Lance Corporal Somaratne Rajapaksa denies personal involvement in the 1996 murder of Krishanthi Kumaraswamy, claiming he only buried the bodies under direct orders from his superiors.
    Through statements made during his trial and a letter sent by his wife to Sri Lankan President Anura Kumara Dissanayake, Rajapaksa has detailed his side of the events:
    • Shifting Accountability: Rajapaksa claims that previous governments used low-ranking soldiers as scapegoats to shield senior military figures. He alleges that the killings were executed at the 7th Battalion Army Headquarters and that the victims’ bodies were transported to the Chemmani checkpoint on the orders of Captain Lalith Hewage.
    • Offer to Testify: He has explicitly offered to testify in any future international investigation regarding the systematic abductions and the Chemmani mass graves, where he claims up to 300 Tamil civilians were buried.
    • Exposing Mass Graves: His initial courtroom disclosures in 1998 regarding the Chemmani location sparked the first major investigations and excavations of mass graves in the Jaffna peninsula.

    Do we need more investigations or reports from Buddhist Sinhala acheologists?

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.