22 June, 2021

Blog

Covid-19, Old Laws & The Government’s Mismanagement

By M.A. Sumanthiran

M.A Sumanthiran PC

Thank you Honorable speaker for the opportunity to speak on this adjournment debate particularly after the Hon. Mahinda Amaraweera invited the opposition to point out short comings, mistakes of the government saying that all of that is welcomed, so in that spirit I wish to point out certain matters where the government has failed but without stopping at that I would also urge the government to take some corrective measures and in the course of my speech hopefully make some constructive suggestions as well.

Primarily this pandemic has been with us for over a year almost one and a half years very early in the day in January 2020, I remember the Hon. Leader of the opposition raising this matter in Parliament and asking the question as to why the airport had not been closed? He raised it yet again around the 2nd or 3rd of February last year and there was no proper reply at that stage from the government. The government was keen to dissolve Parliament, and the very first opportunity it dissolved Parliament, Parliament that should have been in session and taken measures to combat to meet with this National challenge was dissolved for political expediency. And thereafter when we called; all the parties in the opposition called that parliament must be reconvened the government refused to head that, we gave several reasons why Parliament had to meet. At that time, those who were infected were in single digit today we have actually gone to a point where the government seems to have lost control, it’s a sad situation when the health professionals and others who are battling this virus are taking enormous risk and are in the front line, the decision making processes of the government seems to have put even their lives at peril there is no proper decision making process and that is why we asked more than a year ago, that there needs to be a specific law to deal with this situation. Countries world over immediately passed laws, Covid-19 act. The Corona Virus act, in Italy, in the UK, in India in Singapore… several examples, they immediately passed laws to enable a proper legal regime to deal with the situation. Now I’m mentioning this aspect very particularly because we can exchange views in an adjournment debate but over and above that Parliament has a specific duty as one of the arms of the Government, it is this house and this house alone that makes laws to make legislations, and we have with us two pieces of legislations one is more than 100 years old, other is over 150 years old and not fit to meet with the situation that the country is facing today, or the world is facing today.

I heard the Hon. Minister of Justice the other day in this house, he stated that the Government will introduce a new act to deal with this situation, but where is that act? There doesn’t seems to be any urgency in doing what this house ought to do, there are other bills like the Port City bill all being brought post haste, but something that this house should have done in emergency session having been reconvened after dissolution even has not been done even to date. I have presented a private members’ bill, I tendered it last year, it was laying at the Hon. Attorney General’s department for several months and on the 23rd of April it was presented to this house, the first reading is over, one week has lapsed and no one has challenged that bill, now it can be taken up, I have been informed by the Parliament that the matter has been referred to the ministry of Health as per the Standing Orders and a letter has been sent to me, entirely in the Sinhala language, now this is another issue, how many times do we have to raise this, that a Tamil member of Parliament is being sent letters in Sinhala. I am told that even Circulars etc for employees are done only in Sinhala at least in this Parliament can we give effect to the constitutional provisions that there are two official languages in this Country why do you continue to observe this in the breach?

That’s one matter, I have got it read to me and it apparently says, that the matter has been referred to the ministry of health. That’s a good thing but I would urge the ministry of health and the others to have a look at this, this is only a suggestion, the Government should do it, but it’s upon the Government’s failure to bring a law, that meets with this situation, that I have presented this private member’s bill. The Human Rights commission in a letter dated 08th June 2020, wrote to the Secretary to the President, advising the President that the Laws that we have now are not sufficient to meet with this situation. It’s a fairly long letter, after considering all the laws, in extent and they have said that none of these meet with the present situation, particularly to restrain people from their right of freedom of movement, there is no law, under the quarantine and deceases act you can’t stop people from moving, you can only declare certain areas to be quarantine areas. Now it’s almost a year, since the Human rights commission wrote officially and told the government the lacuna in the law, still no action has been taken, now in the bill that I have commended to Parliament, now I’m not saying that, that’s a perfect draft, that is only a suggestion, but at least when someone has presented something like that why don’t you consider it? Because in Sri Lanka in our Country today, the public security ordinance is designed to deal only with public security, and maintenance of public order, not designed to deal with last cage health emergencies like this, quarantine and prevention of diseases ordinance enacted in 1897, is archaic, I mean I don’t have to say that, the scale of emergency should not be managed merely by  regulations under that ordinance, there must be laws, particularly because now we have a constitution and there are  fundamental rights enshrined in the constitution and freedom of movement can only be restricted by a Law, that is enacted by Parliament not by regulations, article 15 – 7 of the constitution specifically lays that down, and there are several judgments that say you can’t do it, emergency regulations are an exceptions, you can do it by emergency regulations but not by any other regulations, so regulations made under the quarantine ordinance will not suffice, we have encouraged the people to abide by these regulations, we are not telling the people to violate them, because it is necessary in the interest of the public health to abide by these, but it must also be lawful. 

I can understand in the first few months of this pandemic we didn’t have a law, but it is no excuse to say that one and a half year after the pandemic broke out, that we still don’t have a law. And a private member bill has to be presented to Parliament from the opposition ranks and still the government is not taking any action. The disaster management act is there, we could have at least used that, even the definition of disaster will not referred to the issue that we are facing today so I urge the government without trading allegations, I have already said that it is the government’s mismanagement of this issue that we are facing a third wave, even the vaccines were mismanaged, it is important to bring a lockdown for the whole country, to manage the third wave, ministers shouldn’t be allowed to interfere in those decisions like Hon. Gamini Lokuge did, all that has to be done, government must take those actions, but must do it also Lawfully and therefore even private hospitals must be permitted. I know that Hon. Sudharshini Fernandopulle said that Ayurvedic institutions can treat patients, if Ayurvedic institutions can treat patients why can’t the private hospitals be allowed to do these, so even at this point in time I urge the government to take proper responsible steps and I urge this house to make laws that are necessary in the interest of the public health situation that we are facing, Thank you very much.

*Speech made M.A. Sumanthiran M.P. on 05th of May 2021 at the adjournment debate.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 3
    14

    Mr.Sumanthiran
    Did you get all letters in Tamil during Yahapalanaya and if not, did you raise it on the Parliament,

    • 6
      1

      Dilshan @
      No doubt during Previous govt, if there were such issues they listened them closely and addressed the issues accordingly.
      Current situation is that nothing seems to work with baggage boy with Ali sabry because he as appreciate in parliament should learn first to dO the basics. Come with single good thing bugger has been successful other than his usual modus operandi regarding ” asuchi clearance ” of his masters? This happens when guy is hand picked for that position, let alone the bugger was unable to settle forced cremation issue until imran khan settled it for the sake of muslims, Shame on on Ali sabry😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌😌

    • 2
      0

      Dilshan

      “Did you get all letters in Tamil during Yahapalanaya and if not, “

      If he hadn’t, does it mean state officialdom under Gota/Mahinda/Weerawansa/Weerasekera, …. can completely ignore the provision of the 13th Amendment to the constitution?

  • 14
    3

    Dear Sumanthiran,
    The major problem of the world and Sri Lanka at present is pandemic of Corona but the major emergency for Rajapaksa family is how to rob this nation and how to make benefits using the Corona. They want to create a Kingdom for Rajapaksa family. That is why they urgently brought Port city Bill to sell this land to China.

    • 2
      0

      Ajith

      “…………………. but the major emergency for Rajapaksa family is how to rob this nation and how to make benefits using the Corona.”

      Please note Sri Lanka PM Mahinda Rajapaksa has been elected chair of the Asian Development Bank Board of Governors – Wed, May 5, 2021, http://www.colombopage.com/

  • 2
    11

    Hold on Summathiran. This is a national issue.

    • 4
      1

      Why cant they yet translate them in to all 3 languages? Is that a big issue if the buggers in leadership are whole hearted about equal treatment to all srilankens? After all after a 30 year old brutal war? 😎😎😎😎😎😎😎

      • 1
        2

        All national issues of SL are decided by a different set of people. Others just waste their time. Fact.

    • 5
      3

      Hold on G,
      This is a parliamentary address not an article on any specific national issue.
      He has raised several very important issues– all of them national.
      Not providing a translation in an official language is also an important national issue.

      • 1
        1

        SL national issues are decided by a different set of people. A fact. Others can waste their time. Nothing happens.

        • 1
          1

          Why are you wasting yours then?

  • 7
    2

    AG Dumbula de Livera has been rewarded with HC post in Canada for not filing a single case against family, crime and corruption. Dumbula in turn thanked and said “he wished to remain in Lanka to render more of his services to Rajapaksas”. Hearing this news , Diaspora has promised DL to keep company, so that he will not feel home sick at all. This is what you call a real a win – win situation. Isn’t it ??

    • 3
      0

      Hope to see much needed change in AG department with the new appointment.

  • 1
    2

    Mr Sumanthiran,
    Could you care to publish your draft bill however imperfect it may be in CT to pressurize the government to take action?.

  • 2
    2

    Gotta is smart in getting a Tamil as new AG so that throgh fear he could flex him to support him. If not they will say he is a kotty supporter or had VP’s image in his face book or say his some body’s some body was a kottiya. We have Sarath to do the rest and to lock him up. And there are enough agents to praise and clap and hoot in the parliament.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 7 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.