29 September, 2020

Blog

LLRC Report: A Flowering Of Freedom OR A Panacea For Despotism?

By Surendra Ajit Rupasinghe

Surendra Ajit Rupasinghe

At the very outset, I wish to state my stand on the issues brought up by the LLRC Report. This is to ensure that this article is read  without jaundiced prejudice.   I have stood against the manipulations of imperialist powers on this issue. I have also accounted for the hideous crimes committed against the people by the LTTE, and that such a policy has no place in the politics of liberation. My sole concern is that, in spite of the recommendations of the LLRC Report, the Regime continues to exercise a chauvinist-militarist  dictatorship over society, which has already rung the death knell of freedom and democracy in this Land. I have stood against the manipulations of imperialist powers on this issue. I have also accounted for the hideous crimes committed against the people by the LTTE, and that that such a policy has no place in the politics of liberation.

There have been a range of polarized views on the report of the LLRC. This is to be expected, given that the Tamil National Question has been the most contentious political issue for  over six decades, emerging at the very inception of constructing the modern Sri Lankan State, following the transfer of power from the British to their local counterparts. I am here more concerned with the fairly honest and sensitive arguments provided by persons in defense of the Regime  and even sympathetic to the Tamil cause, who are open to critical discussion on the core issues generated by the Report. The best argument presented is as follows.

It cites the experience of various countries that abided for a very long time, even decades, before they opened up issues of accountability, given that post-war situations remain highly charged and the political cost of conducting investigations have led to political suicide of governing regimes, and even led to military coups, as in Burundi. They cite the example of Northern Ireland, where it took decades before investigations of war crimes were taken up by Britain, focusing on Bloody Sunday and  the torture and execution  of prisoners of war.

My stand is that there should be a credible, transparent and independent investigation into alleged violations of international humanitarian and human rights laws and laws of warfare, independent of both foreign powers and the Regime. This is because these allegations have brought insufferable shame and infamy on Sri Lanka the world over,

In the case of Sri Lanka, they point out that the Regime is dominated by the extreme chauvinists who would revolt if such investigations were to be conducted and war crimes prosecuted, let alone any move towards devolution. They refer to the fact that the armed forces would feel a sense of betrayal, which would lead to a state of profound demoralization and dissent, and even rebellion. They insist that establishing a credible, transparent and independent investigation internally would be opening up a hornets nest, that would be seized upon by States that have already ganged up against the Regime.  Thereby, patriotism demands that we rally behind the Regime, and not harp on issues of accountability.

Of course, no regime would wish to commit political suicide. However, I raise the question, short of committing political suicide, why cannot the Regime take up and  implement some of the recommendations of the Report that focus on the root causes of the conflict, democratic governance and the Rule of Law? For example, the Report identifies the root causes to lie in successive governments that have failed to address the genuine grievances of the Tamil people. The Report accounts for the violent suppression of the media, and of countless cases of abductions, enforced disappearances, extra-legal killings,  torture and extortion. It calls for the right to information as a fundamental democratic right. The Report calls for the establishment of an independent Police Commission. It calls for democratic political participation of the Tamil people in reconstructing their lives and livelihood and in the development of the North-East.  It calls for prosecution of ‘errant’ soldiers who have committed  atrocities, attested to by  the  piles of testimonies of those who provided evidence at the LLRC hearings.

My stand is that there should be a credible, transparent and independent investigation into alleged violations of international humanitarian and human rights laws and laws of warfare, independent of both foreign powers and the Regime. This is because these allegations have brought insufferable shame and infamy on Sri Lanka the world over, where our people as a whole are victimized by this form of collective shame and punishment. It is our collective right and responsibility to stand for our dignity and honor as citizens of our country, which overrides the survival of any political regime. What has been evidenced so far is a willful determination to deny any and all such allegations (zero casualties/humanitarian war), a persistent refusal to address and rectify issues of governance, a structured and endemic resistance against addressing the genuine grievances of the Tamil people and  with moving towards a democratic political solution. What is needed is a sustained political process of democratization, inspired by a sense of collective atonement as the only true and enduring ethical foundation for healing the wounds of war and bringing about genuine reconciliation to a divided and bleeding country, based on a democratic political solution.

It is this lack of atonement and a spirit of genuine and profound reconciliation that stands as the bottom line indictment of the Regime. The Regime continues to entrench a Sinhala supremacist, chauvinist, militarist dictatorship over society, centered on a continuing military occupation and subjugation of the Tamil nation. It deliberately procrastinates on delivering a political solution, even after the APRC final report had been submitted, embodying the consensus of all communities, by referring to an abortive Parliamentary Select Committee.  Abductions, enforced disappearances, illegal detentions, torture  and extra-legal killings continue unabated. Police brutality is at its height. Karuna and Douglas continue to wield weapons, terrorize the communities and engage in extortion. The Secretary of Defense declares that the Regime shall not be held accountable for any violations against terrorists, in the context in which student movements and Left political movements are being labeled as terrorists!  He declares that the military bases all across the island, and in the North and East shall not be dismantled, but expanded and fortified. The defense budget exceeds the allocations for health and education combined. Colossal funds  are being wasted on mega development projects, some of which have already cost billions of losses of the tax payers money, such as Mihin Lanka, Sports Stadiums, the Hambantota port project and conducting grand victory celebrations. Billions of borrowed funds, with exorbitant interest, are being invested in seven star hotels and hospitals, casinos and bars, luxurious spas and brothels, garden cities and tourist havens, none of which have any direct bearing on alleviating poverty and the suffering of the masses, but fill the coffers of the ruling dynasty and its mafia cronies.  Murderers, rapists and mafia drug cartels with political connections to the Regime continue to roam the streets. Ambassadors of the State boast of having victoriously conducted a ‘war of annihilation to destroy the living forces of the enemy’. Instead of engaging in a sociological analysis and locating the structural roots of the phenomenon of political terrorism, they delight in demonizing  an internal political product of the system as an organization of pathological terrorists, whose fascism is derived from their very DNA, thus covering up for the systematic, gross, state terrorist violations and crimes of the State that finally led to the politics of separatism and counter terrorism. This is the language of conquerors and genocidal marauders, not the language of atonement and reconciliation, not the language of spiritual renewal and rebirth. Certainly NOT the language of Ambassadors of the State! All these factors serve to reinforce the reality that the Regime is not committed to implementing the positive recommendations of Report of the LLRC. It is not committed to moving towards a democratic transformation of the prevailing State and Political Order, as the path towards national reconciliation. Instead, it is committed to enforcing a Sinhala Supremacist,  Militarist-Chauvinist, Mafia-Terrorist  dictatorship over society, aimed at perpetuating the life-span of the ruling dynasty.

Lessons learnt should focus on the experience in conflict resolution in such countries as Northern Ireland, South Africa and the Philippines, where peace was achieved through negotiations, based on a mutual understanding of the legitimate grievances, the needs and aspirations of the stakeholders, and honoring the dignity, equality, autonomy,  security and democratic freedom of all communities. Although defective in many aspects, and class issues have polarized, this process of negotiations formed the basis for reconciliation and the construction of a new State, and the beginning of a  new era. In the Philippines, the Morrow National Liberation Front (MNLF) , which demanded a separate Moslem State in a predominantly (95%) Catholic country, was encouraged to gain consensus from all communities in Mindanao and to formulate a five year development plan that would be approved through a local referendum. The World Bank was prepared to fund this plan. Legislation was enacted by the  Philippine Parliament that endorsed the peace process. Extremist ‘spoilers’ were effectively  marginalized.  It is to be remembered that Nur Misuari, leader of the MNLF, and the organization itself ,  was  demonized at one time  as a pathologically terrorist monstrosity.  Demonizing the other is part of psychological warfare.  But no one went to the ludicrous and demented depths to argue that fascism was lodged in their very DNA!  ( Is this the official position of the State or just some ignorant ramblings of a conceited, demented nut?)The conflict lasted for some three decades, with some 100,000 casualties. Finally, the referendum was passed and Nur Misuari was elected Governor in the autonomous region of Mindanao. Peace was achieved through the most intractable process of negotiations and the combination of exemplary statesmanship from both sides.  We would do well to Learn from these Lessons, instead of gorging ourselves in the blood feast of a vanquished nation and defiling  our souls with victory celebrations, that serve only to glorify bloated emperors and perpetuate dictatorship and tyranny.

*The writer is the Secretary: Ceylon Communist Party ( Maoist)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 0
    0

    There he goes again “…an organization of pathological terrorists, whose fascism is derived from their very DNA…”

    This guy should take some lessons in comprehending the English language from his brother.

    • 0
      0

      Here we can see the difference between a Sri Lankan diplomat and the diplomats from other countries

  • 0
    0

    Don’t try to back off Ambassador, by taking refuge in the English Language. Your formulation expresses your debased thinking, which has become a major obstacle in building national unity and reconciliation. It is a justification for enforcing a Chauvinist-Militarist/ Mafia-Terrorist/ Crony Capitalist dynastic dictatorship. Your language and thinking – and objective-is no different to that of the JHU and the JVP. So much for the ‘ethics of violence’! Besides, it is not the language of science, let alone diplomacy or atonement. You should take some lessons in functioning as an Ambassador of the State. After all, the only training you have recieved is by sucking up to the status quo- Premadasa, Chandrika and now Mahinda- and of course, the armed forces. You climbed your ladder by being an informant against insurrectionary forces who had genuine grievances against the State, however repulsive their political tactics may have been. Your political role is now exposed. Don’y worry about my English, worry about your stupid and concieted verbosity, which is a poor excuse for reasoned debate. Why don’t you reply to the questions I have raised, or are you afraid your slip will show?. Do you believe that the Regime is implementing the Report of the LLRC with committment and passion, that it will account for the series of abductions, enforced disappearnces, extra-judicial killings, police brutality and torture, that it will implement the 13th Amendment, and bring about freedom and democracy in our Land? Can you be convincing with logical argumentative debate? Or do you insist on resorting to eccelectic, theoretical sophistry and political sycophancy? The people will judge, and so will history.

    Surendra

  • 0
    0

    There the Dr.D goes again. When the learned Dr. is short of ideas and words to defend his employer, just like the GOSLspokesmen who have been termed as “Comical Alis” this learned Ambassidor starts calling “an oreagmization of PATHOLOGICAL TERRORISTS. whose FACISIM is derived from their very DNA”. Will the Dr. publish the DNA test result to support what he wrote or Shut up without writting bullshit.

  • 0
    0

    “….And he cloaks his arguments with pompous words and phrases as if he consumes Roget’s Thesaurus 24/7 much like a crack cocaine addict. And just like the latter he cannot coin a sentence without these awkward words and phrases meant for theses and specific academic journals but certainly not for general consumption. I wonder what it would be like having dinner with Dayan? Would he compliment the host with, “This chicken is simply delicious”, or, “This domestic fowl belonging to the species Gallus gallus marinated in balsamic vinegar and sage and thyme does raise the sensory nerves on my tongue,”?…..”

    This so called “political scientist” which Dayan himself calls him and takes a mighty moronic pleasure in doing so is a slipper soup sucker of the corrupt despotic king and made a laborious effort in branding the LTTE as a fascist movement but when the fascist nature of Rajapaksha regime is brought to light, logically proved and his opinion sought he is dumbfound now and behaves as if to have swallowed an anaconda or an alligator! With donkeys like these posted as ambassadors Sri Lanka would no doubt sink to the bottom of every adversity because a left-overs fed and domesticated astray dog knows nothing but to wag the tail to its master and bark at whoever enters the gate or passes by whereas to solve grave and longstanding problems of a country it must see the advent of intelligent creative honest dedicated and principled people and not the crooks and cheats like Dayans and Rajapakshas and their henchmen. Sri Lanka is undergoing and suffering today its most unfortunate period of history because the patriotic and chauvinistic majority donkeys of this country have elected their best donkeys for the ruling of the country.

  • 0
    0

    How about war crimes in Iraq,Afghanisthan,Pakistan etc etc?

  • 0
    0

    Bought up on Aryan-supremacy myths

    Tamil is less, apparent invader from a land far away

    Kill the Vedha, rob the Budha then blame the Sudha !

    This Sinhala v Tamil thing is just a distraction

    Which Sinhalaya will not like greater power to his province !!

  • 0
    0

    It is all well and easy to call for an investigation indipendant of both the foreign powers the regime, but where one can find such mechanism is the question. And who will guarentee for their impartiality?The most difficult of all will be to convince either party of their impartiality!
    The grievances of Tamil people if any certainly must be addressed but their aspirations must be achieved in a democratic and non-violent manner.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 7 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.