9 September, 2024

Blog

Tamils & Sinhalese Have The Same Issue: Whom To Trust?

By Vishwamithra

“One is never afraid of the unknown; one is afraid of the known coming to an end.” ~ Jiddu Krishnamurti

Each election generates its own pace; its dynamic life is basically organic in its development and always rooted in ground. The candidates and their surrogates may be engaged in artificial bravado; their fundamental desire may be more towards impressing the candidate and thereby winning favor from him in case he or she emerges victorious at the end of the campaign than telling the truth to the voter. But elections basically haven’t changed their shades of suspicion. One after the other, these events which we call elections bear some of the most savage aspects of inner realities. Politicians in general and candidates in particular know full well the ups and downs and defeat and victory of politics. Those who endure and withstand the stormy environs of politics will eventually survive, win or lose.

Whoever the voter is, whether Sinhalese in the South or Tamils in the North, his or her first perception of the candidate is one of suspicion and followed by trust thereafter if the narrative of the candidate is believable, beautifully messaged and reasonably trustworthy. It is exclusively upon each candidate to challenge the fundamental message of the opponent in the context of its historical endurance and its relatable demonstration at present. More often than not, the voter would realize his mistaken trust, if so, much later after the election results have been declared and a government instituted.

The Northern voter, especially given his ethnic, cultural and religious composition and differentiation, has been deceived by all our past rulers. From the days and times of Chelvanayakam‘s Federal Party (FP) all the way up to the current Tamil National Alliance (TNA), Tamils have been wronged than the Jews in the sixteenth century Europe. Like Shylock in Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice, Tamils have been ‘more sinned against than sinning’. A majority of Southern Sinhalese might not concede it but it is a fact.

SWRD Bandaranaike let them down once. A quintessential liberal who stated in the early part of the twentieth century that a Federal System is the most appropriate solution for the Tamil question, had to abolish his own Bandaranaike-Chelvanayakam Pact (BC Pact) under the pressure of Maha Sanga and a determined band of Sinhalese nationalists. These Sinhalese nationalists were the fertile ground from which modern-day Sinhalese Buddhist Fundamentalism grew without any disturbance. No Sinhalese Buddhist politician would oppose or challenge Sinhalese Buddhist Fundamentalism. If they did, it would be at certain peril of his or her own political future.

After the abdication of the BC Pact, the Senanayake-Chelvanayakam ACT was initiated by Dudley Senanayake and Chelvanayakam after the 1965 General Election. It promised further devolution of power to the North and East. That agreement too met the same fate which buried the BC Pact. Both SWRD and Dudley did not possess the inner strength, the political will nor the majority in Parliament in their respective times in power to follow to the end of a national issue that had been not only irritating, but grossly underestimating Northern Tamils and their collective anger for nearly a century.

All these disagreements, unkept promises and continuing animosities between a majority of Sinhalese Buddhists and Hindu Tamils created purely for the exclusive ease and use of Sinhalese politicians in the south of Vavuniya, ended up in a twenty seven year war.

The war is over. The Tamil militants and their armies have been completely defeated and crushed. A fair sense of peace is existing in the North. By no means is this the resolution of the Tamil issue. Widowed mothers are demonstrating in the North, waiting for the return of their sons and daughter who were taken by the Sri Lankan military forces at the time of war. No resolution has been reached. Leave alone a resolution, not even a word in regard to the whereabouts of these missing boys and girls is coming out of the closed lips of the government. Southern politics has been so much corrupted and debased even a well meaning politician cannot open his or her mouth about the fate of the missing men and women. Consequently, no closure of the issue could be reached or finalized.

Lands that were taken over by the military during the operation of the war is yet to be settled. Sinhalese politicians simply cannot repeat what they utter in the North in the Sinhalese area. The issue has acquired such a distasteful flavor and it is consuming the entire Sinhalese Buddhist psyche.

This is the context within which the current Presidential Elections are conducted. Both Ranil Wickremesinghe and Sajith Premadasa belong to that foggy untrustworthy enclave of politicians who have repeatedly let down the past Tamil leaders and population. Their political ancestry is no badge that they could wear with any modicum of pride. Between the two, Ranil looks more liberal and ready to extend a more embracing arm to Tamils, yet who surround and support him to get to power are not to be trusted with a dead end of a cigar! The Tamil leadership should know this without condition.

Sajith hails from a farther who was well known for his ultra Sinhalese Buddhist nationalism. His opposition to the 13th Amendment and Provincial Government system is recorded history. His nationalism bordered on downright racism and his conduct in Parliament and as President had always been one of extremes and born out of his elongated egoistic mindset. Unfortunately President Premadasa’s son, Sajith seems to have inherited the same mindset. Overestimation of himself and declaring it aloud to the whole world to hear has been his modus operandi. Promising a full implementation of the 13th Amendment and even going beyond that and issuing a pledge of the 13A is no strange kind of public political conduct for Sajith Premadasa.

But Tamil leaders in the North must take whatever Sajith says to them not with a pinch, but a barrel of salt. Sajith too is being supported and cocooned by some incompetent and opportunistic politicians who have already lost the uncomplicated trust of the people. Both Ranil and Sajith carry the obscene baggage of that stinky and rotten past. They served in the same party- United National Party (UNP) and political hypocrisy that they display should not be disregarded as a matter of course.

Yet Aragalaya-22 may have changed the general psyche of Sinhalese people, at least for a minuscule degree. That minuscule degree of change is what may be necessary for a minuscule improvement of the current situation. If the Northern leadership cannot trust either Ranil or Sajith, the only alternative is Anura Kumara Dissanayake. Days of the JVP promulgating an anti-India and anti-Tamil political stance are over. AKD is now the leader of the National People’s Power (NPP). But the burden AKD carries now is enormous. Despite the possibility of the JVP’s past weighing him down, if one could  repose trust on major national matters in any leader from the current crop, it undoubtedly looks like  AKD.

What the Tamil leadership must bear in mind is AKD’s personal past and his most humble beginnings. Those beginnings are easily relatable to the average dweller in the Northern villager who spends all his time on parched lands, sweating day after day trying to make it easier for the lives his offspring. His efforts and the chores of a Southern farmer are fundamentally the same or sometimes even harder. But relatability and mutual empathy are two fundamentals one cannot discard as unnecessary for any politician.

Tamils in the North may discard both Ranil and Sajith for they obviously represent a past that has been challenged and rejected by the North. They may still decide not to vote for AKD. But voting for either Ranil or Sajith is no option.

*The writer can be contacted at vishwamithra1984@gmail.com

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 10
    1

    … A majority of Southern Sinhalese might not concede it (namely, – Tamils have been wronged), but it is a fact.
    This plain fact is at the core of our, Sinhalese and Tamils, misery.

    • 7
      2

      Might not concede is an affirmation that you my brethren are aware that that is true.

    • 4
      3

      Do a majority of any society concede that they have wronged other sections of society?
      Tamil upper castes and oppressed castes?
      Tamils and Muslims of the North?
      N&E Tamils and Hill Country Tamils?
      This is not to exempt other non-Tamil oppressors but to remember that there is much to rectify on our part.

      • 2
        1

        “Do a majority of any society concede that they have wronged other sections of society?”

        You maybe right, DS SenaNayaker, BandaNayaker, Weeping Widow, Dutta Gamani, ……. JR, Somawansa, ….. Malwattu, Asgiria, ….. never even thought they had wronged ……

  • 8
    2

    … voting for either Ranil or Sajith is no option
    Should not be, for Tamils.

    • 4
      4

      Sumanthiran is a crook and a blatant liar. He works on his personal agenda and not for Tamils. He was a lackey of Ranil for more than ten years and now is going behind Sajith to please Ajith Doval. Sajith has not come to any written agreement with Tamil politicians regarding rights of Tamils, but Sumanthiran wants Tamils to vote for Sajith. One of our Sinhalese classmates wrote in our forum that Sumanthiran is behaving in this condescending manner as he has no pedigree, which statement is absolutely spot on. Tamils should vote for the common candidate to demonstrate to the world that they have no confidence in any of the leading Sinhala candidates. It is time that Tamils to show Sumanthiran where to get off.

      • 5
        2

        You Gnana Sankaralingam are being abusive.

        • 2
          1

          N
          Noticed it only now?

        • 2
          2

          Can you show any abusive word in that. If you do not know English, it is your problem. Sumanthiran is jumping from one side to another without any principle or agreement. Is he not a crook. Sumanthiran is said that he will quit politics if Yahapalana government does not give the rights to Tamils and despite no result is still in place. Is he not a liar. There is a saying in Tamil, that there is no salvation for one without gratitude. Sumanthiran is in parliament because of the help by Ranil, who asked Gota to get STF to stuff votes for him, when Tamils rejected him. Now after being a lackey of Ranil and getting benefits, he is condemning him. What is stated is truth, which hurts crooks and their cronies.

          • 0
            0

            “If you do not know English, it is your problem. “
            I remember your having great difficulty in analysing a sentence in English, and getting all worked up and abusive when told.

            • 0
              0

              Calling someone a crook and a blatant liar working on his personal agenda and a lackey of somebody is not being abusive I guess!.

      • 0
        1

        “It is time that Tamils to show Sumanthiran where to get off.”
        https://www.colombotelegraph.com/index.php/tamils-sinhalese-have-the-same-issue-whom-to-trust/#:~:text=It%20is%20time%20that%20Tamils%20to%20show%20Sumanthiran%20where%20to%20get%20off.

        .
        Yups. High time. First shoot the b*gger in his b*lls, then kick him out!

  • 8
    0

    “Tamils & Sinhalese Have The Same Issue: Whom To Trust?”

    At this rate …… only Stormy Daniels!

    She has more credibility than any Lankan pol …… and she even wiped the floor with the great Donald’s stellar credibility …..

    There’s no excitement in Lankan politics. …… No razzmatazz.

    That’s what “Buddhism” does ……. the ol’ “morals” are neither here nor there.

    One wants to have them ……. while not having them.

    It’s a good ol’ liquid transitory state of equilibrium.

    Pretty STEM.

    • 5
      0

      Hello Nimal,
      No Lester – No STEM😉.
      Apart from that Trump was hated in my part of Scotland since at least 2006 and even before. Trump is a consumate liar as Stormy Daniels found out.
      I asked before – why do Sri Lankan Politicians have to scream their Orations?
      Best regards

      • 3
        0

        LS,

        “Trump was hated in my part of Scotland since at least 2006 and even before.”

        His golf course/club?


        “why do Sri Lankan Politicians have to scream their Orations?”

        That’s all I’ve known all my life! …….. AKD’s measured tone is a novelty.

        That’s why many prefer Ranil to AKD! ……. Native is deaf in one ear. :)))

        • 2
          1

          nimal fernando

          Do you have any election forecast?

          • 0
            0

            “Do you have any election forecast?”

            AKD is going to be the best Lankan president of all time ……. not because he is good …….. but because he has no competition for greatness …….. from any president from the past, present or future! :)))

  • 8
    1

    Sumanthiran and ITAK are saying they are going to support Sajith Premadasa. I don’t know about the ITAK’s reasoning, but the old picture in this article, probably from an old rally, gives a misleading impression that Sumanthiran supports the NPP.

    • 9
      0

      Agnos,
      13 A , which Sajith has promised to implement fully, is the magic carrot. Sumanthiran is going to be very disappointed.

      • 4
        3

        Old,
        “Sumanthiran is going to be very disappointed.”
        Sumanthiran PC is not that kind of Baba. He carries his own bag and baggage on his shoulders. Sumanthiran Challenged in North that if the Secret Solution was not implemented by Yahapalanaya and Evil, he would quit politics. (that much was with Evil UNP.) Under 13A no provincial election needs to be held for the North East, but still some form of government is possible for the rest of the 7 Sinhala Buddhism Only provinces. Is it now, when Manmohan Singh is not in PM seat in India, Sumanthiran going for watered out 13A? Sumanthiran will not be winning a seat in North this time with Tamils vote. So, without any fear, he has started to wash to Sinhala Buddhist parties for a minister position. It appears he is guessing Valaiththodam has more chances than Evil or Anura. So, he is playing his ball in SJB’s court.
        Sumanthiran had lost the last election. Sridharan fired Mrs. Raviraj and instated Sumanthiran. This time he must be with the winning candidate to secure a set after he loses the election.

        • 3
          1

          Except a few Sinhalese, the rest are not in favour of sharing territory and power with Tamils in a fair manner. So provincial councils are out. It is due to international pressure that they are talking about devolution. Sinhalese went to court to get local government elections held and got favourable verdict. At no time they will go to court to get provincial council elections held. This clearly shows their mindset. At present provincial council elections cannot be held without withdrawing the earlier passed act which says that provincial council elections will be held in a hybrid scheme of first past the post and proportional representation. Sumanthiran supported this cunning act brought by Ranil. It is over eight years since it was passed and there had been no effort to devise the hybrid system. So Sajith saying that he will implement 13A fully without rescinding the above act is just hoodwinking Tamils. There is no Sinhala leader from major party who will go against the view of Sinhalese to grant justice to Tamils.

      • 1
        0

        old codger

        “Sumanthiran is going to be very disappointed.”

        In the last presidential elections Federal Party supported Mummy’s Boy Sajith though he promised to build 1146 Vihares in the North East. In 2010 Presidential elections Sampandan and fellow Tamil Party leaders supported public racist Fonseka. In 2005 entire North restrained from voting in the presidential elections, helped Mahinda and his clan to take over the entire country, thanks to nimal fernando’s chum Velupilla Prabaharan who was paid Rs 165 million.

        It won’t be a disappointment but it would be continuation of business as usual.

        It won’t be surprise if Tamil Polity is further divided like the Southern Polity.

        • 1
          0

          Native Vedda,
          … divided like divided like the Southern Polity
          Division among the Southern Polity is tactical; Division among the Northern Polity is suicidal.

          • 3
            1

            N
            The Tamil polity was born prone to division as much as an amoeba.

    • 7
      2

      “probably from an old rally, gives a misleading impression that Sumanthiran supports the NPP.”

      The photo may be old but the fact is that the support of Sumanthiran to Sajith is not really giving support to Sajith. Sumanthiran well aware that his support or Tamils support will definitely have a negative impact on Sajith votes in the South and now there is a possibility it will increase the votes of Sinhalese to Ranil instead of Sajith. Ranil and Sumanthiran are Royal college products.
      Another fact is Sumanthiran now divided Federal Party and he knew well Tamil People are not with Sumanthiran’s Federal Party. Federal party is now killed. Within the Sinhalese Ranil is considered as a fox and within Tamils it applies to Sumanthiran. Both are lawyers and product of Royal College.

      • 2
        0

        Ajith,
        “Within the Sinhalese Ranil is considered as a fox and within Tamils it applies to Sumanthiran. Both are lawyers and product of Royal College.”
        Could you substantiate that Abraham Sumanthiran, was a Royalist, or attended Royal College???
        My understanding He isn’t!!??

        • 1
          0

          Dear Mahila Mahathmaya (not Mahaththaya),
          Mahaththaya is a sinhla term being abused by JVPrs in PUBLIC to heroworship Mahendra Rajapakshe because they feel they re born inferior to others.
          .
          Don’t you think that everything is planted by the media to take revenge on the other?
          The mainstream media is grossly infringing on freedom of the press. Did you watch “Battle/SATANA” yesterday evening?
          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_EEwD3jA9E
          Suranga (a highly biased journo produced by the media whore house) did not allow some of the panelists to come to their thoughts and express them on the occasion. Sirasa TV has been doing it for some time now. They planted that Ranil should be the main person to blame for the “so-called bond scam” according to the former president introduced by Mara and Ajit Cabral. So who is telling the truth? Why on earth is the media taking sides? consequence was marginalization of UNP. Remember ?
          .
          Like Goebbels theories (Hitlar S Germany), if you keep hearing any lie or exaggeration, it becomes public opinion.
          Now all the facts have been elaborated, but as people are made to believe, it was not the JVP but the UNP government that killed our brothers in the late 80’s to early 90’s.
          .

      • 2
        0

        A
        Try to be factual.
        The entire central committee that attended the meeting with an exception or two resolved to support Sajith.
        Further objections came from one who travelled abroad and another who chose to stay in Colombo. (The two are not agreed on a common stand.)
        *
        Decisions seem to be taken in Delhi I suspect.

    • 4
      1

      But Mavai S has protested as he has not been informed.
      The FP seems to be disintegrating faster than I feared after the demise of Sampanthan.

      • 3
        2

        When the twin towers fell on 9/11 Osama laughed, and said we never expected this to happen. We just looked for some fire and a few deaths.

        “The FP seems to be disintegrating faster than I feared after the demise of Sampanthan.”
        The coconuts you broke and the camphor you burned did not get wasted!

        But my confusion is for which you spent your money:
        1). An Easy, early end for Sampanthar Aiya
        2). An Easy, early end for the Federal Party.

        Could you bring here one line of your writing of a good wish for the Federal Party or Sampanthar Aiya, ever in your life?
        “Airthathin Midukello Naavithan Pon Kaedathu!” Isn’t it the arrogance of the stars of the birth time that made the barber demand for gold bars.) It is the stupidity of the readers here for you to come write stories like that, isn’t it?

        • 2
          3

          Giggle giggle giggle!

      • 1
        1

        “The FP seems to be disintegrating faster than I feared after the demise of Sampanthan.”

        REJOICE, REJOICE, REJOICE!!

        • 2
          0

          Native,
          If he wrote “faster than I thought” instead of “faster than I feared”, you could assume SJ is rejoicing. 😉😉

          • 1
            1

            oc
            Not everybody is linguistically skilled.

      • 2
        0

        SJ,

        I am hearing from people on the ground in Jaffna that MS’s son supports SP. So I am not sure how sincere MS is in saying it was only Sumanthiran’s decision.

        • 0
          0

          A
          Thanks
          But I only reported news.
          What games they play is often beyond me.

    • 1
      3

      Agnos,
      My observation leads to:
      It is at Ranil’s behest!
      To make the borderline Sinhalese supporters of Sajith to turn to Ranil.

      • 2
        0

        Nathan,

        Possible. I don’t know about all the intrigues going on in Colombo. See my reply to SJ about Mavai.

        Anyway, unlike in previous elections, Tamil votes are probably going to be more widely split.

        Most of my Peradeniya classmates are for AKD. But looking at the Tamil society in SL, without a unifying and charismatic leader, and with the economic struggles they have to go through, they can’t make up their minds. It may come down to last minute decisions.

    • 0
      1

      Agnos,
      My observation leads to:
      It is at Ranil’s behest!
      To make the borderline Sinhalese supporters of Sajith to turn to Ranil.

  • 4
    0

    The author says “A quintessential liberal who stated in the early part of the twentieth century that a Federal System is the most appropriate solution for the Tamil question, had to abolish his own Bandaranaike-Chelvanayakam Pact (BC Pact) under the pressure of Maha Sanga and a determined band of Sinhalese nationalists“. This is true. But he forgets that Chelva was also facing immpense opposition to the BC fact from his own ranks in Jaffna. Navaratnam had already written a book about the “absolute irreconcilability” of Tamils and Sinhalese and the need for absolute separation. There were shops closed and black flags in Jaffna protesting against the BC pact. Chelva told those die hards that the BC pact was only one step, and separatism will come later. That didn’t build any confidence in the south. Senator Thiruchelvam was one who disagreed with using the BC pact as a step towards separation. As for Banda’s early call for federalism, it was partly to accomodate the Up-Country sinhalese who regarded themselves as being a different community from the low-country Sinhalese. That was also a time when Sundaralingam. Perimpanayagam, and many Northern Tamil intellectuals worked closely with the sinhalese (prior to the Jaffna boycott of the Donoughmore recommendations, demanding fully “swaraj”). By 1948 the up-country low-country Sinhla distinctions had died down, and Banda (low country) had married an upcountry Sirimawo.

    • 2
      1

      “By 1948 the up-country low-country Sinhla distinctions had died down”
      Not that fast.
      It was not simply UC–LC.
      The caste factor was strong.
      The LC were less dominated by the G caste.

      • 2
        1

        By 1948, DSS had ensured that the UC Sinhalese were over represented by disenfranchising the HCT.

  • 7
    4

    Very interesting this is what we Tamils feel. This video is by a north Indian

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GqbLovThG0I

  • 9
    2

    “Widowed mothers are demonstrating in the North, waiting for the return of their sons and daughter who were taken by the Sri Lankan military forces at the time of war.”

    Just to make it clear that the sons and daughters who were taken not only at the time war but at the refugee camps in the Vanni after the end of war.

  • 3
    1

    Sumanthiran wants the best of both worlds…………..
    Sumanthiran wants the cake as well as eat it too………
    Sumanthiran has one foot in the Federal Party and another in a major political Party hoping to form a government……………
    But the main thing is for him to survive at all costs.
    But Twilight awaits him at the next Parliamentary election.
    But still he is hopeful to fill a slot in the National List of any major political party…………
    Hope springs eternal in the human breast eh!?
    As for the Federal Party it has come one full circle.
    A purge is the only way out…………..to start afresh…….

    • 0
      1

      Plato, to start afresh is the only way out, but can you please do something active about it for the benefit of those who cannot formulate what actions to take. Many need instructions.

      • 1
        1

        “Many need instructions.”
        From AMG upstairs?

  • 1
    1

    “One is never afraid of the unknown; one is afraid of the known coming to an end.”
    But there is nothing to fear in the present known coming to an end.

    • 0
      1

      SJ, if the known coming to an end will bring in something better but still unknown, what is the need to be fearful. For those who do not know the difference between A and Z, they need very clear instructions on how to assess and know what is good.

      • 1
        0

        No instruction will help ones “who do not know the difference between A and Z”.
        And do the ones who want to instruct know the difference?

      • 1
        0

        Hello DTG,
        It sounds like something Donald Rumsfeld would have said about “Unknown unknowns”
        Best regards

      • 1
        1

        davidthegood

        “if the known coming to an end will bring in something better but still unknown,….”

        There are known knowns. These are things we know that we know. There are known unknowns. That is to say, there are things that we know we don’t know. But there are also unknown unknowns. There are things we don’t know we don’t know. Donald Rumsfeld
        Read more at https://www.brainyquote.com/authors/donald-rumsfeld-quotes

        Any chance you follow Donald Rumsfeld’s logic?

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.