18 December, 2017

Blog

The TNA Has To Tread With Caution And So Should The Central Government

By R.M.B Senanayake

R.M.B. Senanayake

The Government must recognize that the 13th amendment has come to say. It must realize that there are States where devolution of power has not led to separate states but instead provided a modus Vivendi for a minority to live in peace with a majority giving up the claim to be a separate state.

The people at large do not understand what is involved in the nature of the State and have not learn’t political science. The problems of majority -minority are projected to the people by the politicians and the political leadership. The political leadership wants to exercise a monopoly of political power for themselves and this they do by ensuring that all elected representatives belong to the ruling political party. So in the past the ruling political parties sought to govern the Tamils through co-opting Tamils who were willing to join them for perks like Ministerial posts. But the recent Provincial Election shows that that era is over as at least as far as the North is concerned. So the Government must change its mindset and realize that the way to win the hearts and minds of the people of the North is to resolve their problems particularly the problems of the IDPs which they are legally obliged to do under International Law.. Freedom is what all people desire and it would seem that the civilian population resents the presence of the Army. Surely the Army could like any Secret Service monitor the behavior of suspect individuals un-obtrusively.

The ruling party politicians are averse to devolution of power because it dilutes their power. They oppose devolution of power to the people. The most they are willing to concede devolution of power is to the MPs in the electorates who have been exercising power without responsibility and that too only for members of their own party.

In the 1970s the Leftists who were part of the United Front Coalition set up Janatha Committees often headed by militant trade unionists who were opposed to the bureaucracy. They thought their role was to spy on the officials. The bureaucrats found them difficult to control and in the State Corporations and the districts they created administrative chaos. To counter these so-called peoples representatives Sirimavo appointed District Political Authorities. But there were several electorates and thus several MPs in the district. Soon there were conflicts between those MPs belonging to the same ruling political party in the District.. The obvious answer was to appoint an MP to be in charge of each electorate. But this would mean a large number of Ministers and the Government of Sirimavo was too conscious of its public duty to engage in such an irresponsible exercise. These District Political Authorities also clashed with the Government Agents and District level local Heads of Departments. There are retired Government Agents who served during this period who will testify to the conflict. Anyway these District Political Authorities died a natural death.

The role of an elected Member of Parliament is in Parliament. He is a legislator, not a Member of the Executive branch of the government. Should they be members of the Executive branch? They were not elected to do so. Their interference in the functioning of the bureaucracy was bad enough for it led to complete politicization of the Administration at the local level in the same way as the Ministers in Colombo who decide everything today despite their lack of knowledge, experience and expertise. Since the bureaucrats have been reduced to the status of being their obedient servants they have taken a backseat in the administration. The result is the administrative muddling through we see today. Sirimavo was once toying with the idea of making the District Political Authority a District Minister.

This idea of appointing District Ministers seems to be in the air once again. Bu it will lead to conflict between such District Ministers and the Chief Ministers of the Provincial Councils. Power should be devolved to the people and hence to their representatives elected specifically for the purpose. Giving power to a District Minister will undermine the functioning of the Provincial Councils. Power should be devolved from the Central Government to the Provincial Councils and this cannot be achieved by appointing as Head of the Central Government in the Districts from the National Parliament. The ruling party would no doubt like to win the support of the Tamil people but it cannot be done by putting forward a person who is not acceptable to the people. Any ruling political party including the TNA will no doubt become unpopular at least with a section of the voters with the lapse of time and it is these aggrieved voters that the governing party should woo over time.

It is correct that the centralized services provided by departments of the Central Government may have too much control. But that is why such services should as far as possible be brought under the Provincial Council. One of our historic errors is to assume that government at the grassroots level can be made responsive to the will of people by appointing elected MPs to the local Executive. Burt they do not guarantee that the process of government from the Center will be either sensitive to the people or efficient.

There is also a case for integrating the field services of central government departments in the district or provincial level. Since the Kachcheri is the outfit of the central government this can be achieved only by constant contact and co-operation between the Head of the Central Government’s District administration – the Government Agent and the Provincial Council. This is a lesson that the Northern Provincial Council will have to follow and this task will become harder with a political Head of the Kachcheri.

What is required is to build close co-operation between the central Government and the Provincial Council. If a Provincial Council messes up the people will hold them responsible for their ills and not the Central Government where it is easy to ascribe motives on ethnic grounds.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 0
    0

    RMB says-
    “The people at large do not understand what is involved in the nature of the State and have not learn’t political science.”
    What a discovery.Only he understands these profound theories?.
    May be not. But they understand what is good for the country and for themselves.

  • 0
    0

    The question is whether the Head of government and State is genuinely interested in devolving power to the periphery towards greater self government or in centralising power in themselves. There have been the paradigms of political authorities, district ministers which have been a disaster. Further, should the provincial councils be glorified local councils with no meaningful political power devolved on the people. Bensen

  • 0
    0

    I completely agree with the writer Mr.Senanyake.
    The head of the state and the legislators must understand the feelings of the people and devolve powers to the people in the provincial councils, not only in the North but in all nine provinces. There should not be any kind of discrimination between provinces. To achieve that, the elected members of Parliament should be partriotic. Greediness,corruption and power in the country has to be got rid of from the Top.
    As far as North is concerned,there can be small army stationed in the there but not in hundreds of thousands engulfing most of the Northern areas. At present in Vali-North, almost nine villages have been under army control with 75,000 personnels.So there cannot be reconcilliation and peace in the North. Everyone has to forget about the past and rebuild Sri Lanka.

  • 0
    0

    R M B:

    I agree with some of your observations and disagree with some for the reasons I have given below.

    1)The TNA Has To Tread With Caution:

    I think Caution is too harsh a word as what we are seeking is Just and Fair and I can understand the reason your choice of Word.
    I dont think we have to tread with caution and we have the support of the nations that matter.

    2)And So Should The Central Government:

    I dont think MR and his cronies understand the language which is alien to them. The only think he understands is FORCE and that has alraedy been applied by India and others and the medicine is working.
    I am sure you would have noticed that all the Hawks ( Gotha, Wimal Wansa, Rambukawella) have been silenced.

    3)The Government must recognize that the 13th amendment has come to say.
    *** I would go on further and say that we have to build on the 13th Amendment if we are to maintain the Unity of Sr Lanka as one Nation.

    I am hopeful BJP will come to power and the Tamil fortune will take a Quantum Leap. If the majority want to avoid division of the country they have to fly now.

    4)The people at large do not understand what is involved in the nature of the State and have not learn’t political science. The problems of majority -minority are projected to the people by the politicians and the political leadership.

    *** The reason why the above is happening is because there is a receptive Audience make no mistake.

    5) a)The political leadership wants to exercise a monopoly of political power for themselves and this they do by ensuring that all elected representatives belong to the ruling political party.

    ***I agree with the above to the extent that MR wants to consoldate power for a variety of reasons.
    1) That is his natiure 2) He has ( or shoud I say had)a programme of Ethnic Cleansing so wants to stay in power to complete the task but he has been stopped.
    b)So in the past the ruling political parties sought to govern the Tamils through co-opting Tamils who were willing to join them for perks like Ministerial posts. But the recent Provincial Election shows that that era is over as at least as far as the North is concerned.

    *** The Tamils never had a say in the runnig of the Country except when Chelvanayagam had a Pact. But you are way off the target when you say the Provincial Elections have brought that era to an end. North does not matter to MR to stay in power as his power base in the South is enough.

    c)So the Government must change its mindset and realize that the way to win the hearts and minds of the people of the North is to resolve their problems particularly the problems of the IDPs which they are legally obliged to do under International Law. Freedom is what all people desire and it would seem that the civilian population resents the presence of the Army. Surely the Army could like any Secret Service monitor the behavior of suspect individuals un-obtrusively.

    *** MR does not care about Tamils so he is not going to go out of his way to achieve it because he is a BORN RACIST.

    6)The ruling party politicians are averse to devolution of power because it dilutes their power. They oppose devolution of power to the people ( Meaning Tamils).

    7)The most they are willing to concede devolution of power is to the MPs in the electorates who have been exercising power without responsibility and that too only for members of their own party.

    *** You are wrong on the above as MPs represent a Constituency as individuals and not collectively like Provicial Councils or Assemblies.

    You are answering the very question below:

    The role of an elected Member of Parliament is in Parliament( I would add not in Provicial Councils) . He is a legislator, not a Member of the Executive branch of the government.

    8)Their interference in the functioning of the bureaucracy was bad enough for it led to complete politicization of the Administration at the local level in the same way as the Ministers in Colombo who decide everything today despite their lack of knowledge, experience and expertise.

    Since the bureaucrats have been reduced to the status of being their obedient servants they have taken a backseat in the administration.

    *** The above is Sri Lankan politics and not western Style Politics.

    9)The ruling party would no doubt like to win the support of the Tamil people but it cannot be done by putting forward a person who is not acceptable to the people. Any ruling political party including the TNA will no doubt become unpopular at least with a section of the voters with the lapse of time and it is these aggrieved voters that the governing party should woo over time.

    *** The above is wishful thinking and whether we like it or not TNA manifesto was LTTE manifesto and this was proved when Ananthi secured the secomnd highest number of votes and LTTE blood runs through her body

    We cannot survive as a Nation until and unless we accept that North is different from the South and we are two distinct people and the Tamils cannot live as subjects under Sinhalse Rule.

    • 0
      0

      A good example of Forum comments and illuminating. Thanks.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 300 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically shut off on articles after 10 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.