16 May, 2022

Blog

Trinco District Court Facing Tough Days As Judge Is Not Promoted

By Mohammed Jameel –

It is not long since Mr. M. Ganesharajah assumed duties as District Judge of Trinco. He did not come with a high reputation especially after his attempt wrongfully to punish the Uthayan Editor for Contempt. He was then Magistrate, Jaffna. In that instance, as may be seen from the link provided, the judge tried to bully the Editor into apologizing to him under pain of a contempt charge, and finally the Appeal Court ruled that the petitioner is entitled to the relief he had sought. A writ of certiorari was issued, quashing the Magistrate Ganesharajah’s order to try the editor for contempt. His case was so weak that according to Colombo Telegraph, he sent the Attorney General to court and failed to show up on the last day.

There was also concern over his coming to Trincomalee owing to many women having complained against him in his previous postings in Batticaloa, Mannar and other places where he had been. But not many were too bothered since the judge was high up on the seniority list and, as they expected, would stop blighting the Trincomalee courts soon with a promotion.

There is also one Mr. C. Sugathadasage, an Anuradhapura lawyer practising in Trincomalee. I have rarely seen him mingling with other lawyers in the conference rooms. Every morning he is seen standing at the court entrance as if looking for clients. In recent weeks one George Rajan who was present in court testifies that he saw the judge joining Mr. Sugathadasage in laughing at opposing counsel. Mr. Rajan who is involved in a case before the judge says that he heard Mr. Sugathadasage in open court call Mr. R. Thirukumaranathan, a very senior opposing counsel, Pissu (mad fellow), and as he left the courtroom say for the public gathered at the doorway to hear that Mr. Thirukumaranathan “barks like a dog.” And the usually strict Ganesharajah seems not to notice such breach of professional courtesy, and does not reprimand Mr. Sugathadasage in the least, giving him a long leash that he does not afford others.

A lawyer was of the view that Mr. Sugathadasage is there to inform the government of important cases and that when he appears for a client, the judge’s judgements are skewed because of the influence Mr. Sugathadasage wields with the government. Others cite the case of a young woman lawyer for whom Judge Ganesharajah gave a favourable judgement against Mr. Sugathadasage’s client in open court, and then in his chambers without informing the female lawyer, crossed out his judgement and wrote the opposite. The poor woman is scared to press charges. Was there a transactional cost is what I wonder?

Then last week on 3 March, the President appointed 13 High Court Judges, all Sinhalese, as is his style now. And naturally Ganesharajah is not on the list! Ganesharajah has been on leave since then. Mr. Sugathadasage has also not been seen in court since news of Ganesharajah’s nonappointment was announced. I believe they are in Colombo trying to get Ganesharajah his promotion.

Ganesharajah has not written up his recent judgements. When asked by lawyers for the judgements, the Registrar says they are not available to him because he has no access to the dossiers which are locked up in Ganesharajah’s chambers. People who had adverse rulings early last week have not been able to read what he wrote to see if there are grounds for appeal. A client against whom Mr. Sugathadasage appeared believes it was deliberate to preclude an appeal. Even if Ganesharajah returns to court on Tuesday 8 March, will he have time to write up his neglected judgements? Even if he manages to release them to the concerned parties on 8 March, many of them would have no time to consult attorneys to appeal within the 2 week-window they have to appeal.

A person on the Registrar’s staff was fearful: “When we are unable to give lawyers copies of judgements to file appeals, it is we who will be blamed.”

It is an ironic coincidence, points out a senior Trincomalee attorney, that it was only on 4 March 2022 that Victor Ivan wrote: “Does the judiciary possess the capacity to direct the country towards adopting corrective measures and preventing it from plunging into anarchy when the functioning of the legislature and the executive are already in jeopardy?” The attorney concludes that we badly need the Judicial Service Commission to supervise our judges.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 12
    7

    This kind of article–is it fair ?
    What have these various individuals got to say about these allegations against them ?
    How sure is the writer of these facts or are they just his opinion?

    • 1
      0

      DS
      Fully agree.

  • 11
    3

    I commend the Author for highlighting these obvious misdemeanors of the judiciary. But how come the Author is not charged for contempt while Ranjan R who said the same thing in different words is inside for 3 years. That is Justice in SL – may be it is blind – not in the sense that it was originally said and meant.

    • 4
      3

      ” But how come the Author is not charged for contempt “

      This is Sinhala Bauda Lanka’ . Its royally fu cked. That’s how they roll.

    • 2
      0

      No contempt charges till the Geneva Conference is over, please.

  • 4
    0

    It is the practice of the Attorney General’s department to appear on behalf of Government officials and Gov. Corporation officials who are charged by the public against their misdeeds. Unfortunately, it appears that the AG fails to analyze the mistakes made by the officers concerned and proceeds to defend them. The AG is expected to filter the charges before defending them. It is seldom done, resulting in impunity by the accused. They are free to continue their misdeeds as they do not spend any money for defense. Hence the AG should take care before deciding to come to their assistance.

  • 0
    1

    Two sides of the same coin!!

  • 4
    0

    I am from the Eastern Province and am familiar with Trincomalee. Judge Ganesharajah is a very vindictive man — hence the paucity of interventions here when terrible things are going on in Trincomalee. Just see the way he forced the Uthayan Editor to tender an apology in open court, turning towards the public, and threatening a contempt of court charge if he did not do as ordered. Fortunately the Court of Appeal put a stop to his judicial thuggery.
    I am familiar with a lawyer called Chandrasiri. I believe he is the same as Mr. C. Sugathadasage. Chandrasiri appeared for a client who wanted a person evicted. Ganesharajah did the needful in an ex parte hearing. A young man in the leased residence went to work. On his return he found Ganesharajah’s order that he should not enter his home. That 2 week order was renewed for another two weeks a la Chandrasiri’s request to his friend Ganesharajah.
    That young man, a friend of mine, now has only the clothes he went to work in and is locked away from all his study material. He is now using borrowed clothes. That is Ganesharajah’s justice.
    The Judicial Service Commission should send him away to spare the people of Trincomalee.

    • 1
      0

      Someone commented on Contempt here. It is so unfair when under our contempt laws corrupt judges can do anything and we cannot comment. Ali Sabry must take note as he revises our laws.

  • 3
    3

    “A lawyer was of the view that Mr. Sugathadasage is there to inform the government of important cases and that when he appears for a client, the judge’s judgements are skewed because of the influence Mr. Sugathadasage wields with the government. “
    This and several other accusations are too serious for ‘trial by media’, but narrated in such off-hand fashion.
    Some of the charges made could haul up the writer before court for you guess what.

  • 1
    0

    It appears that Government Policy is to turn the other side when incidents of the nature as per this essay takes place in the North and East of the country.This is applicable in the Law and order situation,corruption in the Public Service etc etc.
    We should not forget that Sarath.N.Silva, Mohan Pieris and types like them adorned the Supreme Court Bench just the other day. They were also heading the Judicial Services Commission.
    This is why people in this country have contempt FOR COURT………………….

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.