22 November, 2026

Blog

“We The People”, But Not In Sri Lanka

By Firdous MHM –

Firdous MHM

This four-part series sets out to prove one claim: Sri Lanka’s Constitution speaks the language of liberty but keeps the final say with those who govern. Placing it beside the United States Constitution, the series will show that the difference between the two lies not in the freedoms their preambles promise, which are much the same, but in whether a citizen can rely on those freedoms in court to defeat a law that violates them. Across four parts, it will demonstrate that the Sri Lankan People never truly authored their constitution, that freedom entered it as borrowed vocabulary rather than as the outcome of a popular struggle, and that its operative provisions systematically prevent rights from being enforced against Parliament. The conclusion it builds towards is that liberty in Sri Lanka is proclaimed but not secured: it exists, in the end, at the discretion of those in power, much as it did under pre-colonial kings and colonial governors.

Both the United States and Sri Lanka open their constitutions with a promise of freedom. The real difference is not in those promises but in whether a citizen can go to court and have a law struck down for breaking them. In the United States, a citizen can. In Sri Lanka, for the most part, a citizen cannot.

The American Constitution claims to be made by the People. Sri Lanka’s 1978 Constitution claims to be made by the People’s Representatives. That small difference in wording reflects a large difference in how each constitution was actually made.

Promises that need teeth

The American Preamble resolves to “secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity.” The Sri Lankan preamble assures “to all peoples FREEDOM, EQUALITY, JUSTICE, FUNDAMENTAL HUMAN RIGHTS and the INDEPENDENCE OF THE JUDICIARY” as an “intangible heritage.”

Neither preamble is enforceable by itself. The US Supreme Court has said its Preamble states the Constitution’s purposes but grants no power. So whatever freedom a preamble promises must be delivered, or taken away, by the rules that follow it.

What freedom means here

In this series, “freedom” means more than being left alone today. It means being safe from interference because no one has the power to interfere with you whenever they like.

A simple example shows the difference. Imagine two tenants. The first has a landlord who never bothers her, but who could evict her at any moment, for any reason, with no court she can turn to. The second has a written lease that a court will enforce if the landlord breaks it. Both may live peacefully for years. But only the second tenant is truly secure, because her safety does not depend on her landlord’s mood. The first lives at her landlord’s mercy.

Political theorists call this idea freedom as non-domination. You are free when no one holds unchecked power over you, not merely when that power happens to go unused.

The same is true of citizens and their government. A citizen whose rights last only as long as those in power choose to respect them is in the position of the first tenant. Freedom is secure only when two things are true: the people themselves have made the constitution, and they can go to court to enforce its guarantees against every part of government, including Parliament. When either is missing, freedom depends on the goodwill of whoever is in charge.

The opposite of this freedom is domination: living under a power you cannot check or challenge. The argument of this series is that Sri Lanka’s Constitution uses the language of liberty while leaving its citizens in the position of the first tenant.

Why would a constitution be built this way? The sociologist Max Weber offers a clue. He described an older form of government he called patrimonial rule, in which power belongs to the ruler personally, much like a family estate. Land, jobs and protection are favours the ruler hands out in return for loyalty and service, and he can take them back at will. People receive these favours; they do not hold rights they can enforce against him. As Part 2 shows, this pattern has deep roots in Sri Lanka, where in the Kandyan kingdom land was held in return for service to the king.

Scholars use the term neo-patrimonialism for the same pattern surviving inside a modern state. There are elections, courts and a written constitution, but power still works as a favour granted from the top rather than a right owed to the citizen. Political scientist Giovanni Sartori had a name for a constitution of this kind: a “façade” constitution. From the outside it looks like a guarantee of rights; behind the front, the guarantees are missing.

Three ways a constitution can take freedom away

A constitution can promise freedom in one place and take it back in another. It usually does this in one of three ways:

Leaving people out. Some people are simply not protected. For example, the original US Constitution gave no protection to enslaved people.

Letting the government limit rights. The constitution gives a right, then allows the government to cut it back, for example, “in the interests of national security.”

Stopping the courts from helping. The right exists on paper, but the courts are not allowed to enforce it against certain government actions, such as a law passed by Parliament.

So the key question for this series is simple: if a law takes away your rights, can you go to court and have that law struck down?

With that test in mind, we can turn to the first question: who actually made each constitution? A constitution that the people write for themselves is very different from one written for them by those who govern. The next two sections compare how each country answered that question. We begin in Philadelphia in 1787, where the American Constitution was drafted and then put to the people for approval, and then move to Colombo, where Sri Lanka’s 1972 and 1978 Constitutions were made.

Philadelphia: a People who argued back

In the American text, “We the People” is the subject that does “ordain and establish” the Constitution. This was a deliberate choice. An early draft listed the people of each state by name. In September 1787, Gouverneur Morris, drafting for the Committee of Style, replaced the list with “the People of the United States.”

The claim was backed by process. The Constitution came out of a revolution fought on the idea that government rests on the consent of the governed. It took effect only after special conventions in each state voted to ratify it. It was argued over in newspapers, pamphlets and public meetings. Patrick Henry even challenged the opening words, asking who had authorised the delegates to say “We, the People” instead of “We, the States.”

Crucially, the People did not just accept what they were given. The lack of a bill of rights became the main objection. Massachusetts ratified only on the understanding that amendments would follow. James Madison introduced them in 1789, and ten were ratified in 1791. The American “People” of 1787 was narrow, it excluded enslaved people, women and most people without property, but those who were included demanded and won changes.

Colombo: an election turned into a mandate

In the Sri Lankan preamble, the People appear only in a side clause. They are said to have “entrusted to and empowered their Representatives” at the general election of 21 July 1977 to “draft, adopt and operate” a new constitution. The main clause belongs to the Representatives: “We, the Freely Elected Representatives of the People of Sri Lanka … do hereby adopt and enact this Constitution.” The People give a mandate; the Representatives make the constitution.

This pattern began in 1972. Sri Lanka’s first republican constitution was meant to break cleanly from the British-made Soulbury Constitution, and its leaders argued that only a Constituent Assembly drawing authority directly from the People could do that. But the 1970–72 Constituent Assembly was simply the sitting members of Parliament. No separate election was held. The 1972 Constitution declared the People sovereign while in practice handing sovereignty to whichever party controlled Parliament.

That “clean break” also removed the main protection for minorities. Section 29(2) of the Soulbury Constitution had barred laws that discriminated against any community or religion. The 1972 Constitution dropped it, while entrenching Sinhala as the only official language and giving Buddhism the foremost place. Appeals to the Privy Council, the one outside court that had enforced those limits, had already been abolished in 1971.

Its makers presented this break as autochthonous, a word meaning “springing from the land itself.” An autochthonous constitution draws its authority from the people of the country, not from a foreign power. That is how the 1972 Constitution was offered to the public: for the first time, Sri Lanka’s highest law would rest on the will of its own people rather than on an order of the British Crown.

That was true of the process, at least on its face. It was not true of the substance. Look at where power actually ended up. Before the British, authority flowed downward from the Kandyan king, and land and status were held in return for service to him. Under the British, it flowed downward from the Crown and its governor, who answered to no one among the governed. The 1972 Constitution did not end that pattern; it only changed who sat at the top. Power now flowed downward from whichever party held a majority in Parliament. The minority protections that had limited that power were removed, and the courts were barred from questioning a law once Parliament had passed it.

In other words, the break was home-grown in form but a return to the old order in content. The foreign ruler was gone, but the idea of a ruler whose authority the ruled cannot check was kept, and, as the rest of this series shows, the 1978 Constitution strengthened it further.

The 1978 Constitution went further. Its preamble no longer even claims that “We the People” enacted it.

Why a general election is not a constitution-making moment

The 1977 election was an ordinary contest to decide who would govern. The United National Party’s manifesto did ask for a mandate to make a new constitution, and the preamble borrows its words. But voters cast one ballot on a party’s whole programme, candidates were chosen for vote-winning appeal rather than constitutional expertise, and no separate constituent assembly was elected.

The purpose matters as well as the procedure. A general election picks a government; first-past-the-post was designed to turn a plurality of votes into a working majority. A constitution sets the rules for everyone, so its legitimacy depends on including everyone, minorities and losing parties as much as winners. Modern standards also expect public participation and transparency.

The 1977 result shows the gap. The UNP won about 51 per cent of the vote but some 140 of 168 seats, about five-sixths. The Sri Lanka Freedom Party won almost 30 per cent of the vote but fewer than ten seats. A government elected by roughly half the country became the body that wrote the constitution for all of it.

How the 1978 Constitution was actually made

The new constitution was produced in three stages, and the governing party controlled every one of them.

The first stage was the creation of the executive presidency, the most powerful office in the new system. It was introduced in September 1977, before any new constitution had been drafted, by amending the existing 1972 Constitution. The government sent the amendment through Parliament as an “urgent” Bill. That special procedure meant it could be passed quickly, without the usual time for the public to read it and respond. It was not even published in the official Gazette before it became law. The opposition walked out of a debate that lasted only about three hours.

The second stage was the appointment of a committee to review the constitution. In November 1977, Parliament set up a ten-member Select Committee: seven members from the governing United National Party, two from the Sri Lanka Freedom Party, and one from the Ceylon Workers’ Congress. The Tamil United Liberation Front, the main opposition party, refused to take part. Ordinary citizens had only one way to have their say: a 21-question questionnaire printed in the newspapers, with about two weeks to reply. Only 281 written replies were received.

The third stage turned a review into a replacement. The committee had been appointed to revise the 1972 Constitution, not to write a new one. It wrote a new one anyway. The two Sri Lanka Freedom Party members objected that this went beyond what the committee had been asked to do, and they withdrew. The full draft was never published in any national newspaper, so most citizens never saw it. Parliament passed the new Constitution on 31 August 1978 using the governing party’s majority, without asking the people to approve it in a referendum. It came into force on 7 September 1978.

The verdict on Part 1

Part 1 asked a simple question: who made each constitution? The answer is different for each country.

In the United States, the people made their constitution. Delegates wrote a draft, but it became law only after the people, through special conventions in each state, debated it and voted to accept it. Along the way they demanded changes, and they got them: the Bill of Rights. The “People” of 1787 was too narrow, leaving out enslaved people, women and the poor, but those who were included had a real say.

In Sri Lanka, the constitution was made for the people, not by them. It was written by a committee controlled by the governing party. The public’s only say was a newspaper questionnaire. The finished text was never put to a referendum. The preamble claims the people gave a mandate to make a new constitution, but all they had actually done was vote in an ordinary election to choose a government.

That is the first sign of the problem this series explores. A constitution the people write for themselves belongs to them. A constitution written for them by those in power belongs, in the end, to those in power. Part 2 asks why the two countries took such different roads.

Next: Part 2: Americans Fought For Freedom. Sri Lanka Inherited Its Rulers

Latest comments

  • 0
    0

    what a lovely analysis and a very useful/timely subject too. tq

  • 0
    0

    It is more meaningful to compare SL experience in a regional context rather than with Western nations. We have stronger collectivist characteristics than the more egalitarian social norms commonly found in the West. In that context, the central theme emerging from your article is equality and equity which is more common in secular societies. In a secular state, the government is expected to treat all citizens equally, regardless of their religion.
    Historically, SL rulers maintained a close relationship with the sangha in governance. Colonial administrations, however, put religion in the back seat, allowing secular characteristics to gradually develop during the colonial period. The very reason why educated people from minority races could secure jobs in the state sector. However, following the political shift of 1956, with Buddhist clergy’s influence, SL movement away from secular governance accelerated. It was further formalized when Buddhism was granted constitutional supremacy under the 1972 Constitution. The district quota system introduced along with, also played a role to disrupt the traditional job market which had equality characters.
    States that patronize religious authority face greater challenges in achieving equality for all citizens. In my view, this remains the fundamental issue that we continues to grapple with.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.

leave a comment