17 April, 2024


When A Doctor Speaks, He Speaks Loud & Straight

By W.A Wijewardena –

Dr. W.A Wijewardena

A doctor in the publishing business

Dr. Sarath Gamini De Silva, a reputed physician with long experience in the government as well as in post-retirement practice, has reappeared in the publishing business once again with his latest, ‘Essays on Random Topics: Common Sense of a Physician’, released a month ago. This is the fourth of his publications.

The present volume contains 30 middle length essays which he has written for over a decade, some of which have been previously published in newspapers or journals. The topics cover diverse subjects of current interest, namely, contemporary Sri Lankan society, its religion, culture, education, youth development, language issues, healthcare system, and politics.

The message he has delivered in them are loud and straight, free from bias, prejudice or affiliation to any sect. They convey his independent reading of topics nurtured and strengthened by observation and inference.

Old school discipline: Hard work is key to success

De Silva belongs to the old school that gives a high value to discipline. Discipline is a composite attribute representing several human qualities: commitment, dedication, humility, humbleness, and flexibility. Those who are disciplined in this manner do not see an easy way to attain success.

Dr. Sarath Gamini De Silva

Success comes, as the old guard in Singapore that elevated that country from the third world to the first world within a generation had believed, through hard work done by citizens at all levels, students at schools, undergraduates at universities and technical colleges, and workers at workplaces. This discipline, accompanied by openness and ability to appreciate social changes with equanimity, is evident in De Silva’s essays in this volume.

Medical practitioners should be versed in both science and art

In a speech at the prize-giving day of the Royal Institute in 2015, De Silva has articulated this vision as follows: “You may have heard your elders referring to the ‘good old days’. You may have heard them say how much better their livelihood was, with less stress, less competition at school entry or at exams, more time to relax or take part in sports, etc. Yet the truth is that most of us in the older generation today are envious of the fun present-day youngsters are having. There were times I myself felt ‘Oh how nice if I were born a few decades later’.”

He has not stopped there. While admitting that those in the medical profession are making an uphill battle to maintain the traditional values in medicine, De Silva has told the students that a medical practitioner should be versed in both science and art. Science will help them to make proper diagnoses. Art will help them to deliver permanent cures to patients.

He has also made a comment on new technologies there. Technology should be a blessing. But students should learn how they could acquire wisdom to understand what it offers. The role of education should be to prepare students to gain this capability. He has also coaxed students to learn English not to show their supremacy to others but to gather a better world outlook.

A good mentor in love with his protégé 

In an article he had penned to Colombo University’s Student Medical Journal in 2008, De Silva has confessed that he had been a hard taskmaster to students and doctors in his clinical unit at the hospital. This is how he has explained it in his own words: “The medical students and doctors in my unit know that I always discreetly point out any irregularities in the dress, posture, words used, the grammar, etc. Recently, I had to correct the way a postgraduate doctor was standing during the ward round and pointed out the fact that the tie did not match the multicoloured shirt. These I feel are matters many would have ignored. Yet I strongly feel that they are important in the making of a complete doctor. It is heartening to note that all my advice is taken in the correct spirit.”

This is in fact correct mentoring and it is the duty of the mentor to mould the protégé in the correct shape. But like a good mentor, his style of moulding those being mentored has been not to tell them about their weaknesses in front of others. Instead, he had done so at specially arranged one-on-one personal meetings.

A candid plea to fellow physicians

In 2003, De Silva was inducted as the President of the Ceylon College of Physicians. In his address at the induction, he pleaded the fellow physicians to make a self-discovery by looking at the mirror. Drawing the attention to the shortcomings of the medical profession, he has said that a problem is not a problem if it did not have a solution. Hence, the profession should find solutions to the existing problems.

Given that Sri Lanka’s resource base is scanty, he has said, “It is time that we started making the best use of the meagre resources available to us, while asking the authorities to provide us with whatever is possible. Let’s be brave enough to change what can be changed, humble enough to accept what cannot be changed, and most importantly, let’s be wise enough to see the difference.”

What this means is that instead of trying to solve all the problems under the sun, a list of priorities should be prepared, and the scarce resources should be used to resolve them. Such a move is in line with the best practices of public policy.

A physician should be of superhuman qualities

The gap in the knowledge between a physician and a patient has narrowed significantly today, De Silva has said in his oration. If a physician does something wrong, he is subject to penalties by courts of law. Hence, physicians cannot abandon the sacred principles and ethics which they should adhere to when treating patients. Despite the superior information available to the patient, he is helpless in the hands of the physician.

Now, De silva advises his fraternity as follows: “This is the reason why there is a tremendous obligation on the part of the doctor to see that he does the best for his patient. He is expected to do his best to arrive at a diagnosis and then prescribe the medicine that is most appropriate for him. This very fact that he is totally at the mercy of the doctor makes him demand that the doctor behaves almost in a superhuman way.

“In defence of our weaknesses, we argue that we are also human beings, that other segments of society are also corrupt, but people do not complain about them, and lawyers charge much higher fees but no one protests, etc. All these arguments become invalid as our function in society is at a much higher plane. Thus, we have to act superhuman and be a lotus blooming out of the muddy waters.”

Value of human touch in treating patients

De Silva has emphasised the value of the human touch in a physician’s relationship with a patient. Modern technology though it has helped physicians diagnose illnesses faster and more accurately, has created a distance between the two parties. He therefore has said that physicians should realise that medicine is science as well as art. His motto is that ‘science will cure the patient faster, but art will make him feel better’. Any curative treatment should be a combination of both these qualities.

Hence, according to De Silva, a physician should necessarily use his five senses and the trained brain rather than relying wholly on modern technology in treating patients. What he means is that physicians who are made up of flesh, blood, and a sensuous heart should activate the same when dealing with patients who are also made up of the same elements.

Shouting out against improprieties

Though De Silva is a physician, he had not been silent when he had seen improprieties in his profession or in society. In these cases, he had spoken loud and straight. One such case is his open letter to the President of the Government Medical Officers’ Association, better known as GMOA. It is a short letter, but it has conveyed in the strongest language what he had felt as an impropriety on the part of GMOA. This he had written as a senior physician, a medical teacher, an elected member of the Sri Lanka Medical Council or SLMC, and a former vice president and a long-standing committee member of GMOA.

Having seen with utmost consternation the GMOA resorting to flash strikes even for minor matters putting the public in grave risks and inconvenience, in this open letter De Silva had advised the incumbent President of GMOA that if a trade union has resorted to strike action, it was a sign of the weakness of the trade union. He had voiced this aloud in TV discussions and in public when he was an office bearer of GMOA.

GMOA using muscle power instead of brain power

De Silva’s main contention in this open letter has been the hard stand taken by GMOA against the private medical school, SAITM, and the use of strike action to attain its goal of seeing the closure of that medical school. Since those strikes had caused immense hardships to the public, he had said that those strikes were really a crime committed against society.

In the past, GMOA had used strike action for forcing authorities to resolve the salary issues of members or other issues which were of a more personal nature. GMOA had struck work on several occasions demanding good schools for the children of its members. De Silva had said that in those good old days such strike actions would have been an unthinkable affair. Instead of using strike action as the last resort, GMOA had been using it as the first resort. Thus, instead of using the brain power, GMOA had been using its muscle power to frighten authorities into submission by causing enormous hardships to patients.

Holding patients at ransom

The tradition of GMOA had been not to seek the support of trade unions in other sectors. But this cherished principle had been abandoned by GMOA leadership. Says De silva in this regard: “What happens now is totally unacceptable. GMOA officials publicly calling general strikes in a militant manner is a very bad trend. Doctors going on strike for general political issues like various trade agreements and the like is also totally unwarranted.”

De Silva has continued in his beratement: “For the first time in the history, a political party leader has been allowed to address the GMOA membership. As I already indicated to you personally, this should never have happened. The net result of all this is that in the public eye, GMOA has become equivalent to any other trouble making trade union in the public sector. The public has lost all respect for GMOA and the medical profession in general. It is inevitable that many suspect your actions to be a part of a large campaign to create political instability.”

De Silva had cautioned the incumbent President of GMOA that he had been projected in the country as a ruthless trade union leader ever ready to hold the sick to ransom to achieve his mostly unreasonable demands.

The evil of being in leadership for too long

If anyone had been in leadership for too long, it was inevitable that the joy of power would make him deviate from the main mission of the organisation which he was heading. This was true for all types of leaders, those in politics, business, or religion. The way to prevent it was to introduce governance principles which would encourage voluntary retirement after a given number of years. That had been the guiding principle of GMOA in the past. But with the incumbent President, it had been ignored.

Hence, De silva had politely suggested that the President in question should step down from presidency once his current term expires. This open letter had been written in 2017. The events since then have shown that De Silva’s good counsel as a senior physician had been totally disregarded.

This letter has been published in newspapers and media. It is not known how GMOA had responded to it.

The misconstrued high literacy rate in Sri Lanka

In an essay on high literacy of Sri Lankans, De Silva has argued that the literacy rate was not an index to gauge the general intelligence level of people. The disappointed De Silva says: “The way the educated people behave with lack of wisdom, common sense, or simple logic leaves much doubt about the quality of education we receive. This no doubt is the result of examination-oriented, book-based education that is being delivered over the years. Vast majority fails to analyse a simple problem or to overcome a minor deviation from the norm in their day-to-day life.”

But there is hypocrisy in some of the so-called intellectuals who do it purposely. According to De Silva, the actions of many politically aligned lawyers during the constitutional crisis of October 2018 were a case in point. They had explored all the loopholes in the law to justify the unconstitutional act of the then President. This was subsequently proved by the unanimous verdict of the Supreme Court on the issue.

Evil of medical professionals playing political games 

According to De Silva, medical professionals too have been to this political game as explained in the essay on ‘Science, Non-science and Nonsense’. This they have done so with no concern for the health and the wellbeing of the nation.

De Silva has documented several such instances from the recent past. One was the banning of the weed killer glyphosate on the ground that it was the cause of the chronic kidney disease of unknown origin rampant in the North Central Province in the country. Another is the issue of sterilisation of women without consent in Kurunegala propagated by monks and medical men with no expertise in women’s health. A third is the promotion of a scientifically unproven native medicine for the current COVID-19 pandemic.

A fourth is the endorsement of compulsory cremation of those died of COVID-19 with no regard for diverse religious practices. A fifth is the instance of doctors trained in allopathic medicine coming on public media and promoting various traditional medicines yet to be scientifically proven. Since this nonsense is uttered by qualified medical practitioners, the gullible people easily become victims. This happens when they breach the code of conduct which they should adhere to when performing their duties as professionals.

A book worth reading

The essays contained in De Silva’s current publication are a good read. They permit readers to have a peep into the sacred medical profession as well as contemporary political issues. They have been penned in lucid and flowing language so that the readers would not get bored halfway through reading them. I recommend this publication to all readers.

*The writer, a former Deputy Governor of the Central Bank of Sri Lanka, can be reached at waw1949@gmail.com

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 0

    I am tempted to write at length. I’ll try to be short.
    I lose patience with those who lecture that Medicine is Science!
    Medicine is not a science. It is an evolving science. Will continue to be so, for ever.
    A good doctor knows that medicines cure just half the problem; The other half has to be cared for by the doctor himself!
    Just an illustration.
    I was afflicted with continuous fever. Mild, yet strong enough to keep me bedridden in a Ward.
    After six weeks stay, I confronted my specialist. “What is that that is preventing you from getting me cured?”
    He said that I needed a psychiatrist and that he was not a psychiatrist!
    I couldn’t help asking him, “It took you six weeks to determine that!”

  • 1

    South Asian Institute of Technology and Medicine (SAITM) – When A Doctor Speaks, He Speaks Loud & Straight.

    Was it a good idea the doctors and students have been protesting for months, requesting the government to shut down the private, the only private university in Sri Lanka currently training medical students. The have been trained to
    A physician should be of superhuman qualities this the golden rule next other
    If theses student give an chance they would have been in front line and the doctors could have been monitoring
    Instead of giving capabilities for short coming of the university the injured cremated the university
    Using muscle power instead of brain power calling general strikes in a militant manner is a very bad trend.

  • 3

    Dear Mr Wijewardhana,
    Thanks for your article.
    Sadly, not many with titles seem to have self confidence yet to stand against the brutal actions of the incumbent rulers. How many more days, weeks they would wait. That has lot to do with sinhala race genetics ( I am also a sinhalaya).
    Dr Anil Jasinghe managed it to the top. There we had to agree with him, because he was not partial. So was the case with Dr Jayaruwan Bandara. But for some hidden reasons, the both were removed from Health ministerial affairs in that line. The theory worked on Ms Dilrukshi Wickramasinge (former FCID lokki) was applied on these both too. Media is worst …. and painted it in favour of incumbent leadership.
    Not just aforementioned two docs but a dozen or more experts that proved their ablities in the fields were not given the chance to add their expertise.

    That donkey- Dr Paddeniya and the bunch who worked diehard to bring the rascals to power let dying the innocient people by their consecutive strikes, were kept above the law.

    All these continued with EXPERTS IN CONTAGIOUS disease control being made silent. Why ? At least one of them could bravely come forward and break the silent.

  • 3

    My commendations to Mr Wijewardena on promoting Dr Silva’s publications. Such publications should be widely circulated & supported by like minded people.

    SL’s apparent ‘high’ literacy rate is limited to reading & writing only, a fault of the education system, which fails to expand the mind to ‘critical thinking’. We are still backward in our thinking, considering the fact we have so much faith in divine power, as demonstrated recently by the Health Minister & other so called intellectuals of the govt., some even qualified in Western medicine. While some of the graduates of state universities who hold high office have a ‘chip on their shoulder’, it is sad that even some old school academics, such as GL. Peris &, particularly those in judiciary, are no better, prostituting their professional integrity for political cronyism

  • 3

    It is time yobs, like the current GMOA President, Padeniya, who is no better than a destructive, self serving trade unionist from the gutter, are publicly shamed & denounced as they are an insult to their noble professions. If I am not mistaken, Padeniya is a punk who encouraged stoning of ambulances gifted by the Indians, which says a lot about the GMOA & its members & I wonder if they have even heard of the oath of Hippocrates. Unless the current & future generations are instilled with ethical values beyond material wealth, it will be a ‘dog eat dog’ society that will prevail in the future.

    • 1

      Sadly, these men though wearing MBBS titles thanks to the free education (through tax payers funds), behave as if their degrees were offered to them by gods. Paddeniya is seen like a dangerous cancer to srilanken health care. Look Paddeniya s proactive role is seen almost every where of the current govt. How come ? Whenever Organic manure instead of inorganic fertilizers, there Paddeniya is seen talking defeding the govt. Even if the bugger is not wearing titles in contagious disease control, he seems to have the audcity to issue expert s like view regarding how its containing should be made. The press is deaf and blind regarding the brutal acts of Paddeniya and the like [edited out]

  • 2

    The trade unions long time ago were hijacked and slowly degraded from inside out.
    This was visible in the west and naturally copied in sri lanka also.
    The anti-unionists get inside, take over and then stage strikes in such a manner
    as to enrage the public. To get people to throw the baby out with the bath water
    and totally dismiss the concept of a union and protecting workers rights.
    You almost never see them protest or strike where its really needed.
    Where workers are being exploited to the point where they are barely earning
    enough to pay their bills and suffering health problems due to over work.
    This is how the freemasons manipulate from behind the scenes.

  • 2

    I am very doubtful that most Politicians in the ruling party are able to read the above article and the book written by the Esteemed Doctor. It is time to cut the money spent on Defence and used it for the Health care of the country.

  • 2

    He has also coaxed students to learn English
    There is a recent trend in sri lanka where
    even people who know english are deliberately
    writing in sinhala on social media.
    They do this in reply to videos or posts written
    by sri lankans in english.

  • 1

    In the sixties, when ‘internship’ was commenced for the first time for medical graduates from the only medical faculty in Colombo, a senior physician suggested a remuneration of Rs 100 monthly for the twelve months!
    A threat of “work-to-rule” increased this to Rs.400.
    The Secretary-Health, a CCS man decided that cadre of medical officers (doctors) should be 97% “curative” and 3% “preventive” !
    The GMOA had to explain to him that cadre of different categories of medical officers have to be decided separately.
    The author of this article is no doubt thrilled with the tales medical practice, as a layman.
    He should also read the Hippocratic Oath.

  • 5

    old codger

    While we are on Health topics could you let me know how are we far can we trust Health Minister Pavithra Wanniarachchi when she claims ” China behind SL’s vaccination programme success” ?


    China no longer believes in long march revolution armed and directed by Red Book. Now it uses party individuals to strengthen and preserve House of Rajapaksa, Bonapartism of the Chinese kind. Yet SJ still wants or insists on China succeeding in its mission to annex this island as its Autonomous region or Special administrative region.

  • 4

    Sir, such noble person is hard to come, If there is one now , in current Lanka he / she will be disappointed and depressed so much so would have left country to a better place where such principles will be valued and cherished. It is like, what if Gandhi was alive today living in India. Over to retired doctor surgeon Janapriya. On this matter, I find it amazing to see the overnight concern shown by many doctors and groups in relation to current pandemic situation. Pediatric prof from Lady Ridgeway, community medicine prof from.Rajarata and few others have come out from hibernation. This situation was brewing for months waiting to explode
    Yet today Pavithra and Mr. Sircular claimed , due to their early vaccination Lanka successfully contained the spread..

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 200 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically disabled after 5 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.