19 November, 2018

Blog

An Independent Election Commission That Doesn’t Hold Elections?

By S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole

Prof. S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole

Prof. S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole

I belong to the so-called Independent Election Commission. I do not know why they call us Independent because I do not see that word in any of the legal instruments that appointed us. That, however, is the perception of the public. They expect us to act independently and hold the long overdue local government (LG) Elections immediately. It is a normal expectation in a democracy.

In the meantime, many contradictory statements with different dates by the Minister for Provincial Councils and Local Government (Faiszer Musthapha), the President, and the PM, among many others, have added to the confusion. The Island editorial (13.10.2016) gives as reason “The entry of a new political force led by the Rajapaksas into the fray will make the situation worse for the ruling coalition” and bets its bottom dollar that “the government will postpone the mini polls indefinitely on the pretext of finalising electoral reforms.” The evidence seems to suggest that The Island is right.

The Joint Opposition periodically visits the Commission demanding LG Elections. Everyone outside the government blames us saying we are independent and must hold elections. The JO at a public meeting even accused our Chairman of being partial to the government. We are the punching bag.Jaffna Mahinda Deshapriya Hoole

The President however spelt out the exact nature of our independence when Economy Next (12.10.2016) reported that the President “warned secretaries of independent commissions that it was he who had appointed him [sic., them] and they should know their “limits” and must keep him informed,” adding that he had decided to speak out and take “stern action.”

At least on the Election Commission, our Secretary is appointed by us and not the President, and we are answerable only to Parliament, not to the President. We Commission Members accepted our positions believing we would be truly independent. We began saying we are an independent commission and will not be summoned by anyone except by Parliament, the only entity to which we report. We have progressively learnt otherwise, culminating in this Presidential threat.

With many things in Sri Lanka being illegal including the apparent sweeping under the rug of night club brawls, the threat is chilling. Worse, in that same Economy Next article, the President said, “military commanders who led a successful campaign to crush separatist Tamil Tiger rebels in May 2009 should not be humiliated by bringing them to courts.” In other words, total impunity and hero-status to those who butchered Tamil civilians in the tens of thousands. That is even more chilling.

Despite the threat of stern action, we must speak up in our newly threatened democracy. Signals of our Commission’s irrelevance have been coming for some time. On 14.09.2016 Minister Musthapha, with many speculative election dates in backdrop, invited us to his Ministry to discuss the LG Elections. We would not have gone but for his telling us that it is to meet the Cabinet Subcommittee on the Local Government Draft Election Act. Traffic as it is in Colombo, we ended up at Union Place at 4:00 PM for the 4:30 PM meeting, looking our best in our ties. (Mahinda Deshapriya of course has his own unique wardrobe!) Secretary H. T. Kamal Pathmasiri, served us good ginger tea and kept stalling us for more time for the Ministers to turn up. Minister Musthapha arrived at 6:30 PM by helicopter with nary an apology. Not one of the other Ministers on the Cabinet Subcommittee (Rishad Bathiudeen, Mahinda Amarasinghe, Mano Ganeshan, Rauff Hakeem, Sushil Premajayantha, Vajira Abeywardena, or Wijeyadasa Rajapakshe) turned up or sent us word that they would not come.

In the course of discussions when one of us was asked to draft an Act and give a timeframe for his work, the Minister said, “Yes, let’s set a time. The problem in this country is lack of discipline.” It did not seem to occur to him that it applied to his own tardiness and his cabinet colleagues’ too.

However, by the end of the meeting we had agreed to a careful timeframe for the LG Elections. Specific time allocations for required actions before elections can be held under the Local Authorities Elections (Amendment) Act of 2012 were agreed to – for the Delimitation Committee to do its work, for the Appeals Committee to hear and dispose of appeals, for translations, for the Survey General to map out the wards, and for the wards to be gazetted. For the first time since we took office in Nov. 2015, we had a date for the LG Elections – we would shoot for March 2017.

After that happy outcome, the Minister, effusive and expansive, said he is being blamed for the delay and asked if any of us thought so. He asked. So I told him that I thought so when Asoka Peiris (Chairman, Delimitation Committee) had promised to finish his work by 15.08.2016 and the Minister gave an unsolicited extension to 31.10.2016.The Minister readily came with the repartee to the effect “I could see that Asoka Peiris was working with impossible dates and ruining his health. I wanted him to have a respite.”

In contrast to Faiszer Mutapha’s 2-hour tardiness at the end of which he did turn up, worse was Prime Minister Ranil Wickremesinghe. He summoned us on 20 Sept. for a meeting at 5:30 PM with a Parliamentary Select Committee. We were told the meeting would be in Parliament’s Committee Room 3 and that one person was already there. We found the room; that one person there was our Commission Secretary. No Prime Minister. After much waiting and inquiry we were informed that the PM had gone out of Parliament without saying where, and was unlikely to be back. Not one word to us warning us not to wait or apologizing. We are taken for granted. We were effectively told we are nobodies. The meeting took place the next day but I had to be back in Jaffna after spending a good quarter of my monthly travel allowance on petrol, and, to stay within my allowance, I did not want to continue eating in tea boutiques and living in cheap government rest houses where bed-sheets are not changed. Besides, what guarantee that he would not abscond again?

That is the backdrop to the straw that broke the camel’s back on 12.10.2016 when The Island reported that “Minister Lakshman Yapa Abeywardena gave the country another surprise when he declared that the long overdue local government polls would not be held till June, 2017.” We are rightly angry when a Minister whose portfolio has nothing to do with Local Government makes such a pronouncement.

At the meeting of the Commission with representatives of parties on 12.10.2016, Chairman Deshapriya expressed our anger and promised that the matter will be on the agenda at next week’s Commission meeting (18.10.2016) after which we would make a press statement. I will say no more because he has asked me not to say anything until that Press Statement is agreed upon by the Commission.

For my part, I will press the Election Commission for LG Elections as soon as possible. It is a democratic right of the people. As I teach in my Ethics class for Engineers, often two rights are in conflict and we must establish a hierarchy to be able to choose. In this case, we have on the one hand, the 2012 Local Authorities Act, which is in force, and we need to wait for the provisions to be implemented and new wards demarcated. We have also pointed out defects in the Act. It was drafted in English and translated into Sinhalese and Tamil, making the claim that in case of conflict between the versions, the Sinhalese translation shall prevail. However, the mistakes are in the Sinhalese version. For example, it says representatives are elected to Districts (as in Parliamentary Elections) rather than to Wards (as in LG elections). So any LG election of representatives to Wards can be challenged. We have pointed this out to the PM who has not bothered to make this simple amendment.

On the other hand, we already have boundaries demarcated – gerrymandered by the old government, it is widely alleged – and these have been gazetted by the present President. We also have the principle of democratic representation, which demands immediate elections. Importantly, the Local Authorities Elections Ordinance of 2005 in Article 25 says elections shall be held 6 months before the terms of office of members end. That deadline is long gone but it does not mean the clause is not operative. If you have to apply fertilizer at the beginning of every spring, just because you miss the beginning of spring does not mean you need to forego fertilizer all together. The Commission therefore has the power to announce elections.

We need to decide on the hierarchy of the two competing claims. Normally when a government goes about its business with bona fides, we must wait for the work of the government to run its course. But it is no longer clear that the delays are not deliberate – a) playing with the public by giving various dates for elections, b) treating the Commission with absolute nonchalance (not keeping appointments and not setting or paying salaries which took a year and a public protest to get it done), c) making an agreement with the Commission on a target date and having an unrelated minister make a contradictory statement, d) not making the simple amendments necessary for elections where members are elected to Wards and not Districts, and now e) having the President himself threaten Commissions.

Do we then wait in fear of unspecified “stern action” by the President and let people be deprived of their democratic right to government by their chosen representative? Or do we exercise leadership and hold elections using the wards gazetted by President Sirisena himself even if they are gerrymandered? If we are challenged, let the courts decide. A commonsense interpretation that I would expect of the courts of what is meant by “District” in a local government bill clearly means “Ward.”

The Commission going for elections could lead to an embarrassing reversal by courts but trying for the right thing is what leadership is about. Indeed, decisive action by the Commission would give pause to those who think they can play with the people’s right to representation and make threats to a Commission.

Chapter XIV A, Article 103 (2) defines the object of the Commission to be conducting free and fair elections and referenda. Postponing elections to suit the interests of one group may still allow free elections, but they will not be fair.

*S. Ratnajeevan H. Hoole – Member, Election Commission

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 5
    4

    Ratnajeevan

    I have in the past criticised you for your religious bigotry, but on this occasion I applaud you for your courageous stand.

    Keep going with your fearless independent stand at the Electoral Commission and make sure the commission acts independently and courageously.

    I hope the Commission comes up with a definite date for the local government elections in its proposed Press Statement on 18th October 2016. If you say the Commission has the power to set the date for the local government elections and if the requirements are met the Commission should go ahead and announce the date for the elections.

    What is clear is that this man Sirisena fears that his party would be wiped out if the local government elections are held now. That is why all his henchmen are setting various new dates (now for mid next year) for holding the elections.

    • 1
      4

      Naga,

      “I have in the past criticised you for your religious bigotry, but on this occasion I applaud you for your courageous stand.”

      Thank you for what you wrote. To be honest I expected another attack on anything originating from the Hoole brothers, Ahilan, Thiru and others. I am pretty sure that these attacks appear later when the often ignorant diasporians in UK, USA and Canada wake up.

      I also thank you for having and using facts despite living far away in Australia. The other diasporian continue not knowing how many Dr Hooles there are, who Ahilan Kadirgamar is and what kind of a church administers Uduvil Girl’s College. This ignorance continues despite documented attempts to correct them.

      • 5
        2

        Why is he writing this here? I ask again – Does he knows there was war went in lankawe between Sinhala government and Tamils? Why?

        This coolie has been dying for power. He came back looking for the job he ousted from. Unfortunate EPDP going to dismantled. Nobody can take him back. He got job paper boy job at Yahapalana Goverment. Coolie was 110% sure when he was taking the appointment. Did this guy wrote to Parliament(or prime minister) that he will resign if the parliament is not resorting his authority? Then why is he crying that he report only to Parliament? Didn’t these coolies wrote the Federal Constitution is not an urgent matter. There is a dead urgent to have the smaller LC’s election conducted?

        The constitutional council itself is a corrupted,faulty body.Then what is the use of talking about the appointment of these councils? The Yahapalanaya government offered a paper boy job to Sumanthiran too, but he rejected. Mano Ganesan has complained if he is not provided the need resources he going to resign. He accepted the job, but he knows what his jobs contains.

        Radhika, Mahendran, Indrajit, Kathirgamar, Deva, Pillaiyan, Karuna, Coolies…. I give you the choice, you pick a name from the list and convince Tamils these traitors accepted the Sinhala Government’s Jobs, at least,even to serve Sinhala Civilians. Radhika and Karuna had one time good friendship. What happened to when Ranil rejected Karuna? Karuna went from Ranil and put up with Old King, now no where.

        An ordinary journalist Ekneligoda’s wife Santhiya still fight for justice for her husband. A man stood for Prime Minister Post was murdered. That influential family gave the call for justice in consideration for material benefits. Alelandeswarar and other clowns from Kathirgamar gang who come to CT preach Tamils how to win their rights should feel ashamed of them every time when they see the photo of the woman named Santhiya Ekneligoda, in the news media.

        You fool has to remember the council job is not an elected job by Tamils. They don’t accept Coolies. They don’t give a damn about even if the Sinhala Government doesn’t conducts General Election. They want their land back. They don’t want army and coolies administer them.

        • 3
          5

          Mallaiyuran,

          Rubbish. There are hundreds of Tamils who are working as doctors, teachers, clerks, sweepers, cleaners, engineers, etc under the government of SL from Jaffna to Hambantota. Are you going to call all of them traitors? Do you think they all should work under the TGTE government?

          • 4
            3

            You are not bothered to answer any of my questions.

            It is not that you are misundering my question. But, you have, under different names, repeatedly worrying that Tamils are still employed in government service as ordinary employees in south and not completely wiped off by 1958, 1977, 1983, 2009.

            IC should recognize your worries and use R2P to free Tamils.

  • 3
    2

    I belong to the so-called Independent Election Commission. I do not know why they call us Independent because I do not see that word in any of the legal instruments that appointed us.

    Even though there are no legal docuemtns that appoints you, you were happy to accept it. Iam pretty sure, that comes with money too. I am pretty sure, as it is called independant, you thought you would be the bull in the China shop.

    As usual, the favorite item of everybody working in Sri lanka is just protesting whether it is reasonable or not.

    Otherwise, why an engineer should rot inside the election commission. You can certainly do better things.

  • 1
    4

    Dr Jeevan Hoole,

    “We have progressively learnt otherwise, culminating in this Presidential threat.”

    It would be interesting to know what authority is supposed to keep the President and other politicians away from putting pressure on you, the courts and police.

    Your independence should be guaranteed by an authority and this authority is not doing its work at the moment. In more developed countries politicians would not even dream about interfering in courts, police work and independent committees would they?

    Keep up the good work!

  • 1
    8

    In a democracy all elections are about allowing the electorate to select leaders whom the electorate want.

    If elections just are not held, why go through the sham of having “independent commissions”? Let us be grateful to Prof. Ratnajeevan Hoole for exposing all this sham, and writing about it in such a way that even a child can understand what is going on. And thanks for giving us all that information about the meeting on 14.09.2016.

    Today’s “the Island” has the entire article, and also an editorial on the subject:

    http://www.island.lk/index.php?page_cat=news-section&page=news-section&code_title=55

    If “national elections” – and these Local Government elections have to be held throughout the country – are treated with such levity, what can one expect of various other bodies (I mean work places etc) where elections are held? And when early warning is given of mistranslations, even those are not corrected.

    We must stop tolerating such farces, and thank persons like Prof. Hoole for the exposures. But I wonder what his fate will be?

  • 0
    2

    We can elect them but can we respect them anymore? I am not sure.

  • 0
    3

    Why does the good professor had to defile his most timely exposure of the actions of the political nitwits and their appalling behavior by referring to “tens of thousands of Tamil civilians butchered” fighting the terrorists, which is substantiated speculation.

  • 1
    8

    Dear Ratnajeevan,

    Thanks for revealing all the misdeeds by the powers that be, the Minister, the Prime Minister and the President. Not holding LG elections has major repercussions for political stability already being revealed both in the South and in the North. This is apart from it being a violation of a fundamental right (franchise) and people’s sovereignty (again franchise) in the Constitution. Apart from the fundamental definitional defect in the Elections Act, e.g. ward is named as district in the Sinhala version, as far as I am concerned, there are many inconsistencies and defects in terms of democracy and fairness.

    Whatever the obvious defects of the initial delimitation report which the present President gazetted, I also wonder how come a review process is allowed to make fundamental changes to the delimitation, going far beyond the initial demarcations. I understand that the number of the new wards has almost doubled the initial number.

    I hope and encourage the Commission to make a firm determination at its next meeting on 18 October and hope you all would come up with a firm press statement. Please don’t resign, but urge the Minister to fulfil all the procedural requirements to have the LG elections not later than March 2017.

  • 3
    4

    For me these peoples’ education is useless. They are very selfish. Any way with elections what do you get, another expense. another screw up.
    It looks you don’t think reasonably. Instead, you say, this is the rule, it has to go that way whether it is required or not.

    Anyway, as an engineer if you invented or aseemblied something NEW, would it run the 100% correct as soon as it assembled, did you expect that ?

    Why people are this selfish, self-centerd and always whining, complaining. What did they do to help Sri lanka except sucking up when ever possible.

    These people are prehighly prejudiced. For example this australia – naturalized guy, he never sees what his govt is doing in the world, in the middle east, in Naury, adn to Aborginies.

  • 3
    4

    Prof Hoole’s motto is whining and complaining.

    As a Tamil how much he has criticized his own society against social disparities. Has he ever criticized himself asking as an engineer what he is doing instead of helping the country if not Tamils only, but economically and not how to assemble bombs.

    He was very good at writing racist articles promoting “Tamilness”. Now, he wants the election commission to be active 100% correct right away.

    What is his mentality here. IS he saying that everything that Sri lanka doing is low quality.

    Even though he is an enginner he is a religious – bigot and a Tribalist. Other than that, he can not contribute positively to the country or to the society.

    Did he ever contribute ever positively ?

  • 6
    0

    dim softy,
    stag night??
    “Even though he is an enginner he is a religious – bigot and a Tribalist. Other than that, he can not contribute positively to the country or to the society.”

    To be fair to him he is not street wise. SriMao who was crazy about suddhu hamme appointed Chelliah Kumarasuriya who wasn’t a great engineer either but diplomatic person.
    You can be assured he won’t perform much with religion now that he has colourwashed the main faith because of culture of the northern village.

    “Did he ever contribute ever positively ?”

    CBK’s selection of diplomat LK contributing positively ended his life.
    The cause of that fascist gay skinheads aren’t you one of them dimsofty??

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 300 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically shut off on articles after 10 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.