26 May, 2019

Blog

Now, It Is Thirteen Minus

By Kamal Nissanka

Kamal Nissanka

Initial post war reconciliation expectations are now totally failed In Sri Lanka as the attempts are taking to dilute the powers of the provincial councils in the eve of the northern provincial council election. Thus national question that was manifested in the Sri Lankan political landscape since early 1920’s will be remained in continuity. Historically, the issue was further aggravated with the introduction of electoral methods in the early legislative councils and later with introduction of universal franchise under the Donoughmore system. In the course of time Sri Lankan national question    was transformed into a power sharing issue.  Since then number of popular proposals such as Fifty- Fifty of G.G.Ponnambalam, BC Pact, DC Pact, Rajive Gandhi- J.R.Jayawardene Pact (Indo-Lanka Accord of 1987) were introduced to cope with the problem. There were other attempts too in the form of constitutional reforms .Our two major constitutional attempts in 1972 and 1978 faced lots of criticism during last 35 years as both these constitutions failed to incorporate the minorities into the bodypolitc. Next major change, the Provincial Council (PC) system triggered by Indian intervention lasted for nearly quarter century is now under criticism and a debate had been evolved as to the suitability of provincial council system.

The major actor in Tamil politics, until May 2009 was the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) which opposed the PC system and their aim was to create a separate Tamil speaking mini state within the island of Sri Lanka. One school of thought that opposed the creation of a mini state advocated a centralized administration opposing all types of devolution. Their view was that any devolution to North would ultimately lead to a separation.  Another school of thought that opposed the separatist agenda of the Tamils advocated the defeat of the LTTE and thereafter to introduce a power sharing package. A third school of thought that emerged in the  hay day of LTTE war advocated that it was an unwinnable war and the best is to have a power sharing package as taking LTTE as the sole representative of Tamil community in Sri Lanka. In the midst of these arguments and debates the PC system survived  in the South but people were not happy  about this political authority  as it had become a  method  of wielding power  by  the same people  who are enjoyed  power in the centre.  Close relatives of leading politicians were promoted to stand for provincial councils making it a political extended family. However this situation arose as a result of the district propositional electoral system that included a preference system.

Mahinda Rajapakse administration that   came to power in 2005  appointed Prof Tissa Vitarana to look into the  matter of power sharing  but in the course of time President himself lost interest and then suddenly found the solution to the issue lies in the in the 13th amendment itself  and wanted to activate the 13th amendment in full  length.

The nature of the debate in the post war situation is different because on the one hand India, EU and USA are pushing for a political solution to the national problem in the form of constitutional reform. President is said to have been agreed to 13+ with Indian authorities at one stage.

On the other hand the political elements who advocate a solution through economic development deny the theory of power sharing to the North and East. They in fact want to revoke the 13 th amendment which was a brain child of India.  Moderates advocate that in the post war period if a true mechanism of power sharing is introduced that would bring lasting peace to Sri Lanka.  Another factor is the growing Diaspora that is able to influence western governments and UN agencies openly.

By every means the recent introduction to dilute the 13th amendment is a 13 minus. (13- ). Some of the amendments such as need of the consent of majority provincial councils to introduce legislation to some subjects affecting provincial councils are a step in the re-centralization program. It would further enhance the hands of the President as he could manipulate the provincial council system through the political authority and as a leader of a party.

The first north east provincial council was a disaster owing to many reasons. Ultimate result of indo- Lanka accord was the creation of seven provincial councils to Sinhalese dominated provinces. As the government is determined to dilute the powers of provincial councils the reconciliation agenda will be severely affected. If the present administration wants to revoke the 13th amendment without introducing a power sharing package to the north and east it would definitely invite for greater troubles to the island nation.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Latest comments

  • 0
    0

    “If the present administration wants to revoke the 13th amendment without introducing a power sharing package to the north and east it would definitely invite for greater troubles to the island nation.”

    Another Soothsayer.

    Remember the earlier version “LTTE can notbe defeated”.

  • 0
    0

    ” They in fact want to revoke the 13 th amendment which was a brain child of India”

    So, you want Sri Lanka to remain an Indian Colony ?

    “On the other hand the political elements who advocate a solution through economic development deny the theory of power sharing to the North and East.”

    Power is for economically – rich people.

    IF they are not economically self-sufficient for whom the power is for ?

  • 0
    0

    Kamal Nissanka,

    The 13th is needed because, what we have now is a police that protects the regime.

    With the 13th, there will be Provincial police that will protect the local provincial people, because the current police does not protect the people. It only protects the regime.

    Listen to what Ven. Maduluwawe Sobhitha Thera is saying. It is in Sinhala.

    The law must be fair to all, says Ven. Maduluwawe Sobhitha Thera

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mdZW_gk8fYI

    Police Not be politicized – Sobitha Thero

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3_9DW-A1MUU

    The law must be fair to all, says Ven. Maduluwawe Sobhitha Thera

  • 0
    0

    By tinkering with the constitution at this stage the govt risks destabilising the entire system. Govt seems to pulling on the side of the racist minority in the south, the Gota/JHU/BBS combine. Result will be a sham election and no solution to the problem. I dont think that 13A is totally the brainchild of India. It is not possible that JR would have agreed to such a situation. India may have pushed for devolution at the most.

  • 0
    0

    The Thirteenth Amendment was introduced to ensure devolution of power to the Tamil minority. The Sinhala provinces were dragged in for the benefit of politicians. From the point of view of the national question, which in essence is one of reconciling majority/minority relations, it’s the North and the East that need devolution. So the Thirteenth Amendment should be amended to restrict devolution to the North and the East. To devolve power to the Sinhala provinces is a waste of public funds, and it only legitimizes, and legalises, local thuggery and local mismanagement of public funds. The Sinhala Provincial Councils are simply white elephants maintained for purposes of political patronage and profit for corrupt politicians. Prior to the creation of the Provincial Councils system, local administration was carried our efficiently by a Ministry of Local Administration. The Thirteenth Amendment should be amended to devolve power exclusively to the North and the East, and it should be Thirteenth plus as the president promised.

    Sinhala Patriot

  • 0
    0

    what is the position of the Liberal party on this issue?

  • 0
    0

    The 13th Amendment would not have been necessary if the Tamil people had received justice and fairplay.

Leave A Comment

Comments should not exceed 300 words. Embedding external links and writing in capital letters are discouraged. Commenting is automatically shut off on articles after 10 days and approval may take up to 24 hours. Please read our Comments Policy for further details. Your email address will not be published.