Growing up in Sri Lanka in the 60s and 70s, our ambition was to secure a government job, retire by age 55, and enjoy a good pension. I often saw my male relatives doing just that, reclining in easy chairs with their legs propped up—a common and comfortable sight. However, the 80s brought dramatic changes. We scattered across the globe, embracing diverse cultures and values. In the USA, particularly, we’ve been conditioned to believe that age is just a number and that life is endless, with us as the Energizer Bunnies, going on forever.
This optimistic view was suddenly upended last week with President Joe Biden‘s announcement of his campaign termination following his disastrous debate performance. Suddenly, age-related mental decline and dementia were thrust into the spotlight, challenging the notion that we can defy the effects of aging indefinitely.
Age-related decline in mental acuity has long been considered a norm, often dismissed as “senior moments” for those over 60. Historically, this wasn’t seen as a major concern in many societies. Even Dr. Alzheimer’s early work, over a century ago, focused primarily on presenile dementia, largely overlooking senile dementia. However, the identification of amyloid plaques and other brain deposits has shifted the focus. This discovery spurred extensive research aimed at understanding and mitigating the effects of these plaques, expanding our awareness and approach to cognitive decline associated with aging.
Despite significant progress in understanding its pathology, the ongoing spectacles in the U.S. Senate and among many elderly world leaders clearly demonstrate that we have yet to solve the problem of mitigating, let alone reversing, age-related mental decline. For over a century, scientific efforts have largely been in vain, leaving families frustrated and sometimes confrontational. Hope often outstrips reality. Consequently, I have faced criticism for speaking out against costly neurological tests that have made little impact on the relentless progression of this condition.
As the elderly population grows, the economic burden of dementia on countries is becoming increasingly unsustainable. As a result, the quest to cure dementia has emerged as a formidable contender alongside the ongoing efforts to cure cancer. Following decades of disappointing results with initial medications, there has been a resurgence of enthusiasm among researchers and the pharmaceutical industry, particularly in the realm of monoclonal antibodies. This renewed interest has invigorated the field after a prolonged period of stagnation. However, the exuberance has been tempered by again disappointing outcomes. Despite significant reductions in brain plaques, the prohibitive side effects and high costs have outweighed the negligible clinical benefits.
At this juncture, these repeated disappointments leave us with one option: to confront reality head-on. When it comes to jobs involving physical labor, there is a consensus that earlier retirement is preferable. Conversely, it is the white-collar professionals who often harbor the delusional belief in their own invincibility, conveniently shielding themselves from scrutiny. Recently, Nobel Laureate Venki Ramakrishnan addressed this issue, bluntly pointing out that the best ideas typically come from young minds, while older individuals rest on their laurels and exploit the younger generation. He cited the academic hierarchy as an example, but this phenomenon is even more rampant in politics.
As longevity increases, early retirement can become a burden on the younger generation. However, this doesn’t justify clinging to positions of power indefinitely. Elders must acknowledge that their waning productivity can stall progress and should step aside to allow the younger generation to assume leadership roles. They can still contribute meaningfully by sharing their knowledge and experience as mentors and teachers, using their skills in pattern recognition to perform valuable tasks that benefit the workforce.
As the pace of research accelerates, I’m optimistic that a solution will eventually be found for this scourge. In the meantime, we must not become delusional about life in general. The twilight years are an inevitable part of our existence; while we can push the boundaries slightly, we can never eliminate them entirely.
After all, reclining in an easy chair on your veranda, sipping king coconut water on a summer day in upcountry Sri Lanka, and watching trains wind through verdant tea terraces while reminiscing about your glory days with a friend, isn’t a bad way to spend one’s twilight years.
RBH59 / July 28, 2024
“President Biden’s involvement in global conflicts has not only opened doors for war but also highlighted the significant stress placed on him. This intense pressure may contribute to cognitive decline and related mental health issues. The potential impacts of high tension and stress on cognitive functions, including dementia and other forms of mental decline, have been thrust into the spotlight. He did not enhance decision-making abilities, and foster resilience in the face of global challenges. Switched off practices such as meditation, deep breathing, and mindfulness can play a vital role in mitigating the adverse effects of chronic stress These ongoing War thinking have far-reaching effects on mental health, impacting not only leaders but also the affected populations and lost his President made him to forget what addresses in question time
/
old codger / July 28, 2024
“After all, reclining in an easy chair on your veranda, sipping king coconut water on a summer day in upcountry Sri Lanka, and watching trains wind through verdant tea terraces while reminiscing about your glory days with a friend, isn’t a bad way to spend one’s twilight years.”
The problem is that the friends who are forced to listen to the same old stories on every visit, have a hard time staying awake, unless they are senile themselves.
Is this repetition of stories an early indication of dementia? It seems to affect people even in their 60’s, but some in their nineties are unaffected.
/
SJ / July 29, 2024
oc
Mental health is protected to a good degree by keeping oneself active, mentally in particular.
Lack of company and prolonged isolation are likely to worsen things for the old.
One helps himself/herself by keeping busy in some way. Friends and family too can help by engaging with them in helpful ways.
Little grandchildren are often great healers.
Medication should be the last resort.
/
old codger / July 30, 2024
Chiv, SJ,
By coincidence, I was watching a sad but interesting movie about elders a few days ago:
https://youtu.be/W_jqag3sIlI?si=ac-HFiqCiXEfyAbu
/
LankaScot / July 30, 2024
Hello OC et al,
At my Father’s Funeral (aged 83) in Aberdeen (Humanist) a couple of Friends and Family gave short speeches, we played some of his favourite music and finished of with a speech by a Humanist Celebrant. He didn’t know that my father was not a great fan of Dylan Thomas, but he recited the poem,
–
Do not go gentle into that good night,
Old age should burn and rave at close of day;
Rage, rage against the dying of the light.
The rest is worth reading https://poets.org/poem/do-not-go-gentle-good-night
–
The ones that keep active, don’t dwell too much in the past, eat a good diet and keep an interest in family and friends, will keep healthier longer. Lack of stress is also good for you, so beware of becoming addicted to CT commenting😉.
Best regards
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
Old,
We came to the West just before entering the middle age. Against many doctors’ advice, Rice-curry is the steady lunch, always. If it was missed at lunchtime, unavoidably, that would be the dinner. We both cook it and eat it. Almost every day religiously! Age-old recipes! We brag to our American friends that the Tamils’ recipes are more than 2,000 years old, except Idly, believed to be introduced to Tamils during Raja Raja Cholan’s time. Maybe Mr. Modi, during one of his visits to the Moon, may find something new, like Raja Rajan’s idly. Until then, we are eating Siri Ma O’s imported rice. Sofas are here, no easy chairs. The next routine is peeping in CT for what is cooking……, There are many news media, radio, TV Channels are available…. But the CT’s the extra spicy, extra salty and extra tangy ……is unique! Anyway, how do you get tired of these classical things so easily? You may be old but not ripen, that is why you are so easily becoming tired of the action center. “Those who know the nuance of taste only look forward to the Ariyalai’s dried Palm juice plates. Others just eat anything and wouldn’t spend time going to Ariyalai and buying those special ones.
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
They say “too sharp is too blunt”. In Tamil it is said in another way too “Sontha Selavilai Choonium Vaikkirthu”. For almost 4 years, the Republican Party was preparing for this election. Until a few days after the debate, they had produced good results for their long efforts. Trump was leading in almost all states, especially the pendulum ones, they swing between the elephant and the donkey. It sounded like Cassius Clay playing with a high school kid, the election campaign was for Republicans. Without any effort, they knocked out President Biden using his stammering during the debate. That is where it seems it had gone wrong. The knock was too early, even before the players entered the ring. So, for the official game (“Nija Vilaiyaddu”), democrats have replaced the player.
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
When Hillary Clinton lost the election, there was an opinion, there, that she was not anything less than President Trump in qualities or qualifications, but that decision was made by Americans voters based on Man-Woman preference. Knowing this, President Biden came with Female VP Harris as his running mate, in 2020. President Biden was a Black president’s VP, earlier. That made me think that he was having a different idea in taking Kamala Harris as his running mate. Even during his 2020 election, his problem of senility was observed and talked about. So, the idea was, if he could not complete his term, he wanted to leave the responsibility with a woman president. At that time, the VP was not a strong figure, unlike now she is. But Biden is successfully managing his full term. There didn’t any need arise for him to leave the job with the VP and resign, in the middle of his term.
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
Again, In Tamil, Valuvar said “Ennie Thuniba Karumam”. We all think of a plan before we start even the trifling matters. But we almost always rush, because we are pushed by our fear and greed. Republicans, before they deliver the knock-out punch and eliminate President Biden from competition, they failed to understand that Biden would have been the best candidate to ensure that no women candidate would get any chance in the recent future elections. They, too, might have been fearing that if Biden wins, certainly the presidency will go to Kamala Harris, incontestably, during his 2nd term. So, they rushed and spoiled the chance they had for an easy victory.
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
The republican election campaign left a feeling in the minds of American citizens that if Biden remains in the race, he will be the worst candidate, so, whether democrats win or lose, it is very urgent for the country that democrats change the candidate. To create and reinforce this feeling, instead of attacking the Democratic Party’s policies, Republicans concentrated their attacks on Biden. Heeding to the voters’ concern, Democrats replaced their candidate. Now the masses are starting to think that the Democrats are a party that listens to people’s concerns & worries. Alas, by spending their own campaign money Republicans have created an advantage for Democrats and disadvantages for themselves. On the hindsight republicans are accusing the Democrats of changing the rule in the middle of the game. Even If they realize what has gone wrong, to equalize their stand on the people’s mind with the new status of the democrats, creating a similar event to demonstrate that they too care about people’s opinion as much as or even more than Democrats, is not possible, especially within the short time remain for the prospective election.
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
All of a sudden Trump felt that he had lost the rudder lever of his boat. The long four-years of preparation was wasted in front of the last-minute democrats’ surprise. He informed the public that his campaign was set to focus on President Biden, as democrats had withdrawn him, so now Republicans have to even rewrite the speech scripts, and they have to start everything all over again…….. Chaos! Republicans’ blind, opinion-creating campaign that “if Biden were a candidate Trump would be a young and energetic president and if any other Democratic enters the race that candidate can be better off” has forced the people to reevaluate their opinion once the Democrats had changed their candidate as Republicans’ blind folded campaign suggested. Republicans didn’t expect their vigorous, concentrated attack may successfully eliminate Biden, but all they looked for was Biden to be irrecoverably weakened until the election was over. Stunned Republican Speaker even declared that they would go to court because Biden leaving the election is not a democratic process, so Democrats were undermining the democracy by switching the candidate. Surprisingly, still Republicans have not understood where they lost their path, so they instead of attacking democrats’ policies, attacking Kamala Haris’ “Face and Race”
/
Mallaiyuran / July 30, 2024
I think, by now President Biden may be contending that he won the race even without entering the race because this would be the situation he was looking for from the time Hilary lost her election. “That is, Republicans appointed 6 Justices to SC and undid the American’s pride of Roe V. Wade. But Democrats brought the first black president and first female president as their record.
/
chiv / July 29, 2024
OC, my mom is now 97 years old. For her age her memory seems good. Where as my dad had dementia in his early 80’s which progressed to a stage where he could’t identify us at times, fortunately died by age 85. What is significant is that short term memory is what impaired in the early stages ( cannot remember events which took place in a day to a week ). Long term memory is usually intact until middle / late stages. Family members who are not aware of this fact, will not recognize the problem in the early stages. Other scuttle signs are difficulty focusing, mood changes, misplacing things, at times, unable to remember familiar names, struggling to find right word or follow conversations can be seen. ( repetitive speech is one ), Dementia in general can be divided as Alzheimer’s ( with an early onset and a rapid progress, leading to higher morbidity / mortality ) and non Alzheimer’s type. ( late in onset, gradually progressing ). According to causes and pathology there are various types a) vascular, which is most common among our people because of high prevalence in Diabetes, Hypertension, lipid abnormality,smoking, alcohol related , Parkinson’s ) where multiple bleeds overtime causing degenerative brain disease, others include Lewy body, frontotemporal, mixed . . . .etc. Even Covid may cause in certain people due to vasculitis, auto immune surge….
/
chiv / July 29, 2024
I just read a new study published in JAMA.. Researchers from Lund Uni, Sweden found a cutting edge blood test, p- tau217, which can diagnose Alzheimer’s with more than 90% accuracy, compared to current methods with 70 % accuracy for specialist and 60% for primary care doctors. Current methods are expensive, hard to access and often have long waits. Hopefully this blood test can streamline diagnosis and early treatment. Tau protein is a pathological marker of certain neurodegenerative disorders including AD.
/
SJ / July 29, 2024
“This optimistic view was suddenly upended last week with President Joe Biden‘s announcement of his campaign termination etc.”
If a society could not recognize that the man had a serious problem during his first year at the White House, it truly deserves the President it will elect.
/
Gobi / July 29, 2024
Dear Chiv,
You’re absolutely right. There is now a blood test available and several monoclonal antibodies that can slow the progression of amyloid plaques, albeit with concerning side effects such as brain swelling and hemorrhage. While the clinical benefits over a year are positive, they are still not very impressive, especially considering the prohibitive cost of $25,000. Similar to heart disease, not everyone with plaques exhibits symptoms, as there are extenuating and predisposing genetic factors, such as ApoE4 homozygosity. The critical question remains: is this blood test early enough to intervene effectively, or is it already too late? These are the loose ends that need addressing. For now, a healthy lifestyle and good genes are our best defenses.
Thanks,
Gobikrishna
/
andy1747 / July 29, 2024
Thanks Dr. Gobikrishna for this important article. We all know that MCI ( mild cognitive impairment) and subsequent dementia are having devastating effects in the developed nations through economic and social burden. Unfortunately developing country like Sri Lanka is set to face this enormous problem too. These are the three things already happening leading to this disastrous situation. 1. Explosion of diseases of modern civilization like diabetes ( insulin resistance), 2.physical inactivity (in the name of convenience) 3. exponential growth of older (octogenarian) population.
Apparently prevention as well as slowing the disease progression is the best strategy in dealing with this devastating disease. Unfortunately cutting edge technology in diagnosis this disease is not going to help much except for future planing to deal with the individuals.
Regular physical activities /exercise have shown that not only it prevents the disease but slows its progression. Healthy diet like our traditional diet or similar ( Mediterranean) has definitely play a major roll. Both strategies, we very well know prevent or reduce the incidence of diabetes/ insulin resistance whereby help in preventing or reducing the progress of dementia. Unofficially Alzheimer’s dementia is called type 3 diabetes. The same amyloid plaque build up in type 1 and 2 diabetes happen outside the brain and type 3 happens inside the brain.
https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/peptide-treatment-could-reverse-cognitive-decline-alzheimers-disease
Andy Somesan, MD
/