By Susantha Hewa –
Dr. Amir Ali’s article titled “Battle for the Parliament” published in Colombo Telegraph of September 29, 2024 is encouraging because it has a strong appeal to all those who wish to see the unity of all Sri Lankans belonging to different faiths.
It is no news that religious and ethnic differences have been a major cause of social segregation. And, these artificial divisions had served the crafty politicians who had ruled the country in the past. They had exploited, among other things, religion and ethnicity as a way of preventing the electorate from understanding their common problem of widespread poverty, which had nothing to do with their religion or ethnicity.
The two labels of ethnicity and religion that are stamped on us at birth, depending on where we are born, have not served any useful purpose in human civilization. A new born baby, no matter where he or she is born, is invariably labeled as belonging to this or that religion and ethnicity. No child can escape this branding, which, however is purely circumstantial with regard to the variety. No empirical test would identify any newborn baby to be intrinsically Sinhalese, Tamil, Muslim, Buddhist, Christian, Hindu or whatever. It is the way the infant gets conditioned by the immediate social environment, which happens to be the family that gradually initiates the newcomer into its religion and ethnicity. Any baby, irrespective of his or her biological parents, would grow up acquiring the two labels of ethnicity and religion of his or her guardians. Just to give an example, a baby of “Tamil Hindu” parents would be an ardent “Sinhala Buddhist” if he were brought up by a family bearing the latter label, and vice versa. It’s nothing but a matter of chance but their stamp is permanent and potentially divisive, and, what’s more, you are hooked for life. Human history would have been much less bloody had it not been for these two socially imposed stickers.
Let’s take religion. In any society, religion is supposed to be the major repository of moral values. Of course, the mere mention of the word religion brings to mind all good values – love, sympathy, generosity, etc. However, ironically, the plural form of religion is quite disappointing and even scary. That is, “religions” would automatically be associated with segregation, aggression, hatred, persecution, bloodshed, war. Very rarely is the term “religions” associated with peace and harmony. The very term “religious harmony”, which indicates the need for the reconciliation of different religious communities, is ironical in that all religions are supposed to make us better humans, isn’t it? If our religions had made us more sensible and sensitive, we should have been able to say with regard to religions, “the more, the merrier”, right? However, our history is strewn with examples that prove the reverse of it, which is, perhaps, “the more the scarier”? And, all those who are ready to fish in segregated waters, it would be “the more, the easier for us”.
The point is, it’s nothing to do with the moral dimension of religions. Generally, we have no quarrel over moral issues, no matter what religion we have inherited. We all are touched by kindness, sympathy, gratitude, honesty, generosity, etc. etc. And, we all oppose injustice, selfishness, cruelty, cunning, don’t we? Sam Harris, the neuroscientist and author, in his “The Moral landscape” says, “Just as there is no such thing as Christian physics or Muslim algebra, we will see that there is no such thing as Christian or Muslim morality…” The same applies to Buddhist, Hindu or any other “morality” available in society. When someone does an act of kindness, can any of us classify it as Buddhist, Muslim or Christian variety?
In fact, the element of estrangement owes to the entrenched habit of religious indoctrination in childhood, which denies the child the right to “learn” any religion or religions of his choice as an adult. It’s not surprising that a method which so patently violates children’s right to remain unaffected by his parents’ religion till they are intellectually strong enough to understand religion in all its subtlety, is highjacked by sneaky politicians to keep us artificially divided as a means of distracting us from the real issues that have kept us locked in poverty and ignorance. It’s time that lawyers and human rights activists thought of this culturally entrenched brainwashing of children which violates their right to choose their religion at an appropriate age. After all conditioning of young minds to impose the religion of their parents’ choice is against the freedom of religion ensured by the constitution (Articles 10 and 14(1)(e) state: “Every person is entitled to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including the freedom to have or to adopt a religion or belief of his choice”). A tradition, no matter however sanctified it may be, should not be blind to its negative consequences with respect to social cohesion.
Why allow religion to be a tool of unnecessary social alienation in the hands of scheming politicians? It is a pity that we are made to think that programming of young children is the best and only way to create people with better empathy.
*The writer taught English at Moratuwa University for 24 years and got retired as a senior lecturer in 2020.
Lasantha Pethiyagoda / October 2, 2024
Religion by its very nature is divisive and exclusive. It is unfortunate that people are made to believe that their own god is better than someone else’s god, without a shred of evidence to support it, except testimonies of believers of that faith or belief system. Cunning politicians use this as a tool of control, not just in poor third world countries but in some “developed” countries too. Secular states that keep religion away from statecraft are the best for the people.
/
Leonard Jayawardena / October 2, 2024
The author cites with approval Sam Harris’ statement in his book “The Moral landscape”: “[T]here is no such thing as Christian or Muslim morality [because they are all the same]….” The author adds: “The same applies to Buddhist, Hindu or any other “morality” available in society.”
No, there are differences of morality between different religions as originally taught. Jesus’ moral teachings include non-violence (“turn the other cheek”) and pacifism (both in the Sermon on the Mount), though mainstream Christianity does not subscribe to these. In Islam it can be a duty to avenge any wrong done to fellow Muslims. The same applies to Hinduism. In Christianity, monogamy is prescribed but in Islam up to four wives are allowed–if you consider this a moral issue. Homosexuality is a sin in Christianity (and disapproved in Islam) but, as far as I know, neither Buddhism nor Hinduism has a position on that issue.
The Buddha prohibited killing of animals, though he had no problem consuming animal flesh when served to him. Neither Christianity nor Islam contains such a prohibition, and in Hinduism (and also Islam) animal sacrifice is a part of the religion.
/
SJ / October 3, 2024
“In Islam it can be a duty to avenge any wrong done to fellow Muslims. The same applies to Hinduism.”
Which Hindu code may I know? It is a ‘religion’ with no common code of ethics or morals.
/
Leonard Jayawardena / October 3, 2024
SJ:
“Which Hindu code may I know? It is a ‘religion’ with no common code of ethics or morals.”
You are right. It is unwise to make a generalized comment about Hindu morals. I was thinking specifically about the conversation between Arjuna and his charioteer Krishna in the Bhagavat Gita.
/
SJ / October 3, 2024
LJ
Thanks
/
Svenson / October 4, 2024
‘The Buddha prohibited killing of animals, though he had no problem consuming animal flesh when served to him.’
.
In 1983 about £110m worth of gold bullion, diamonds, and cash was stolen from the Brinks-Matt security warehouse at Heathrow Airport in London by armed robbers. Most of the gold was never recovered. Today its almost impossible to buy a piece of gold or diamond jewellery that has not originated from that robbery. If I buy a gold ring, that may make me many things, but it doesn’t make me an armed robber.
.
Likewise eating the flesh of a dead animal may make me many things, but it doesn’t make me a killer of animals.
/
RBH59 / October 2, 2024
Why Let Socially Imposed Faiths Divide Us? Leaders with a militaristic mindset may use such strategies to maintain authority, as creating chaos or division can make it easier to justify stronger control measures.
It sounds like you’re discussing the idea that certain groups or leaders may be using organized violence or manipulation, possibly by inciting religious or ethnic tensions, to consolidate power. This can happen in scenarios where people are intentionally divided through fear, aggression, or hatred, often for political gain or control.
In such situations, those with qualifications or knowledge in peacebuilding, conflict resolution, or diplomacy might be concerned. They would likely focus on promoting dialogue, understanding, and nonviolent solutions, as opposed to methods that divide or escalate tensions. Would you like to delve deeper into any part of this or explore specific examples?
/
Ruchira / October 3, 2024
A good piece and some thought provoking ideas I personally can relate to. Religion has always served the purpose of accomplishing social conformity thus control of masses. The author has forgotten so many other such arbitrary categories that create divisions in the society. Particularly in this part of the world – caste is still an issue, even in Sri Lanka, though it may be not so apparent. The skin colour is another. The author also makes the mistake that politicians are in charge and that they could make a difference. Nothing’s further from the truth. Politicians are just another piece on the Chess Board. Shots are called by players that you don’t see on the board. You will not see them unless you get out of the conventional system of thinking. Who is in charge then? One may ask! Which is a good question. Most often people refer to Powers. That Be or TPTB as those in charge. Only god knows who they are. They could be anyone from Mafia to POTUS to Terror outfits like the LTTE. And of course the Church and The Mosques.
/
old codger / October 3, 2024
“And of course the Church and The Mosques.”
It is significant that those who claim to be against socially imposed faiths have left the Mahanayakas out.
/
SJ / October 3, 2024
Although the top two Mahanayakes are not from his caste?
/
Ruchira / October 3, 2024
….and their hired perverted psychos like old codger from Prince of Wales Moratuwa, who 9only knows how to to take sexual advantages of servant women by having anal and oral sex with them, and finally somehow getting them pregnant with triplets, but don’t have enough intellect to understand the contexts within which certain written words are wrotten about. Him and his school – both will soon be history… 🚀
/
LankaScot / October 3, 2024
Hello Ruchira,
Hugh Everett was right about the Multiverse. You are definitely a visitor from one of these other Universes.
Best regards
/
old codger / October 3, 2024
So, is your daughter still hiding in the Mosque? What is she hiding from? Perverted Angoda inmates ? Queen Ruchira?
/
SJ / October 3, 2024
CT
What degree of sickness do the gatekeepers allow?
/
gurudev / October 4, 2024
Ladies and Gentlemen, It’s better to be civil and polite.
Should not the religions be our personal and private affairs in this day and age?
Historically, all over the world, religion and governance appear to have been mostly very cooperative with each other. Leaders of each group have been patting each other’s backs to be in power and to rule the majority of ordinary people. Eventually, people in some countries like Russia and China formed a new religion known by various names such as Communism, Marxism/Leninism and Socialism.
Many Feudal /religious cultures ended up as Dictatorships.
Almost everywhere in the world where religion has played a key role in governance it has become a disaster. This we see irrespective of religion. Examples are, Most countries in South America, Burma, Iran, Cambodia, Sri Lanka and others. In Sri Lanka our culture really is based on a Haamuduru/Mahaththaya cultre, for the sinhalese folks. For the Tamil and Muslim friends, it’s the same. We have been brainwashed to believe that our religion/culture is the best and superior to the rest. Of course, the caste system was and is there.
It’s a shame even at present, the Marriage Proposal columns in the newspapers specify the caste.
/
Ruchira / October 4, 2024
I can see clearly now the rain is gone. The Roman Catholic Church is the spiritual arm of Italian Mafia. Can’t wait to nail all the churches for the crimes that they have been commiting over several millennia. Only predicament is whether to start from the Vatican itself in a top down fashion or from Cardinal Malcolm Ranjith and the likes in Colombo!
/
Susantha Hewa / October 3, 2024
Our religious ‘identity is imposed on us at our birth. From infancy we are made to feel that we belong to our parents’ faith. As infants, we are inescapably initiated into it through an intricate process of conditioning including rituals, visits to places of worship, narratives highlighting the uniqueness of the founder of the religion, an explanation of ‘afterlife’ dissimilar to others, etc. As children we grow up feeling that we belong to a group of ‘lucky’ people who have the ‘true’ faith. Unfortunately, all this happens before we can cognitively understand our religion’s doctrine, or any other. This gradually strengthening forced ‘identity’ alienates us from others. The programming of young minds hardly leaves any room for a rational choice of a religion as a mature person, which would have been possible had we been spared the culturally sanctioned religious indoctrination happening in our early years. Now what? Those shrewd politicians – be they ‘militaristic’ or ‘democratic’ – have very little to do to exploit this deep-rooted and irrational faith-based distancing to consolidate their power and distract an otherwise unbiased public from understanding their politically determined poverty, which they have for centuries attributed to individual ‘weaknesses’, supernatural agents, etc. Thanks.
Susantha
/
LankaScot / October 3, 2024
Hello Susantha Hewa,
There are many places in the World where “Our religious ‘identity is imposed on us at our birth” does not apply. My friends from India, Sri Lanka, Nepal and other Asian Countries could not get their heads around the fact that I was British and not Christian. It was even more difficult for them to understand that I was an Atheist. What used to be termed Religious Instruction has been replaced by Religious Education and “In Scotland, parents have a legal right to withdraw their children from religious and moral education if they feel the curriculum conflicts with their own beliefs” This right should be adopted by all Countries including South Asian ones.
For us, starting school in the 1950s, this was the first concerted effort to instill a belief in a God. They failed miserably and later on when we were older and allowed/decided to question the Teachers directly, you could see the anger on their faces.
These days are gone, the Church of Scotland has tiny Congregations and the “non-religious” are a now the Majority. “In the 2022 census, 51.1% of respondents said they had “no religion,” up from 36.7% in 2011 https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/czddp0j488qo
Best regards
/
Nathan / October 5, 2024
Hello LankaScot,
The religious believe that there is a God.
Are you certain that there is no God?
/
LankaScot / October 6, 2024
Hello Nathan,
You cannot prove a negative, it is a logical fallacy. Science never claims 100% certainty. However when you make a claim that something (or a process) exists, you should be able to show concrete evidence for it.
If the claim is for something extraordinary, you should have pretty extraordinary evidence to back it up. E.g. Einstein claimed that time was altered by Gravitational forces. The anomalous orbit of Mercury and the bending of light near large masses proved him correct. GPS relies on Einstein’s equations. “Satellite signals designed to keep your car on the right road would be off by miles if not corrected for the effects predicted by Einstein’s math”. https://www.sciencenews.org/article/einsteins-genius-changed-sciences-perception-gravity
Do you think that the Velociraptors or Mammal like Reptiles were discussing the question of God as they veered towards extinction at the end of the Cretaceous 66 Million years ago. Change happens and Gods have nothing to do with it.
Or maybe you can show me some concrete evidence?
Best regards
/
Nathan / October 6, 2024
Hello LankaScot,
We are walking into unknown territories.
Your confidence reflects your attitude.
.
An incident:
My sister had in her hand a letter addressed to me.
It was from the Department of Education.
I guessed it to be carrying my Admission Card.
She was curious.
She said, “You believe in some odd theories. What have you to say about the #”
“Add the individual numerals in the #. Put together those would add to 8”.
She opened the letter. Did the addition.
“8”!
/
old codger / October 6, 2024
Nathan,
Have you heard this?
An Atheist is like a blindfolded man looking for a black cat in a dark room.
A believer is like a blind man in a dark room, but looking for a cat which isn’t there.
Take your pick 😁
/
Nathan / October 6, 2024
old codger,
An incident:
A man walked in thru our gate.
He was half naked; Nothing above his waist.
He said that he was a Palm Reader.
I showed no interest.
He wanted to convince me.
I nodded reluctantly.
He asked me to gather a little of the loose coarse brown grain of sand on the ground.
I did.
He extended his open palm.
I put the sand on his palm.
He closed his palm.
He mumbled something.
When he opened his palm there was perfectly white Holy Ash!
What is your pick!
/